Three witnesses who testified in a pending civil case have been acquitted of perjury by a court which deemed their testimony as irrelevant to the outcome of proceedings.

In addition, the Gozo Court presided by Magistrate Joe Mifsud warned on the increasing number of cases especially on the sister island, of people who file perjury complaints lightly. The courts should not serve as fora to accentuate divisions even on trivial matters, and the police need to tread carefully on such cases to prevent abuse, he said.

The case involved pending civil proceedings which had been instituted by Maurice Hili who was seeking compensation from Francis Attard, Carmel Attard and Carmel Vella, for the injuries sustained in an incident dating back to August 2001.

During these proceedings the court had accepted a request, through which Mr Hili’s son, his daughter and husband, had been summoned to testify over a separate incident which was not related at all to the case. This was done to clear Mr Hili’s reputation. Subsequently, the Attards’ filed an application claiming that Mr Hili’s relatives had committed perjury.

In his ruling Magistrate Joe Mifsud expressed his disagreement for such practice, saying that the courts were no “washing machine” to clear one’s reputation but to decide on the issues brought before it. In this respect he remarked that the civil court should have never acquiesced to Mr Hili’s request as this had no relevance to his compensation claim.

Consequently he ruled that even in case the witnesses had not been loyal to the truth, they could not be held liable for perjury as their evidence had no bearing at all on the final outcome.

Lawyer Georgina Schembri was defence counsel whereas police inspector Bernard Charles Spiteri.

Sign up to our free newsletters

Get the best updates straight to your inbox:
Please select at least one mailing list.

You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of our emails. We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By subscribing, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing.