Advert

Malta relegated to Serie B - PL spokesmen

Standard and Poor’s report yesterday shows that Malta has been relegated to Serie B, Labour MP Karmenu Vella said this morning.

Addressing a news conference he said that the report was a certificate of five years of incompetence, the result of broken promises, uncertainty and indifference to warnings the government received in the past few years from, among others, the Central Bank and other credit rating agencies.

Mr Vella noted that this was Malta’s second downgrade since November.

The country’s debt was reducing its flexibility and it was borrowing for unproductive projects. The government was paying €250 million in interest, which amounted to 8.2 per cent of its revenue. If this went up to 10 per cent, Malta would get have downgrade.

Asked whether Labour had a roadmap the repayment of Enemalta’s debt, Mr  Vella said €316 million were being paid through a special purpose vehicle over a 25-year period and the remaining €519 would be outstanding debt.

Through labour’s energy plan, Enemalta would make a saving of €187 million a year, €77 million of which would be used to reduce tariffs. The rest of the savings would be used to, among others, start eliminating some of Enemalta’s debts.  No target date as to by when these debts would be eliminated was given.

He said that a Labour government would not privatise Airmalta and Enemalta.

Labour MP Charles Mangion mentioned the reference to Malta’s low female participation rate in the S&P report and said that Labour had an aggressive plan to increase this. It would be announcing this plan in the coming weeks.

MEP Edward Scicluna said that Labour’s measures for economic growth would be announced soon. He stated that the party would say how much each measure would cost.

The issue of the Prime Minister’s claim that 20,000 jobs had been created was raised with Prof. Scicluna saying this was a figment of the Prime Minister’s imagination. According to official statistics, he said, the Labour Force had increased by just 4,000.

Prof. Scicluna said that the PL’s report on energy would not be published in full as it had the percentage of profit margin the government was willing to give the private sector going in for the expense.

“We published enough to show the plan is credible,” he said.

Mr Vella noted that most proposals announced so far would lead to savings rather than expenses.

 

Advert

140 Comments

Post comment

Please see our new Comments Policy

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

For more details please see our Comments Policy

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

A Bezzina

Jan 17th, 18:48

Well said!!

Joe M Borg

Jan 17th, 17:34

We blame PL because a few weeks before the budget vote, TWO credit raters gave Malta full marks. It was after PL voted against a budget (which they, after all, intend to fulfil), that they changed their opinion. PL 'missed' the part that said that although all around Malta other countries were crumbling (including Joseph's Cyprus), Malta is still doing very well.

Joe M Borg

Jan 17th, 17:39

Probably Dr Bezzina intends to stand for the election again. It will be entertaining, after the success he achieved last time!

victor bonello

Jan 17th, 17:00

the energy question is just the tip of the ice berg. We need a change in Govt. not just to save 100 or 200 euros, but to rid ourselves of the people responsible of squandering millions - the BWSC power station, the Arriva flop, the Farimount contract, Air Malta etc etc etc..The PL has already taken steps to prevent corruption, something PN never did in 25 yrs, and will never do.

Joe M Borg

Jan 17th, 17:42

Victor. What about the Iceland flop; the Cyprus flop; the VAT flop; the 33 taxes flop; the stipend flop;? Should we change from one flop to a worse flop? If Joseph had been in Gonzi's place, he would hae followed Cypru's success. Thankfully, Gonzi was at the helm, and we were saved from sure disaster. Should we trust Cyprus Joe?

Joe M Borg

Jan 17th, 17:43

LIKE :-) Like the many who fell to PL's VAT gimmick. Being sorry afterwards does not help.

Jason Zammit

Jan 17th, 17:15

good one mate :)

Joe M Borg

Jan 17th, 17:44

This is the best one I've heard today.

M Borg

Jan 17th, 16:16

Well the answers should be enough for us. They want to spare us the trouble of going through the workings, have they got any ?

After all we are not experts. Have they told us who the experts are ?

Well no ....maybe that is also a " sensitive " element !

George Calleja

Jan 17th, 15:31

Malta has had various foreign and local coaches but it remained stuck in the doldrums. Maybe they need someone with many titles after his name to boast its placings.

M Borg

Jan 17th, 16:10

Just ask yourself, whch is the best for you , having a job and things staying as they are now or paying €100 less on your W & E bills and risking your job.

You will quickly get your answer

Frank Gauci

Jan 17th, 15:54

Iktibli l-lottu siehbi !!!!

M Grima

Jan 17th, 12:59

Are you serious.

The PN make merry when an EU report, some head of sate or one of the credit rating companies comes out with something positive, yet blames it on Joseph Muscat when it reflects the haphazard and inefficient way GonziPN has been governing. Am I surprise? No, because I expect that from the masters in hypocrisy

Eve Axiaq

Jan 17th, 13:05

Oppozizzjoni isimha maghha, xogholha huwa li tikkritika. Inkella ma tissejjahx oppozizzjoni.

M Grima

Jan 17th, 13:05

You're just a sad little puppy whose only argument is to repeat the half truths which your PN has been feeding you. The only reason why our economy has not bulldozed is because the private sector, especially the financial one has been prudent in the way it has managed its operations. And, this is no thanks to GonziPN, which has crippled Enemalta and the Maltese economy with its mavericks.

Joseph Camilleri

Jan 17th, 13:40

why do you worry to speak to these doom and gloom party. glitzy posters shiny iphones in squares and yet all this money is coming from a country where they themselves are speaking of a country finanzi fis sod because they are displaying it themselves. lejber is just a bunch of sad moaners who have no idea that Work should be the bait and not 25% special one time offer !

Andre Briffa

Jan 17th, 13:53

haha well said!

Eve Axiaq

Jan 17th, 12:55

Mela anke int tlift il-fiducja f'Gonzi li se johrog tellief?

Jason Zammit

Jan 17th, 12:59

No 1 halili it Team favorit tieghi fil kwiet siehbi u it tieni i do agree with your second comment , ara xfarsa ikun fijom hemm fuq dawk , lizjed jibatu lil Joe Debono Grech hahahahhahahahahah bit termos u il hobs tal malti jithlilom fil parlament hahhahahahhaha

Peter Paul Cassar

Jan 17th, 13:36

le hasbuna preskritti hux!!

Kenneth Williams

Jan 17th, 12:47

Staqsi lill FRANCO DEBONO

J Debrincat

Jan 17th, 13:15

I find this argument very weak. Surely a budget should not have been put up by a government which did not have a clear majority to rule and was intent on stringing it’s term out as long as possible. the issue was not necessarily the budget but the government that tried to implement it. the lines became blurred and it became a vote of confidence for PN, of which it failed. Irresponsible

John L Galea

Jan 17th, 13:55

It was Franco debono who voted against not the PL. Also Gonzi knew this from much before but for their dirty tactics they presented the budget the same sot hat they can blame it on the PL during the election campaign as they have nothing else to offer.

Mr B Vella

Jan 17th, 12:39

You should go and read the report before you start commenting.......!!!

Mark Brincat

Jan 17th, 12:42

Angelo ... S&P's report is based on PAST performance not FUTURE ... so ... yes ... Tonio Fenech is to blame ... for the huge debts (as mentioned in the report)

A. Agius

Jan 17th, 12:46

Mr Vassallo, can you please quote where the S&P report mentions the proposed power station please? It surely mentions the ever growing Enemalta's debts but could not find anything about PL's proposal

Kenneth Williams

Jan 17th, 12:50

Bl istess argument tieghek il power station tal labour l anqas ser nohorgu penny wiehed ghax dik ser ihallasa il privat ...jew ma tifhemx jew ma tridux tifmu biex thawdu l imhuh...mhux taghna ta ...

Eve Axiaq

Jan 17th, 12:51

@Angelo. Ghaliex anke int TLIFT il-fiducja f'Gonzi li mhux se jirbah?!

Denis Pace

Jan 17th, 14:04

Who do we believe?
Germany, the major economic force in Europe OR Karmenu Vella, architect of the shambles of the dark days of the 70's/80's??

C Busuttil

Jan 17th, 12:19

le dawk l-ohrajn li jiehdu 500zieda minghajr hadd ma jkun jaf!!!!!!!!!!!

ghalfejn tparlaw jahasra

A Tonna

Jan 17th, 13:15

Well said Mr Busuttil. Ma nistaghx nifhem kif nies bhal dawn jigu ngannati hekk u jibqghu icapcpulu. Bil-fors li ghandhom xi balla flus xi jroxxu u jigu jaqghu u jqumu minn mhux sinjur daqshom biex dawn l-affarijiet ma jaffettwaghhomx.

Andre Sammut

Jan 17th, 14:33

@ C Busuttil Ahjar jiehdu l 500zieda u Malta tmur tajjeb kif marret (mhux qedt nghid li kollox ward u zar ta!!) imma fejn pajjizi ohra konna tajjeb!!), milli ma jihdux 500 zieda u nidhlu go hajt!!

Alan Xuereb

Jan 17th, 12:15

Prosit, well said!

M Grima

Jan 17th, 12:25

What a short memory you've got, I guess because it suits you. Remember Dr. Gonzi harping that we should follow the Irish model back a few years ago. Remember how fondly he used to grin and tell us that the Maltese should imitate the Irish tiger Thanks to your PN, especially Tonio Fenech, we have now been downgraded yet again in the space of a few months.l.

That's GonziPN for you - Amateurs

C Busuttil

Jan 17th, 12:26

What about Ireland, the example to follow according to the PN ?

It seems that we are following the Irish example after all.

the government has no merit in avoiding the economic meltdown, it was thanks to the conservative business operations of our banks, otherwise the gov would have had to borrow to save the banks. Not to mention that we have ALREADY a VERY BIG BIG deficit

M Grima

Jan 17th, 12:27

Be patient Dr. Cutajar, the beef is still being dished out.

PN - promises, plans haphazardly, fails to deliver

PL - plans professionally, promises, delivers on schedule.

Marco Galea

Jan 17th, 12:33

Please M Grima, enlighten me about what PL has delivered on schedule!!

George Cutajar

Jan 17th, 12:36

No problem in waiting. Only if you cook the beef too much you tend to ruin it.

Jason Zammit

Jan 17th, 12:45

@ M Grima


PL - plans professionally, promises, delivers on schedule.

Tista itina xi ezempju fuq dan listatment sur Grima ????? ghax sa fejn naf jien PL promised NO VAT and he intoduced CET+33 new Taxes......sa fejn naf jien PL wedni stipendji lili lewwel wiehed u meta tela is Sur Bartolo qalilna li dawn huma self .......ghajdilna ftit sur Grima what PL Promised and he delivered ax insejt


M Grima

Jan 17th, 12:49

@ Marco Galea

Definitely not these :-

- Mater Dei
- Cirkewwa Terminal
- Manoel Dimech Bruidge
- Arriva project
- Closure of Marsa Power station
- BWSC extension
- Gozo's slaughter house
- Crafts Village
- White rocks sports complex
- Hundres of roads all over Malta & Gozo
- Reduction of Income Tax
- Legal reform
- Cancer Unit
- Whistleblower act
- Gozo Helicopter service

A Tonna

Jan 17th, 13:20

Mr Grima insejt ic-cirasa fuq il-kejk; l-Smart City fejn sehinba talabna biex immorru naraw il-bini tiela.

Jason Zammit

Jan 17th, 17:21

@ m Grima

i have been 5 hours waiting to let me know what PL promises anf he delivers .....5 hours waiting u baaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Wally Vella-Zarb

Jan 17th, 12:14

I think that it is you who never learns. First learn to read and then maybe you will be able to understand what is written in the S&P report and why we were downgraded.


effie stafrace

Jan 17th, 12:14

shame on you mr zammit.when was malta in seria a?we had 2 recessions in four years and a lot of families are on their knees.with these debt that is being mentioned the future looks bleak and it will take a lot off time our standard of living will be decent again

Jason Zammit

Jan 17th, 12:50

@ effie stafrace

our standard of living will be decent again ?????

are you serious ???? switch on your TV , put it on Euro News and have a look around so you can see all the protests and the disasters many countries are in ..... u ahna paxxuti

have a break my friend

A. Agius

Jan 17th, 12:12

If Gonzi had the people's interest at heart he would have asked Austin Gatt to resign and (irrelevant) FD would have voted with the government for the the budget. But "il-par idejn sodi" were not enough to persuade Gatt to resign, yet expected PL to vote in favor of the budget instead. Gonzi also had the option to call an earlier election, but that would have not been in the interest of the PN!!

A. Agius

Jan 17th, 12:12

so who chose the card which would do more harm to our country?

Eric Bonello

Jan 17th, 12:35

PT1 .In your own pathetic words, you expect the government to give in to FD demands & call an early election because FD said so, than again no matter what was happening internally in the PN, the opposition had a duty to play its role & in that if failed, it chose to topple the government, it chose to vote against the budget & it chose to deprive the Maltese families

effie stafrace

Jan 17th, 12:18

mr galea a company in halfar is using the contract method to employ workers.some workers had their contract terminated and renewed for three times in one year.does this mean that 3 jobs where created?

Marco Galea

Jan 17th, 12:31

no Effie it means that the workers in Hal Far got a job renewed for three times, when in other countries they would be unemployed and there will be no company in Hal Far!

S. Cuschieri

Jan 17th, 11:59

unproductive projects?? excuse me? do you think that improving our infrastructure, building new schools, building up projects to attract tourists, and loads of other stuff can be described as 'unproductive'???

you must be kidding me! & to call it a 'fab quote' is even more detrimental!

Joseph Aquilina

Jan 17th, 12:13

So I guess for lejber better schools and a better health system are an example of unproductive projects! Wow! I am now more scared of what lejber would do if ever trusted to lead us for 5 years!

M Grima

Jan 17th, 12:34

@ C Galea

You forgot to mention Smart City or rather Ghost City which was the PN's war cry during the last election wherein it was promised that it will create 5,600 jobs. You also failed to mention the Crafts village which has featured in the last three electoral manifestos of the PN and also the White Rocks sports village complex.

Should we trust PN to give us more of the same? NO WAY!!!!!

M Grima

Jan 17th, 12:41

Wrong Eric.

Yes, the debt was still there but it was supposed to decrease with government's partial repayments according to the budget speech. This never happened and the debt continued to increase. The result was S & P's downgrading. Mention one instance when the opposition voted in favour of a government's budget. NEVER.

Admit it Eric, you and your party are in Panic mode

Warren Griscti

Jan 17th, 12:04

The bubble that only burst was that of finanzi fis sod mr joseph.malta has been shown that we don't have finanzi fis sod. Gonzipanik

John Borg

Jan 17th, 12:23

Ask the EU Warren re Finanzi fis sod ... better than asking Joseph PL

Warren Griscti

Jan 17th, 12:06

Il faqar tahtkom zdid habib.

John Borg

Jan 17th, 12:06

Mela is super one biss tara sur gauci?, qatt ma dawwartlu naqra fuq il BBC News u smajtom jejdu li Malta hu wiehed mil aktar pajjizi fl EU li ghandu finanzi fis sod? ... Nahseb li huma iktar kredibli ir rapporti li tohrog l EU milli ta Joseph PL (jekk johrog rapporti)! ahna fatti jridu u mhux paroli.

R. Azzopardi

Jan 17th, 12:02

Qed tkun generuz hawn habib. nahseb 3rd division ta l-MAFA is more likely.

Advert
Advert