Recover, recycle and reuse
Many believe that Dom Mintoff’s demise marks an end of an era. I think not. The past is a mirror of the future and if Labour continues recycling expired components, its economic and financial policies will lead Malta to bankruptcy.
Muscat’s insistence a couple of years ago for the Government to copy Cyprus’s economic road map reinforces my argument.
The statistics of the World Competitiveness Report of the World Economic Forum published this month show that, of 139 countries, Malta has climbed from 50th place to 47th whereas Cyprus has slipped from 40th to 58th place.
This alone confirms that Muscat and his sidekicks simply have no idea how the economy works and they had better stick to what they know best: bluffing.
Moreover, the legacy Labour hopefuls bequeathed still haunt us till this very day.
Many of them operated under Mintoff and Karmenu Mifsud Bonnici and we have already had a taste of their high-handed politics. Others served under Alfred Sant’s short-lived government between 1996 and 1998.
Labour has tried to change its image but it can never change . It is hereditary. It is what old, new and newer Labour is made of. Revisiting the miserable track record of Labour’s future Cabinet of ministers will confirm my point.
The aspiring Minister of Finance is 62-year-old Leo Brincat. He is a smooth, calculating and controlled politician. His reputation was irreversibly tarnished when his name appeared on the infamous racist Facebook group although he has since withdrawn it.
Serving as Minister of Finance and Commerce under Sant he gained three memorable credits to his name – the honour of introducing 33 new taxes in 22 months, the removal of VAT and the hotchpotch he made of the ‘new’ fiscal system CET.
Everyone but Labour knew that CET was a non-starter and Sant confirmed it when, on national television, lost for words, he was at sea when trying to explain the ins and outs of the system.
Another Labour guy, so much in the political spotlight at the moment, is 63-year-old Karmenu Vella.
This old hand is writing Labour’s electoral manifesto and it remains a mystery why the task was not bestowed upon a young, fresh and forward-looking individual.
Twenty-eight years ago he was Minister for Industry under Mintoff and, later, Minister for Tourism under Sant. Describing Mintoff’s era as “the golden years”, he will have us forget that, thanks to his dismal record as Minister for Industry, Malta registered an unsurpassed record of unemployment, reaching the 10,000 mark. And this when there was no world recession!
Heaven forbid he is ever allowed to ruin what this Administration has struggled so much to achieve.
Suffice to say that during the current global financial crisis, the Nationalist government has created 20,000 new jobs and Malta and Germany are the only countries whose unemployment rate is lower than it was before the international financial and economic crisis.
Another 60-year-old Labour guru, championing education, is Evarist Bartolo who comes over asa cool, calm and moderate gentleman hardly ever showing his true self: a veritable Oscar winner for performing in sheep’s clothing.
He served as Minister for Education and Natural Culture under Sant and was the culprit who converted student stipends into a burden to be paid back to the Government in full.
Quite a far cry from the annual €23 million the Nationalist government grants students today with no strings attached.
It is futile for Labour to promise that it will not meddle with stipends again because if it broke its promise so blatantly in 1996 what guarantee do we have that it will not do so again?
Bear in mind that Edward Scicluna, Labour MEP, another would-be Finance Minister, has already publicly argued against the sustainability of students’ stipends and free health. Worse still, he is going around endorsing and promoting Mintoff’s take on economic growth, as in state control, restricted imports, ministerial interference, quotas, bulk buying, military labour corps etc. Shudders and shivers.
Another 62-year-old spring chicken is Labour’s international secretary, Alex Sceberras Trigona, who, is guilty of having shamefully signed a ‘top secret’ military agreement with North Korea's genocidal dictatorship when he was Minister for Foreign Affairs in 1982. We can only wait and see whether he will trip up the staunch anti-EU 70-year-old campaigner, former Labour deputy leader George Vella, and pinch the Foreign Affairs Minister’s post.
There are also many others vying for a ministry but heaven help Muscat if he leaves the two younger boys in waiting – Jason Micallef and Silvio Parnis, the Minister for the South to be, out of his new Cabinet.
Both have sworn that Labour will be a government for Labourites with Micallef already threatening to expel a leading popular presenter from PBS and Parnis assuring supporters that Labour already has a plan in place of what jobs the ‘red’-eyed boys were going to get.
Likewise, the future Minister for Gozo, Justyne Caruana, who compared Labour’s opponents to “snakes” not belonging to Labour’s “family”, warned that a Labour Government will be a government for Labourites. Hisssss!
And these people are still in the Opposition. Imagine what they will do if they are ever in power!
History has a habit of repeating itself and instead of Muscat’s promised new ‘mature’ political season we are lumped with a second-hand superficial, intimidating and hostile Labour gang of dinosaurs and wannabes desperate for power.
Malta deserves far better.
10 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
andrew falzon
Sep 29th 2012, 11:29
Kull meta naqra il- kummenti ta BS nisthajjilha bhall dak il- bniedem li qieghed f` nofs ocean qed jghereq u jipprova jaqbad ma kull tibna biex jipprova isalva. Infakkru lill qarrejja li BS tahdem mal-partit nazzjonalista u il- hobza taghha tiddependi mil partit li ikun fil gvern allura fl- interess taghha li titfa kemm jista ikun hmieg lejn il- PL. Issa lill Berta u lill martinelli, li irid jikkummenta fuq l affarijiet interni ta pajjizna meta hu ilu li emigra lejn il- Canada min 1960s ( meta il- partit tieghu stess kien halla lill maltin fil guh u l-injoranza) infakkarhom jekk ghadhom ma intebhux li il- kritika harxa lejn il- pn gejja mhux minn naha tal pl izda minn fost id-deputati parlamentari u ex ministri tal pn, infakkarkhom ukoll li il- pl tant inbidel u kullhadd qed ihossu komdu li jghamel parti minnu, li sahansitra nazzjonalisti kbar li kienu tal qalba qed jinghaqdu mal pl. Jekk ghadkhom ma indunajtux, fil granet li gejjin ser jinghaqad iehor mal pl u sahansitra ser jibda itella programm ta diskussjoni fuq is-super1 TV!!! Musmar iehor fit tebut ta gonzipn!!
@ j martinelli & serracino inglott
Halli infakkarkhom ftit fil hnizrijiet tal pn u ghalfejn issa xebbajtu lill kullhadd.
5 Biljuni dejn fil kaxxa ta Malta, l- enemalta hija monopolju f` pajjizna u xorta fallejtuha u ghandha EUR600 miljun dejn, seamalta fallejtuha u ghalaqtuha, Airmalta fallejtuha bil hnizrijiet u decizjonijiet hziena li hadtu u li swew il-miljuni kbar f` telf, transport malta falluta u b` xeba problemi ma l- EU, kemm fis sezzjoni ta l- avjazzjoni kif ukoll f` tal marittima, ir-riforma fit transport pubbliku kienet flop kbira, renewable energy ma tezistix minkejja il weghdi tal windfarms, l- skandlu tal powerstation tal BWSC li tahdem bl- iktar fuel li ihammeg (@ martinelli, filwaqt li il- kanadizi qed inaqqsu id-dipendenza mill HFO!!), EUR 500 zieda li il- prim ta lilu innifsu u lill shabu il- ministri filwaqt li lill poplu bellalu kontijiet gholjin taddawl, prezz gholi tal gass u xeba taxxi, il-korruzzjoni li kien hemm fil bini ta l- sptar il- gdid, id-djun li akkumulaw entitajiet tal gvern bhall freeport, transport malta u mepa etc etc etc.
Joseph John Camilleri
Sep 29th 2012, 16:27
Dawk iz-zmienijiet ghaddew biex ma jerghux jigu.
Tony Camilleri
Sep 28th 2012, 11:22
The more you write this nonsense the more we shall make sure to give the N the order of the boot.
Guido Farrugia
Sep 28th 2012, 11:22
Malta deserves far better.
So be it Berta. Yes in due time.
G. Bugeja
Sep 28th 2012, 10:33
The people are fed up of hearing and reading nonsense. It is a well known fact that despite of what modern economists or those who pretend to be economists say, under Mintoff's economy our Country had moved forward in all aspects of life. Social services were introduced, two thirds pension to all workers, pension for the disabled, flat increase to all workers, introduction of the national minimum wage, bonus, free health service, free eduction and other services were introduced. Further to that, in 1987, when the PN took over, Malta had no debt whatsoever, but instead Malta had a reserve amount of more than 500 million Maltese liri. Apart from political advantaces that gave Malta and the Maltese an identity, which Malta lost during these last years. Everybody has the right to write what he likes, but the facts are there and r emain there, whether you like it or not.
Joseph E Briffa
Sep 28th 2012, 11:29
@ G bugeja......Everybody has the right to write what he likes, you say. Yes that right was given back to the Maltese by Eddie Fenech Adami, after it had been completely denied for 16 long years by the successive Labour governments. So even you ought to be grateful for this. You say that Mintoff gave Malta and the Maltese an identity; indeed he did but for the wrong reason. North Korea has an identity, because of Kim-il-Sung and his descendants who treat their people like chattels.
Tommy Vella
Sep 28th 2012, 12:22
What good did those 500 million in the kitty do us? He was like a head of the family who hoards money in the bank leaving his children foodless, clothesless ...
500 million in the kitty and a worse than second hand telephone system, a power station belching smoke, no goods in the shops to buy (unless of inferior quality), no water in the tap, a lot of holes with some road around them, a university for a few hundred students at most, ...
Mr ALBERT LEONE GANADO
Sep 28th 2012, 10:31
Economics may not be your forte dear Berta but even reading a primer will tell you that the current predicament of Cyprus is due to the economic disintegration of Greece. God forbid but if Italy or the UK had to have a similar economic meltdown we would be in a much worse economic situation than Cyprus. Perhaps you may also want to reflect on how Iceland although still out of the EU and unlikely now to join has managed to recover much quicker than any country in the EU.
I am sure that the PL government will be one based on justice and equity not one like a local version of Orwell's animal farm were a few fat cats and pigs get richer whilst the worker and middle class get poorer. Can you deny that the income concertina has scandalously widened over the last decade. If we do not vote this trend out we will end up like the USA where ten per cent of the population own 90 per cent of wealth.
J Martinelli
Sep 28th 2012, 14:15
Mr Ganado, has it escaped your attention that Cyprus is an independent country and is responsible for its own economic policies?
If Cyprus' predicament is Greece's near bankruptcy, can Malta not argue the same way since the major countries it trades with are as hard pressed as Greece? And yet, Cyprus' economy would gladly be at par with Malta's.
What is in Maltese DNA which automatically self-inflicts unnecessary criticism of its own accomplishments?
"I am sure that the PL government will be one based on justice and equity..." Justice and equity? Are you sure you're not confusing 'frame-ups', 'false allegations', 'University courses of a minister's choice' and 'under the table land deals', with 'justice and equity'? Or is it 'equality' you mean?
Is the Labour Party itself confusing 'equality' with 'equity'? Not surprising since its 'young and forward-looking' stars have such a poor command of the English language.
Carmel Serracino-inglott
Sep 28th 2012, 15:08
Mr ALG,
Whilst BS has stated the truth as I know it you did not convince me with your arguments. To vote LP is playing with fire which burns. The people that BS mentioned all were alive, during the great oh so great Mintoffianeconomics , and surely kicking and be sure they are still kicking . The work of this government is all there for everyone to see but the work of the old guard of labour has to be mentioned Many of the people are still the same. It is our sacrosanct duty to refresh the minds of people who do not 'talk' politics . Beware the old labour is still very much alive despite new clothing. And by the way why are they ashamed of what has been done?
Please choose the reason of your report below: