
Friday, 28th March 2008 - 16:13CET
UPDATED: Anglu Farrugia claims election corrupt practices
Labour MP Anglu Farrugia today called on the Police Commissioner and handed him a three page document which he said backed his claim that hundreds of votes were “bought” before the general election.
Dr Farrugia, the opposition spokesman for justice in the last administration and himself a former police superintendent, did not go into detail on how the votes were “bought” but said prices varied between €70 and €150 and in one case there was a bonus of €1,500.
Dr Farrugia appeared to be making the allegations in his personal capacity and was not accompanied by Labour Party officials when he gave a press conference outside police headquarters.
He first made his claim two weeks ago on television, when he also said he was interested in contesting the election for the MLP leadership.
PN general secretary Joe Saliba, who had been present when the allegations were made, had appeared to dismiss them.
Dr Farrugia said the allegations were reported to him after the PN victory and he felt it his duty to ask the Commissioner of Police to investigate.




RSS
Comments
One has to see what could or should happen if the case were somehow to be proven to have a foundation of truth given the current circumstances.
I would personally stop here and conclude by saying that comments now are superfluous as the Commissioner of Police - who enjoys the public's trust based on his track-record - needs to be allowed to carry out any investigation without any form of public pressure.
What is interesting, however, is the news coming from Italy where just last week there were newspaper reports alleging vote buying schemes involving Italians living in Germany in relation to the forthcoming Italian elections on April 13th and 14th. Interestingly, the price quoted varied from 10 to 50 Euros per vote (and a journalist managed to buy a number like this).
This was then followed by allegatons involving vote rigging through the use of mobile phones in election booths - where people were to be paid if they presented a photo of their ballot sheet with the necessary candidates given preference.
Now, just today, the Sky TG24 announced that a major case involving the Calabrese mafia was uncovered in Buenos Aires and another case involving a Sicilian politician with the surname of Micciche' and 50,000 votes was being investigated in Philadelphia!
So, we have all to be careful whichever way we comment: Nothing is new under the sun! I only hope that nothing of the sort ever happens like this in Malta.
I don't need to say "I hope to God he won't be elected MLP leader" coz I know that even the most blindfolded diehards won't elect him.
He's beyond belief.
And so are all those here who believe him.
Well I wish him well, hoping he will get the job.
With a leader like Dr Farrugia, the PN will be guaranteed another term in office. Wow
My argument was that before every election, whoever is in power tries to win votes in the last days before the election.
SO ACCORDING TO DR. FARRUGIA ALL THE ELECTIONS OF THE LAST 20 YEARS ARE INVALID. AND WHY HE WAITED SO LONG TO TALK, maybe because he's in the leadership battle only now !!!
Mr J.Scerri
How many people were employed with the public sector before the 1992 election?
With all due respect to everyone, I have a nagging suspicion that all this hullaballoo is nothing but deviation ploy, concocted with the sole aim of making us shift our focus from the more ineteresting and mundane goings-on within the MLP as a result of the no-holds-barred battle for the leadership seat, exactly as we are doing now in this blog!
Was this the only election that had the selling of votes? I doubt it. All the comments here are about those people who sold their vote to the Nationalists. What about those people who sold it to the Labour, AD, or AN? After all, how can we tell that? But I'm sure that Anglu Farrugia would not include these people in his list.
And what about those people who in reality did not want to vote or couldn't be bothered and had an opportunity to sell their vote? This would mean still not voting and getting cash for it -- great bargain! What else would you want? I know people who live abroad and were not coming to Malta to vote and were thinking about selling their vote to the other party, but didn't in the end becauase they thought they would be better off going for a holiday to Malta for just €35 and maybe invalidate (or not) their vote once at the voting booth.
Please stop doing any more harm to out country. If an investigation needs to be made, fine do it. But do not make the people fight between themselves over you stupid politicians. We have better things in life than fight for you so that all you politicians in the end will gain.
MLP, PN, AD, & AN -- you are all the same in the end. The welfare you try to maximise is your own and not the country's. You will only do things that will you personally will benefit from.
We definitely need a change and we should be able to do everything possible in this small country of ours, but in the right manner.
If fresh elections are held, we who served as assistant commissioners, counting agents and whatever, shall we be paid for our service during the useless election day? Shall we be reconsidered for the job during the new election?
If the answer for both questions is in the affirmative, I thank you very, very much, and egoistically speaking, and hoping that it would not be corrupt practice, I would hope, that if the new election will be nulled again, we will be paid again and reconsidered for the job during the eventual new election.
And so on, and so forth.
I have the money, and I want my party to win so I decided {on my own will} to buy votes in the various ways that some readers here described. What has the party to do with this ? I am guilty without any doubt but does invalidates an election even if there were many of these buyers ??!!
What’s some 100 bucks compared to a MEPA permit, a licence, a cosy job with a quango, a chosen tender, juicy consultancy assignments, govt. housing, a waived hefty fine…..can we dismiss that these vote eliciting feats occur, and unfortunately seem to be condoned by all?
Moreover, how appropriate were the billboards and mail shots financed from taxpayer (not party) funds?
Finally what are some euros in a citizen’s pocket, compared to the thousands secretly accepted by political parties from businessmen?
So who is buying whom, when, where, how and why and more crucially, what are the consequences?
Finally I wish to take this opportunity to congratulate Albert Fenech on his comments and hope that to-days young voters must realise that it was the MLP THAT GAVE THEM DIGNITY WHILE THE CONSERVATIVES FOUGHT TOOTH AND NAIL AGAINST ALL THE BENEFITS, TOO MANY TO MENTION HERE
What I ask is, why the election time was extended? Wasn't it because there were a lot more illiterate voters this time?
This is a banana republic country and dictatorial like government and supporters (if you say something against, then you should succumb).
Dear Anglu, people voted for corruption, and this was part of it, that's why they wanted the GonziPN, cos with them in Government corruption business is easy and blessed. So let's all be one corrupt happy family.
Dear Daniel Micallef,
PN are surely no saints... as well as MLP mind you... BUT you should never shout to loud cause it can back fire!
A Chinese proverb says '' go around your own house 3 times before you judge others'' ... and it seems MLP haven't done that yet.
This happens as follows:-
A person finds another one in need of money from the other side of the political spectrum and give him money to vote for his party. The voter will pretend to be "iletterate" and vote to the other party in front of party officials in the voting booth - this to ensure that money has delivered the desired outcome.
WE should have statistics on how many have voted as "illetarate" ans whether any how previously voted alone, now needed assistance. this would should whether vote rigging occured.
hopefully investigations will deliver justice - and if anybody did this, they will pay.
Simply put, it boils down to either: It is true and the culprits pay the consequence, no matter who, why, where and what colour OR It is untrue and Anglu, what? Goes Scott free? I think, at the very least he should be charged with presenting misleading information to the police and for being a general nuisance.
"@M. Brincat - remember that if Anglu tal-iljunfant’s allegations are correct, it’s the Labourites who sold their votes for thirty quid. That’s how much they love their party."
HOW CAN HE BLAME DR. GONZI, if someone outside the party has done so !!! Dr. Gonzi is not responsible for the PN supporters (more than 143000),
I think that the only election were votes could had been 'bought' without money but the govt. was GUILTY, that was in 1987 when 7000 people were empoyed by the MLP in the public sector in the last 3 weeks before the election.
WHERE WAS DR. A. FARRUGIA THEN ?
is anyone saying that the Pn is purer than white?.....of course not....i don't think there's a politician or anyone in this world ( apart from the POPE maybe) who's purer than pure and I think that JPO should resign....but thats not the argument here... the argument is that whether this is true or not if you think that the MLP lost because of this than you're only fooling yourself!!!! yes lets wait for the investigation but in the meantime i do hope that some of you here make a deep political analysis and look at the fact that your Party told you that you were going to win and lost, that your party twice in 5 years told you that you should celebrate and you had to return home after an hour....Have you ever thought how you look when you do these things!!?....I mean even now, in the frentic push of those who have robbed the MLP from you , you are excluding people like Alfred Mifsud and G.Abela....and why? Because they haven't been loyal enough!! Why are they afraid of giving a voice to the tesserati?? If the tesserati feel betrayed by G.Abela give them a voice to say it.......don't suffocate it and presume to have the power to speak in their name. Dear Labour supporters can't you see that your Party has NO ALLIES....who are Labour's friends??? With ppl like A.Farriuga the MLP will remain where it is: attractive ( VERY attractive it seems from this blog!!) to Labourites...it will remain the sole property of the Labourites.....it will remain a very big influential Party stuck to Opposition benches!!! ......come on this is the truth and no JPO and no wild claims are going to cover this reality. Do you want to be winners again or not? Do you want to win an election or not?? I think yes.......shouting slogans and hating Gonzi from morning to night aint going to help!!!
Maybe after the the JPO case now nationalists should know more that their party is not as pure and saint as some project it...
If the epilogue of Dr. Farrugia's allegations will be the holding of fresh elections, as the perception in these comments is, it will not be fair that th Labour Party will face the electorate with a new leader.
Therefore the election for a new leader of the Malta Labour Party should be postponed indefinitely until the investigations are over.
Is this again a VIRTUE that has only now discovered by you and all those behind that Glass, red painted building just discovered now.?
Is this a VIRTUE that you and all those behind that Glass, red painted building just discovered now.?
Ask those who were Assisstant Commissioners during the last election, how many of them heard people taking photos with their mobiles. It's not the case of who you support, but I hope that people are still honest and demand to know the truth!
And if what Dr Farrugia is saying is the truth, then what will happen then?
If the PN wants to be credible that it wants to fight corruption, then the PN ought to help Dr Farrugia (and not condemn him) so that the truth shall be know.
Above all, this has always been a party that enlisted God and the Church as their “witnesses”. Thus Lord Strickland was branded a “freemason” by the infamous slanderous testimony of Terrinu, was interdicted by the Church Authorities and subsequently lost the General Election. This was the same party that expressed sympathy for Mussolini and his fascists. This was the same party that branded Dom Mintoff “a communist” and led the Church Authorities to interdict him and MLP supporters, leaving the PN free to win successive elections in 1962 and 1966, and failed to back Mintoff in his 1958 drive for Malta’s independence (Malta’s Archbishop then was Sir Michael Gonzi – I believe the great uncle of the present PM Dr. Lawrence Gonzi). This is and was the same party that refused to accept the result of the 1981 General Elections even though they had agreed to the pre-electoral terms, causing years of political and economic turmoil. This is the same party whose leader was taken to Court and fined for slandering MLP Leader Dr. Alfred Sant and was later Prime Minister and then made President of Malta.
I record these facts lest we should ever forget.
Song Request----"the only Way is Up.....Labour" (hahahahahahaha)
My question to Dr Farrugia is as clear as crystal -
Answer 'Yes' or 'NO' . I shall not repeat it again.
No other arguement or justification from anyone is relevent to my direct question.
I know enough about the case you mentioned and I also have known Dr . Farrugia since we were in our teens. We are still old school freinds.
I do not share ALL his political views but I have respect for this person maybe more than some individuals from his same political field.
This is why I am asking him this question because I know he is intelligent enough to respond in a most credible manner.
Are we to blame only the MP's if this is true? If these dear angel knows who they are, is he going to accept them in the MLP? If "Labour voters" sold there vote, this thus mean that 150euros or more are better than a 5 year Labour Goverment, better than half surcharge? (seems it would be certainly so)
I am understanding the concept of reception class...another year of indoctrination of Socialist values, maybe!!!
Song request: Lemon Tree
.........by the way i was laughing on the 10th and the 11th of March.....thinking that all those ballerina's were not enough, all those corruption charges were not enough, thinking that those wails of pain and poverty were not enough, thinking that 20 full years were not enough and the people struck a deal and the deal was Gonzi..............go on vote Anglu as Leader, go on show that socialism runs in your blood, go on elect him Leader of Opposition.....you'll be handing the PN more electoral victories....go on call my bluff!!!!!
P.S---when 8,000 jobs and hundreds of govt. flats were given on the eve of the 1987 election the ppl still voted Karmenu OUT!! 'Coz the ppl wanted change!! This time the desire for change seemed to be much less!!
On more of a serious point;, you are comparing Mata to Zimbabwe and calling Malta a banana republic. If it is so, why don't you back your bags and leave. Let me remind you, Malta always gave its' contribution on the international arena; and for it, Malta is a respected Country. That should make every decent Maltese proud. Through Malta's initiative in the UN,we can boast as a Nation that Malta has left a lasting legacy for all that comes after us and to thank us as a Nation. Yes, I am referring to the Law of the Sea which was championed by Ambassador Pardo whom Mr. Mintoff quicky deposed in 1971,
Personally before joining my camp I prefer to wait a bit but if the allegations are proved then I will lead a campaign for radical measures.
What a pity. What is good for the goose is not good for the gander. Shame, shame, shame.
I suppose they do not even dare to contemplate the outcome should it prove to be true.
The lemons must be VERY sour this season.
Dear editor
Will you please send me a quotation for such an advertisement to be published on your site for at least once a year until 2013?
Thank you.
Lets make a deal...you are blaming gthe whole Labour party because Anglu is accusing your beloved party with Xiri tal voti....OK deal...
So does it mean that if your Blue crystal clear Anglu JPO is found guilty thta means the whole Nationalist party is guilty include Gonzi? Deal or no deal...
I say it is a Deal ha ha ha ..........
it's only rumours,that a certain individual bought quite a few votes.If it were true,a million euros here and there wouldn't matter much!Just another investment.Everybody knows which side his bread is buttered.This will not change the outcome of the election,but it might show that certain people are not above the law,or maybe they are!!
(1) There is the default method; you give me your voting document and I give you money and then I destroy your vote;
(2) You take a mobile picture of your voting document after you have voted in the polling booth, show me the picture immediately you leave the polling booth and I pay you the agreed price;
(3) You grant me a favour that is accomplished before the election and I hand over my voting document;
(4) You send me an Income Tax rebate by post - which is what I received days before voting day when this rebate should have been paid in December 2008 - and hope this will "induce" me to vote for you;
(5) On the eve of elections MEPA issues hundreds of permits and go-aheads;
(6) You portray one of your candidates being a "victim" of a smear campaign, induce thousands of sympathy votes and get the candidate elected from two districts and then do your level best to get rid of him AFTER the elections.
I cannot vouchsafe that (1) to (3) were in operation, but certainly (4) was dishonestly rampant and (5) always a distinct possibility whilst (6) was a dead cert.
Free and fair elections? I think that Dr. Mugabe of Zimbabwe has even copied our model. Days before his election he has handed out hundreds of free vehicles to doctors and Government officials have been touring villages informing them that unless they vote "properly" they will have their food supplies cut off.
The affinity between Malta and Zimbabwe - we are both distinct Banana Republics!
However I must point out that this evening on the local media was mentioned the fact that 2 ministers were involved in this case. if this is true would it mean that the PN will have 3 MPs undergoing investigations (including JPO)? If so this is serious, the case alone if true is very serious indeed, more than the Mistra case in my opinion. If proved true this could lead to nullifying the election results considering the very narrow margin with which the elections were won.
Of course we have to wait before jumping to conclusions. However well done to Dr Farrugia for bringing forward such evidence. People who voted MLP deserve investigations. I truly hope that the required investigations be carried out and the MLP should stress this point for the sake of their significant number of supporters. Also this could be a case of moral abuse on some MLP supporters who were being horrified to sell their vote. We will wait and see.
Some actually hope fresh elections will be called?
My goodness, isn't it about time you slap your faces a bit and wake up?
Did it occur to you there is a reason MLP are not backing him up?
1st. selling/buying votes is illegal.
2nd. if selling/buyinh can be tied to government - then that is vote riging - and election can be called void.
I heard of thousands getting "favours" before the election , maybe there was money involved too.....
Neither you nor I know Exactly what goes around during an election campaign .
From illegal betting to bribes , to phone calls asking for favours from Govt MPs two days before the election or else 'NO VOTE', Mass employment two months before an election.
If one had to investigate corrupt practices throughout the years who knows what will come out ? I heard a lot of stories which were said to have happened in the 1981, 1987, and other election campaigns.
'Isma bilfors u emmen jekk trid' the saying goes.
The only thing I am asking Dr. Farrugia is a simple question - ANY REGRETS ?? answer YES or NO.
I am not questioning the GOVT majority - It would be more worrying if we had a government with an absolute minority of 48% and an opposition with 52% .
I can understand the urge some MLP supporters have for the time to come when this govt might crumble.
Mind you, nothing can be taken for granted. We know what happened in 1996 - 1998 . This is why the second amendment in the electoral law was created and approved by both parties.
So let's see if we're understanding : According to Dr. Farrugia's statement, he's saying that for some of the MLP supporters, their party in govt is not worthed more than 70 EUROS. He must have great consideration for his party's supporters.
And how many votes were bought in this PATHETIC story ? Let's say 1566 (the difference between the 2 parties) at 785 EUROS each (the average between 70 and 1500), total : nearly 1 million 230 thousand Euros. And they were paid in CASH, CREDIT CARD OR PAYPAL ??
Continue to live in DREAMLAND, at least there you won't be defeated !!! But pls don't make fool of the maltese people AND RESPECT THEIR VERDICT GIVEN IN THE ELECTION and for once don't be a BAD LOSER !!!
Dr. Farrugia's 'PR move' is unfortunately ill-timed - if his motive was justice he did not need the media to follow him, the report could have been handed to the Police Commissioner confidentially.
So the (investigative) question is: what is his motive and what does it mean for the future (?) labour leader and the labour party?
Ok, but what about if this is true?? We will have a Government whose few votes of relative majority was obtained by fraudulent practice.....what's next
What if Dr. Farrugia's claims are wrong? What should we do to him?
But what if his claims are found to be true? What should happen then?
You get elected in parliament not by buying votes but by generating genuine opportunities for the people to make money from
This is for example, an offence to the intelligence of thousands of people who work in the ICT sector. A sector in which the MLP has absolutely no vision at all
I don't think he is crazy enough to produce a report without facts.
If the report proves nothing, then call him pathetic as much as you want, but what if he is claiming is true ?
LOSER!!!!