Ten accused over improper disposal of human remains
Ten people who work at the Addolorata Cemetery were accused in court today with improper disposal of human remains in skips outside the cemetery in Paola.
They were also accused of failing to transfer human remains within the cemetery with due respect.
The accused are Saviour Agius, 56 of Floriana, Paul Briffa 46, of Zebbug, Saviour Zammit, 55 of Cospicua, John Micallef 48, Hamrun, Francis Mansueto, 45, of Floriana, Joseph Muscat, 53 of Paola, Terence Agius, 42 of Floriana, Emanuel Fsrrugia, 60 of Valletta, Paul Genovese 43 of Sta Lucia and Paul Muscat, 57 of Cospicua.
All pleaded not guilty.
The case first came to light in mid-October last year when a Health Department official was reported to have asked the police to investigate what appeared to have been the burning of human remains (bones) near the Addolorata Cemetery.
The Health Ministry said at the time that the fire was noted near Sta Lucija outside the cemetery grounds. The official noted that items that were being burnt included wood, cloth and human remains.
58 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Francis Grech
Feb 22nd, 22:57
So I think that this is the time that our arciac Malta church should consider to introduce cremation in Malta as there is no space in the canneria were to keep all those human bones, it proves a point that when we die the remains of our bodys will only be scattered all over the place so its not true that when we go to meet our maker he expect us to be in full body that's the only reason that the Roman church don't allow cremation.
Maria Genovese
Feb 22nd, 19:29
Excuse me, before you all go and accuse these poor workers which I know one of them really well, who I know what kind of person he is and would never do such thing. I know how much these people work and how many times I have seen them put their lives in danger just to bury coffins 6 feet under.Its a dangerous job and they put their life at risk. Then why does everyone go and accuse them of burning bodies and throw them into skips? Does anyone have such proof? I live just just a few blocks away from the cemetery, do you know how many times I've heard of people doing vandalism at night over there? And stealing jewellery from the corpses at night? Who knows maybe they are capable of burning them as well. I know that everyone has their own opinion, and I do feel sorry for this action because it's hurtful but please do not go and accuse someone who did not do such thing without having any proof because it's very shameful and disrespectful how they just posted their name in public without such proof, and such comments insisting that these poor men have to lose their job. It's not nice, these workers do have familiers to take care of aswell.
C Muscat
Feb 23rd, 09:23
Agree 100%.
Fran Abela
Feb 22nd, 10:13
John Attard - there are other people who would want to do such a job if they really want to work. Excuse me, but if one does not want to do such a job one should just not apply for it. Are we now going to excuse everything on the basis that no one would not want to do such a job ? You know what happened in the UK when English people refused to do certain work, this work was delegated to non-British who wanted to work. Hopefully this will not become the situation in Malta.
C Muscat
Feb 22nd, 13:52
Jien minn dan li qrajt ma rajt xejn. Naturalment naqraw dak li inkiteb u jien harist lejn l-etajiet u x hin rajt li dawn kollha maturi u probabli ilhom jaghmlu dan ix-xoghol ghexieen ta snin kelli nistaqsi lili nniffsi x seta gara.
U bilfors nahseb li ma gara xejn differenti milli dejjem gara u l-post baqa jitnaddaf bhal dejjem u jkolli nahseb u nghid li dalwaqt sejjer jigri xi haga jew inbieghu c-cimiterju jew ser nibdew crematorium u allura jkolli nerga nistaqsi lili nnifsi biex inbiegh ic-cimiterju jew nibni crematorium ghandi ingennen lil haddiema!!!
Mill-bqija bhas-soltu kull min qed jikteb bhali ma jaf xejn!!!
C Muscat
Feb 22nd, 09:43
Ikolli nzid li dan gie issa ghax hemm xi haga tinhema; jew privatizzajoni jew hruq. Meta wiehed jara kemm ghandhom zmien u tara li dawn kollha ilhom jaghmlu dan ix-xoghol hafna snin...tista' tghidli kif issa qabdu u ghamlu hekk u hemm min ilu ghoxrin sena jew izjed u qatt ma kellu xejn.
Naghmel appel lil qorti li jimxi kif suppost u ma jdumx xi mitt sena biex jaqtaghha din il-kawza....justice delayed justice denied.
Victor Pulis
Feb 22nd, 08:47
Make no bones about it what these persons are alleged to have done is dead wrong and a grave offence to human dignity...
Saviour Laferla
Feb 22nd, 07:46
The skip where the bones of human remains were found is outside the Cemetery grounds. Anyone could have thrown these bones there. So why on earth were these poor gravediggers accused of such crime, when anybody could have done it. When gravediggers clean a grave they always try to pick all the bones out of the wet and dirty garments and if a piece of tiny bones are stuck to these garments it is surely not their desire to leave them to be thrown away.
Paul Joseph Mifsud
Feb 22nd, 09:12
Mr Laferla,
How many acquaintances do you know who go about with HUMAN remains in their possession waiting for the opportunity to dispose of them in the first available skip they encounter? Common sense dictates that persons with human remains in their possession must have easy access to a cemetery. No wonder then that the first suspects are cemetery employees!!
Saviour Laferla
Feb 24th, 12:53
Mr. Paul Joseph Mifsud,
For your information and for others who do not know...there are 42 cemeteries around Malta and Gozo. These accused gravediggers only handle remains from Addolorata Cemetery and Rabat Cemetery. All other cemeteries which mainly are church owned beside Mosta, One of Zebbug, Mellieha and St paul's Bay which is in Burmarrad are handled by private persons who find it most difficult to didpose of used coffins and dirty garments. IT COULD BE ANYONE. Now do you understand how many persons are involved?
Dan Vella
Feb 22nd, 07:40
unbelieveble they have no respect , shameful for what they did.
Saviour Laferla
Feb 24th, 13:10
As if you know they did it.
R. Gauci
Feb 21st, 23:05
And I previously thought that no cremation services where available in Malta.
Jackie Hammett
Feb 21st, 22:14
I think its very disturbing to know that maybe one day your friends or relatives end up thrown in a skip like a piece of rubbish,this must have been going on for years,i think its awful and not Hygienic,please bring cremation,i think its only fair we can choose the way we want are burial.
David Sims
Feb 21st, 21:55
Laws must be enacted and procedures for disposition of remains created. I have been a funeral provider for 20 + years and I am shocked to see how things are handled .
Charles Alamango
Feb 21st, 19:38
Not only in Malta.. but what about accountability????This is unbelievable!
C Muscat
Feb 21st, 19:34
Niskanta kemm hawn bravi!!!! Jien kull meta mort funeral ta l-gheziez tieghi dejjem rispett rajt.
Jekk il-gvern irid jipprivatizza c-cimiterju ma ghandux ghalfejn jaqa f dan l-att. Jekk kienu qed jippruvaw izommu nadif x hemm hazin...u mela jkasbru l-mejtin meta dawn xogholhom mal-mejtin u ghandhom l-gheziez taghhom mejtin u midfuna hemm. Nixtieq naf min ma ghandux lil xi hadd mejjet!!!???
Joseph Vassallo, (Bugibba)
Feb 21st, 22:05
Dawk li biex ma' jghaqilhux il-kaptelli inizzluhom kwazi rashom l-isfel, ukoll tghid li juru rispett? Jien nahseb li hafna mill-kadavri jinkisrilhom ghonqhom f'dik is-sitwazzjoni. Dan kollu biex ma' jghaqilhux l-ahhar zewg kaptelli ta;, mhux biex ma'jhaffrux xi hofra ta' sitt piedi.
X'differenza ta' rispett bejn funeral Malta u funeral l-Ingilterra!
C Muscat
Feb 22nd, 09:39
@Joseph Vassallo, (Bugibba) dak li qed tghid int ghandek ragun pero jien qatt ma inzertajt hekk. Fl-ahhar sena kelli xi erba darbiet bejn hemm u cimiterju iehor.
Joseph Vassallo, (Bugibba)
Feb 29th, 18:37
@ C Muscat:
Int qatt ma' nzertajt hekk, u jien qatt ma' nzertajt mhux hekk.
Jien ukoll attendejt hafna difniet. Dejjem l-istess storja bit-tebut jinzel kwazi rasu l-isfel jekk ma' jiehux ukoll xi tisbita ghax jahrabilhomx ghax flok cinga (webbing) juzaw habel tond tal-qanneb, u dan jizloq.
Jekk trid tara rispett lejn il-mejtin, ara ftit kif jittrattaw il-kadavri l-undertakers inglizi, ghax bhalhom ghadni qatt ma' rajt, ghall-anqas quddiem nieshom.
Hawn Malta, lanqas jilbsu decenti ghall-funeral dawk li jahdmu fic-cimiterju, ahseb u ara kemm ser inizzlu l-mejjet bil-winch tal-oqbra jew jaghttu t-trab bit-tapiti.
U kemm tara nies jirfsu fuq l-oqbra tal-madwar? Dan ukoll rispett?
D. A . Agius
Feb 21st, 19:30
Any comment on the actions they are accused of is not needed. Whether they are guilty or not, that must be decided at the end of the trial, based on facts.
On the other hand, can someone put the Government on trial for not allowing cremation? I believe the facebook group below already indicates that quite a number of people are in favour, and if you are, add yourself!
https://www.facebook.com/pages/Lets-introduce-Cremation-in-Malta/166451503419665?ref=ts
P. Vincenti
Feb 21st, 19:23
I find Jeremy Camilleri's attempt at being humorous rather childish.
This has nothing to do with my beliefs and all to do with the fact that the remains of those people could very well be his own relatives for all he cares.
You should grow up a little Mr Camilleri. The world is not so black and white and there is life beyond intolerance towards others.
Jeremy J Camilleri
Feb 22nd, 11:56
P Vincenti..at I find your attempts at refusing to practice what you preach hypocritical.
Of course, if you think that condemning someone BEFORE they are found guilty, and metaphorically baying for their blood is ok than fine...its your conscience after all..
Now riding on a bandwagon? now THATS childish...
Jeremy J Camilleri
Feb 21st, 19:22
so all the people accused of a crime are guilty? far from it....so many people are accused and found no to have been guilty.
.
Joseph Goerge Borg
Feb 21st, 19:20
I cannot follow why on earth the cemetery workers do not remove off all the slabs so that they can lower the coffin easier and faster. They remove only two slabs and have to use all their energy and comedy acts to finish the job.
I am very sorry,, but throw these workers out and I am willing to do the job with my family members.
Mark Spiteri
Feb 21st, 18:34
When I had seen this service on Italian tv about abuse during Cremation, I was so shocked. Seems like even in Malta we have no people with no respect towards our loved ones.
Hope if they are fined guilty, they will be severley punished
http://www.video.mediaset.it/video/iene/puntata/227145/golia-cremazioni-multiple.html
A Camilleri
Feb 21st, 18:30
Ina serious note its time that a crematorium should be built in malta for those people that prefare to be cremated instead of buried.
David Sims
Feb 21st, 21:58
I agree and I am willing to build it.
twanny borg
Feb 21st, 18:24
nispera li jekk jinstabu hatja dawn ma jithallewx jahdmu aktar fic-cimiterju jarmuna fl-iskips lilna u l-mahbubin taghna.
vella m
Feb 21st, 18:10
Cremation please and soon!
Joe Grech
Feb 21st, 17:50
Could I please ask: Who on earth is the MINISTER responsible for this obscene, insensitive and unacceptable alleged ABUSE?
Will s/he resign?
Is the Hon. P.M. going to do anything if these reports actually turn out to be true facts?
We raised hell (and rightly so) when a number of graves were desecrated.
Are the authorities going to raise hell following this incident?
Do they really care to prevent us Maltese looking worse than savages?
Mario Busuttil
Feb 21st, 18:12
The only responsible for the action caused are the ten man accused - if they are found guilty....Why always get the Minister involved and to resign,he didn't act irresponsable ....or we like to add always a politican in scene....
John Attard
Feb 21st, 18:32
I agree with Mario Busutill!
alfred seguna
Feb 21st, 17:18
It is a known fact that in Malta no one is ACCOUNTABLE and RESPONSIBLE.This is from top to bottom.Every new scandal or abuse will make the previous one forgotten.It took some time to be discovered because I think it might have been a common practice.I always thought that there was a place where they put bones when they clean the graves.They used to call it Kennirja I think.Even the chapel is now neglected.I think that in Malta nobody cares.I think the cemetery falls under the Ministry of Health.May be as usual we leave things to deteriorate so that then we say that it is better if it is given to the private sector.History repeats itself for someones benefit.
J. Camenzuli
Feb 21st, 17:00
Vera tal-misthija.Jien giel attendejt funerali u bqajt totalment iddizgustat bl-attitudni ta in-nies li jahdmu fic-cimiterjuImma kif lanqas Fic-cimiterju ma ahna organizzati??!!!
Paul Caruana
Feb 21st, 16:44
Before we go all self righteous against these workers, are we sure that the government is providing them with adequate training and facilities as to how they should dispose of human remains, following the periodic cleaning of public grave sites prior to reuse?
Paul Attard
Feb 21st, 16:52
That maybe true but anyone with an ounce of sense would have questioned it. There is something profoundly wrong with what happened that needs to be addressed urgently. That is someting from the grassroots all the way to the top.
eddie vella
Feb 21st, 16:44
@ Fran Abela
Agree with you 100%. But on this island nobody cares, nobody is accountable and no one is nobody.
Jeremy J Camilleri
Feb 21st, 16:43
Has anyone, catholic Vincenti included, ever heard the term innicent until proven guilty??
Malta..a nation of judges and jurys!!!!!!
John Micallef
Feb 21st, 17:44
Exactly, Jeremy, and, by jove, I would like to be the executioner sometimed too...
Joe Portelli
Feb 21st, 16:38
Obviously a law onto their own - cremating human parts in hospitals or cemetery must have a permit and documented incase its turned into a convenient body deposal. However these people that work in our much valued cemetery seem to have no respect on this holy burial ground - along with my relatives and friends we have on many occasions heard swearing, spitting and vulgar talk when visiting tombs of our parents - and none of the ones swearing were below 45 years - they should know better - I hope this behaviour is soon clamped on because it disturbs a lot of families deceased buried on land where these people are principal rulers. Well done for the action taken so far.
Ms.D. Galea
Feb 21st, 16:32
How disgusting!
Another reason why cremation should be introduced.
P. Vincenti
Feb 21st, 16:30
This is utterly unacceptable, completely disrespectful and worthy of a very severe response.
Joe Portelli
Feb 21st, 16:43
Absolutley !
A Sultana
Feb 21st, 16:28
either or. burnt like that or continued to be chewed by tiny animals. they are just BONES! no human being was hurt in the process
Fran Abela
Feb 21st, 16:26
I should think these were not the remains of their loved ones.
Fran Abela
Feb 21st, 16:23
These men, if one can call them such, should all be dismissed instantly if the claims are found to be true. We are all clamouring for accountability and this is one instance that all should be accountable for their actions, starting from top to bottom please.
John Attard
Feb 21st, 18:37
East Fran, and who wants to do their job anyway! Maybe you or? Tghid li kont id direttur tac cimiterji ma nirrezenjax jew u mela le Fran, u l-pensjoni igibhili shuna inti!
Tony Busuttil
Feb 21st, 16:22
oh my God.......................
why since october this came to light now?
I dont think this was the first time, is this an excuse to privitise the cemetery?
I think the authorities should make a proper statment. We all have our loved one's over their.
kevin camilleri
Feb 21st, 16:21
tal biki:((((
Victor Rodenas
Feb 21st, 16:20
Dan ic-cimiterju ghandu jinghata lill-privat.Kif isir id-dfin bhal-issa tal biki,it-tebut jitnizzel quazi dritt,naf li dawk li jahdmu hemm huma ftit,u jkollhom hafna xoghol,izda mhux hekk.Niskanta kif il- Knisja ma tghid xejn,forsi ahna Tempju tal-Ispiertu S-Santu meta nkunu hajjin biss.!
Vincent Galea
Feb 21st, 16:13
Why man would continue to trust in man is what is surprising to me.
Mr D.S. Scott
Feb 21st, 16:08
A number of gravediggers and certain funeral service providers should look deeply into their conscience if they have any left.
Jeremy Gambin
Feb 21st, 16:02
These chaps have introduced cremation without anyone noticing before
j dough
Feb 21st, 15:43
won't someone PLEASE open a crematorium and let us leave this earth in dignity?
the way our departed are treated at the cemetry is dreadful. i appreciate that for the gravediggers it is just 'a job' but shouting to each, other jumping down on to coffins already in the ground and leaving coffins on the pathway till the gravediggers, ropes and other paraphenalia are all gathered is not acceptable.
no only is it extremely undignified, but only adds heartache to the griefstricken mourners.
Fran Abela
Feb 21st, 16:24
Agree totally. About time we had a crematorium in Malta.
John Attard
Feb 21st, 18:40
Agree crematoruim now ! and fast! MEpa easy on this one please......wara kollox mejtin se jkun hemm...jew tindahal l FAAA issa wkoll minhabba l permess!
Mario Busuttil
Feb 21st, 15:43
Moda gdida ta incenatur ....ilhom jintremew twibet u fjuri hziena ghal zmien twil wara certi hitan tac cimiterju tal Addolorata...forsi issa jieqfu la awtorita indunaw.