Pro-EU voters: time to use one’s head
Austin Bencini
The determining pro-EU vote has to use its head, now more than ever, since Labour has become more difficult to read than it was in 2003 and in 2008.
Everything hinges on whether Joseph Muscat is a Eurosceptic or a convinced pro-EU integration exponent. It is unfortunate that he blinked and proved hesitant on Angela Merkel’s full endorsement of Malta’s economic success.
Let’s use our heads: Labour alleged partisan bias by Merkel because her party and the PN are both in the Popular Party. If so, then the EU is in trouble since Germany’s drive for financial rigour cannot apply to 20 out of the 27 EU members. Only seven have centre-left governments! Muscat, as a former MEP, should distance himself from the allegation against Merkel.
Muscat needs to unequivocally prove that he is in favour of greater EU integration necessary to prevent the recurrence of the great nightmares brought about by the difficulties experienced by Ireland, Spain, Greece and, to a lesser extent, France and Italy and which economically risk dangerously to be adrift of both the euro and effective participation in the Single Market.
The contrast with Malta’s successful economy couldn’t be more striking when compared to the draconian austerity measures spurred by the German Government and imposed by EU institutions on the economically drifting countries mainly of southern Europe.
Ten years from Malta’s accession to the EU, the electorate could have thought that the question of membership might not be at issue. Yet, in fact, would this be so?
Tactically, Muscat is determined to avoid the EU membership question from rearing its head at this election and what he wants Labour acquiesces to in a manner not seen since the heydays of Mintoffianism. The quick, clinical and decisive manner in which Muscat removed the ‘relevant’ presence of Anġlu Farrugia would be proof enough of that.
EU scepticism, although still rampant within Labour’s rank and file and in its media, will undoubtedly be kept in check during the campaign.
In fact, Alfred Sant, Labour’s most vociferous anti-EU campaigner, will not contest the elections and is, ironies of ironies, earmarked to contest the next MEP elections. It was Sant who recently equated the EU to the Soviet Union and its satellite countries.
The facts corroborate Merkel’s endorsement, which is reflected by authoritative local appreciation of the Government’s success in keeping us economically firmly in the EU, particularly from the commercial community.
“The country’s adoption of the euro, together with the implementation of important regulation,” stated economist Gordon Cordina in The Commercial Courier, “led to an outstandingly strong and resilient financial sector allowing the economy to retain employment levels, even during the worst of the crisis, thus avoiding the negative impact of weak labour markets”.
New Labour deputy leader, Louis Grech, confirmed his misgivings of whether the EU was good for Malta’s financial services. It is hoped that now he knows.
Tancred Tabone, president of the Chamber of Commerce, Enterprise and Industry, pointed out that our booming tourism “played a major role in sustaining economic activity and accounts directly to 10 per cent of our gross domestic product”, not to mention 29 per cent of GDP if indirect impacts are considered.
Malta, therefore, is not considered an economy at risk. The GDP for 2012 is expected to grow by one per cent.
One still hears rumblings among Labour senior ministers of “renegotiating” membership conditions without any information released by Labour on what this entails.
Pro-EU Yes voters, be prepared to use your heads now more than ever since any mistake on our part now may mean the economic unravelling of so much that was achieved over the past decade of EU membership.
16 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Mark Borg
Jan 12th, 18:40
All the this baloney coming from the country top (!) constitutional experts. Pathetic indeed! How did the fable of "Cry Wolf" go Dottore Austin Bencini? You, if anyone, should know.
Francis Saliba M.D.
Jan 12th, 17:34
All these complaints of alleged "scaremongering" by the NP suggest strongly that these people are really getting scared that voters would be opening their eyes to the unpleasant truth submerged under deceptive propaganda gimmicks..
Joseph Agius
Jan 12th, 18:12
Yes, Francis. "Gimmicks", glad you have found that words for us.
James McIntosh
Jan 12th, 18:19
PN are the masters at scaremongering propaganda
GL Calleja
Jan 12th, 19:10
Dr Saliba may I remind you that the political gimmicks go both ways. That is why they call them political gimmicks.
C Busuttil
Jan 12th, 16:50
Hallina Austin tridx
How can I trust the PN again after they gave themselves a 500 euro increase behind our backs.
I voted for the EU although I must say that I am not entirely satisfied at the manner they left us alone regarding illegal immigration. This time NO VOTE .. EU or not
John Azzopoardi
Jan 12th, 16:27
The EU is no longer an issue.........Write about something else.
Albert Farrugia
Jan 12th, 15:49
Absolute drivel. So much that even the PN itself is avoiding playing the EU card this time. For in this moment, the Maltese government itself has become EU-sceptic, conpared to other governments like France and germany. Malta is against the financial tax, for example. More EU integration at this stage can mean only more political union. Something which the Maltese PN government is dead set against
John B. Borg
Jan 12th, 13:01
I am not surprised that Dr Bencini jumped on the PN's scaaremongering bandwagon. What surprises me is his lack of sound arguments to back his weak attempt. Is there anything wrong about commenting on Angela Mekel's dive in support of Dr Gonzi's election campaign? Is criticising Merkel a sign of Euro-scepticism? Joseph Muscat is on record that he wants Malta to get the best of our EU membership.
Francis Saliba M.D.
Jan 12th, 17:24
@JohnBBorg.
There is nothing wrong with asking questions. What is wrong is to expect an answer to silly questions. It is illogical to "want to get the best of our EU membership" and at the same time embark on a policy regarding electricity generation that goes diametrically opposed to EU criteria and invites the imposition of penalties and the loss of EU financial assistance. "Tbazwir" won't do,
Joseph Camilleri
Jan 12th, 12:49
The pro EU voters, you may recall, elected 4 MEPs on the LP ticket and half as many on the NP one.
Guess Labour's position today is rather clearer than what it could have been at the time of the MEP elections.
Eddy Privitera
Jan 12th, 12:43
Austin Bencini: I guess you are more worried about the scandals which have happened under GonziPn , are unravelled !
James McIntosh
Jan 12th, 12:28
Achievements since joining EU . Vastly inflated fuel and water costs, absolute chaos in the imported car business, food costs rising daily, post graduates unable to find suitable jobs to name but a few. Wow, we should all applaud the PN for saving us. We must not also forget the 5 BILLION euros of debt built up. See how good this Executive has made Malta. Time to use ones head and dump these fools
C Cassar
Jan 12th, 15:22
oh dear, the voice of the uninformed.
Joseph Agius
Jan 12th, 11:59
The war cry is: Bring on all scaremongers. Good try, Dr Bencini; but better luck with you next salvo.
James Grech
Jan 12th, 09:22
Round and round, twist and re-twist the lawyer goes.
Please choose the reason of your report below: