Tribute to a soldier, patient... and hero
Maltese surgeon visits grave of a remarkable war victim
Video: Patrick Cooke
A UK-based Maltese cardiac surgeon last week paid respects at the grave of a British soldier he believes was one of the first in the world to undergo successful heart surgery.
Norman Briffa’s trip to the military cemetery in Pietà last Wednesday was the culmination of more than a year’s research into the case of Private Robert Hugh Martin.
Private Martin of the 1st Derbyshire Yeomanry Regiment was on horseback when he was shot in the chest on his 21st birthday in Salonika, Greece, in November 1917.
He had enlisted to fight in World War I despite being underage after a young woman had shown him a white feather, which symbolised cowardice, when he was on his way to Dore and Totley train station in Sheffield.
Wearing a poppy in memory of the war dead, who will be honoured in today’s Remembrance Day services, Mr Briffa, 51, explained that Private Martin was transported to Malta with a bullet lodged in his heart on board the hospital ship Glenart Castle.
One of his stretcher bearers when he arrived in Malta was from the same town as Private Martin and remarked, “It’s a long way from Dore and Totley isn’t it Bob”.
A successful operation to remove the bullet was carried out at St Elmo’s Hospital in Valletta.
The Daily Malta Chronicle reported at the time that the operation “attracted extraordinary interest and attention” and was “the talk of the island”.
Malta was known as the ‘Nurse of the Mediterranean’ in World War I as many injured Allied soldiers were evacuated to the island for treatment.
Despite the success of the operation, Private Martin died of septicaemia in March 1918 and was buried in Pietà.
“It is very touching to see his grave,” said Mr Briffa after he and his wife Susan spent a moment of quiet reflection at Private Martin’s final resting place.
Private Martin’s great-niece brought the case to Mr Briffa’s attention last year after she attended a talk in Sheffield by Mr Briffa on the history of cardiac surgery.
Mr Briffa was initially “respectfully sceptical” about the story as efforts to perform chest and cardiac surgery did not really commence until the 1920s, according to most surgical history books.
Many text books ascribe initial efforts at surgery to treat heart and major vascular injuries to Dwight Harken, a US Army surgeon stationed in England in World War II.
However, after exhaustive research, Mr Briffa discovered that British surgeons in World War I did attempt to operate on bullet injuries to the heart. Among them was Sir Charles Ballance, who worked in Malta during World War I.
Mr Briffa, who lives and works in Sheffield, said he enjoys history and he found the story of Private Martin fascinating.
“His story and the story of the surgeon who operated on him deserve to be remembered,” Mr Briffa said.
6 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Mr John Montague
Nov 12th 2012, 08:01
Great detective work Mr Briffa - much applauded
James Borg
Nov 12th 2012, 07:03
This is very interesting. Dr Briffa should write a paper about his research and submit it to war historians in the UK. In medical/surgical history this would be the second time of a first time operation of its kind ever performed on the islands. During the Knight's period the first eye cataract operation was also performed in Malta. For the size of our islands, our history's rich in many ways!
Anthony Paul Naudi
Nov 12th 2012, 05:55
Bis-sahha ta dawn li mietu ghalina, illum ahna lkoll liberi u nghixu fil-paci. Dawn eroji tad-dinja.
A.P.Naudi
T Cassar
Nov 11th 2012, 20:37
http://www.worldwar1.com/tgws/rel009.htm
Word limit did not permit the due reference so it is stated above. The actual BMJ could not be accessed but if the above info is correct cardiac surgery certainly cannot be attributed to WW2!
Certainly thank you for the info however!
T Cassar
Nov 11th 2012, 20:32
In WW1 Mr. George Grey Turner a British Regimental surgeon: sutured the pericardium , left a drainage-tube in the lowest part of the sac and another along the outside near the suture line. He held the flap of chest in position with catgut sutures, and brought drains through the center of the lower oblique incision. The bullet was not removed but the patient lived to see WW2 . BMJ 2:487-489, 1940
Anne Farrugia
Nov 11th 2012, 12:48
How very interesting. Thank you for sharing.
Please choose the reason of your report below: