Silvio Zammit asked for €60 million, Swedish newspaper says
Snus manufacturer Swedish Match has claimed that it was asked for €60 million by Silvio Zammit to influence a decision by former Health Commissioner John Dalli on a tobacco product.
The company's communications manager Patrik Hildingsson was quoted in the Swedish newspaper Aftonbladet.
He said that a Swedish Match employee met the businessman in Malta after he had sought contact.
"The Maltese businessman expressed to us very clearly that he was speaking on behalf of Dalli. He had a manner and information that made us wary," Mr Hildingsson said.
"He said it was, in principle, political suicide to lift the ban and, therefore, he wanted money for it, simply put, since the career (of the EU commissioner) would be over afterwards."
Swedish Match declined the offer and informed the Commission of what had happened, Mr Hildingsson said.
According to the newspaper, €10 million were to be paid immediately, and €50 million once the law was changed.
108 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Kieron O'connor
Oct 21st 2012, 11:20
It would be interesting to know what other trading in influence goes on around the Island that doesn't make it to the press?
Angelo Vassallo
Oct 20th 2012, 14:00
@ EDDIE privitera
Imma kemm tiflah tkun OPPORTUNIST? Ma ghandna niehdu xejn bi kbir min ghandek EDDIE ghax "dear leader joseph" muscat hekk jaghmel il-hin kollu, u inti EDDIE "follow the "dear leader" - OPPORTUNIZMU SFRENAT U SFACCAT LEJBURISTA
Eddy Privitera
Oct 20th 2012, 18:08
"Opportunist" ghax qed nemmen lil John Dalli sakemm ma jingibux provi li ma jhalli l-ebda dubju li Dalli ghamel xi haga hazina ? Taf li INT m'ghidt xejn ? X'inhi l-pozizzjoni tieghek, int ukoll lest tikkundannah qabel jiddefendi ruhu ?
U xi tghid ghal-ahhar FROGA tal-power station Sur Ang ?
Joseph Camilleri
Oct 20th 2012, 09:52
@ eddie privitera
can you please clarify your position as to why you are defending dalli in this manner? again red eyesight only! oh sorry I forgot that it is white flags only now.
Ms D. Borg
Oct 20th 2012, 09:30
Suppose the Swedish company had accepted to pay 60 million to Silvio Zammit, then what? Would Dalli have changed his decision?
Eddy Privitera
Oct 20th 2012, 09:23
A certain infamous blogger is trying to tear John Dalli to bits without waiting for developments and conclusion to this case. She is 100% convinced of Dalli's guilt ! I would rather be proven mistaken for believing in Dalli's innocence. than condemn him at this stage !
Eddy Privitera
Oct 20th 2012, 08:41
Ex- commissioner John Dalli has asked the Attorney General to conclude his investigation by next week if possible. And not take 4 years as had been the case in the previous investigation about John Dalli, when it was found that the accusation about him had been false !
I guess that all the Maltese people agree with John Dalli , that the local investigation should be concluded urgently.
Joseph Camilleri
Oct 20th 2012, 09:47
@ eddy privitera, I do not get your point. Something tells me that lejber once again has used commissioner dalli to hit at the government and has backfired. Now lejber cant hit back because dalli was usefull to torpedoe parliament since it is in a very tight situation. I cant forget how delighted the lejber station was to report remarks by dalli that parliament is not functioning. I do wonder!
Joseph M. Saliba
Oct 20th 2012, 10:32
Yes I agree with you and this case should be treated with utmost urgency as justice delayed is justice denied. If found that he knew that he was being used and did nothing about it than Mr Dalli should face criminal charges, However if he is found that he was in good faith and he knew nothing then Mr Dalli should be reinstated as COMMISSIONER. BAROSO IS NOT THE EUROPEAN UNION WE VOTED FOR.
Eddy Privitera
Oct 20th 2012, 18:27
Joseph Camilleri: was John Dalli wrong when he said that parliament was not functioning ?
Paul Sammut
Oct 20th 2012, 07:56
All I know is that the legislation is being put aside for the moment or forever and that the tobacco industry has won the battle while Mr Dalli has been made the scapegoat of Barroso. Everybody in the legal camp knows that hearsay evidence is rubbish. I expected much more from Barroso ! He must be holier than the Pope ! No way !
Joseph Camilleri
Oct 20th 2012, 09:50
@ paul sammut wow and you must the the european unions prophetic messenger to tell us about this conspiracy theory! This whole thing is filthy and I am not surprised at nothing. " I am a decent nationalist, if you follow my comments I always try to do my best to stand besides this government who is absolutely clean in this matter yet greedy pigs do exist and is hurting us all.
joseph gaffarena
Oct 20th 2012, 04:43
Surely they are not nationalists but pure opportunists.
Mark Cassar
Oct 20th 2012, 04:00
All these goings on and coming to light bits and pieces of info, and if the price asked for was 60 million, either the middleman was not thinking to ask for such a ridiculous figure in order to influence or indeed this is all a charade.
Charles Grixti
Oct 20th 2012, 00:20
With all of this, one has to wonder what was the whole story behing the approval of GMO potatoes for the EU.
Joseph Borg
Oct 19th 2012, 23:42
OMG - 60 Million - jara ftit kbir is-sur Zammit!
Listiani Lestari
Oct 19th 2012, 23:33
Was Silvio Zammit Acting alone? And how did Silvio came to that massive sum? Who are they, those behind Silvio Zammit? Malta is dramatically experiencing a reformation of change in mentality. Politics are not anymore an investment in the making of huge profits out of position in the governmental administration. We are not longer a stupid nation. There are still other jackals within both parties.
Alfred Cassar
Oct 19th 2012, 21:24
Could it possible be that this Swedish company, seeing that Dalli was going to ban their product, wanted to get rid of him and created the whole story?
I'm just asking, not defending anyone and not siding with anyone
Antoine Vella
Oct 19th 2012, 21:58
Alfred Cassar, can't you read? Dalli wasn't going to ban snus: it is already banned and the issue was whether the ban should be lifted.
Adrian P. Cassar
Oct 20th 2012, 06:40
It could be.
If Dalli was aware of Zammit's "lobbying" he knew that he was not doing it as a volunteer because he had snus at heart!!
If Zammit was asking for 60 million he was aware that he could get Dalli on board. It is very unlikely that he would ask for that money, only to then say "I'm sorry, no can do..."
james hughes
Oct 19th 2012, 21:23
that what happens when you are greedy, 60mil, wow, not at least 1mil, even that is too high lol,
Stannis Baratheon
Oct 19th 2012, 23:28
Now he gets 0
A. Mizzi
Oct 19th 2012, 21:17
Think BIG!
Make it worth your while!
Claire Busuttil
Oct 19th 2012, 21:06
if found giulty these 2 gentleman, should be given a very harsh sentence from the EU court, and another from the Maltese Law court, they STAINED our reputation as maltese and of our island, and should be treated extremly seriously.
Eddy Privitera
Oct 20th 2012, 08:45
Claire Busuttil: Up to now it was Barroso who has "stained our reputation" by forcing John Dalli to resign without waiting for John Dalli's defence on this matter. We weill know who "stained" malta's reputation at the end of the investigations and any possible court sentence.
E. Azzopardi
Oct 19th 2012, 20:29
Well, is there any proof of that? Is there anything in writing or recorded?
Julie Spiteri
Oct 19th 2012, 20:24
Now with the Tobacco directive stalled again barely just before its launch, the beneficiary is:The Tobacco Industry producing cigarettes. Snuss affects the health of users only; cigarettes are the top cause of death and disease of smokers and also affect passive smokers. Currently oral tobacco producers are at a huge disadvantage with a restricted market such as Sweden as oppose to a global one.
j brincat
Oct 19th 2012, 20:10
"
Michael Gatt
"Whatever you do in your life, you should never try to mess up with Swedes... They are disciplined people and make sure that everything is done in a perfect manner"
Would suppose so, but who made the offer, a Swedish company, no?
(jb)
(jb)
Michael Gatt
Oct 19th 2012, 18:11
Whatever you do in your life, you should never try to mess up with Swedes... They are disciplined people and make sure that everything is done in a perfect manner.
martin chetcuti
Oct 19th 2012, 18:40
Agree 100%. Their record year after year regarding anti corruption is something they can boast about and we as Maltese are well behind....
Anthony Paul Naudi
Oct 19th 2012, 19:08
If someone made a big mistake like this , he must pay for it very harshly .
Joe A. Borg
Oct 19th 2012, 19:17
The 9,350,000 inhabitants of Sweden reported 1,410,000 offences to the authorities in 2009 approximately 151 offences/1000 inhabitants). The number of reported crimes have increased radically since the collection of national statistics began in 1950. Much of this has been attributed to a higher level of reporting of crimes, but the largest factor is the absolute increase of incidents
mr a borg
Oct 19th 2012, 20:55
indeed the swedes' reputation for rectitude will make sure that no one suspect any foul play in them!
the swedes' real goal?
http://www.thelocal.se/43190/20120912/
C Borg
Oct 19th 2012, 20:59
And if all Swedes were 'saints' except one?
Shall we conclude that that one is also a 'saint' because all others are 'saints""
Claire Busuttil
Oct 19th 2012, 21:07
@gatt, u forsi ghandna nitaghlmu minnhom...le??
Claire Busuttil
Oct 19th 2012, 21:10
@Borg....yes... their problem is the immigration from eastern EU countries....like romania and bulgaria....that`s why their crime rate increased
Joseph Bugeja
Oct 19th 2012, 17:45
I think that EU should get it's house in order.
Whether this is true or not will always be a bone of contention.
The truth is that one person (an EU commissioner) has so much power in his hands.
Not very democratic for someone chosen by the cabinet or members or even a prime minister of one country.
Francis Saliba M.D.
Oct 19th 2012, 17:37
Swedish Match, manufacturer of the snus banned throught Europe outside Sweden, should mention that the bribe sum alleged by it was in answer to its specific request for that information. Therefore, it was either an attempt to bribe and corrupt or to entrap, if not both by the morally superior Swedes.
ANTHONY PAVIA
Oct 19th 2012, 17:48
At last Dottore we have found some common ground.
Robert Agius
Oct 19th 2012, 17:56
...the fact also remains that while tobacco is legal and consumed across all of Europe, something which is less harmful is not allowed....the rest is superfluous.
Francis Saliba M.D.
Oct 19th 2012, 18:23
@RobertAgius.
Tobacco undoubtedly kills millions and the European Commission is correct to object to its wider dissemination. It is immaterial that it is legal. That is no reason why the abuse of other harmful drugs (even if less harmful according to you) should be encouraged. Two wrongs do not make one right.
Please stick to the subject of the blog without trying to promote drug abuse.
Robert Agius
Oct 20th 2012, 11:49
@ Dottore
I'm merely pointing out the contradictions and twisted reason that exist in our current laws. What is wrong here is pretending that lobbying is done without the influence of the most powerful drugs - $ and power.
Luciano Pace Parascandalo
Oct 19th 2012, 17:36
for those quoting the Corruption index kindly note that this is merely a perception index.....just what the people think....and with most Maltese being morbidly suspicious or envious of anything that walks than no one wonder anyone having it better than us is perceived as corrupt
carmel cassar
Oct 19th 2012, 17:33
The more info that comes out, the more proof that somebody wants him out of the way.
Francis Saliba M.D.
Oct 19th 2012, 17:28
Irrespective of the sum involved, the inescapable conclusion is that the tobacco lobby was either offering a bribe or indulging in criminal entrapment.
So much for the racist claim of Nordic moral superiority over the Mediterranean people that incidentally is an insult to the obliging Director General of OLAF, Italian Giovanni Kessler as much as it is to the Maltese.
R. Caruana
Oct 19th 2012, 17:38
You forget that the tobacco lobby made the report hence your conclusion is inescapably flawed.
Francis Saliba M.D.
Oct 19th 2012, 18:09
@ RCaruana.
I forget nothing. Please, read my comment intelligently.
I am totally against the scheming, powerful and corrupting tobacco industry shamelessly roping in an ingenuous OLAF so as to facilitate the sale of its deadly merchandise outside Sweden and adding Dalli's scalp to the millions killed by its merchandise, worldwide.
Alfred Vassallo
Oct 19th 2012, 19:15
@R. Caruana
And you forgot that it was the tobacco lobby that send that particular email to the Maltese middleman asking for the price entailed to set up a meeting with the Commissioner.
C Borg
Oct 19th 2012, 20:53
Anyone who is or wants to be 'clean' files the report immediately without doing any further contacts, not when he is 100% sure that the directive is not going to be favourable.
We neither know the content of the meetings nor how they have been organized nor under which pretext.
Mr Peter Korsten
Oct 19th 2012, 17:14
For those claiming a frame-up, have a look at the Corruption Perception Index of 2011:
http://cpi.transparency.org/cpi2011/results/
Sweden is in 3rd place, with a score of 9.3. It's one of the least corrupt countries in the world.
Malta scores a meagre 5.6.
So, do you really believe in a frame-up? If the EU anti-corruption agency says he knew about the contacts?
M Borg
Oct 19th 2012, 17:41
tobacco is big money !
Franco Attard Trevisan
Oct 19th 2012, 17:49
First of all OLAF said it has only 'circumstantial evidence' that Dalli was aware of what was happening and the only thing they are 100% sure of is that Dalli was not involved in any corruption.
Secondly I don't believe much in coincidences and this morning's news that the EU offices regulating tobacco were broken into and many files disappeared smells too fishy to me.
Franco Attard Trevisan
Oct 19th 2012, 17:52
Who actually gained from all this apart from the pro tobacco lobbyists??? Shelving the directive for an undefined period means millions in profits!
Francis Saliba M.D.
Oct 20th 2012, 06:00
A Corruption Perception Index is NOT an index of the actual corruption level in a country. It is a measure of how the citizens of that country view their own level of corruption. Unbiased foreigners might not share that opinion
Joe Tabone
Oct 19th 2012, 17:04
Swedes also have their fair share of 'shady' contacts and contracts - http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/11/business/worldbusiness/11iht-corrupt.4.5672628.html?_r=0
Funny how they portray the image of zero tolerance to kick backs and seem to attribute it more to the med culture!
martin chetcuti
Oct 19th 2012, 17:14
Sweden is in 3rd place while Malta is way back on the 20th place according to the EU 2011 Barometer for corruption among European countries, therefore I think while they still have there fair share of 'shady' contacts and contracts they surely have a record that they can boast with....
Claire Busuttil
Oct 19th 2012, 21:12
@tabone....allura qed tigustifika li gara?!?!?!? prosit eh!
Tony Ellul
Oct 19th 2012, 16:59
Let no one judge before justice takes its course. At the moment we are capitalising on hearsay which means absolutely nothing other than pure sensation.
David Farrugia
Oct 19th 2012, 15:57
They need to prove this serious allegation. Otherwise I would suspect that they set up Dalli to sabotage the EU tobacco directive.
C Muscat
Oct 19th 2012, 15:55
They did not!!?? have to pay !!!!! anything???? to buy more time by shelving for a third time the ban!!!!
Barroso check.
John L Galea
Oct 19th 2012, 15:52
I would have asked even for 30million for just setting up an appointment...jahasra!!!:)
liza Elizabeth
Oct 19th 2012, 15:30
Norman Hamilton should do another special program ,by inviting again J DALLI. CAN SOMEONE ANSWER ME WHY THE PL AND J MUSCAT STAYED SILENT ABOUT THIS ISSUE REGARDING J DALLI, HOW IF IT WOULD BEEN SOMEONE ELSE INSTEAD LIKE SIMON OR CASA.!!!
Kenneth Williams
Oct 19th 2012, 16:07
Why Norman Hamilton...why not Peppi ...he likes this kind of stuff. and why Joseph should say something shouldn't be our GONZIPN should talk and give us answers. He is the one that appointed him.
Eddy Privitera
Oct 19th 2012, 16:16
Liza Elizabeth: How stupid of you to ask such a question when all we have had is an allegation/accusation on one side and a denial on the other ? Did you expect Dr. Muscat to condemn outright John Dalli without waiting to see how this is going to end ? Not even Dr. Gonzi has done that. In fact, Dr. Gonzi today said that he was not sorry for appointing John Dalli as commissioner !
P Azzopardi
Oct 19th 2012, 16:19
hear hear !!
M Farrugia
Oct 19th 2012, 19:42
Eddy Privitera donnok ma tafx kif tintlab il-lobgha politika. Kieku twelid il-bierah nghid pacenzja imma inti taf daqs haddieor li l-politikanti jitkellmu kif jaqbel lilhom u xejn aktar mhux hawn Malta biss imma anki barra. Ara per ezempju il-grupp tas-socjalisti ewropej iridu li l-kummissarju l-gdid jintaghzel wara l-elezzjoni. dawn x'interess ghandhom meta jintaghzel il-kummissarju?
mark borg
Oct 19th 2012, 20:11
liza ...maybe you are forgetting JD was appointed by Gonzi and that he was a minister for some 20 yrs with the PN in government,so why are you even trying to associate Dalli with Labour ?? when I dare say he is a PN icon......
Eddy Privitera
Oct 20th 2012, 08:55
M. Farrugia: Naf sewwa kif il-politici jighabu l-loghba politika. Naf ukoll li Barroso u shabu fil-Kummissjoni huma politici UKOLL ! U naf ukoll kif il-kumoaniji kbar jaghmlu minn kollox biex jinfluwenzaw lill-politici. U ghandhom flus bizzejjed biex jaghmlu dan. Pero naf ukoll, xi jkunu lest jaghmlu biex ifixklu lil dawk il-politici li ma jhalluhomx jinlluwezawhom. Aqra aktar u ssir taf !
Mr charles azzopardi
Oct 19th 2012, 15:27
Bondi plus please take note .. a program which was just a summary of what we already heard + the biased view of Lou ...
Joe Calleja
Oct 19th 2012, 17:21
I FULLY agree with you Mr. Azzopardi !!
ALBERT FENECH
Oct 19th 2012, 17:53
Yes, it was a disgraceful programme with the Lou Bondi trademark fudged all over it - innuendo, sarcastic comment, sinister questions left hanging in the air and overall a smear campaign on John Dalli with latent implications that he was being courted by the PL. Gutter journalism at its lowest.
ALBERT FENECH
Joe Busuttil
Oct 19th 2012, 20:47
What? Are you still watching Lou's program? Why not watch Ice Age 3 or Madagascar 2 on Italia Uno instead? I can assure you it's more educational.
marcus bonello
Oct 19th 2012, 15:23
Oh well, it wasn't such a big sum after all, why all the fuss :)
Joseph Borg
Oct 19th 2012, 15:11
Not bad for a retirement plan!
Mr Andrew Camilleri
Oct 19th 2012, 15:11
I get the impression Swedish Match is desparately trying to shift the search light on Dalli and Zammit, away from itself. I hope these guys are investigated.
Vincent Galea
Oct 19th 2012, 14:57
Human greed has been around since Adam and Eve.
It is not going away.
Godwin Dalli
Oct 19th 2012, 14:53
If the news item is correct , then how much will my vote be worth come election day?
Daniel Borg
Oct 19th 2012, 14:52
Wow tajjeb.. xmisthija mal barranin..
Joe Busuttil
Oct 19th 2012, 20:49
It's one every week. Last week we had the bendy buses one. Wonder what next week holds.
David Galea
Oct 19th 2012, 14:49
I hope that Swedish Match could produce such allocations. May the real truth comes out.
Sissy Muldowney
Oct 19th 2012, 14:48
Is it just a coincidence that his commission was working on an anti-tobacco law? Is it a coincidence that work on this law has now been frozen? Is it a coincidence that the offices of anti-tobacco NGOs in Brussels, close to the EU Parliament, were burgled when the area around them is full of special and ordinary police of all kinds because of the current "European Council"?
Lino Maniscalco
Oct 19th 2012, 16:40
Is this a coincidence that OLAF concluded their report just a few days before the directives had to be presented. Doesn't it looks like it has been tailor made????
Ronnie Callus
Oct 19th 2012, 19:06
@ Sissy Muldowney:
Its true, how come that the offices of the anti-tobacco NGO's in Brussels got sacked. Who has the interest to do so ????? This should be taken seriously and investigated because it's not fair that one points his finger on Dalli when there is no 100% proof yet.
Anthony Arpa
Oct 19th 2012, 14:47
Il Miljuni saru qisom hekk xi ftit mijiet .... J-Alla li f'dan il kaz tohrog il verita tal fatti kollha ..
M Borg
Oct 19th 2012, 14:43
Is this some kind of joke ?
J. Abela
Oct 19th 2012, 14:42
Hazirata
Angelo Polidano
Oct 19th 2012, 14:42
I must be naive but isn't it that 60 million euros is a bit of exageration? I wonder how many 60million euros profit a year this company makes.
Alfie Lewis
Oct 19th 2012, 16:52
Angelo, I have been following this issue on the internet Swedese Match makes 400 million euros each and every year AND THAT IS PURE PROFIT AFTER TAXES
Alfie Lewis
Oct 19th 2012, 17:00
image if they could sell their product in all 27 countries in EU, which they cannot than that 400million could easily triple , so what 's 60 million to them , sheer peanuts
martin chetcuti
Oct 19th 2012, 14:42
''Greed is a bottomless pit which exhausts the person in an endless effort to satisfy the need without ever reaching satisfaction''. - Erich Fromm
John Spiteri
Oct 19th 2012, 14:40
€60 Million buys alot of pizzas!!!
Paul Bajada
Oct 19th 2012, 14:37
Alla jbierikna u jkompli maghna! 60 miljun Euro! mhux ta bxejn iridu l ahjar jobs u kuntatti ma l Europa. Ghall xiex dhalna fl Ewropa ahna? min qed igawdi?
stephen koludrovic
Oct 19th 2012, 14:36
Now would that sum be + Vat?
Mario Busuttil
Oct 19th 2012, 14:31
Izjed ma jkunu sinjuri...izjed jaghmlu ghal zaqqhom.....Il garra gejja u sejra ...fl-ahhar tinkiser....Kemm huwa ahjar meta taqla il paga u meta tmur tistrieh fuq l -imhadda torqod u tonhor...milli taghmel iljieli tewden...!!!!!
Svetlana Borg
Oct 19th 2012, 14:24
And we are supposed to believe this crap coming from Sweden?
Thomas Cauchi
Oct 19th 2012, 14:24
Nittama li li kullhadd jiehu li haqqu issa, mhux nghamlu is shows b'xi tifel ghax inqabad ipejjep joint, u nhallu 60 miljun imutu fuq ruh ommhom, dejjem jekk dak li qieghed jinghad huwa minnhu! Pero c'mon, 60 miljun.. offiza lejn il poverta tad dinja! U dawn ma jithallsux bil-karawett lanqas!!!
Jay Oatmon
Oct 19th 2012, 14:24
So if the allegations are true, Silvio Zammit was acting as John Dalli's fixer/bagman?
X Borg
Oct 19th 2012, 14:23
60 million, the plot thickens - like a slab of concrete.
Another suspended sentence on the way ?
G Caruana
Oct 19th 2012, 14:22
VAT included?
Joseph Micallef
Oct 19th 2012, 14:17
Now this is very strange. Why should you accuse someone of curruption if that someone did not know about or did not accept your bribe? The whole thing is so obvious, dawn raw kif sa jpattuhilu u rnexxilhom s'issa. I hope J.D. sues them for 60 million and wins.
C Muscat
Oct 19th 2012, 14:05
They did not!!?? have to pay !!!!! anything???? to buy more time by shelving for a third time the ban!!!!
Barroso please check.
Anthony Pace
Oct 19th 2012, 14:03
The most the company achieved is to put back the EU directive by a few months on tightening up the sale of cigarettes and warnings on every packet!!!
Albert Critien
Oct 19th 2012, 14:03
If they were willing to pay out sixty million euro it must have been worth hundreds of millions and the knowledge that Commissioner Dalli had, so to speak, already passed judgement, then these people must be by now offering the sixty million and more to get at Mr Dalli
Eve Axiaq
Oct 19th 2012, 14:00
Mela meta ndunaw li mhux se jirnexxilhom jaghmlu l ligi kif iridu huma kixfu kollox biex iwahhluh lil Dalli u Zammit. Imma fl istess hin dan juri li Dalli ma kienx se jinxtara bil flus. Ta lanqas hekk nifimha jien.
GL Calleja
Oct 19th 2012, 13:56
Usually, where there is smoke there is fire.
J Demicoli
Oct 19th 2012, 14:26
Except in the new power station extension. Remember?
There was smoke but apparently there was no fire!!
John Vella
Oct 19th 2012, 13:48
not bad 60 million!
Dom.J. Bugejja
Oct 19th 2012, 14:41
John By to-day's standard its peanuts although i wouldn't say NO to just a tiny fraction of that amount.
Please choose the reason of your report below: