Advert

Labour's cost estimates 'an insult to intelligence' - Busuttil

PN deputy leader questions PL figures and reiterates that proposals were 'copied'

Labour's cost estimates 'an insult to intelligence', Busuttil says. Video: Matthew Mirabelli

Labour was "insulting people's intelligence" in claiming that its 800-plus proposals would cost the country €300 million less than the Nationalist Party's more "realistic" list of 125 proposals, PN deputy leader Simon Busuttil said this morning.

Dr Busuttil also reiterated his belief that the PL had "copied" swathes of its manifesto from the PN equivalent, saying that "in some sections, even the wording is the same".

Speaking from within the sheltered environment of a Xemxija greenhouse, Dr Busuttil attacked Labour leader Joseph Muscat for having questioned the PN's cost estimates.

"It's a bit rich of Dr Muscat to question our cost estimates when he hasn't even presented his, apart from a global expenditure figure," he said.

Dr Muscat yesterday said the PN had based its cost estimates on unrealistic GDP growth forecasts.

Dr Busuttil also stuck to his guns when asked about his remark to PL candidate Deborah Schembri that she had "the face of a Nationalist".

"I did not insult Deborah Schembri. If Deborah felt offended I apologise, but I simply noted that once you remove the PL's glossy wrapper you'll find the Labour of old. Karmenu Vella first entered Parliament when I was seven years old," he said.

Dr Busuttil was speaking shortly after having been given a tour of a Xemxija greenhouse by a local farmer. Together with Rural Affairs Minister George Pullicino and the PN candidates on the 12th district met with farmers, discussed their agricultural methods and use of EU funds and had a taste of some freshly-plucked tomatoes.

There are few major policy divergences between the two parties within the agricultural sector, with both parties' manifestos promising more specialised EU funding, an insurance scheme for farmers and a more concerted effort to brand and label Malta-made produce.

Advert

126 Comments

Post comment

Please see our new Comments Policy

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

For more details please see our Comments Policy

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

A. Sultana

Feb 8th, 16:04

Many thought (including me) that Joseph Muscat was going to bring a new style to politics but his comment on Tonio Fenech that 'Dehriltu l-ma..' coupled up with copying the manifest and not replying to questions even though all the transparency he preached about shows that he learnt nothing in Brussels but is part of an oligarchy whose trademark is old style of politics.

Valentina Muscat

Feb 8th, 16:30

@sultana do you know that jm was quoting tonio fenech ?

A. Sultana

Feb 8th, 17:40

@muscat yes I know very well. Do you?

A. Sultana

Feb 8th, 17:44

Tonio Fenech never never said that she appeared to him. He had said that probably she would be weeping in light of what was happening. I do not find it neither funny nor excusable to use the name of our Holy Lady to ridicule Tonio Fenech just because the latter is a devotee.

Mary Borg

Feb 10th, 22:54

@ Sultana: If he were a real devotee, he wouldn't even dare mentioning her name in vain. What do politics have to do with religion?

David C

Feb 8th, 16:27

In my opinion, those costings in the past 5 yrs needed to fail. Otherwise the whole country would have failed. I was one of the graduates in the past 5 yrs and most probably if the govt. didn't inject more money in the economy (and thus failing to meet their surplus target) then I, along with all my other graduate friends wouldn't have found a job immediately! You need to see the circumstances

charles v schembri

Feb 8th, 15:22

Mr Grech your voluminous icomments contain no substance.

How come suddenly whilst LP supporters propagate these continuous gaffes by PN ,it so seems that LP fans write and think as if in panic.

Mr Grech spend some time reading intelligently and conclude that LP, its folks, d manifesto and its surreal clamour for peace, unity and change are just wares in a flee mark

John Cole Smith

Feb 8th, 15:26

You cant blame him, he's his mentor!

John Holmes

Feb 8th, 14:35

Now we all know at whom Simon and Lorry were glazing at, with such fascination, they really look up to him, LOL.

A. Sultana

Feb 8th, 15:33

You forgot to say that PL's manifesto mentions the biggest part of PN's manifesto. Even Muscat confirmed that when asked.

Mario Scicluna

Feb 8th, 13:30

Tista tispjegalna int ghala l-PN mhux ser jhallas ta' l-overtime lil Pulizija wara li dawn hadmu ghalihom u ilhom snin shah jistennewhom? Tista tispjega ghala ma tnizzel xejn fil programm elettorali tal-PN fuq din il-materja?

Joseph Mifsud

Feb 8th, 13:44

Twanny...jekk trid mur aqra il programm kollu u tkun taf

twanny borg

Feb 8th, 13:51

Jekk qatt kien hemm partit li rranga l-kundizzjonijiet tal-pulizija kien il-pn anzi il-pl kull ma ghamel nehhilhom id-dritt li jbieghu kwart tal-penzjoni. Darba il-pl biss qed iwieghed li se jaghti dawn il-flus lill-pulizija ghandu jghid issa u mhux wara ma jaghti xejn. Diga' minflok li qal se jithalsu qal isiru ARRANGAMENTI. Ghandhom ikunu jafu kemm issa. Le?

Mario Scicluna

Feb 8th, 15:43

Kif irranga l-kundizzjonijiet tal-Pulizija skond int? Billi minflok thallsu tal-overtime fi flus inaghataw time-in-lieu? Billi minflok thallsu ta' xogholhom,irrangaw il-bitha tad-Depot bl-irham u bil-madum mdawwra bil-hbula biex tkun hemm ghal parenza biss? Billi gew imweghda suppost union, li fil fatt kienet biss assocjazzjoni, illi l-kap taghha ikun il-Kummissarju nnifsu? Bil paroli u pozi biss.

twanny borg

Feb 8th, 15:28

George, Mhux ahjar isir dibattitu bejn joseph muscat u anglu farrugia?

charles v schembri

Feb 8th, 13:20

Kindly ask that to Perit Karm Vella. He admitted he is no expert on costs of proposals.

I suggest you take a break. You insult labour oriented electorate

L Zammit

Feb 8th, 15:05

Envy for Simon at its best.

Ronnie Callus

Feb 8th, 13:19

Sew qaltlek dik tal-hanut f'Rahal Gdid - KEMM INT ZGHIR.

Manwel Sinagra

Feb 8th, 15:21

"Simon you are not realising that by continuing like this it is not the traditional labourites you are insulting but the people who decide whom to elect in government. People who think with their heads and do not want you to think for them."

Pierre, Don't you think that statement suggests that you think that traditional labourites are not capable of thinking with their heads?

Pierre Fenech

Feb 8th, 22:26

Manuel I am sure that Simon is not targeting the traditional albour voters but he is trying to stop the heamorage of traditionally PN leaning voters who are fed up with this arrogant governement. He was projected as a fresh look but he is simply projecting more of the same. This will not lure the 40% who do not feel affiliated with any party. This is what I meant. The other 60% will not move.

Joseph Attard

Feb 8th, 13:43

Veru taħsbu li Simon jgħaġġibna, għax aktar naraw lilu milli l-PM

Ronnie Callus

Feb 8th, 12:13

Well said Philip.Two proffessors one of whom wanted to sue TVm ! does not even known their regulations.

Luke Bonnici

Feb 8th, 13:05

changes in mentality will not happen overnight (more like over a whole generation) ... and changes in the law costs money. MPs have to debate laws in parliament, lawyers have to make sure that there are no loop-holes, consultations, etc... etc... need I say more?! I'm not commenting on which party's programme is more credible!

Andre Briffa

Feb 8th, 12:19

Wow! You must be an economist.

M Cutajar

Feb 8th, 12:44

Naqbel mieghek Sur Williams. U nghiduha kif inhi mela la skont Dr Busuttil il-proposti huma ikkuppjati ,tal-inqas m'ghandhomx ghalfejn jikkritikawh mela ghax inkella jkunu qed jikkritikaw lilhom innifishom

Kenneth Williams

Feb 8th, 13:34

@Andre Briffa

Ma tantx trid tkun ekonomista biex tghamel din is somma kul ma trid tkun taf tghodd u taf titkellem u tikteb bl isvizzeru.

Suada Bratanovic

Feb 8th, 13:10

Hi Mr.Koludrovic,
great to see you are still with us on this Earth!! Hope you are ok??!! Why dont you know somebody else date of birth??Much more close then Churchill!!!! Be happy and enjoy your internet. May God give you health, clear mind and happynes, maybe, maybe you will remember him one day!!!???

Joseph Mifsud

Feb 8th, 13:02

I hope you are happy with the strategy adopted by the PN....SCAREMONGERING AND DIRTY TRICKS....well done

Joseph Mifsud

Feb 8th, 13:00

How can you still mention the 600m energy plant that PN "estimated"?? Not even the PN kept on mentioning it since they realised that people are not trusting their figures anymore.

Eddy Privitera

Feb 8th, 13:04

Anthony Scicluna. The capital for the new gas power station will be coming from the private company. And the cost is almost HALF what Tonio Fenech invented, and which you repeated parrot-like !

twanny borg

Feb 8th, 13:13

@eddie privitera-iva bil-bakketta magika ta' joseph il-privat johrog il-flus minghajr ma jdahhal aktar lura!!

Johnny Zammit

Feb 8th, 12:54

Prosit Mr Callus ......

May we compare the old faces

Karmenu Vella vs Francis Zammit Dimech = Karmenu Vella !!

Advert
Advert