Advert

Busuttil says Muscat has no credibility to defend energy plan

PN Deputy leader Simon Busuttil this morning reacted to opinion surveys showing Labour still enjoying a big lead over the PN, saying it needed to be explained that voting PN was crucial for the country.

Speaking in Nadur, Dr Busuttil said the PN had given the people a secure past and a secure present, and it had the results to show that it could offer a secure future.

In contrast, the PL was making empty promises aimed at deceiving the public.Its campaign so far had been built on its energy plan, yet within hours the PN showed how it was full of holes, including a funding shortfall of €200m. So would power tariffs really fall, or would they rise? Or would taxes rise instead of the tariffs?

Furthermore, Labour was proposing a power station which the country did not need, And it wanted to build it in two years, something which could not be done if the normal local and EU procedures were observed.

When Dr Muscat was confronted with the holes in his plan, his only reaction was to put his own political credibility on the line, Dr Busuttil observed. But what political credibility did he have when, in the past, he backed proposals to ditch VAT and when he wanted to have a Partnership instead of EU membership? 

Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi said Labour's proposals would drive Malta's economy into a wall 'gas down'.

The proposal, he said, would undermine Malta's financial stability and cause unemployment. Labour, he said, should not be allowed to play about with the people's future.

 

Advert

164 Comments

Post comment

Please see our new Comments Policy

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

For more details please see our Comments Policy

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Alfred Falzon

Jan 13th, 21:44

One death could not have been due to the Power Station emissions since she is a grandmother and her father must, in all probability, have passed away some years before the Delimara Power Station was built!

That does not the least challenge the truth of what she stated and we share her deep bereavement for indeed the sad story she recounted is heart-breaking.

Alfred A Falzon

Robert Gatt

Jan 13th, 22:00

Eddy - it's your comment which is insensitive. Gonzi & Muscat were in Gozo today. Gonzi spoke at length about PN's implemented projects in Gozo, as well as PN's vision for Gozo; Muscat did not utter a single word on PL's proposals for Gozo. Why? Two reasons - 1. He spent his stay in Gozo trying to justify PL's energy plan; 2. PL's past vision for Gozo does not augur very well for Gozo's future!!

Edgar Gambin

Jan 13th, 23:18

The Prime Minister not only sympathizes with people with cancer but also is building a hospital for those suffering with cancer. Didn't One News tell you this? Shame on Joseph who chose to take advantage of such tragedies. Is this not cras insensitivity?

HENRY FENECH AZZOPARDI

Jan 14th, 00:59

Stop playing the game Eddy.

My father, mother and sister died of cancer so what. They were born in Valletta and lived in San Gwann. Eenery should be stopped from being politicized. Who are we to judge and vote in favour or against. Both parties should reach a concensus and deliver together what is good for the country. This is not a game of football. The future of Malta is at stake.

Mario zerafa

Jan 14th, 02:03

Int bis-serjeta?! Whilst sympathising with the poor women and understand the remote link between asthma/cancer and air pollution, I cannot help but question the level of IQ it takes someone to associate such instances to politics.

Edgar Gambin

Jan 13th, 23:21

Do you mean that Anglu, Louis and Toni were torn to pieces by just a poster boy?

John Azzopoardi

Jan 13th, 20:47

so right..........you must have seen my post earlier here............I don't remember Busitill for anything else except the failed burden sharing policy...............Could you imagine if this guy is elected. I just wonder where they found him.

Ann Galea

Jan 13th, 18:50

Yes by telling constituents to go to the grocer and defend the government and tell them to pray for you and your votes

Eddy Privitera

Jan 13th, 21:06

Edgar: The surveys just published this morning in The Sunday Times and Malta Today prove who must be getting mad !

Lawrence Fenech

Jan 13th, 18:48

@Carlo

You are right, Simon came back to Malta half hearted and Tonio Borg went to Brussels half hearted all for the sake of a slnking government.

K Grech

Jan 14th, 01:25

Mhux hekk biss, izda trid tajd ukoll li dan maz zmien li gej ser ikollu jinbidel zgur, barra li ovjament ghadu laqqas biss qieghed jopera sura ta nies. Imma meta tqalleb fuq il yellow pages kultant tiehu page b ohra uxx

Carlo Cassar

Jan 13th, 17:16

Mr Vella, you're echoing what you hear from the PN side. If you heared what the experts said yesterday on Dissett in a balanced discussion lead by a balanced presenter, you can notice that what you are saying is nonsense. Safety is close to 100% on the proposed system and the new ps is by far less harmful than the one in operation with hfo. M'Xlokk and B'Bugia welcomes the removal of the chimney.

Adrian P. Cassar

Jan 13th, 17:24

Hmmmm....2 mosta domes vs cancer. Who knows what I would choose?

M Borg

Jan 13th, 18:58

'@ Adrian Cassar

You aca find cancer in every corner of the world. Do you think they can stop cancer if they were to have " 2 Mosta domes " ?

Pity no on told the whole world this !!

K Grech

Jan 14th, 01:30

As Carlo said this method of energy will be less harmful. None the less this topic about tanks and no storage tanks is funnily enough nonsense, because either if we go for a pipeline in the future, which labour also addresses it as a complimentary energy proposal for energy mixing, and if we go for the current labour proposal we will still need storage space.

K Grech

Jan 14th, 01:35

And also when it comes to talking about waste and no waste of money, don't we truly identify the bridge to nowhere and the new parliament (plus 500 raise which will be taken again if re-elected GonziPanic) as being waste of tax-payers money? The government was to realize prior doing the BWSC fiasco that this HFO will deliver nothing but severe health problems of the areas in the surroundings.

Mr Joe Micallef

Jan 13th, 16:58

Azzopardi which part did you not understand of PN energy policy? in a few words
Part 1 BSWC plant - current cost per unit 15c
Part 2 Interconnector and closure of Marsa - cost per unit 11c
Part 3 Gas Pipeline - cost per unit 8c7
Part 4 Closing Delimar 1

PN agrees with Kema report becasue it is one of the reasons for the above. PL despite Kema are happy with 9c7

All price are current

X Borg

Jan 13th, 19:06

@Mr Joe Micallef

Everyone is quoting prices and what about timeframes.

1. So electricity is going to cost us (someday) less than half the present day consumer price (oil now about $100).
2. Prices quoted are probably cost. What interests us is how much we will be asked to pay !
3. Who can guarantee these prices ? or are they also only pinned on the Mad Hatters hat.

Mr Joe Micallef

Jan 13th, 20:44

X Borg that is the crux of the issue!

No one, with a shred of responsibility can guarantee prices. What can be guaranteed is that with a gas pipeline unit costs will always be less than with shipped gas.

K Grech

Jan 14th, 01:51

@ Mr Joe Micallef,
Its for that that PL is saying that in the future a pipeline will be complimentary for our energy creation, PL hasn't swept the idea out, but what is the use of having only a pipeline which might sometime (hopefully never) get damaged? will we end up with no electricity? Thus I think that in the future being PL or PN we will have both methods running together.

Mr Joe Micallef

Jan 14th, 11:02

Grech you just can't be serious. So let me get this - For PL to commit itself to buy energy from a private company for 25 years (10 of which for a fixed price) the interconnector will only used 20% capacity (financial madness 1). To add to the madness you are saying that PL will also install the gas pipeline.

This really is Carroll stuff!

adrian sammut

Jan 13th, 18:33

It seem that Ms Angela Merkel who is practically keeping the European economy alive has a much different and credible opinion than yours. I dont think she was coaxed by Gonzi into complimenting Malta on its economic stability!

Maryanne Camilleri

Jan 13th, 19:12

Mr.Sammut, Mrs. Merkel has a habit of providing political support on a partisian basis to Heads of Government who belong to the European People's Party. She tried the same tactic with Monsieur Sarkozy but to no avail. The certificate of government competence is not given by foreign Governments but by the people who will pass judgement on the performance of its Government.

matthew tanti

Jan 13th, 21:03

since you seem to think you know so much, perhaps you can help us understand why most of the world , including the EU, chooses gas pipelines, rather than shipping gas around?

J Martinelli

Jan 13th, 15:47

Electric trams? Where? Taking over swathes on roads already clogged with cars & trucks?
Build special ring roads around the coast, costing billions? Who will pay?
More Industry? What does Labour know about industry & jobs?
Joseph went outside the EU for his fantasy PS, certainly he wouldn't approach the EU for such a project, or will he? Are we in or are we out, Joseph?
Another half-baked idea.

Mr Joe Micallef

Jan 13th, 15:57

Ha Ha Ha! This is another chapter (although I really cannot pin it down) from Carroll's masterpiece!

Joe M Borg

Jan 13th, 16:35

The trouble is that PL is ALSO expanding 2 atom bombs just opposite M'Xlokk. If an accident happens, 'l-Gherix' will take off! I believe PL media made fun of Austins proposals for electric trams, did they? Hmmmm!
Cyprus Joseph said that we can keep the pipeline, AND have the ships coming in! Very economical! And what about the 600,000, MINUS EU FUNDING?

Adrian P. Cassar

Jan 13th, 17:27

Joe M, you seem to be an expert on gas tank safety and Mediterranean economies. X'kien ma hrigtx ghal-parlament?

Mr Joe Micallef

Jan 13th, 19:10

Cassar with those salaries I'd rather do something else! Mind you I'm no expert in tank safety and Med affairs.

Experts wouldn't even be bothered with this sham!

R Axisa

Jan 13th, 19:18

@Joe M Borg - if you just heard the expert talk about gas safety on dissett yesterday! You're just talking nonsense when you're mentioned atom bombs. Inform yourself before you write about it - u tkunx beccun tibla' kollox.

Mr Stephen Borg

Jan 13th, 15:30

You are quite easily impressed I gather.

Joe M Borg

Jan 13th, 16:38

Sour grapes, Chris. Simon is so good, that PL went into a frenzy, and brought their own man from Brussels. Unfortunately for Anglu, he had to surrender his chair, 'a la Cyprus Joe'! PL are throwing all insults at Simon, which indicates that they were not that happy with his election.

Willie Grech

Jan 13th, 16:50

@ Joe M Borg

"PL are throwing all insults at Simon." Can you please mention some of these so called insults that you claim the PL is throwing at Dr. Busuttil?

Christopher Sammut

Jan 13th, 18:10

Mr Joe M Borg I am not insulting Dr Simon Busuttil and never heard Dr Joseph Muscat or any of his team insulting Dr Simon Busuttil, if I am right at the PN head quarters there were insults against him, he confirmed so as well and I was annoyed with this attitude against him as he dont deserve such treatment, that is why I came to this conclusion my friend, you must inform yourself better. g night

Joe M Borg

Jan 13th, 16:41

Hekku, Matthew. Basta tghaddi ta' Cyprus Joe. Gas gej kontinwament, U JUZA L-VAPURI, basta tghaddi tieghu. Bhal Dr Gimmicks. Inehhi l-VAT, ifarrak l-ekonomija, idahhal CET, basta tghaddi tieghu. Malta ndunat li ghamlet zball afdatu meta kien tard wisq. U hekk hemm cans li jigri iss. Il-proposta ta' rohs fit-tariffi tghama n'nies, jitla PL, jonfoq 600,000,000, ifalli, u mbghatu ahna. Boq!

R Axisa

Jan 13th, 19:23

Infakrek li l-power station li nbniet tahdem bil-heavy fuel oil, zejt li jnigges l-arja. Infakrek ukoll li ghal ragunijiet partikolari, il-gvern kien naqqas l-ammont tal-emissions skont ir-regolamenti biex tkun tista' tinghazel din il-power station prototype. Jien ma nafx minn fejn int, imma l-incidenzi tal-asthma n-naha tas-south hija wahda fenominali, u l-kazijiet huma pjuttost serji.

Alfred Falzon

Jan 13th, 21:25

Both main Parties enjoy walks in mazes and their supporters delight in following their footsteps!

That's why we have a highly enjoyable Promised Land electoral campaign that lasts so long!

Alfred A Falzon

Edgar Gambin

Jan 13th, 18:24

With your very sound reasoning do we need another power station when we just had a new one. Hawwadni ha nifhmek.

W. Cassar

Jan 13th, 21:46

If we don't get the interconnector up and running then the answer is..... Yes without a doubt!

Edgar Gambin

Jan 13th, 18:26

Spot on. A very valid question.

R Axisa

Jan 13th, 19:25

Regarding full membership with you - there are a lot of PN supporters who are coming to a conclusion that the EU is not the EU as explained by the PN before the referendum.

Mr Joe Micallef

Jan 13th, 20:50

R Axisa - whilst I don't agree you may be right, but I can assure you that there are as much, if not even more, PL guys that think the opposite - hence the EU barometer survey which showed that over 75% are happy with membership.


Adrian P. Cassar

Jan 13th, 17:34

George, how do you measure your economic well-being? By the money you have saved or with the money you are in debt?
Do you think 5 billion in debt is good? Inlahquk ministru tal-finanzi

Adrian P. Cassar

Jan 13th, 17:35

It is called ACCOUNTABILITY Francis.

Mr Joe Micallef

Jan 13th, 17:08

Hi Wisdom, Gonzi PN ruined the country so much that others are referring to us as a model to follow. Take up fishing you need it.

Adrian P. Cassar

Jan 13th, 17:38

Min qallek Joe, in-NET?
Merkel coming to Malta for advice?

Mr Joe Micallef

Jan 13th, 19:07

Cassar you're right Merkel is coming for advice!

But not from Gonzi, but Cyprus Joe - she wants to learn about the utility miracle of getting the private sector to fund a country's energy requirements.

Oh maybe I shouldn't say Cyprus Joe, that may put her off!

Edgar Gambin

Jan 13th, 18:34

Ask Anglu, Louis and Toni about Simon. Simon 3 - 0.

Edgar Gambin

Jan 13th, 18:39

Everyone can cook. But what's important are the ingredients in the pan. Joseph doesn't want to speak about those. He just want us to swallow the balbuljata. Now way.

George Cassar

Jan 13th, 12:50

He cannot. His party is still weighed down by some really old anchors. And remember, he was shot to fame with our money sponsoring the MIC!

Anthony Falzon

Jan 13th, 15:05

Whay revolution are you talking about....the one by Anglu when the M.L.P. leader was discribed as "not credible" by his own deputy?

Adrian P. Cassar

Jan 13th, 17:39

Mindu meta PN supporters think Anglu is a hero?

Francis Saliba M.D.

Jan 13th, 13:13

@KennethWilliams
Il-weghda ta' tnaqqis fl-income tax kienet valida meta saret imma dizastru ekonomiku dinji ma ppermettiex li jitwettaq. L-importanti hu li Malta me rvinatx ruhha ekonomikament bhal ma gara lil hafna pajjizi vicini. Il-Kancelliera tal-Germanju Merkel ma tahsibiex bhalek li ilna gas down ghall go hajt u skuzani jekk nemmen lilha u mhux lilek.

Francis Saliba M.D.

Jan 13th, 13:14

Please re-phrase in comprehensible English or translate into some other language.

Emanuel. Vella.

Jan 13th, 16:20

tajba din prosit sur Joseph Brincat,jghogbitni hafna hafna.

Salvu Sciberras

Jan 13th, 14:44

If Malta weathered the recession better than most countries, where is the fiasco? A record number of tourists, a record number of people in full-time jobs, 22,000 new jobs, 5,000 jobs saved during the recession, 20,000 University students and thousands who graduated from MCAST. No wonder Merkel has praised Malta's economic miracle! Remember how Labour handled a much milder recession in the 198o's!

Adrian P. Cassar

Jan 13th, 17:47

Salvu, thank God not everyone watches NET news and believes everything Gonzi says. Not everyone is gullible to creative mathematics like you.
More over, many people know that Merkel's party is an EPP member like PN.....we wouldn't expect her to endorse labour would we?

jm busuttil

Jan 13th, 13:18

@ George Cassar

PN proposals will follow soon.

What we know is that PL's does not work and already thrown out of the window.

Save from telling us the people who agree with the PL enough was said by one Association which due to what was said by two of its members ( you know who) created chaos within the Association.

Advert
Advert