The departure of four prominent judges – Joseph Galea Debono, Philip Sciberras, Joseph D. Camilleri and Carmel Agius – has revived calls for the judiciary’s retirement age to be raised past 65 years. The government has no intention of doing so. Waylon Johnston turned to lawyers to see what they think.

Cedric Mifsud, 31, Pietà
If judges are still capable of delivering and have no health problems they should be allowed to continue with their job. Just two days ago I appeared before a tribunal that was presided over by a retired judge and I can say I was very satisfied. Although the judge had retired some time ago, he carried out his work well and still contributed to the country.

Veronique Dalli, 30, Mosta
I believe the age should be raised because there are very valid members of the judiciary who have reached a certain level and are excelling because of their experience but unjustly have to retire. It is unfortunate, unjust and cruel not only on the judges but on the institution as a whole because the more time passes the better they become. Judges in England can remain up until the age of between 70 and 75. The government’s decision not to raise the retirement age is bad when you see the type of judges they are letting go.

Marion Camilleri, 30, Sliema
I think it’s a shame to have certain judges with so much experience, which is difficult to get because of the delicate nature of the work and the responsibilities, retiring simply because of age.

Carol Zammit Montebello, 45, Balzan
I’m in agreement that the age should be raised because it’s a pity when they have to retire after gathering all that experience and knowledge.

Joe Mifsud, 42, Mosta
The issue should be looked at on a national level. For example, why doesn’t the head of a department stay on until 70? It also depends on how long the adjudicator has been serving. I think this should be seriously discussed. However, I believe the age limit of 65 is fine because others should be given a chance to be appointed.

José Herrera, 47, Lija
I think the time has come to start discussing this issue, even at a parliamentary level. The Labour Party has not yet taken a stand but, speaking personally, I’m in favour of revising the system because the way things stand it is taking the independence of the courts away. When a judge is close to retirement, he starts looking for another job because the judiciary’s pensions are low. When a judge is in his 60s, he is in his prime.

Owen Bonnici, 30, Marsascala
I believe the age limit should be raised. When the judges retire they are left with a ridiculous pension and no job. Following retirement they should be given a judicial role within the legal camp.