Advert

EU summit: Fresh financial proposal for Malta 'still unacceptable'

A revised financial package for Malta has been proposed in EU Budget talks at the European Council in Brussels, but Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi told timesofmalta.com last night it was still unacceptable.

The European Commission had originally proposed to slash Malta's financial allocation by some €300 million in view of the economic progress the country had made and pressures to reduce the EU Budget. 

The summit was suspended at half past midnight and will resume at noon today, allowing time for a raft of new proposals to be studied and discussed informally before formal negotiations continue.

Dr Gonzi said the latest figure being proposed for Malta by Council president Herman Van Rompuy meant a slight improvement over previous figures but was still "absolutely unacceptable" for the island, meaning more negotiations are required.

He also said that Malta's slight gains were not yet secured and risked being lost by the morning if other countries continued to insist on cuts in the EU's overall budget.

Dr Gonzi refused to cite the latest figure on the table but said it was better than the other proposals.

Malta obtained €855 million in EU funds for the past seven years but was initially offered €534 million for the next seven years. That figure further deteriorated to €480 million before the summit began.

Several countries, particularly the UK, are insisting on budget cuts to reflect austerity measures being taken back home.

Dr Gonzi said the negotiation process was complicated and an agreement was still far from being reached, with various EU leaders sticking strictly to their positions.

This was the same analysis expressed earlier by European Parliament president Martin Schulz in a press conference.

However, Dr Gonzi recalled a similar situation in 2005 when he took part in the previous budget discussions.

"It is still too early to give up or to be optimistic," he said, adding that although countries were divided, compromises were often found in the EU.

Advert

90 Comments

Post comment

Please see our new Comments Policy

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

For more details please see our Comments Policy

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Ross Stephen Micallef

Nov 23rd 2012, 16:59

why should the UK accommodate then, they have enough problems themselves, how about our Maltese Government sort out their own problems instead of passing the buck to every one else. we wanted be be Independent and to be part of Europe so we should be big enough to stand up for ourselves and sort out our own problems

Amante Reale

Nov 23rd 2012, 12:27

In case you didn't notice, Malta *is* a poor country.

Mr mike Knight

Nov 23rd 2012, 13:23

With respect to u my Maltese friend, Malta should not look a gift horse in the mouth, and should be thankful for small mercies, remember malta gives less to what it receives, and the poor countries as you call have the right same rights as Malta, and i believe the UK should really cut the subsidies that Malta receives by less then a half. End of story, and thats how it looks from where i'm sitting

Joseph Fenech

Nov 23rd 2012, 12:07

Nispera li jekk ma jigiex elett, ma jmurx jghid li xorta tela" kif ghamel hu u il - Partit Socjalista ( jew LIBERALI ISSA ? ) WARA LI QAL LI REBAH IR - REFERENDUM TA ' L - EU.

IFTAH MOHHOK, HABIB

Anthony Scicluna

Nov 23rd 2012, 11:46

Too true

Ronnie Callus

Nov 23rd 2012, 13:08

Fullyagree with youJoseph.Our government is boasting all the time how well we are and not like them ( although at the same time theNational debt and defecit are always on the increase) and now he is asking for the same amount of moneyas previously had.Most probably than not he brought the stone over his feet and they are going to put him / us in an awkward situation.They always boasted moneynoprob

HENRY FENECH AZZOPARDI

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:16

You must be kidding. How Can Joseph negotiate when PL said the EU would give us 1.5 million? Kemm tinsew fejn tridu.

George Cutajar

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:25

Le ghandu jmur Alfred Sant!!!!!!

Adrian Gouder

Nov 23rd 2012, 11:01

Don't forget that Alfred Sant said the EU would only give us €1 million, i.e., he had already surrendered to that amount, and he was being helped by Josef Muscat.

R Attard

Nov 23rd 2012, 11:02

U tahseb li ha jbaxxu rashom kollha ghax ikun hemm Joseph?

N Azzopardi

Nov 23rd 2012, 11:15

Dejjem ahjar mill-1.5million li kien qalilna li sa jghatuna Alfred Sant

Pierre Azzopardi

Nov 23rd 2012, 14:13

Ha ha Joke of the day my friend. B' 1.5 million kieku bqajna skond l-ewro xettiku u Kandidat gdid ghall-ewropa Alfred Sant. Filkas keep the change ta.

M Sciberras

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:27

Other countries support the UK's position on wanting a smaller increase than the Commission proposes but then differ from the UK on the rebate and size of the increase of the budget. Only Sweden and Holland signalled they would support the extreme UK position of a total freeze, but they will compromise. Cameron, hamstrung by Tory eurosceptics, won't - to the detriment of UK interests. And ours.

John Grima

Nov 23rd 2012, 11:23

you have hit the nail on the head. People forget that most of the EU funds come from Germany, Uk, Italy, France, Netherlands and Denmark. All these countries have their own problems to contend with especially Italy, so it is a bit of a cheek for other member states to expect to be given more funds. Those states should start to live within their means.

Robert Mawby

Nov 23rd 2012, 11:24

Well said Celine, here in the UK everyone is cutting down on spending, from individuals to Councils and even the Government. My local Council has switched off every 2nd street light in Northamptonshire to save money so its time for the EU to cut back, not increase its budget! The UK sends £53million per DAY to Europe and I for one wants to know what they do with it?

Celine Grech

Nov 23rd 2012, 12:40

@Robert Mawby - I know the feeling, we live in Northants too ;)

Ross Stephen Micallef

Nov 23rd 2012, 16:54

total agree, currently living in Wales my local council and Welsh Government have had to make cuts that effect us, so why should other counties get more of our money when its need to invest at home. Many counties openly hate the UK and condemn us but yet are more than happy to ask us for more and more money

HENRY FENECH AZZOPARDI

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:22

As usual you have all wrong Eddy. Malta has been pocketing twice as much as it contributed according to Prof Edw. Scicluna this morning. You have been repeating that Malta has been paying more than it received. Now you have the cheek to state that IN FUTURE Malta would be receiving less and pay more. Where is the truth?
That is proof that Malta is progressing under the PN.

George Cutajar

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:24

Good for you. Now wait for your PL to get into Government and try to take us out of the EU. With people like you all is possible. Why not ask KMB to do like Alfred Sant and contest the next MEP elections? That would certainly double the u-turn.

M Cachia

Nov 23rd 2012, 11:35

Where does this say this in the article above. Even if slashed by 300 million Malta still remains a net receiver. And if in the future Malta becomes a net contributor, this would mean that it would have advanced so much thanks to being included in the EU. Also one needs to factor in the increased trade EU membership has made possible, everything is not so black and white as you argue!

Jesmond Chetcuti

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:10

exactly....many in here talk about the 855 mil over 7 years , but no one mentions what is our contibution, so that we can work out exactly how much we are getting from the EU...

HENRY FENECH AZZOPARDI

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:29

Yesterday I had the previledge to view your comments on TVHEMM. All you had to say was the shortage of some medicine, which is far from the huge problems other neighbouring countries are experincing. Then you mentioned poverty. Malta has no poverty. However, there are certain instances when due to drugs, alkohol, gambling, separations, single mothers etc families find it difficult to cope.

HENRY FENECH AZZOPARDI

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:40

Eddy you seem to forget that you have been saying for a long time that Malta is paying more that it received, so how come you want such an answer for the coming seven years?

I suggest that you compromise with your self belief before you put pen to paper. Ghax issa vera hawatni.

Martin Borg

Nov 23rd 2012, 12:09

Hearing you on TVHemm yesterday with your message of doom and gloom reminded me of the good old days under your idol Dom. Hemm zgur konna third world country sur Privitera . Barra mil fatt li diskors bhal tieghek il bierah probabbilment kien iqallak xi xebgha nobis .

Ronnie Callus

Nov 23rd 2012, 13:21

Well said Eddy, to know how much we are getting from the EU one has to deduct what we are paying first. These facts must be known and not speaking in the air. Dr.Gonzi please ask Dr.Tonio Fenech to give us a correct balance in the accounts.

marthese schembri

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:48

Yes thats nice, very encouraging pal. have a nice weekend, i am sure alot of Maltese will appreciate your gesture.

Robert Agius

Nov 25th 2012, 09:49

Dead right! austerity measures everyone but not amongst the EU bureaucrats. SHAME!

M Cachia

Nov 23rd 2012, 11:36

How? Every argument you put forward is easily and rationally torn to pieces.

Eddy Privitera

Nov 23rd 2012, 09:54

Mario P. Sciberras: The amiount of money we pay directly to the EU budget is not all the money EU membership is costing Malta. 'Open Europe' has said that according to its study, it is costing Malta €72.5 million a year to introduce and implement EU regulations. Besides the money collected in import-duty from non EU countries which we collect but have to send to the EU !!!!

Andrew Cutajar

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:01

Mario, a question : IN > OUT = GOOD while OUT > IN = BAD ? .... Actually both are OK, joining the EU is not free money, its a community where those with more (not plenty) help those with less. If we are closing in on EU average, then we should contribute more than before and get less back than before. The real issue is how the OUTs are spent to drive GDP. Also, try EUROSTAT for those numbers

Mr Tony Gatt

Nov 23rd 2012, 09:45

@ victor Laiviera
David Cameron is not in a very strong position politically but all parties in the U.K. are united that waste in the EU must be brought under control before more money can be considered. One thing that can be done is to stop the European Parliament shuttling between Brussels and Strasbourg every couple of months at a cost of about £20 million per annum.

B. Storace

Nov 23rd 2012, 09:50

Don't point the finger at Gonzi alone..Every politician, including those sitting with him round the negotiating table, will hang on to power as long as they can and while their time limit is still ticking away.

George Cutajar

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:04

Yes Mr. Laiviera I am sure you and your ilk are rubbing your hands in glee seeing this matter evolve. If you think that all this is due to the local political scene than you simply have no idea how the EU works.

If you honestly believe that the situation would have been any different had your great white hope been leading negotiations than you are very mistaken.

Eddy Privitera

Nov 23rd 2012, 09:55

Agelo Vassallo; Tkunx redikolu ! Jekk hemm il-probabilita li l-PL jirbah l-elezzjoni, jista jkun irid li l-flus jonqsu ????

Joe Borg (Senior)

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:14

Sure Ang li vvutajt lil GonziPN, jekk ahna il-LEJBURISTI ha nkunu fil-gvern jumejn ohra ghalfejn ghandna nifirhu!!!!

Joseph Grech Attard

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:24

If it were not for the Maltese MEP's, from both sides, to cinvince EU MEPS, from all sides, the story would have been different. Remember this was a secret vote. As much as those who said they shall vote against, but voted in favour, there could have been others who said they shall vote in favour, but voted against. Let us compare like with like please. This is called justice and fairnness.

HENRY FENECH AZZOPARDI

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:34

You hit the nail on the head, a very good one.

Mr Tony Gatt

Nov 23rd 2012, 09:49

It looks as if the days of the 'ghal-erwieh' as they used to say when I was a boy are coming to an end for Malta!

Eddy Privitera

Nov 23rd 2012, 09:57

C. Cassar: Spjega ftit kif jekk skond int, il-livell tal-ghixien f'Malta ghola, kif il-faqar zdiet tant - 8,000 persuna aktar qed jghixu fil-faqar ???

Andrew Cutajar

Nov 23rd 2012, 11:15

EU is not about free money - its about solidarity. If you are not proud to help countries in need, you have no place in the EU ... if we are doing better while others are doing worse, the balance must change and we must be fine with it. Gonzi should be making sure we get a fair deal, not the same deal - I suspect his posturing is just that

paul camilleri

Nov 23rd 2012, 13:19

free money?? maybe you forget that the VAT we pay goes to the EU, and if our country needs what we were given in the past to ensure that our flight of finacial indipendence is to suceed, if this is not supported then we too will fall into the same situation as Greece and Spain.

G Mangion

Nov 23rd 2012, 09:36

M. Attard:

li Tinnegozja allura ifisser Talab ? kieku hekk Tliet kawarti min Malta talaba !!! grow up .....

Eddy Privitera

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:00

M. Attard: Jien ma nghidx qed jittallab. Jaghmel sewwa li jieqaf lill-UE. L-ipokresija pero hi, li meta Dr. Muscat kien qal li fl-interess ta' Malta jaghmel l-istess haga - anki juza l-veto (kif qed jhedded bil-kliem Gonzi) - tghidx kemm qalulu li jekk jaghmel hekk Malta tispicca wehedha abbandunata !!!! Gonzi mid-dehra tghallem. Jew forsi ghax waslet l-elezzjoni !

Evarist Saliba

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:09

Ghandek ragun. Tassew li ma tafx x'inhu jaghmel Gonzi. Ghalxejn nipprova nispjegalek ghax ma hemmx min hu aktar trux min dak li ghandu widnejn izda ma jridx jisma'.

Eddy Privitera

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:02

Mark Borg: Gonzi qatt m'accetta li jaghmel " cost-benefit analysis " dwar kemm qed nircievu flus u kemm flus qed tiswielna s-shubija. Ghaliex tghid ???

Celine Grech

Nov 23rd 2012, 09:47

Well said Eve. Why not cut these perks? Why build another building opposite that being currently used?

Charles W. Sammut

Nov 23rd 2012, 08:11

Daqs kemm innegozja b'suċċess il-Burden Sharing tal-immigranti llegali.

Mr Joe Micallef

Nov 23rd 2012, 08:19

Had your vote prevailed, we would not even be negotiating but rather prostituting Malta as your masters always did!

Eddy Privitera

Nov 23rd 2012, 10:04

Joe Micallef: When Malta was outside the EU in 1987 Labour left LM 450 million in Malta's coffers, not €6,000 million national debt !

Ronnie Callus

Nov 23rd 2012, 14:09

Eddy,mhux Lm460,000,000 (Liri Maltin) biss imma anke xi deheb li Mintoff kien ihobb jinvesti fih biex jghamel tajjeb ghal Malta. Fejn marru dawn kollha u flokhom ghamilna 6,000,000,000 euro dejn.Tghajja taqrah in-numru ahseb wara thallsu.Imbaghad jigu jghidulna kemm ahna sejrin tajjeb,mhux bhal pajjizi ewropej ohra.Veru ma'nistax nifhem.Ghalhekk issa ta' l-EU se'jnaqsulna 45% mill-Budget li jtuna.

Advert
Advert