Advert

Updated: Ex-Commissioner warned Silvio Zammit in August against harming his reputation

John Dalli has revealed that last August he wrote to Silvio Zammit, warning him in a legal letter that he would hold him responsible if he harmed his reputation.

The former European Commissioner told The Times that he wrote to Mr Zammit as soon as he heard certain allegations from OLAF, which was investigating trading in influence.

Mr Dalli said that Mr Zammit wrote back, but he gave no further details.

When contacted, Mr Zammit refused to comment.

Mr Dalli resigned over the case on Tuesday.

Meanwhile, Mr Dalli yesterday emphatically denied any knowledge of the cash-for-influence request made by Mr Zammit, his former canvasser to a Swedish tobacco company.

In a second interview with New Europe magazine in five days, Mr Dalli insisted he was not corrupt.

“Absolutely not,” he responded when asked whether he had any knowledge that a Maltese businessman was asking for money to alter EU tobacco legislation.

He gave the same answer when asked whether he was “bribable”.

Mr Dalli resigned as commissioner on Tuesday after an investigation by the EU’s anti-fraud unit, OLAF, found he was aware that a Maltese businessman was using his contacts with the EU Commissioner to trade in influence and he did nothing to stop or report this activity.

The businessman is restaurant owner and circus promoter Silvio Zammit, who until Tuesday was the Nationalist Party’s deputy mayor in Sliema.

Mr Zammit was named by Mr Dalli in the first interview he gave New Europe last week. The businessman owns Peppi’s restaurant in Sliema and was Mr Dalli’s canvasser on the 10th district at the last election.

Mr Zammit allegedly approached Swedish Match, a tobacco company, with an offer to influence the upcoming review of tobacco legislation if they paid him a large sum of money.

Swedish Match produces snus, a smokeless form of oral tobacco that cannot be sold in the EU except Sweden. The company has long clamoured for the sales ban to be lifted opening up a potential market of €300 million.

OLAF would only say the amount Mr Zammit asked for was “substantial” and no transaction ever took place because the company reported the matter to the Commission.

But on Friday Swedish newspaper Aftonbladet quoted a company official saying Mr Zammit asked for €60 million – €10 million to be paid immediately and €50 million when the ban was to be lifted.

Mr Zammit declined to comment on Swedish Match’s claims and Mr Dalli yesterday said these were “fantastic” figures. Mr Dalli reiterated this was entrapment by the tobacco industry to delay the legislative changes that would have tightened packaging regulations, among others.

When asked whether he knew Mr Zammit was speaking to the tobacco lobby on his behalf, Mr Dalli specified he had “absolutely no knowledge of this communication”, with reference to the illegal request.

Mr Zammit had in fact organised two meetings between Mr Dalli and snus lobbyists in 2010 and last January. The businessman has denied any wrongdoing, insisting his lobbying activity was above board.

Mr Dalli insisted whoever was proposing a change in the treatment of snus in Europe was “crazy” because a court had already thrown out a challenge to the ban. “It is political suicide to change anything like this,” he said.

During the interview, Mr Dalli was presented with an extract from a report compiled by tobacco company Philip Morris in August.

The report quoted OLAF head Giovanni Kessler supporting the position of tobacco companies against changes to packaging rules.

Mr Dalli’s reaction was a jibe at Dr Kessler: “If anybody is investigating Giovanni Kessler he will be using this as unambiguous circumstantial evidence.”

This was a reference to OLAF’s conclusions that “unambiguous circumstantial evidence” connected Mr Dalli with Mr Zammit and the attempt to trade in influence.

The extract quoted in the interview makes reference to testimony Dr Kessler gave an Italian parliamentary committee in June where he said changing tobacco packaging – as proposed by Mr Dalli – would make counterfeiting easier and cheaper.

Mr Dalli said the postponement of new tobacco legislation meant the tobacco industry will continue to make billions of euros every day at the expense of people’s health.

In a subsequent interview yesterday with Aftonbladet, Mr Dalli said he wanted to obtain a copy of the report to find out the accusations being levelled against him and said he would take legal action in Malta, Brussels and Luxembourg to clear his name.

Advert

97 Comments

Post comment

Please see our new Comments Policy

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

For more details please see our Comments Policy

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Francis Attard

Oct 21st 2012, 19:00

Hawn Malta kollox jghaddi habib u biz-zmien jintesa.

A. MICALLEF

Oct 21st 2012, 17:38

May I also ask, how did Silvio Zammit acquire the site in Sliema front and than built a restaurant ??
Was this site offerred to the general public by a call for public tender ?? There was no restaurant/kiosk
and it was Mr. Zammit who originated this restaurant during a nationalist administration on this site.

Ronnie Callus

Oct 21st 2012, 17:01

Proset Joseph, u terga dawn kollha warajhom se' jhalluhom.

m. borg (slm)

Oct 21st 2012, 20:23

Kemm tista tixtri voti b'sittin miljun ewro !!!!

maria theresa grech

Oct 21st 2012, 22:37

Eh bilhaq!!!!!!!!! ilkoll nahseb insejna, Dalwaqt ser jkolna elllezjoni. Kemm ser lkolna Canvassers godda!!!!!!!! Miskin il Poplu!!!!!!

E. Vassallo

Oct 21st 2012, 21:00

Fully agree!!!

john muscat

Oct 21st 2012, 15:53

Many of his ilk are amongst us. We must make a thorough clean up in the PN.

john muscat

Oct 21st 2012, 15:54

Many of his ilk are amongst us. We must make a thorough clean up in the PN.

Joseph Scicluna

Oct 21st 2012, 16:27

@ john muscat


"We must make a thorough clean up in the PN."

This has been going on for some time and they are being gathered in the skip, you know where!!!!!!

Mrs Maria Rosaria Brincat

Oct 21st 2012, 16:36

We must make a true clean up from all members of parlament from both sides otherwise or else our country and all of us are going to drown.

Michael Seychell

Oct 21st 2012, 14:44

Keith even if one were to believe that there is some corruption under the PN, be assured that when
compared to that under Labour which apart from rampant corruption violent atrocities were committed, including murders, beatings by the police, imprisonment to wisthle blowers, and frame ups.

If you were young at the time you should read "Liberta Mhedda"

Giovanni Rizzo

Oct 21st 2012, 12:59

Agree with you.

Mike Hunt

Oct 21st 2012, 14:18

Smacks of expecting Zammit to fall on his own sword should a cunning plan go pear shaped. But all this is conjecture.

Joe Grech

Oct 21st 2012, 11:23

Well said!! 100% correct.

John Caruana

Oct 21st 2012, 11:24

Actually even July was too late.
The letter needed to be issued before OLAF was even informed about it.

Ronnie Callus

Oct 21st 2012, 13:06

Well said Mr.Lewis. Although Mr.Dalli is saying that he wrote to Mr.Zammit regards this matter, Mr.Dalli was obliged to inform Olaf or whom concerned regards this matter. This was a great mistake in my opinion because Mr.Dalli should have known this.

A.M. Galea

Oct 21st 2012, 14:29

Maybe he was born in Dingli Circus . Did'nt you know that the Sliema Local Council was and still is a Circus in itself .

JOSEPH MUSCAT

Oct 21st 2012, 12:44

@joseph gafferena imma din il kumidja x- ghanda xtaqsam mat Tv`S ta 60`s jew xi permes biex tibni bicca art li kienu jigru go Malta. Din laffari grat fil kumjunika Ewropey kas ta 60 miljun EURO,u cara u tonda li hemm politikant Malti imdahhal fiha, skond OLAF,Disgrazja ohra ghal Malta taht il PARTIT TAL- FRODI.

Ronnie Callus

Oct 21st 2012, 14:08

Sur.Gaffarena, jien niftakar anke biex ituk tank ilma ghar-raba kont ridt thallas lil xi hadd fi, zmien il-partit nazzjonalista ta' sittinijiet. Biss tnejn hziena ma' jghamlhux wahda tajba. U zgur li mghandnhiex nimxu fuq il-passi hziena li mghoddija. F'din il-bicca dahlet Malta kollha, tlifna l-kredibilta mall-barranin.

mark cassar

Oct 21st 2012, 11:14

If only you had an idea who the person, Hon. John Dalli, really is , you would understand that this case was concocted against someone who tried to resist opposition to strict anti-smoking regulations. Therefore Our dear Brussels disposed of him, wait and see.

Mike Hunt

Oct 21st 2012, 14:34

Your argument is flawed. If there is no case, it doesn't mean that there is nothing else taking place. On the other hand, if this is the case it doesn't mean that there is more going on.

Claudia Spiteri

Oct 21st 2012, 14:20

Dalli spoke in private with Lawrence Gonzi and in public he said his e-mails were being hacked. There's more to this than meets the eye. Hear everything Dalli is saying and piece up the jig saw. Silvio Zammit is doing the right thing by not speaking.

Dennis Zammit

Oct 21st 2012, 15:53

The pudding must have been already baked if Barroso was ready to sack the Qormi guy in 45 minutes !!!

Franco Attard Trevisan

Oct 21st 2012, 12:00

the only (big) problem I see is that Dalli sent this letter to Zammit AFTER OLAF started investigating... I still don't know what OLAF is referring to (as evidence) when they say Dalli knew about Zammit's actions ... In a way, though not necessarily, sending this letter ma be used against Dalli because it proofs he knew what Zammit was doing

Mike Hunt

Oct 21st 2012, 14:29

I've seen some of your comments on the matter and it seems you are convinced that JD is just an innocent victim of Big Tobacco conspiracy. I have no love for smoking (I don't smoke, don't drink, I just bake pot in my brownies) but how can you vouch for JD? If you are so sure of his innocence what evidence are you holding on to? Or is it just PN myopia?

A.M. Galea

Oct 21st 2012, 14:44

Mr Franco Attard Travisan . How can you send a letter before you know that you are being investigated . If you do that , it clearly shows that you knew of what was going on . It was after Mr Dalli was being investigated by OLAF that he knew what was going on and who was behind all this . It is amasing how OLAF came to the conclusion that Mr Dalli knew what was going on without any real proof.

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 21st 2012, 16:52

@MikeHunt.
I do not vouch for John Dalli but I vouch still less for OLAF after the sorry spectacle of an evasive Kessler when he was being quizzed by the international press and Barroso's indefensible drastic reaction even before Dalli could defend himself.
Those who make the accusation (OLAF) are bound to present probative evidence - not I.

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 21st 2012, 17:12

Dalli sent the judicial letter when OLAF informed him that he was under investigation. Many weeks later, Kessler was misleading when he accused Dalli that he had done nothing to stop any illicit dealings between Zammit and the Sec. Gen. of ESTOC. This alleged failure to take remedial action is the gravest accusation against Dalli - but it now seems not to be true.

Dennis Zammit

Oct 21st 2012, 15:52

Mistake . . . needs a lot of thought.

Difficult to believe that neither he nor his friends ever knew what the Imqaret guy was doing. He has so many 'mejta bil-guh' around him who adore him that someone else fingers if not hands must have been in the pie.

Charles Sammut

Oct 21st 2012, 10:39

well, if this were to happen ( 3rd Conditional ) Johnnie will sue the pants off the EU Commission, off OLAF, off Zammit and off Swedish Match and he will stand to gain more than Euro60million!
Me thinks that these beings would still be wearing their pants in the future!
The islanders wait with bated breath for this to happen...we shall see...

...and the beat goes on...and the beat goes on....

Kevin Sciberras

Oct 21st 2012, 12:05

Flimkien kollox possibli! Even frame-ups

joyce darmanin

Oct 21st 2012, 18:59

allura jien nistaqsi ,din kumpanija min fejn sabitu lil Silvio Zammit minn fuq face book jew yellow pages hehee?? kif ma sabetx lili jew lilek,nies komuni biex nghadullha kelma!!!!!!!!

j brincat

Oct 21st 2012, 10:27

If this happened in Labour's time 'li kieku holl xaghrek u gib iz-zejt"

Who knows whether our state TV would broadcast feature upon feature about this saga and all day long?


(jb)

Giov DeMartino

Oct 21st 2012, 10:47

Ara min laqa' u ddefenda lil Dalli, lil JPO, lil Mugliett, lil Dimech, lil Cyrus, lil Woods....

Giov DeMartino

Oct 21st 2012, 11:01

Super One is doing that, Mr Brincat.

Eddy Privitera

Oct 21st 2012, 13:21

Giovann: Ghax ma tghidx lil Net TV jistedinhom lil dawk li semmejt ? Ghadek ma kkommmentajtx dwar il-kwistjoni ferm aktar serja ghal pajjizna, dik tal--hsara kbira tal-impjant suppost gdid ta' Delimara ! Ara x'bellajthulna !

Giov DeMartino

Oct 21st 2012, 17:15

Ed, kieku ma kontx pensjonant xih bhali kont nikkumpatik, imma int......Xi tridni nghidlek nghidlek fuq il-power station? Se jehel il--gvern ghax magna thassret? Jew int kont taf x'se jigri? Darba l-lejber gabu krejn ggantesk minn barra. Malli wasal haw inqaleb u kellhom jiskrappjawh. Allura? Ma tarax li l-argument tieghek mas jixraqlekx? Int QATT ma ghedtli kif kont mort ma S> Rita. Next

m farrugia

Oct 21st 2012, 22:07

u min jaf xi hmieg ghad johrog la jitla il labour

min jaf xi jweghdu ta postijiet u flus

min jaf... jpo ambaxxatur, dalli min jaf xhiex ha jpattu ta kull darba li marru fuq one tv ipaxxuhom

j brincat

Oct 21st 2012, 10:22

Only in Malta!


(jb)

Peter Bonnici

Oct 21st 2012, 11:11

@ J Brincat. And it was definitely only in Malta when a shipwright and a plasterer/painter became ministers.

Franco Attard Trevisan

Oct 21st 2012, 12:03

I guess, being used to sticking around clowns is a big asset in Maltese politics my friend :)

R. Farrugia

Oct 21st 2012, 12:56

Very simple Mr.Brown, being a mayor in this country and promoting a circus are more or less the same thing...!

Dennis Zammit

Oct 21st 2012, 15:48

We have a ZERO guy without ever getting 1 vote in a General Election as Leader of the Opposition. Mind you, he is perfect for the job . . . he opposes everything.

m farrugia

Oct 21st 2012, 22:04

cos people vote for him and a lot of slimizi stay at home bi ksuhat instead of electing serious councillors, ghalhekk disastru totali

M Cassar

Oct 21st 2012, 11:14

Olaf informed Dalli he was being investigated on 11th July and since then questioned twice with assistance. A bit late in the day for him to write to Zammit don't you think? Why did he never say publicly that he was being investigated? And were his accusations of email hacking by pn people just a few days after the 11th, a ploy? After all we now know he never did lodge a report with the police!

mark cassar

Oct 21st 2012, 10:39

Bloggers all, why not wait with most of your stupid comments. John Dalli is strictly anti smoking and takes the health of his grandchildren and family very seriously and contrary to what many insinuate he is not bribeable.
His reputation is above board. This case will not be the first were somebody takes advantage of his honour.

carmel parnis

Oct 21st 2012, 19:33

Why simply a letter and not a report to the police ? mmmmm was it a registered letter ?

Advert
Advert