A Spanish collector plans to auction what he claims is a newly-discovered 8mm version of a film purportedly showing Marilyn Monroe having sex when she was still an underage actress known as Norma Jean Baker.
A Marilyn Monroe expert, however, said the actress in the film was someone else, considerably heavier and less feminine than the legendary film star.
"That's not Marilyn. The chin is not the same, the lips are not the same, the teeth are not the same," said Scott Fortner, who has a sizeable collection of Monroe memorabilia, including a belt he said proves how much more petite she was.
"Marilyn was a tiny little thing. And I know that for a fact. I own her clothing."
Collector Mikel Barsa said in an interview yesterday that he wanted at least £310,500 for the sexually explicit six and a half-minute, grainy black-and-white film, which he says was made before 1947, when Monroe was not yet 21.
He said it was an exact copy of a 16mm film discovered more than a decade ago.
Mr Barsa brokered a sale of that film to a European magazine in 1997, which he said in turn sold 600,000 copies before a collector bought the original 16mm reel for £745,000. Copies of that version are still circulating on the internet.
"People with romantic notions have denied that it's Marilyn Monroe and have invented stories" to raise doubts about the film, Mr Barsa said in his office in Buenos Aires, Argentina, lined with pictures from his days as a concert promoter.
"This film shows the real Marilyn Monroe - it was only later that the studios discovered her and transformed her."
The face of the woman in the film looks considerably different from the Monroe who emerged later as a star, but more similar to the Monroe seen in one of her first movies, 1949's Love Happy, which shows the actress before she lost weight, added a beauty spot on her left cheek and became one of Hollywood's most enduring stars.
Monroe died of an overdose of sleeping pills in 1962 at the age of 36.
Mr Barsa said he had no idea how the two original copies ended up in the hands of the people who sought his help selling them and refused to identify any of the principals involved.
He said that in the 1940s sex films were often made using side-by-side 16mm and 8mm cameras, since audiences used both formats.
The collector said Mark Roesler of Indianapolis-based CMG Worldwide, which has managed the image and estate of Monroe, threatened to sue after the earlier version surfaced in 1997. Mr Barsa said nothing ever came of it after the owners offered to sell the film to CMG.
Mr Roesler did not respond to requests for comment.
Mr Barsa says he plans to auction the film himself on August 7 at a memorabilia collectors fair that he has organised in Buenos Aires and is hoping for publicity similar to the scandal he generated when he screened the 16mm version at a similar fair in Madrid in 1997.
News coverage of his auction is already creating another buzz on the internet.
His part of the deal is a 10% sales commission, he said.
A variety of sexually-explicit films and pictures have been attributed to Monroe over the years, fostering a long and unresolved debate.
"In the Marilyn community, people have debated this for years and years and for the most part it's widely believed that this is not her," Mr Fortner said.
But even Mr Fortner said Monroe's image changed considerably as she became a star - that she had some plastic surgery, learned how to hold her face differently in modelling school and adopted a mole on her left cheek.