Wretched observers of budgets
This is going to be some week in Malta’s political and economic history, taking place in the context of a report on living conditions which demands much more seriousness from those two sectors and the paladins who lead them. The report, based on a survey carried out during 2011, shows that unacceptable thousands of Maltese households are living at the edge of relative poverty. Within them thousands cannot afford a square meal two days running.
Still more thousands, 17, were unable to heat their houses properly last year. They must be thanking the Maker wintry conditions are late in coming this year. When they arrive they will be the unfortunates who cannot come in from the cold, not even to spy on those of us who are living comfortably off.
We are talking of over 15 per cent of the population, some 65,000 overall. They are, in the main, the responsibility of a political class that has not done enough for them, that has left them in the lurch even as it rants on about the progress run up in our society.
Listen to the Finance Minister say just that when he delivers the Budget Speech on Wednesday. His main theme will be that, although our neighbours and markets are having another tough year, we are managing to perform near miracles. We are still edging up economic growth. The standard of living is still rising. Unemployment is relatively low, if you do not consider 6,800 quasi-unemployables an insignificant total.
He will not say anything about income and wealth distribution, about inequality. Strangely, our statistics, other than the survey on living standards, do not say anything about income and wealth distribution to allow us to make our analysis. On Wednesday the Finance Minister will not paint a rainbow. But he will be upbeat, presenting quite a rosy picture.
And there are, of course, people who are living well. Who earn far above the median income. Who might be said to be living on the edge of prosperity. They are the apple of the eyes of the political class. They will be singled out for delivery of a promise to make amends for not carrying out another promise, to lower the income tax burden for some.
Before the 2008 election the Nationalists solemnly undertook to slash the band of those who pay the top rate of 35 per cent income tax. They did not deliver because, the Finance Minister and the Prime Minister claim, economic conditions were not right. Now, prophets that they are, they anticipate the time will be right in about two years. Reality is that this will be another piece of electioneering with the general election round the corner, no matter how much the Prime Minister prevaricates in calling it.
It will be interesting how much more electioneering will be contained in the Budget Speech, a last sweep to make up for what has not been done while praising what has been accomplished.
There will also be a purely political aspect to it. The Finance Minister, without saying it, will be demonstrating what a seasoned stalwart performer he is. With 10 years of budget building and administering, he will be mouthing, he runs his deputy leadership contestant into the ground.
Minister Tonio Fenech will of course be right. He is a thoroughly experienced minister, a thoroughbred, in glaring contrast to the total administrative void of MEP Simon Busuttil, the other contestant. Even without the slimy loud whispers going on, Fenech should still win by a length or two, though you never know.
The significance of that will be lost on those living at the edge of poverty. The only race they are interested in is one that takes them away from the poverty margin towards where they can live a decent life with access to the basics of modern living. That is what history will be judging, though unfortunately too late to do anything for those who for the time being remain the wretched of this little corner of Earth.
12 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Henry S Pace
Nov 27th 2012, 09:58
FLASHBACK to his old days as Minister of Finance.
What we are sure about that animal food would not be reduced to keep the people happy.
Those were the days of the 'Deserta period' The people are looking for something better.
Mhux hekk Sur LIN?
Giov DeMartino
Nov 26th 2012, 20:27
Strange conclusions: In Malta we have 2 vehicles for every 3 persons; thousands are in the habit of taking a holiday abroad at least once a year; many persons can afford to have a wife and a partner; all places of entertainment are normally fully booked; the great majority live in luxurious apartments; millions of euro are contributed towards all sorts of worthy/unworthy causes; time up.
Eddy Privitera
Nov 26th 2012, 18:15
An excellent article. Just watchTonio Fenech on wednesday precisely doing what Lino Spiteri has written here !
George Cremona
Nov 26th 2012, 23:42
Spiteri's current predictions are as trustworthy as the ones he used to make when being a Finance Minister even though he served for very short periods in that position. As trustworthy as your own past electoral victories' predictions Mr. Privitera .
George Cremona
Nov 26th 2012, 17:18
As usual armchair critic as rightly labeled by Dr. Alfred Sant. Has Lino Spiteri forgot his solemn but fake prediction of 'IS-SENA TAL-IMPJIEGI' when he was Finance Minister and which eventually proved to be one of the worst year in employment in the Maltese political history since Independence?
Carmel Camilleri
Nov 26th 2012, 16:03
To them all. Go and tell it to the marines.
Mr Andrew Camilleri
Nov 26th 2012, 12:13
Gonzi in 2008 promised income tax cuts - but delayed them immeditely after the election as he claimed the economic climate had changed within a few months of his promise. He did not foresee this of course. Now he wants tax cuts spread over two years. Have his powers of foresight improved so much? Or is this another exercise in vote buying?
Godfrey Camilleri
Nov 26th 2012, 12:04
Why all this fuss to reduce the 35% tax band? What percentage of the population will this effect. 25% are pensioners and so the majority will be not be touched by this band. 15% are in the poverty bracket. At least another 25% will also be out of it. Are the unions clamoring for the remaining 35%? Yet such a percentage makes a strong voter base so it will be worth appeasing.
Emanuel Muscat
Nov 26th 2012, 11:37
I think they should cut all their "vices' first: smoking,obesity,mobile-hogging,betting,etc..
The church is giving out EU food anyway.
Mr Andrew Camilleri
Nov 26th 2012, 14:18
Exactly - let them exist (not live) on EU handouts. That is exactly what we want for our people. Incredible!
Joseph Agius
Nov 26th 2012, 11:17
I believe that in these last days before the budget one or two of our political priests, who NEVER speak about the suffering poor, will be remembering them in their written and spoken homilies ...to tell us that Jesus told us that the poor "will always be with us".
Evarist Saliba
Nov 26th 2012, 10:11
I agree that Tonio Fenech is not likely to refer to a rainbow in his budget speech. That label was used by a Socialist finance minister when he presented his budget, and re-using it would expose Tonio to the accusation of being a plagiarist.
Please choose the reason of your report below: