Advert

Conflicting opinions on timing of election call

‘He feels a duty to complete his mandate’

Top PN strategists are advising the Prime Minister to postpone the election until after the Budget, despite pressure from some quarters to put an end to the uncertainty caused by rebel MPs.

If Franco Debono wants an early election, he will have to vote for it. Why should the Prime Minister do the job for him?

Rumours are rife within both political parties that an election could be called in the coming week, but sources said Lawrence Gonzi’s advisers are telling him otherwise.

They want parliamentary procedure to take its course on the motions against Transport Minister Austin Gatt, much in the same way as when MPs Franco Debono and Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando contributed to the unseating of Justice Minister Carm Mifsud Bonnici and EU Ambassador Richard Cachia Caruana earlier this year.

This would show Dr Gonzi was treating his Cabinet members equally, and would dismiss claims that he was prepared to tie the vote against Dr Gatt into a confidence vote in the Government.

Crucially, however, this strategy would also allow the Government to present a Budget in November, as planned.

Dr Debono and Dr Pullicino Orlando are more likely to back the Budget with Dr Gatt out of the picture, a scenario which would give Dr Gonzi even more time to call an election.

“Dr Gonzi had already said he wants Austin Gatt to step down and work on the PN’s election campaign,” sources told The Sunday Times, indicating that the Prime Minister might already have a plan to replace the seasoned minister.

“The ball is in Dr Gonzi’s court and he might choose to do otherwise. But considering his past decisions, he has shown himself to be very cool-headed. He feels a duty to complete his mandate.”

Presenting the Budget and getting it approved would be seen by some PN insiders as a feather in Dr Gonzi’s cap, since it would show voters he managed to run the country smoothly till the end of the legislature, despite the crisis in government.

Conversely, if Dr Gonzi were to call the election imminently, it would prove he was unable to serve his full term. The absence of a Budget would also instil doubt in people’s minds about the real state of the economy.

“The Budget will show that the economy was managed excellently, despite all this strife,” sources said.

Ironically, voting down the Budget could put the spotlight on the Labour Opposition, which would be prematurely forced to unveil its economic plans for the country, one top official said.

Going for a November election would also ensure a near-certain landslide defeat for the PN at the polls.

But even though postponing the election until late January or February could give the PN more chance to recoup thousands of lost votes, some party members, including certain key Cabinet members, do not think this strategy is sustainable.

“Dr Gatt would be the third lost Cabinet member. Who will be next?” asked one Cabinet source.

Although the motion against Dr Gatt is similar to the one against Dr Mifsud Bonnici, many Nationalists believe they should be dealt with differently.

With Health Minister Joe Cassar also in Dr Debono’s line of fire, pressure is mounting on the Prime Minister to pull the plug now instead of continuing to limp towards the Budget, with ministers potentially falling by the wayside.

“Parliament has been hijacked and so has the national mood. No one is talking about Government’s performance anymore but about when the election is going to be held,” a Cabinet source said, adding that the motions of no confidence were also hampering the Government’s job of passing crucial legislation such as the IVF and cohabitation Bills and the Bill to abolish theatre censorship.

Meanwhile, the business community is feeling the brunt of the instability.

But another Cabinet source ruled out calling an election before the Budget, saying that the Government should not do Dr Debono’s dirty work.

“If Debono wants an early election, he will have to vote for it. Why should the Prime Minister do the job for him?”

Tomorrow, the Speaker is likely to be asked to decide the way forward after the Opposition presented its motions of adjournment.

Advert

64 Comments

Post comment

Please see our new Comments Policy

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

For more details please see our Comments Policy

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Christopher Ripard

Oct 7th 2012, 23:42

No successes?

What about MCAST, Uni, a new oncology centre, a new power station, new roads, record tourism, keeping Malta afloat in a huge recession, controlling our waste streams, including treating all sewage, blue flag beaches, huge international respect, especially over the Libyan crisis, huge expansion in the aviation services industry . . . a "bad" PN administration does 10 times more good than Labour ever did - but that's not difficult.

"Meditate gente, meditate"

A Trapani

Oct 7th 2012, 21:53

"It seems a Deja Vu of 1987 with the difference that this time its the PN not labour and will not be just 5000 votes that make the difference" ..... That's not the only difference though.... In 1987 the new government inherited a destroyed country in a disastrous state with a mess in education, complete mismanagement, corruption, poverty, discrimination and a nation of beggars, this time, Joseph will inherit a completely changed and developed country.

joseph borg st john

Oct 7th 2012, 21:06

Like it or not you have to wait . GONZI will tell you when no one else.

Schembri Ray

Oct 7th 2012, 18:13

And the labour called it 3 years before!

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 9th 2012, 08:50

@ Schemdri Ray.

Labour called a general election "three years before" only because it had no choice left, after it had miscalculated and after losing a vote of no confidence of its own creation!

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 7th 2012, 17:55

@ John Zammit, today at 15:02.

One does not exclude the other. In our recent history, the Nationalist Party has been so frequently successful in winning one general election after another precisely because the Malta electorate decided democratically that the interest of the nation coincided with the election of a Nationalist Party government.

And that is true whether it is typed in Caps Lock or not.

carmel cassar

Oct 7th 2012, 18:44

Do you rearly have any doubts?

Cornelius Murphy

Oct 7th 2012, 19:06

When you look at what Labour have on offer (no plans, no policies and a bunch of old dinosaurs from the '70s and '80s) and compare that with the way Dr. Gonzi is steering the country successfully, against all odds, through a terrible economic crisis, you soon realise that the interest of the nation is to have PN in government. Things might be different if there were an alternative, but there isn't.

Joseph Mifsud

Oct 8th 2012, 02:09

@ Cornelius

You said that the PN lead the country successfully through the crisis. Please mention one manouvre PN adopted to secure the country against the crisis.

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 9th 2012, 08:45

One cannot reasonably hope that a country be run "smoothly" when the whole world is passing through a an international financial turmoil. The most that one can reasonably hope is to weather the storm as well as the other countries. Malta has been credited by international agencies with coping better than most. That is a well-deserved accolade from neutral observers with no axe to grind.

Alfred Vassallo

Oct 7th 2012, 15:54

And pray John Zammit -PH.D. Tell us all what do you know of BANKRUPTCY and economic disasters considering that you have NEVER been IN or OUT of goverment?

John Zammit Ph.D.

Oct 7th 2012, 16:49

Alfred Vassallo, I don't have to be in government because I experienced bankruptcy when there was Alfred Sant in government. That was the worst Labour Government and that is why I left Labour for good.

stephen koludrovic

Oct 7th 2012, 11:21

I do not think that FD is there to do anybody any favours. He is just doing what in his own opinion he thinks is right.

fredu debono

Oct 7th 2012, 11:42

yes sure and we get rid of him. get rid of this jealous guy called FRANCO DEBONO>

Joseph Vassallo, (Bugibba)

Oct 7th 2012, 12:00

Tad-dahq ir-riferenza ghal "vaganzi kollha" ghal kemm dam wieqaf il-parlament.

Li kont minnek Ronnie, niccekkja ftit id-djarju tal- ministri u l-prim ministru u nara kemm hadu "dawk il-vaganzi kollha" ghax sa fejn stajt nara jien, ix-xoghol baqa' ghaddej avolja ma' kienx hemm tlablib u battibekki fil-parlament.

Minhix cert imma ghandujkun il-prim ministru xi tlett ijiem ha break. Dawn anki l-Hdud u l-festi jahdmu imma ghandujkun, l-kotra tahseb li min jahdem bil-fies biss ikun qieghed ghax-xoghol; dawk li jahdmu b'mohhom mhux xoghol ikunu qed jghamlu imma jkunu irposati.

Ara ftit l-attivitajiet tul "il-vaganzi kollha" u inkludi anki dawk ta' Franco Debono u Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando ghax anki dawk ma' qaghdux b'idejhom fuq zaqqhom.

Paul Bajada

Oct 7th 2012, 11:16

indeed. he may simply want to be the longest serving PM without parliamentary majority in the history of Maltese politics.

Biker Man

Oct 7th 2012, 16:04

You have a point here BUT
Wouldn't you, me and all of the people commenting here opt for the second option if we were in his position?
Be honest now.

Ronnie Callus

Oct 7th 2012, 10:45

Well said Ethelbert. Probably they do not know maths because even in projects contracts they say one think and results another. ( Money no Problem)

Joe Felice-Pace

Oct 7th 2012, 10:54

According to constitutional practice, a government loses its right to govern - and therefore has to resign - when it is defeated in the House of Representatives on a motion that implies confidence. As far as I know, this has not happened as yet.

Ronnie Callus

Oct 7th 2012, 11:12

@ Joe Felice Pace:
Of course it does not happened ! But you should know why. This is because Dr.Gonzi is always delaying the vote to be taken. He is more interested in his seat than our country.

fredu debono

Oct 7th 2012, 11:43

jekk jispiccaw kollha l-ministri FRANCO DEBONO xorta ma jsirx ministru ghax jekk ikun se jsir hu mmur jien.

J Busuttil

Oct 7th 2012, 11:38

@ Lawrence Fenech

Always mentioning instability, when you decide to mention it again give us an example.

Fran Abela

Oct 7th 2012, 10:37

Cling to power my foot. Dr. Gonzi has the majority of the people's mandate to complete his term in office. I just cannot understand why you will not understand this. When the time comes if the majority of the Maltese electorate decide to vote in the PL as the next government then so be it, in the meantime just have some more patience Mr. Brincat. Why the rush ? Maybe it is the PL who is so eager to be in power at all costs ?

K. Vella II

Oct 7th 2012, 11:05

@Fran Abela

"Dr. Gonzi has the majority of the people's mandate to complete his term in office."

How are you so sure? Has there been an election since this tragicomedy started?

Alfred Falzon

Oct 7th 2012, 11:21

@ Fran Abela

Did you think likewise when the late Dom Mintoff took to task Sant's mismanagement and arrogance?

Power at all costs is liable to backfire!

Alfred A. Falzon

Jeffrey Mallia

Oct 7th 2012, 12:15

@ Fran Abela........did you have the same opinion in 1998 ??

Antonella Briffa

Oct 7th 2012, 11:49

"U x'jigi jekk fil-budget ikun hemm hafna mizuri li jkomplu jfallu lill-Malta halli gvern Laburista jiret dik is-sitwazzjoni? "

Mhux ahjar tizen sew dak li tkun ser tghid Maria? Kumment tad dahk jiddispjacini nghidlek! Ninsabu ferm ahjar min pajjizi ohra, pero l-importanti huwa li tirrepetu d-diskorsi bi kliem ovju tal PL, imma minghajr l-ebda ideat konkreti. Apparti, ghaliex ma tilluminanix bil proposti tant tajbin ghal Malta taghna li ghandu l Gvern Gdid? Jekk lanqas gharrafna bi proposta wahda, allura kif ezatt ghandna navdaw lil PL fil gvern? Kif , jew ahjar, JEKK il PL jiddeciedi jaqsam maghna xi pjan hejja ghal Malta, allura hemmhekk itini ghazla li nivvutalu.

Advert
Advert