Cyprus tries to rework divisive bank tax
Cypriot ministers have rushed to revise a plan to seize money from bank deposits as part of an EU bailout, in an effort to ensure lawmakers support it in a vote later in the day.
The weekend announcement that Cyprus would impose a tax on bank accounts as part of a 10 billion euro ($13 billion) bailout broke with previous practice that depositors' savings were sacrosanct and sent a shiver across the bloc, causing the euro to tumble and stock markets to dive.
Ahead of the vote in parliament, the government was working on a plan to soften the blow to smaller savers, by tilting more of the tax towards those with deposits greater than 100,000 euros - many of them Russians, eliciting an angry reaction from President Vladimir Putin.
The government says Cyprus has no choice but to accept the bailout with the levy on deposits, or go bankrupt.
A Cypriot government source told Reuters the introduction of a tax-free threshold for smaller bank deposits was under discussion but not yet agreed.
The euro zone has indicated that changes would be acceptable as long as the return of around six billion euros is maintained. If the Cypriot parliament votes the deal down, the euro zone would face a real risk of being dragged back into crisis.
"It is up to the government alone to decide if it wants to change the structure of the ... contribution (from) the banking sector," European Central Bank policymaker Joerg Asmussen, who was pivotal in the weekend negotiations, told reporters on the sidelines of a Berlin conference.
"The important thing is that the financial contribution of 5.8 billion euros remains," he said.
Residents on the island emptied cash machines to get their funds over the weekend. The move also unnerved depositors in the euro zone's weaker economies and investors fearing a precedent that could reignite market turmoil that the European Central Bank has calmed in recent months with its pledge to do whatever it takes to save the euro.
The euro fell before tempering losses. European stocks did similarly, dropping two percent before more than halving losses.
In the bond market - often the most reliable guide to euro zone stress - safe haven German Bund futures shot up while Italian equivalents dived, suggesting some concern that Cyprus could infect its larger neighbours.
"The crisis is back," one bond trader said.
Brussels has emphasised that the measure is a one-off for a country that accounts for just 0.2 percent of European output. The worst fear is that savers in other, larger European countries become nervous and start withdrawing funds, although there was no immediate sign of that on Monday.
U.S. economist Paul Krugman wrote in The New York Times: "It's as if the Europeans are holding up a neon sign, written in Greek and Italian, saying 'Time to stage a run on your banks!'"
PUTIN ANGRY
Cyprus's banking sector dwarfs the size of its economy and its banks have been severely hurt by exposure to much larger neighbour Greece.
Its open economy has meant that its banks also attract cash from Russians. Moscow is considering extending an existing 2.5 billion euro loan to help bail the island out and said it had come to no decision.
Russian President Vladimir Putin criticised the bank levy as unfair and setting a dangerous precedent.
"While assessing the proposed additional levy on bank accounts in Cyprus, Putin said that such a decision, should it be made, would be unfair, unprofessional and dangerous," Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov told reporters.
Approval in Cyprus' fractious 56-member parliament is far from a given: no party has an absolute majority and three parties say outright they will not back the tax. A vote initially planned for yesterday was rescheduled to give more time to build a consensus.
Faced with a growing public backlash, Cypriot finance ministry officials began discussions with lenders yesterday to lessen the blow for smaller savers.
Yesterday, a source close to the consultations told Reuters authorities were hoping to cut the tax to 3.0 percent from 6.7 percent for deposits under 100,000 euros. The rate for deposits above that would then be jacked up to 12.5 percent from 9.9 percent.
Cypriot President Nicos Anastasiades, a conservative elected just three weeks ago, said in a TV address that the tax was an alternative to a disorderly bankruptcy. It was painful, but "will eventually stabilise the economy and lead it to recovery".
Savers who lost money would be compensated by shares in commercial banks, with equity returns guaranteed by future revenues expected from natural gas discoveries, Anastasiades said. But many legislators remain unconvinced.
"Essentially parliament is called to legalise a decision to rob depositors blind, against every written and unwritten law," said Yiannakis Omirou, speaker of parliament and head of EDEK, the small Socialist party. "We refuse to subscribe to this."
16 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Alex Ellul
Mar 18th, 20:10
Why was this not applied to Ireland,Spain etc? Because then Gwrmany could afford to bail out others, but now it has not got any money left while the German citizens themselves are fed up with bailing out the lazy laggards. In fact there's a rebellion within Merkel's party, telling her to get Germany OUT OF THE EURO ZONE. This faction from the Christian Democrats is abetted by economists and lawers
keith perry
Mar 18th, 22:50
Alex Ellul: Firstly many Germans detested the idea of joining the Euro currency.
For the unaware the Russian connection is through offshore money laundering - yes other countries have it but check out the amount of russian money for such a little place - by the way Putin isn't a fan of offshore russian business by these people.
And it was the Cyprus President who refused to tax only big depositor
Michael Sammut
Mar 18th, 19:39
We have consecutive Nationalist governments to thank for putting us solidly on the same track through our unsustainable debt. This is a sword of Damocles, a question of time before it eventually falls. Someone please explain to me how this debt will ever be paid back. The day will come when extreme measures will need to be resorted to. For now we have hidden everything as well as it could be.
Peter Murray
Mar 18th, 17:56
It is estimated conservatively that up to 50% of deposits in Cyprus banks are held by Russian ciitizens .It is one thing for the EU technocrat bully-boys to mess with little ole Cyprus but they dont want to upset the Russians.Furthermore,the Russians have given a loan of 2.5 Billion euros to Cyprus which they are now re-considering.
keith perry
Mar 18th, 22:59
Peter Murray: A lot of that money is laundered not legitimate, thats what has caused the fuss.
Discover how much money Cyprus has handled - And Putin is not a real fan of these people, probably because he isnt getting his cut.
The 2.5 Bil loaned to the previous commie president mainly disappeared into public sector pension funds! and still left Cyprus broke.
Do they need 57,000 pub sect staff?
Michael Sammut
Mar 18th, 16:28
This exact same situation happened in Ireland. Why weren't the depositors targeted then? Two weights two measures in the Eurozone.
keith perry
Mar 18th, 23:11
Michael Sammut No it's not the same as Ireland - The depositor request was for a levy fee on insured and a higher rate on uninsured depositor leverls all over 100.000 euros A lot of it Russian and a lot of it laundered - there was no mention of sub100,000 accounts. It was the Cypriot president who refused to hit the high depositors more than 10% and burdened everyone else - We are now angry!
John Azzopoardi
Mar 18th, 15:48
This is a real sad story for Europe...........Who is ever going to invest in cyprus again............And Maltese citizens be wary of our government and how they manage our econonmy and finances as this can happen to us also. Many of these countries - Cyprus, Spain, Greece, Italy, France, Portugal, Ireland had robust economies...more so than Malta -- and in 5 years time they went almost bankrupt
Mano' Xerri
Mar 18th, 13:19
I wonder can anyone tell me could this happen in Malta as it seems that this is only the first move before the rest of the euro zone follow suit.?
richard reece
Mar 18th, 14:15
That is a very good question, it wouldn't surprise me the least if the rest of the banks in other countries including Malta might? if necessary follow Cyprus's example, which will create chaos as it is doing now with many Cypriots and expats from the UK. I see that Russian investors are not happy with the banker's decisions.
Peter Murray
Mar 18th, 15:17
Whats to stop it from happening here Mano?As lest we forget we were one of those countries who voted for this tax decision didn't we!
John Azzopoardi
Mar 18th, 16:58
Of course it can happen to Malta.......if money is spent left and right with no checks in place, our economy falters and our country and credit ratings are downgraded, YES IT WILL HAPPEN TO MALTA. Everyone should be on the look-out for signs of any financial problems. It will be in your best interest.
keith perry
Mar 19th, 11:07
I would just like to point out that the Cyprus government applied this to ALL banks in Cyprus and ALL accounts - even from other countries with branches there Russian, British etc..
As someone in Cyprus at present, This hasnt just popped up out of the blue, its been coming for years..
Would you buy and pay for a house and not get the title deeds? with the connivance of lawyers, polticians??
Paul Meilak
Mar 18th, 13:15
Nisperaw illi issa Joseph Muscat irrealizza kemm kien tana pariri hziena meta kien fl-oppozizzjoni.
Peter Murray
Mar 18th, 12:21
Whatever slant they put on this tax is any form is a disgrace and a violation and the last time Cyprus was subject to such a sustained attack was back in1974 when the North was invaded by the Turkish army.However,then it effected Cypriots only and not any non-Cypriots as this tax clearly does.This is a monumentally obtuse decision which will have immensely negative repercussions on the eurozone.
keith perry
Mar 18th, 23:22
Peter Murray this is not a new thing, Mitterrand when he was president of France imposed such a levy on high percentage depositors.
You speak of a sustained attack..The last one was by the previous President Christofias who screwed his own people allowed gross corruption and turned a national surplus into a major disaster for all,
Blew up our power station and denied responsibility!
Please choose the reason of your report below: