Italy’s recession pain stretches to a year
Italy shrank further into recession in the second quarter for a 2.5 per cent yearly decline, data showed this week, threatening attempts by Mario Monti‘s technocrat government to control a debt crisis that is undermining the whole eurozone.
A 0.7 per cent fall in gross domestic product, only slightly better than the first quarter’s 0.8 per cent decline, means the Group of Seven economy has now been contracting for at least a year, according to figures from government agency ISTAT.
This will weaken tax revenues and hit jobs and consumer spending, a vicious circle which makes it harder for Monti, who is aiming to cut the budget deficit to 0.1 per cent of GDP in 2014, to meet his public finance goals.
Italy has been the eurozone’s most sluggish economy for more than a decade and is at the forefront of the debt crisis, with borrowing costs bordering levels seen unsustainable over the long run.
Investors have become increasingly concerned about Italy‘s ability to bring down public debt of around 123 per cent of output, a mood that threatens to spill further into the bloc.
Monti passed austerity measures worth more than €20 billion at the end of last year to head off a mounting debt crisis but the package, made up largely of tax hikes, sapped consumer morale and deepened the recession.
“The austerity measures are obviously weighing on the economy,” said Vincenzo Bova of MPS Capital Services. “Investments and consumption, both private and public, are the hardest-hit areas.”
Tuesday’s data was slightly weaker than expectations. The median forecast in a Reuters survey of analysts pointed to a 0.6 per cent fall. Activity may have been weakened in the second quarter by a powerful earthquake that crippled industry in the productive northern region of Emilia-Romagna, but analysts saw the decline continuing.
“There is no sign of any change of trend for Italy,” said Intesa Sanpaolo analyst Annamaria Grimaldi, who forecast there would be no return to growth in the eurozone’s third-largest economy until “well into 2013”. Employers’ lobby Confindustria forecasts the economy will contract by more than 2.4 per cent this year, twice as much as the government’s official projection of -1.2 per cent.
With Italian benchmark bond yields still stubbornly close to six per cent, Monti has repeatedly warned his European partners that unless they show flexibility towards Italy on public finances, the country could soon be run by a eurosceptic government with little commitment to fiscal consolidation.
He told the German weekly Der Spiegel last week that what he needed from Germany and the EU was moral support, not financial help, and added that he was concerned about growing anti-euro, anti-German and anti-EU sentiment in the Parliament in Rome.
“I’ll stay in office if all goes according to plan until April 2013, and I hope that I can help rescue Italy from financial ruin with moral support from some European friends, especially Germany,” he said.
Monti, whose popularity has plunged from record high levels soon after he took office, has said he will not seek to remain in power after a national election due next spring.
On Tuesday he sparked a political storm after he told the Wall Street Journal that the gap, or “spread”, between yields on Italian benchmark bonds and safer German Bunds would be “1,200 points” if Silvio Berlusconi’s government, which was replaced by Monti’s in November, had remained in power.
He had been asked why the spread, which currently stands at around 440 basis points, or 4.4 per cent, had not fallen further despite his government’s efforts.
Fabrizio Cicchitto, the Chamber of Deputies leader of Berlusconi’s People of Freedom party, led the criticism, calling the remark “an unhelpful and stupid provocation.”
Despite the centre-right’s protests, Monti won final parliamentary approval on Tuesday for additional spending cuts worth some €4.5 billion this year.
The savings will help rein in the deficit and delay a planned two percentage point increase in sales tax until at least July of next year.