France, Germany face EU legal threat over pig welfare

Some of Europe’s biggest pig producers including Germany, France and Spain face legal action over their failure to meet a January 1 deadline to implement new EU animal welfare rules, EU sources have said.

A quarter of the bloc’s 12 million sows are still being kept on farms where individual cages known as sow stalls remain in use, despite being banned from the start of the year.

The huge scale of non-compliance could raise fears of a larger-than-expected drop in EU pig production as a result of the ban, which could increase pork prices for consumers and dent soaring European exports to Russia and China.

The level of compliance is particularly poor among large producers in France, according to data submitted by governments to the European Commission, EU sources said.

“It’s now up to these countries to take action, and in some cases that means closing down whole farms,” said one source speaking on condition of anonymity.

The Commission, which enforces EU animal welfare rules, is preparing legal action against countries that have yet to meet the deadline, with a formal announcement expected next month. The bloc’s health and consumer affairs C­­­ommissioner, Tonio Borg, was raising the issue at a meeting with EU farm ministers in Brussels.

Despite the prospect of legal action and farm closures, officials said the Commission would oppose any move by EU governments to block imports from countries that failed to meet the deadline.

The EU ban was first agreed in 2001, and several EU countries including Sweden and Luxembourg outlawed their use before the EU deadline. Britain has had a ban in place since 1999.

In total, 10 EU countries met the January 1 deadline: Austria, Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Romania, Slovakia, Sweden and Britain.

Malta and Hungary say they have since enforced the ban.

Several other countries including The Netherlands, a major producer, are likely to be close to full compliance, the sources said.

In October, Commission officials told a meeting of EU farm and industry experts that pig production would fall five per cent by 2014 as a result of the rules.

French pig producers’ group FNP estimated the ban would add €650 per pig to costs in a sector where many farmers are already breaking even or making losses. Last year the Commission banned the export of eggs from producers who failed to meet a January 1, 2012 ban on battery cages. But the difficulty in tracing pork meat back to individual producers compared with eggs, especially in processed products such as salami or chorizo, makes a similar ban impossible, officials said.

Sow stalls, or gestation crates, are metal cages roughly two metres long and 60 cm wide used to hem in pregnant pigs and make them easier to control.

While some producers say the cages reduce ear-biting and other forms of aggression between sows, animal welfare campaigners say they cause psychological damage to animals that end up caged for most of their adult lives.

EU farmers produced a record 22.7 million tonnes of pork in 2010 – twice the volume of the US but still far behind China’s output of 51 million, EU and US data showed.

EU pig production currently amounts to 110 per cent of its consumption, so while domes-tic shortages are unlikely, the bloc’s growing exports could suffer.

In 2011, its pork exports grew more than 20 per cent to reach three million tonnes, with Russia and China among the major destinations.


See our Comments Policy Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated.

Comments not loading? We recommend using Google Chrome or Mozilla Firefox with javascript turned on.
Comments powered by Disqus