Advert

Debono presents motion for halt and review of St Philip's Hospital acquisition process

Nationalist MP Franco Debono has presented a motion in Parliament calling for the process for the acquisition of St Philip's Hospital by the government to be halted until the whole acquisition process in examined by the Auditor-General or the Public Accounts Committee.

In his motion Dr Debono complains that the House was not informed about the acquisition of the hospital, which will involve an outlay of €12 million over a number of years.

This acquisition, he points out, was happening just four years after the government opened Mater Dei Hospital. 

The process, so close to a general election, was raising certain doubts which needed to be addressed.

The motion says that the fact that the Health Ministry was long subject to strong criticism for its mismanagement and lack of vision further underlined the need for parliamentary scrutiny. 

In his motion Dr Debono also calls for a reform and modernisation of parliamentary standing orders and reforms to give parliament its proper dignity.

Advert

95 Comments

Post comment

Please see our new Comments Policy

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

For more details please see our Comments Policy

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Alfred Fenech

Oct 11th 2012, 11:02



Dr Debono Keep it up. Remain tough.

Peter Zahra

Oct 11th 2012, 12:32


So according to your logic, Mater Dei is a fiasco ??

I would like to ask a simple question to all these moaners, if you had the need to go for treatment in hospital and St Luke's was still in operation as it was, which hospital would you prefer ????

And by the way, for your info, it was Dr Alfred Sant that said that Mater Dei is a state of the art.....

Peter Maughan

Oct 11th 2012, 09:43

I think Mr Attard is wrong. Every Parliament needs a Dr Debono and without such a figure Governments can run unchecked. I think the Maltese Parliament will be a poorer place without him.

Eddy Privitera

Oct 11th 2012, 09:53

P.Attard: If you are thinking, or hoping, that GonziPN will be getting ride of Dr. Franco Debono because he won't be in parliament, I believe that you are gravely mistaken. Dr. Debono seems determined to rid GonziPN of the people who have high jacked the party, according to him. He is still fairly young and time is in his favour.

P. Attard

Oct 11th 2012, 11:37

What happens now if labour had to win the next election (most probability) and say Mr. X pretends a ministerial post which is not given to him; he starts stamping his feet against every initiative taken by his party, which probably would have a one-seat majority. What would happen then? Start another never ending charade?

Eddy Privitera

Oct 11th 2012, 09:54

H. Meilak: Kellna l-Mintoff li hada kontra l-gvern u l-partit tieghu fin- 1998. Qatt smajt li qala' xebgha ???

Anthony Falzon

Oct 11th 2012, 10:46

EDDY, MINTOFF MA QALAX XEBA DAK IN NHAR GHAX KIEN GHAD GHANDU IL BULIJIET LABURISTI JIPROTEGUH U GHALEK HADD MA GHAMEL HEKK KONTRA MINTOFF.

H. Meilak

Oct 11th 2012, 14:56

Sur Privitera, mhux ovvja li mhux qed nghid ghal dak iz-zmien jien. Jien qed nghid meta Mintoff kien fl-aqwa tieghu. Kien hemm nies li ma kienu jittolleraw ebda kritika u tinsiex li dawn in-nies l-iktar li ghamlu hsara kien lil partit laburista stess. Ziju tieghu li kien laburist imma kien jirrispetta l-opinjoni ta kulhadd niftakru jghid "dawn in-nies ha jispiccaw ikissruna huma stess."

Tommy Vella

Oct 11th 2012, 08:59

Bħal dak li qallu kulma jagħmel sptar huma s-sodod.

Mela d-dar tiegħi hija sptar għax għandi s-sodod!

Ronnie Callus

Oct 11th 2012, 09:54

Tommy Vella;
Bl-istess argument lanqas li-sptar St.Philip ma' jghamluh is-sodod ghax irid ikun hemm li staff ( tobba) jmexxuh, u dawn hafna minnhom jekk mhux kollha jahdmu f'Mater Dei. Mela allura id-differenza tkun li flok jahdmu f'St.Philip b'dik il-kera fenominali jahdmu f'St.Lukes bit- 12.000,000 euro. Mhux hekk.

Tommy Vella

Oct 11th 2012, 12:13

Apparti l-istaff ,sptar għandu bzon infrastruttura ta' makkinarju, operating theatres, etc li f'St Philip's hemm u f'St Luke's mhemmx.

Tajjeb inwaħħlu bill-board li titkaża li l-pazjenti jkollhom jistennew u meta ssir xi ħaġa biex dan jiġi evitat ingergru.

Eddy Privitera

Oct 11th 2012, 09:59

C. Merciaca; Actually, Mater Dei was Fr. Charles Vella ( a great supporter of the PN) idea. His plan was that the hospital would be run by the italian hospital, San Raffaele in which Fr. Vella was involved.

R. Balzan

Oct 11th 2012, 09:11

@ Maria Camilleri - Franco mhux qed jilghab mas-sahha tal-poplu ghax dik loghba tal-PN. Imma qed ihares l-interessi ta' flusek u flusi.

Maria Camilleri

Oct 11th 2012, 14:11

Mela meta l-gvern jahseb biex jaghti servizzi ahjar fis-sahha lill-poplu ikun qed jilghab bi flusna? X'kont tghid kieku ghamel hekk il-partit laburista? Nahseb li kont taqbel mal-kiri tal-isptar u ma kontx tghid li l-gvern qed jilghab bi flusna.

Alfred Cassar

Oct 10th 2012, 21:28

Mela lbierah is-sur Eddie gerger li fl-isptar Mater Dei m'hemmx sodod bizzejjed.......... u llum igerger ghax il-Gvern se jiehu l-isptar St Philip

Ara veru certu nies twieldu f'din id-dinja propju biex jeqirdu fuq kollox.....lanqas it-tfal zghar ma jaghmlu bhalhom

Joseph Portelli

Oct 10th 2012, 21:45

Ara min qieghed jghid prosit lil Franco!!!!!!!!!! nimmagina li Franco ferhan hafna l-lejla ghax Eddy qallu Prosit (mhux eddie ta'!!!). Dan hu l-istess Eddy li tant hadem biex Malta ma tidholx fl-Unjoni Ewropea; li tant ghadu jahdem biex Malta tohrog mill-Unjoni Ewropea .

Joseph Camilleri

Oct 10th 2012, 22:13

@ eddy privitera

mela la qed tiehu gost b dan nista nistaqsik jekk stajtx taghmel hekk fi zmien mintoff jekk ma tkunx taqbal mieghu?

John Scerri

Oct 11th 2012, 08:22

Ghaziz Eddy Tista ssemmi haga wahda...wahba biss tajba li ghamel dan il gvern? jew tiehu pjacir b'dak kollu li hu kontrih?

Eddy Privitera

Oct 11th 2012, 10:09

Joseph Camilleri: Mela Mintoff qatt kien se jaghmel il-frejjeg li ghamel il_PN fil-kuntratt ta' mater Dei , li jispicca jkollu jibni sptar iehor hdejh, u jikri sptar iehor privat ?!

Eddy Privitera

Oct 11th 2012, 10:14

John Scerri: Tridni nsemmi haga wahda li ghamel tajjeb dan il-gvern mela le. Meta m'accettax li Malta tidhol fil-ftehim dwar it-taxxa fuq transazznjonijiet finanzjarji. Ohra. Is-settur tal- internet gaming u l-Sevizzi Finanzjarji, li l-oppozizzjoni laburista qablet 100% maghhom u kkoperat. Tajjeb hekk ? Issa tista tghidli int xi haga tajba li ghamel il-Labour ?

John Scerri

Oct 12th 2012, 07:36

Mela le ghaziz Eddie : holoq is servizzi socjali , pensjoni minima, vot ghan nisa, edukazjoni sa sittax, paga ugwali ghan nisa u l-irgiel, nehha t-tallaba mit toroq, holoq djar u flats ghal dawk fil bzonn, children's allowances, sahha b'xejn, holoq welfare state Dan kollu kien u ghadu tajjeb.

Imma dan kollu u aktar ghamlu Mintoff BISS u Leader laburista stess ghajru traditur u n-nies emmnuh !

Carmel Serracino-inglott

Oct 10th 2012, 23:46

Just NO . It is for the people and if you are against it like Franco then you are against the welfare of the people.

Ms D. Borg

Oct 11th 2012, 08:00

Those on the 'government bench' have every right to send their children to the school of their choice just like you and me. So let's stop this nit picking once and for all please.

Lawrence Fenech

Oct 10th 2012, 21:12

@Mercieca.

The Mater Dei which took 15 years to build cost 600,000,000 euros instead of 300,000,000 euros. Usually government contracts are given a 5% miscalculation either way i.e. plus or minus.

J. Debono

Oct 11th 2012, 06:58

@ C. Mercieca

Actually Mater Dei was MLP's idea not PN's.

If you remember correctly the PN wanted to keep SLH and buidl the then called San Raffaele, which was going to be a specialized hospital with only 400 beds.

It was Alfred Sant's idea to stop SLH and instead upgrade San Raffaele to a general hospital, and doubled the beds from 400 to 800. The PN continued with MLP's idea.

Brian Gatt

Oct 11th 2012, 08:39

J.Debono,

you are slightly wrong MLP yes changed the plans to upgrade San Raffaele to a general hospital to house up to 1000 beds, then the Pn cam back in Govt and re-changed the plans to have a hospital that can house 600 beds.

That is the difference between the two parties PL is a forward thinking party - if the Original MLP plans were kept we would not be in this situation.

anthony bartolo

Oct 10th 2012, 22:34

Another spoke in the wheel for a change......................any motions please?

Freddie Micallef

Oct 10th 2012, 22:43

what for ..because he is saying the truth?...tell me where he is wrong mr zammit

anthony bartolo

Oct 10th 2012, 22:58

Franco qal ''Taghjthom cans bizzejjed'' ................ u dan minn hu u lill minn ta cans,mela hu mhux pati mill gvern.?...........jew mill opposizzjoni ghax issa qed nithawwad.

Mr Anthony Briffa

Oct 11th 2012, 08:21

As soon as Dr. Gonzi blows the whistle there goes Dr. Franco Debono and all his heroic motions against his own party and will become political history. Fr. Debono is very conveniently forgetting that he was elected on the PN ticket and the votes he received are votes which belong to the PN party. I am sure that the PN supporters who voted Dr. Louis Galea feel cheated now after voting in Dr. Debono.

Eddy Privitera

Oct 10th 2012, 21:07

Andrea Sammut: Miskin il-poplu Malti li dan il-gvern ghabbieh diga b'aktar mid-dobbju tad-dejn nazzjonali li kien hemm qabel. U qed ikompli jzid ir-rata b'dawn il-kuntratti bl-addocc !

Joseph Borg

Oct 10th 2012, 23:02

I agree perfectly with you.

Mr Anthony Briffa

Oct 11th 2012, 09:48

Did you forget Privitera when your friend KMB employed 8,500 persons with the government and para statal bodies before the 1987 election from which we are still suffering their expenditure contribution in the deficit? Did you forget the continuous drain of public funds that went into the drydocks and malta shipyards because of the militancy that governed the goings there? Hallina Privitera.

Mr Joseph Galea

Oct 10th 2012, 21:49

I think you meant obviously. It seems you are oblivious of the meaning of the word obliviously. And the government will fall down from where? For whom are you writing jb?

Freddie Micallef

Oct 10th 2012, 22:44

naqbel perfettament mieghek

R. Saliba

Oct 10th 2012, 20:22

and how do you know how much it will cost?

Ray Buhagiar

Oct 10th 2012, 20:23

Are you aware that buying medical equipment for St.Lukes will cost more than 12 million euros.

Martin Saliba

Oct 10th 2012, 20:54

It was your goverment who went against the peoples health when they designed and built a hospital smaller than what we had when that was allready getting to be to small . Some might say they did not know what they were doing . In my opinion they knew very well what they were doing . Now it is time to reap the rewards of what seemed to be incompitence but was not

Eddy Privitera

Oct 10th 2012, 21:09

J.Busuttil Li qed jitlob Franco hu li jsir skrutinju serju indipendenti mill-Awditur Generali u l-parlament halli l-poplu jinghata sodisfazzjon dwar dan il-kuntratt ta' tant miljuni. Jaqaw int ma tixtieqx tkun taf l-affarijiet sarux sewwa jew le ?

J Busuttil

Oct 10th 2012, 21:33

@ Martin Saliba

It seems you forgot that Labour had two years in government whilst the hospital was in construction, and the plans were even amended. No problem keep on moaning about the bed spaces l-aqwa il- Labour jghid le ghall kollox.

If (God forbid) you or your family need to be hospitalised and no bed is available than you will realise that you and all who agree with you were wrong.

Jana Vella

Oct 10th 2012, 20:08

Who told you St. Luke's is empty??? Just pay a short visit there and you'll see several wards still housing elderly people!!!

J Busuttil

Oct 10th 2012, 20:09

@ Mark Piscopo


I thought you are more intelligent. Don't you know that most of the equipment was transferred to Mater Dei. Some of the equipment is worth more than 12 million to purchase. Grow up.

J Zammit

Oct 11th 2012, 07:38

jekk hemm bzonn, hemm bzonn...
jien nixtieq li l'MUNM ikollha is soddod kollha li ghanda bzonn... imma bi prezz ragonevoli u mhux nispiccaw inhalsu kera fuq post li jiswa daqs il kera li ser inhalsu

Mr Albert Dimech

Oct 10th 2012, 20:00

Minn qallek li dan ser isolvi l-waiting lists meta dan ser ikun għar-rijabilitzzjoni u mhux spar akut?

R. Saliba

Oct 10th 2012, 20:23

Mr Dimech, hwo many operations were cancelled this year due to shortage of beds?

Advert
Advert