Advert

Muscat: We have been orphaned

Joseph Muscat greets Dom Mintoff during his first visit to the new Labour headquarters.

Joseph Muscat greets Dom Mintoff during his first visit to the new Labour headquarters.

Labour leader Joseph Muscat in his first reaction to Dom Mintoff's death said today that 'we have all been orphaned'.

Dr Muscat visited Mr Mintoff's home soon after the former prime minister died aged 96 this evening.

He said Mr Mintoff had died as he wanted to, at peace, at home, surrounded by his children.

He said he had been told by his daughters that he had died peacefully.

"Malta has lost the architect of its freedom, a giant of its political history" Dr Muscat said.

He said Mr Mintoff was the source of controversy, but many considered him as the greatest asset this country ever had. His political adversaries too recognised that Malta would be different now were it not for him.

He was the man who, against all odds, put Malta on the world map. Malta started being taken seriously by the foreigners.

Dr Muscat said he only first met Mr Mintoff 20 years ago but he was impressed by his vision and energy. For his own thesis he had spoken at length with Mr Mintoff and was impressed by his insight, his love for his country and his unprecedented love for the workers.

Mintoff had built a living monument for himself through social benefits such as pensions, children's allowance, the free medical service, free tuition, stipends, the minimum wage the right to sick leave, equal rights for women, the right to vote at 18, the separation of church and state and  so much more.

Dr Muscat said there had been a difficult period between the Labour Party and Mr Mintoff in recent years, but he was pleased that over the past four years that chapter was closed.

He wished to thank Mr Mintoff for everything he had done, Dr Muscat said.

Advert

86 Comments

Post comment

Please see our new Comments Policy

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

For more details please see our Comments Policy

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Mark. Galea

Aug 21st 2012, 10:23

Speak for yourself. The majority of Malta was orphaned during 1981 and 1987. And I STRESS the word MAJORITY.

Victor Vella

Aug 21st 2012, 11:09

Tell us where was that majority? Mintoff was executing the same constitution that your party voted for it. You should be ashamed of yourself. Mintoff was responsible enough to change the constitution to give you chance to get to power. Today your GonziPN lost the MAJORITY and still clinging to power. And I stress Today your GonziPN is not credible let alone continue clinging to power to a hung parliament. Why does your regime have not gone to Parliament as Mintoff had done to solve this impasse where the people of this nation have been living in uncertainty fort he last seven months?.I repeat shame on you because at this time of a death of a person it was not my intention to talk about politics.

Mark. Galea

Aug 21st 2012, 11:42

@Victor Vella

Talk and praise Mintoff how much you like. But the word WE excludes more than half of the people who lived during the 1981-1987 and had a vote. Do you understand that?

Mark. Galea

Aug 21st 2012, 11:44

@Victor Vella

If Eddie Fenech Adami is not with us any more, we will not say we are orphaned. We would say we lost a great person ...

A. Sultana

Aug 21st 2012, 11:47

Lm4 zieda u 65% taxxa.. Kemm qishom insewha dik in-nies!

Claire Busuttil

Aug 21st 2012, 16:51

@Cocker- OOHH please 'a scar that will never heal' how pathetic......he had his reasons to go against dr.Sant and the party. His priority was Malta, and it`s people, and not the party. We was never afraid of stating what he thought was right for his country, even if this meant that unfortunately many people from his party called him traditur and hated him. That`s why he is so different from other politicians!!

Gianninu Saliba

Aug 21st 2012, 17:33

Those that were lucky enough to have a job were given LM4 salary increase, but the whole nation went through hell, had no democracy, had no job opportunities, no electricty and as the saying goes, not a drop to drink. That was Mintoff for you.

Julian Borg

Aug 21st 2012, 08:25

I agree it will be massive because Mintoff had a unique way of mesmerising those who followed him. It is inversely proportional to the effect it had on those who did not follow or support him because of what he did to them and their families.

There is no doubt that he had a profound effect on Maltese politics - as to whether it was positive or negative or a bit of both - is up to the individual to decide.

RIP

Connie Deguara

Aug 21st 2012, 03:51

I agree with you S.Farrugia.There was none of that before Mintoff only begging in the streets.

Richard Caruana

Aug 21st 2012, 07:27

For historical accuracy, the vote for Maltese women was granted by the MaDonald Constitution of 1947 draftd by the British. Don't see what Mintoff had to do with it.

Carmel Borg

Aug 21st 2012, 09:27

Mintoff ta c-children's allowance mhux billi tejjeb l-ekonomija izda billi ha l-flus lil min kien jistinka (sa 65% taxxa barra l- bolla) u taghhom lilln haddiehor. Illum it-taxxa hija 30% inqas tammetti jew ma tammettix dawn huma l-fatti.

adrian micallef

Aug 21st 2012, 09:38

Sur Farrugia, id-dritt ghall Vot lin-niesa, gie bil-mghodija taz-zmienijiet. Jekk mghamiliex il-perit mintoff kien jghamilha il-perit cikku jekk il-perit Freddie. Rigward ic-children's allowance u l-pensjonijiet, ma taghna xejn, ghax biex tiehu xi haga trid thallax 10 darbiet iktar l-N.I. Contribution l-ewwel. Mohhkom mghaluq kontu u mohhkhom mghaluq tibqaw.

Haga wahdi tani zgur li meta kont zghir ma stajtx immur skola, kelna immoru nitghalmu god-djar u meta kbirt l-istess partit tieghu nehha l-istipendji. Nixtieq inkun naf ezatt dak li tak lilek.....nabseh xi ftira shuna.

Jason Zammit

Aug 21st 2012, 09:39

Are you serious S.Farrugia ??????

l Ifrizzar tal Pagi idoqlok xi haga ghal widnejk ? li il PN ma setawx jamlu meeting goz Zejtun ???? il glied tal Barani ???? L universita fi zmien Mintoff ???? Il pbs bis suldat fil bieb ???? .....i could go for hours but im a bit busy working

i guess you have very short memory

e farrugia

Aug 21st 2012, 16:09

Jien nghidlek la tinkwetax! Hafna qed jiktbu u johorgu dak li jigihom f'halqhom. Hawn min qal illi trid thallas 10 darbiet aktar NI sabiex tiehu childrens allowance u beneficcji ohra. Nghidlu lil dan is-sinjur, dak iz-zmien u sa llum, taht dan il-Gvern ghadek thallas xahar NI, izda jaf li l-Perit Mintoff, kien assigura pensjoni ghal ulied pajjizna, tajjeb jew hazin, jaf li kien assigura childrens allowance, jaf li tah is-sick leave, jaf li tah is-sahha b'xejn? Illum bil-paroli kollu u hdura zejda, jaf fejn ninsabu bil-bolla li aktarx hu stess qed ihallas? Privatisation tal-pensjonijiet! Jaf li dan il-bniedem halla biljuni ta' liri maltin f'gid filwaqt li dan il-Gvern hallielna ma wiccna xeba' dejn li sa fejn nafu ahna jlahhaq 5 biljun ewro?
Din hi s-sitwazzjoni li ma riedx Dom Mintoff!

Alfred Falzon

Aug 20th 2012, 23:52

@ Julian Borg

Shame on you!

The Labour Party owes its reputation to Dom's wise and pragmatic leadership, and to NOBODY else!

Alfred A. Falzon

Joseph Brincat

Aug 21st 2012, 00:13

Julian Borg
@ We learnt to live without Mintoff 25 years ago. We are not orphaned
Yes we are orphaned for he is the father of the Republic of Malta in which you make part of too., you like it or not !!!!

Julian Borg

Aug 21st 2012, 08:22

@Alfred Falzon
You prove the point I was making

@Joseph Brincat
Did you feel orphaned when GBO passed away - the father of our Independence - by your yardstick not mine?

Alfred Grech

Aug 21st 2012, 00:04

Very well said Mary and I'm in full agreement. One may disagree with what Mintoff has done but the fact remains it was he who eliminated poverty from our country. If anyone is interested to read some vile comments, please tune to Madame Vile, Daphne Caruana Galizia.

Mr David Ganado

Aug 21st 2012, 09:31

One has to earn that respect and unfortunately he lost it all with the way he did things. All those eulogising him only see the improvements they got, but not the rest of the damage he and his thugs brought on Malta in order to get those 'improvements'

Frans Aguis

Aug 20th 2012, 23:21

I guess you do not know what orphaned means.

Mr D Grima

Aug 20th 2012, 23:32

It means he was the father of the Republic of Malta in which you make part of too.

Ben Agius

Aug 21st 2012, 02:20

Anglu: don't take everything literally!

G Tonna

Aug 21st 2012, 06:37

Yeah but this guy was against independence and wanted integration with our oppressors at one stage! What do we make of that?

C Calafato

Aug 20th 2012, 22:48

neither in mine, if he has been orphaned, I know who my father is

C Calafato

Aug 20th 2012, 22:49

Niether in mine, if Muscat has been orphaned I wasnt.

J. Mizzi

Aug 20th 2012, 22:50

He wasn't speaking in your name but in mine!

Kevin Sciberras

Aug 20th 2012, 22:55

Were it up to your party no one would be able to speak!

John Williams

Aug 20th 2012, 22:59

u oqod kwiet Antoine, se nibdew bil paroli fil vojt jaqaw!!!!

robert pace

Aug 20th 2012, 23:06

He speaks in the name of all Maltese unlike our Prime minister who speaks in the name of PN supporters only.

Mr Joe Micallef

Aug 20th 2012, 23:25

Not even for me or my family's to whom this person and supporting thugs caused inestimable moral and physical harm.

Other than that, as for all mortals may he rest in peace.

Biker Man

Aug 20th 2012, 23:31

Neither in mine. When I was a boy, Mintoff locked out my father from his teaching job, leaving him and his whole family, me included, to go beg for money to the rest of family members, as we had no savings. This for some ten weeks.
John Williams, ahjar tara sew min bdieh il-paroli fil-vojt. Int jaqaw xi wiehed minn dawk bir-ritratt ta' Mintoff u bix-xema quddiemu d-dar? Hehe. filkas ahsiblu wahda ghal Joey wkoll tinsiex.
Anyways, may the deceased man rest in peace now.

Dorianne Pirrone

Aug 20th 2012, 23:42

I haven't been orphaned either thank you very much but nice try Sur Muscat!!!

Byron Camilleri

Aug 20th 2012, 22:59

Kieku ghadek tghix go pajjiz li terz minnu kkontrollat mill-Inglizi inkluz il-banek u x-xandir.

Aaron Cremona

Aug 20th 2012, 23:40

@Byron Camilleri,
If it's not freedom, than what is it ?
Ok then, bring back the free ambulances we had whilst labour was in government, given to us from the labour's dear friend Gaddafi.
Everything was cheap and useless, it's when the PN went back in the government that Malta took a big leap to start competing with other big countries (:
For me, yes it is freedom, but that just our oppinion.

Dione Pace

Aug 20th 2012, 23:19

And a bad one, at that.

Antoine Vella

Aug 20th 2012, 23:46

We were freed in 1987 but there are those who would bring back the Mintoffian regime.

K Mifsud

Aug 20th 2012, 23:59

Yes Mr Vella, the same regime that gave you all your social benefits.

Antoine Vella

Aug 21st 2012, 00:35

No paltry social "services" can ever excuse a dictatorship.

Robert Cassar

Aug 26th 2012, 19:22

@ Antoine Vella

Very Well Said!! - 'No paltry social "services" can ever excuse a dictatorship.'

Says it all really....no need for any other comment posted!

Advert
Advert