Government considering autumn trapping derogation for golden plover and song thrush - FKNK
File photo.
The government is considering the application of a derogation to permit autumn/winter trapping of the golden plover and song thrush, as recommended by the Ornis Committee, the Prime Minister told hunters.
In a statement, the hunters’ federation, FKNK, said a delegation of its top officials, led by president Joe Perici Calascione, had a meeting with Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi and Environment Minister Mario De Marco.
The meeting focused on hunting and trapping issues, particularly the application of a derogation to open an autumn/winter trapping season.
FKNK reiterated their opinion, as expressed during the Ornis Committee meeting, that such a derogation could be applied to permit trapping for the seven finch species.
The Prime Minister, however, referred to the reasoned opinion that Malta received in relation to the application of past trapping derogations and said the government was solely considering the application of a derogation to permit trapping on the golden plover and the song thrush, as recommended by the Ornis Committee, the FKNK said.
The meeting also discussed other topics, including spring hunting, fixed autumn/winter hunting seasons, CABS and 'drones', the Majjistral Park, close-rings for captive bred birds, wild rabbit hunting and trapping, the carnet de chasse and law enforcement.
73 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Pippo De Marco
Sep 21st 2012, 14:21
This government says that it is 'Considering' this issue. Yeah, of course it is ... NOT !
If GonziPN acted on everything it considered then that would indicate that it 'listens' to the people - Yeah, As if !
Mr Eric Camilleri
Sep 21st 2012, 10:39
Il-Pn dejjem hadem ghall-elezzjoni biss!
Il-poplu ibghati ghal 4 snin u mbghad l-ahhar sena jibdew gejjin id-diskussjonijiet!!
Issa ser tifthu l-istagun??? Ilhom 4 snin jistennewk Dr.Gonzi!!
Ara kemm gejjin cameras u ritratti jekk dejjem jintlahaq ftheim! Nahseb lanqas l-akbar top model ma' hadet ritratti daqskhom matul dawn l-4 snin!
M. Bezzina
Sep 21st 2012, 10:31
People trapping for the birds and Dr.gonzi trapping the people for their votes
M. Bezzina
Sep 21st 2012, 10:30
Eelection on the approach...
Joe Scerri
Sep 21st 2012, 10:13
Ah, votes , votes and even more votes. Rememeber you gain some , you lose many......
OMAR SAMMUT
Sep 21st 2012, 10:02
Tghid fadal cwiec jemmnu dawn l-affarijiet?F hames snin issa kellu ftit cans jiltaqa ma tal-FKNK ghax waslet l-elezzjoni.Possibli insewa l-ittra ta qabel l-elezzjoni li kien bghat Eddie Fenech Adami.Jien zgur ma nsejtiex u nispera li il-kaccaturi u in-nassaba ma nsewiex l-anqas.Nispera ukoll li l-FKNK taf x qed tamel,tiddiskuti ma gvern li fadallu ftif xhur,forsi kumbinazzjoni?
Victor Calleja
Sep 21st 2012, 09:37
Gonzi jaf ikun nassab aktar min nassaba tal gojjini.
Johnny Xerri
Sep 21st 2012, 10:39
imma issa l gojjini wara 4 snin saru tal post...hraxu u mhux la kemm jamel qelba...it tahrik ul ajat drawh
Mark Ellul
Sep 21st 2012, 08:21
Il poplu m ghadux fidil.. Issa kullhadd jafa din ic cajta sur gonzi.. Nanseb Amilt zball missejt Dan l argument..
ruth klotzer
Sep 21st 2012, 08:09
Is the election near by any chance???
Charles Grima
Sep 21st 2012, 08:05
Jaqbadni d-dahk nara l-kummenti ta kaccaturi (nassumi Laburisti!!!), li qed jahsbu li la (jekk) jitilghu tal-lejber, jiftah il kacca is sena kollha!
U ma tarawx! U ma tarawx!
98% tal popolazzjoni temmen li ghanda tispicca l-kacca....
Johnny Xerri
Sep 21st 2012, 10:48
nobody believes that hunting will be permitted all year round...
but then again nobody believes that we are getting the maximum allowable as per the EU birds directive.
and everybody (including hunters) knows that the PL will give hunters the max allowable under EU legislation.
what makes me laugh is that PN supporters believe that all hunters are laburisti...just mentioing my family & nephews, uncles , cousins...well PN lost 37 tesserati...(mine & my dad's, my 9 uncles, 13 cousins, 6 cousins children, 7 nephews)...plus the rest of the family will amount to around 100 votes...plus we use to rally in a lot of votes from disgrantled PN supporters especially hunters...just one family may effect a minimum of 300-350 votes
u ma tarawx! u ma tarawx! li ser nergaw nivutaw lil min sawatna...issa jivutaw tal birdlife ul bella compania
Emanuel Muscat
Sep 21st 2012, 11:05
Nassumi li 98% hija naqra vojta siehbi!!
Brian Grech
Sep 21st 2012, 15:52
Mr Xerri intom il-kaccturi ma tikbru qatt elezzjoni wara elezzjoni tirrikattaw!! Nassigurak li jekk hemm numru kbir ta kaccaturi u l-familjari taghhom li huma ta rikatt ghal votida daqstant iehor u ferm aktar hemm ambjentalisti.Politicians KEEP THAT IN MIND!!!!
Johnny Xerri
Sep 21st 2012, 19:27
Mr Grech,
hunters are not bluff...infact last election I personally collected and posted the votes to PN Headquarters...on the otherhand the environemntalists have never acted likewise or elected an MP from alternativa demokratika...and neither have they elected an MEP from PN or AD who had anti hunting candidates.
Hunters have tried for years to hold talks with the govt...hunters have been reasonable by demanding only what is inline with EU legislation...but if the govt does not listen...then its the recieving end who is at fault and not the voter...and a chance was given as duing the last election we posted the votes...govt did not listen...so this time round vote PL...simple
J Scicluna
Sep 21st 2012, 07:11
Even if LG is honest, which I personally doubt, it is too little, too late.
Recalling written promises and guarantees by himself and other from within the PN on a regular pre election basis I never did and will never beleive a word of what these 'servants of the maltese people' will promise.
You kept calling for help when the wolf was not around just for the fun of it, now that he is around look for help elsewhere.
Bunch of liars, promises and bla bla bla.
Mr Alexander Azzopardi
Sep 21st 2012, 01:02
Government considering autumn trapping derogation for golden Votes!
D. Xerri
Sep 21st 2012, 00:38
Government considering autumn trapping derogation for golden plover and song thrush !
Aaaaah Really :~) ..... and Why Now :~) ?
What a Power Hungry Government - All he sees is VOTES !
louis scicluna
Sep 20th 2012, 23:59
IL- Gvern qied jonsob lin-nassaba. HA HA HAJ. U halluna.
Ivan Calleja
Sep 20th 2012, 23:46
Xi hmieg ta' politika!!!!
Mario Camilleri
Sep 20th 2012, 23:45
Fool me once, shame on me. Fool me twice, shame on you!
Francis Raeymaekers
Sep 20th 2012, 23:23
Desperate times call for desperate measures. This lot are well past their sell by date.
Jean Paul Galea
Sep 20th 2012, 21:15
Another derogation another lost vote malta is not only made of hunters.
Johnny Xerri
Sep 21st 2012, 11:37
but only hunter pose a credible threat...
just ask yourself...what success has the PN had with its self declared anti hunting MEPS...remember edward demicoli and alan deidun?
what success has alternative democratica ever had?
people vote according to priorities...hunters have hunting as top priority...antis have the love of birds as mid or bottom priority since they consider other issues as top priority.
Steve Zammit
Sep 21st 2012, 21:56
Halli minnek Johny I put birds and environemnt as top priority...so simple I don't vote PL
Charles Grixti
Sep 20th 2012, 21:00
The PN has become a whore for votes.
Johnny Xerri
Sep 22nd 2012, 19:19
Just to lighten up the argument...I wouldn't go that far...it would be rather an eyesore to see the likes of the PM & AUgostino Pio in a mini and leather boots...all spiced up!!!!
Peter Midler
Sep 20th 2012, 20:54
Goverment beware! Birdkillers have votes, but bird lovers and other decent people have votes too.....just in case you do not know!!
Johnny Xerri
Sep 21st 2012, 11:32
Mr Midler...the question being...who uses his vote on this issue...the hunter or the anti...
if antis use their vote on this issue...then why did alternativa democratica always tally no more than 2 pence of votes...
the governemnt should not have middled with anything that would attract it more losses than gains.
Jay Oatmon
Sep 20th 2012, 20:35
This small bird in a very small cage says it all for me - solitary confinement for life just because his captor believes he 'owns' this wild bird.
Mario Nicholas Pace
Sep 20th 2012, 20:05
As usual election seems near so votes are important . I s the European union so powerless that it keeps on letting these injustices continue?
Johnny Xerri
Sep 20th 2012, 20:35
No Mr Pace, the EU is not powerless...but simply unconcerned unless the Birds Directive is not complied with.
In otherwords....unless the seasons violate the EU legislation you have to live with them
D Borg
Sep 20th 2012, 19:52
my family's vote..............Alternattiva the Greens
Johnny Xerri
Sep 20th 2012, 20:33
so instead of the usual 2 pence of votes they will have 2.5 pence this time round!!!
M. Cardona
Sep 20th 2012, 21:53
As if you had ever considered otherwise!
J Vella
Sep 20th 2012, 22:13
and with your votes they will bring two quotas
M. Cardona
Sep 21st 2012, 07:38
D Borg, as if you ever considered otherwise!
Mr l Azzopardi
Sep 21st 2012, 10:12
not only yours david
Anthony A. Mifsud
Sep 20th 2012, 19:40
I happen to be a trapper, but I will never forgive what this heartless Govt did to all my fiends both trappers and hunters, Issa iried jinhabb
Sur Gonzipn, you too much floops , now it's too little to late....
Il hsrra sartt
Ninu
anthony sultana
Sep 20th 2012, 19:36
I have news for you PN, remember 2008 election, you won it with spring hunting close, but this time you are going to loose it with hunting for all the year around.You keep forgeting the people that love nature.
Darren Micallef
Sep 20th 2012, 21:33
Riddle of the year. Hear hear people, hunters are the people that love nature. That is why they shoot them, illegally or not!
Johnny Xerri
Sep 21st 2012, 11:28
hunting all year round...???
and didn't pn lose it with hunting as usual in 1996?
and didn't they win it with hunting open in 2003
PN will lose the elcetion because they applease the wrong sector...because of corruption (which proven or not...only fools don't acknowledge), because of the €500 / week salary increase,...plus plus plus
when seasons are banned the govt looses votes...when seasons are opened the govt does not loose votes...hunters do vote with hunting as a top priority....antis do not...proof is that if they did Alternative Democratica would tally more than 2 pence worth of votes
s grima
Sep 20th 2012, 19:34
@ lin nasaba u kacaturi issa ergew ivutawlu ha jkompli ..........
Michael Manduca
Sep 20th 2012, 19:32
People are put in jail for committing a crime. These poor birds are put in jail for nothing. Bird trapping should be totally abolished.
How about trapping a human (one of these bird trappers preferably) and putting him in a 7'x7'x7' cage and hear him swearing his life away? Then we'll take him to Valletta in the cage, for a belgha te' u pastizz, and compare his swearing to the swearing of other trapped humans.
The trapped birds don't whistle for enjoyment but because of their frustration and suffering. AND THESE PEOPLE CALL THEMSELVES BIRD LOVERS. How utterly stupid.
Johnny Xerri
Sep 20th 2012, 19:27
It is imperative to note the ignorance re conservation that some people mirror.
The golden plover and song thursh as legal game in many EU member states examples being, Cyprus, Greece, Italy, Spain, UK (plover not thrush), Ireland (plover not thrush), France.
So can anyone explain to me...please enlighten us...what will be different if another country targets these species....especially when this country is not on any migratory route and only encounters a small proportion of the migration that results only due to prevailing weather conditions.
My heart bleeds for your plea...yet nobody bats an eyelid when virgin land is transformed into a concrete jungle...at Zebbug Gozo, an area known as Saghtrija has been raped...untill a few years ago dispite hunters hunting there, there were a couple of breeding BLUE ROCK THRUSH...Malta's national bird...go there today...there is a hotel sized block of luxury appartments...the ridge has been excavated in order to build a parking space and the natural environment that withstood the test of time despite hunters using the land has now been destroyed.
God forgive them for they do not know what they are doing!!!
Charles Grixti
Sep 20th 2012, 21:01
I agree both the birds and their habitat are and have been destroyed. That does not excues one evil over another though.
Pippo De Marco
Sep 20th 2012, 21:41
Its incorrect of you to state that 'nobody bats an eyelid when virgin land is transformed into a concrete jungle..' I, for one, very much object to the rape of this contry's virgin land and the loss of our architectural heritage and national identity. In fact, I am so sickened by this government's track record of assisting developers in the ruination of anything 'Maltese' that after an adult lifetime of voting PN they can kiss my whip. - And don't get me stated on Gonzi and his desecration of Valletta, or I won't stop... !
Suffice to say, that unlike the principled fellows of the FKNK I would not sit at the same table as the current Prime Minister. And when one is his would-be clique members knocks on my door ahead of the next election they will get it with both barrels (metaphorically speaking, of course).
As for trapping song birds or, worse still shooting them, I really don't get it. - Just because other nations allow such primative behaviour, doesn't mean that we have to follow them into the cultural abyss. Apart from upsetting a minority, there is no logical reason why Malta cannot unilaterally lead the way to enlightenment and confiscate all privately owned firearms. - Let's put an end to the Police/ALE having to play hide and seek with the so-called 'Poachers' and the 'We don't know who they are' cherade with the supposed 'law-abiding hunters'.
And if you think that sounds undemocratic, then that's another thing that the FKNK could have spoken with Gonzi about ... He wrote the book on ignoring democracy and doing his own thing, regardless of what the people say or want.
Johnny Xerri
Sep 21st 2012, 11:09
Pippo De Marco,
there is one logic reason why firearms cannot be confiscated...I for one would not allow the confiscation unless I have committed a crime with my firearms...if you believe that with a strick of a pen firearms can be confiscated...rest assured that the first 3 notices I would affix to my house would be.
'Only fools thread through paths that angles fear'
'May God have mercy upon these fools, because I won't.'
and
'Next'
Charles Spiteri
Sep 20th 2012, 19:17
PM. Shame on you... You are not going to get the bird hunters/trappers vote as it is too late in the day. You are surely going to loose votes from those against bird hunting/trapping. SHAME SHAME SHAME
Pippo De Marco
Sep 20th 2012, 21:42
Give him enough rope, Charles.
R. Balzan
Sep 20th 2012, 19:07
U ilsien il-gver dejjem jitwal u jitwal. Sa l-elezzjoni jkun fih xi 5 piedi u jkun niexef ghal kollox. Ghax kemm iddum tilaq?!
rene bartolo
Sep 20th 2012, 19:03
I am not against trapping but I am against putting a bird in a cage.
A Camilleri
Sep 20th 2012, 18:56
poor bird in such a small cage instead of being free where it should be. this will not increase the votes for the PN.
Karl Consiglio
Sep 20th 2012, 19:32
Agreed, its so barbaric.
A.f Ellul
Sep 20th 2012, 19:58
Poor birds that are in a small cages for a few days,So what did you say about the killing of the birds that are destroyed for ever.You didn't know what are you saying,It is better to stop hunting and leaving the trapping because they let the bird live but hunters kill the birds.which one of these has mercy?
leon camilleri
Sep 20th 2012, 23:10
these birds live freely in the wild ... but only a few used to be caught by trappers . these trappers used to take care of these birds and keep them in the best condition they can . keeping them in good condition , in aviaries results in the breeding of these birds in captivity . a bird would not breed in captivity if it is not kept in a good condition . when they are put in these small cages called ' gabjetti ; they are kept in good condition as well and a sign that the bird is happy and is in good condition is that the bird sings fluently all the time . when these birds are caught there life is doubled cause if in the wild a linnet lives for 2 or three years , in captivity it will live for 5 or more . in captivity the bird does not has to find problems to find food and water cause they are gven to him daily and they are not in fear that they can be caught by bigger birds of pray or snakes . sure that this bird is so poor ?
Mr M Grima
Sep 20th 2012, 18:45
Taqlawx paniku nies. Jien ma nafx ghala dawn iz-zewg speci tista tisparalhom u nassab ma jistax jaqbadhom hajjin..... u tinsewx li fl-ewropa ukoll jikkacjawhom, sa fejn naf jien ahna fl-unjoni ewropeja qedin!!
John Borg
Sep 20th 2012, 18:45
All these stupid comments that Gonzi wants to appease hunters is just a load of crap. hunters can shoot and kill thrushes and plovers. so what is the problem by trying to convince the EU to allow trappers to catch them? a bird in an aviary is for sure better than a dead one!
Mr C Camilleri
Sep 20th 2012, 20:13
..... and a free one is better than a trapped one ! so please cut the silly talk. this is all about gaining votes.
M. Cachia
Sep 20th 2012, 18:33
“Every nation has the government it deserves.”
(“Toute nation a le gouvernement qu’elle mérite.”)
Joseph de Maistre (1753-1821)
Jay Oatmon
Sep 20th 2012, 21:20
Very true - and the reason that the dictators stayed in power so long (Libya, Tunisia, Egypt, Syria etc) is because the ordinary people did not speak out loudly enough to be heard, and the dictators used 'patriotism' to stay in power.
Eve Axiaq
Sep 20th 2012, 18:25
Ipokrezija fl aqwa taghha! Mela issa f' daqqa wahda ma jimpurtax min natura ta qalbhom. Ghax kull vot jghodd u mela l'ghasfur!
victor bonello
Sep 20th 2012, 18:22
typical Gonzi PN style - Pjaciri mhux drittiet. - Are these people going to be allowed to shoot and trap these birds or not!!! it is as simple as that.
E. Azzopardi
Sep 20th 2012, 18:11
Yes, it is very sad. This is not the way to run the country.
I thought that trapping was abolished in 2008, as per EU regulations. Hope that the country will not get involved in any fines.
Anyway, this will in fact be to the detriment of the PN. They will lose more than gain. Pleasing the few but making the majority angry. It will not work.
Johnny Xerri
Sep 21st 2012, 10:53
as long as trapping is regulated as per the birds directive no fines will be faced by malta.
if such fines are impossed no probs...i publically declare that i will pay these out of my own pocket...the only string attched will be that 1st my vote is invoiced to an equivalent amount against all those that dished out false info to hunters and trappers...once that cheque clears I will pay the fine.
deal or no deal
Joseph Brincat
Sep 20th 2012, 18:07
The government is considering the application of a derogation to permit autumn/winter trapping of the golden plover and song thrush, as recommended by the Ornis Committee, the Prime Minister told hunters.
is considering , is considering so he let them hoping ?????
N. Agius
Sep 20th 2012, 17:53
.... anyway this will not win trappers' votes. They know they have been betrayed considering what was promised to them before we joined the EU.
Paul Caruana
Sep 20th 2012, 17:52
Rather sad really....still, every vote counts!
The calculation here of course is that, in this environmentally indifferent country, being pro hunting/trapping will not cost the government any votes. In fact, it should win over a few extra ones.
Jay Oatmon
Sep 20th 2012, 17:42
This government is completely out of sync with the public feelings on the bird shootings (legal or illegal).
The PN believes this may it will win votes - whereas it will lose votes with any relaxation of the rules and laws that attempt to contain the shooting of birds (legal or illegal).
M. Cardona
Sep 20th 2012, 20:04
Mr Oatman, which part of trapping as opposed to hunting didn't you understand? OOPs sorry didn't realise it was you again Mr Oatman.
Anthony A. Mifsud
Sep 20th 2012, 20:30
and you?
How could you possibly.cant you let lose for once?Ninu
Kenneth Grima
Sep 20th 2012, 17:40
Election is coming Gonzi irid jinhabb
DUNCAN ISHMAEL
Sep 20th 2012, 20:28
mhux ha jirnexxilu jinhabb imma ta ax lilna l kaccaturi ilu jamlilna hsara u weghdiet fil vojt!!!! tghid mhux ha jdawwarni b daqsekk!!!!
Please choose the reason of your report below: