Nineteen foreign banks in the European Union will need to set up new holding companies so that regulators can scrutinise them more closely, an EU discussion paper says, mirroring steps taken by the United States.
The European Commission proposed last November that banks headquartered outside the bloc consolidate their EU activities under an "intermediate parent undertaking" or IPU in response to US moves to require foreign banks to set up such companies.
The commission, which is the EU's executive, has now fleshed out its thinking and has made a preliminary estimate that 19 foreign banks will have to set up an IPU. Between them they operate via 53 subsidiaries and 53 branches, with 35, more than a third of the total, in Britain alone.
[The EU is proposing that] banks headquartered outside the bloc consolidate their EU activities under an "intermediate parent undertaking"
Britain leaves the bloc in March 2019, which makes having a "proper framework" for supervising non-EU banking operations "even more relevant", a discussion paper, which was reviewed by Reuters and is dated September1, said.
Separately, the bloc has already proposed that clearing houses that handle large amounts of euro-denominated assets should be jointly supervised by Brussels after Brexit.
Subsidiaries of foreign lenders make up 42% of banking subsidiaries in the bloc, up from 36% in 2008, but EU regulators have only "limited access" to timely data on what goes on across these operations, the document said.
"As a consequence, the supervision of subsidiaries that belong to the same third-country group, but operate in different member states is fragmented and hence might result in regulatory and supervisory arbitrage."
An IPU would "not necessarily increase capital or liquidity requirements", it added.
The European Central Bank, which supervises top eurozone lenders, and the Single Resolution Board, in charge of closing down those lenders if they fail, both want foreign branches, and not just subsidiaries, to come under IPUs.
The commission, however, is sticking to its view that branches should not be included. Subsidiaries are directly supervised by the country they are in, while branches are supervised mainly by the bank's home country.
The EU proposal needs approval from member states and the European Parliament to become law, and major changes are often made during this process.
The 19 banks are Bank of America, Citi, Credit Suisse, Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan, Morgan Stanley, Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group, UBS, Bank of New York Mellon, Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, State Street, Sumitomo Mitsui Financial Group, Mizuho Financial Group, Wells Fargo, Bank of China Ltd, Agricultural Bank of China Ltd, China Construction Bank Corp, Nomura Holdings, and Royal Bank of Canada.
The document said the benefits to financial stability of creating IPUs would "clearly outweigh" unquantified potential one-off costs of reorganisation.