The easiest answer is No
Scene – option 1
Michael (10 years old) – Mum, can I sleep over at Jessie’s tonight?
Mum - No
Michael bickers and frets, throws a tantrum, eventually gets tired and sleeps
End of story
Scene – option 2
Michael – Mum can I sleep over at Jessie’s tonight ?
Mum – Will there be an adult with you?
Michael – Yes of course mum
Mum – ok then
Michael – will you drive me there?
Mum – ok
Michael – yeah
Mum - promise me you’ll behave and give Jessie’s mum no trouble
Michael – Don’t worry mum Jessie’s parents will be out, his brother Mark will be with us
Mum - Jessie’s brother is only 12 years old
Michael - Oh! Come on mum, Jessie’s parents will be coming back at midnight, we promise to behave
Mum -No dear, midnight is too late and Mark is too young to take care of you
Michael - Then why don’t you stay with us till midnight?
Mum – Ok then
Packing of bags, pillows, sleeping gear, breakfast gear and soft animals ensues
Car travel follows
Mum sits on the sofa whilst Michael, Jessie and his brother play guitar hero at full blast
Mum’s ears start to bleed
The kids finally go to bed and mum sleeps on the sofa until Jessie’s parents arrive
Mum wakes up with a stiff neck
Half asleep mum drives home at midnight
In bed, mum worries about her child in ‘that’ house
In the morning, mum fights with husband about who will bring their son back home
Issue is brought up for the rest of mum’s life...and the story never quite ends
The point I’m trying to make is that whenever we’re faced with a difficult or complex situation, whenever we’re asked for anything or put on the spot for a favour, the easiest answer is to say No.
It’s simple, it’s direct, and you get to move on unencumbered, and with less weight on your shoulders.
This stands especially true when it comes to proposed legislation that is not only complex, liberal, and most likely to be unpopular but also controversial.
When something like this is proposed around election time – a time when you need all your forces (and every miracle) to help in bringing back votes, ‘No’ is definitely the answer of choice.
I’m referring of course to the Governments direct and unambiguous rejection of the Opposition’s proposal to allow surrogacy under special circumstances. With the Government’s history of being more conservative than a Victorian parlour, I didn’t expect any better. Had it happened at a different time during the administration I would however have expected them to at least pretend to listen, argue and consider, but at this time of year, and with what’s lurking for them around the corner, I’m not surprised one bit that they just blurted out a clear-cut, unequivocal NO.
As Joshua Harris once wrote – “The right thing at the wrong time is the wrong thing.”
6 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Eric Soames
Nov 24th 2012, 15:40
Wondered if Jessie was a girl. It might have made the conundrum more interesting. It's OK for a twelve year old to be left alone, but I'm not sure about babysitting without an adult close by and to be slumped on the couch when the other parents come home might be seen as judgmental. As for the subject of this blog; stand by for the howls from those not possessing a womb or the desire for/kids.
Peter Mercieca
Nov 28th 2012, 17:58
I don't possess a womb but I have kids, and Alison is right! In most situations "no" is often the right answer for rearing kids. My parents gave me and my sisters limited allowances and we are all thankfully very well balanced individuals (or at least we like to think so ha ha). 2day I see too much leniency, open discussions and tolerance for what the kid wants above what is basicly right or wrong
Andy Farrugia
Nov 24th 2012, 12:59
And I thought Atwood was simply indulging in fiction when she wrote "The Handmaid's Tale" about SURROGATE mothers, handmaids, wombs on two legs and wombs for rent! Go figure!
Tanja Cilia
Nov 24th 2012, 10:07
In a nutshell - let your yeah be yeah and your no be no. See either: Matthew 5:37 or http://www.metrolyrics.com/let-your-yeah-be-yeah-lyrics-jimmy-cliff.html .
Ethelbert Schembri
Nov 24th 2012, 10:03
It's very simple, at this point in time the PN have no time for damage control for their immaculate conservative holier than thou image, so they say NO!!
Jonathan Camilleri
Nov 25th 2012, 17:48
I wouldn't say creating legislation is as fast as you would like us to believe Ethelbert; law drafting is quite a bureaucratic process and in all fairness, it should be so given that it affects the ethics of the whole nation.
Please choose the reason of your report below: