Advert

Updated: Borg Olivier attacks Muscat for 'trying to hide his actions' over Mistra

Updated - Adds PL reaction - PN General Secretary Paul Borg Olivier told a press conference this afternoon that the party stood by its claim that it was Joseph Muscat who had given the PN indications in 2008 that the PL was about to target Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando on the Mistra affair.

He said that his move had effectively pulled the carpet on then Labour leader Alfred Sant.

Dr Borg Olivier showed a clip taken on February 25, 2008, where, he said, Dr Muscat had warned of the attacks about to be waged by the Labour Party. Dr Muscat had then, in a conversation, passed on the information about the Mistra campaign.

Dr Borg Olivier recalled that in June 2008 then PN General Secretary Joe Saliba had revealed in The Sunday Times how Dr Muscat revealed the information in a conversation. At the time, Dr Muscat made no denial. He was only doing so now.

The PN General Secretary added that recent media comments by Dr Sant also showed that information given to the PL about Mistra had not come from the Nationalist Party, as the PL was now claiming. Jason Micallef, then PL General Secretary, was also on record as saying that the information to the PL had not come from the PN.

The issue now was not Mistra itself, Dr Paul Borg Olivier said, but how Dr Muscat was now trying to hide his actions.

PL REACTION

In a reaction, the PL said Dr Borg Olivier's press conference was a ridiculous attempt to deceive.

Only Dr Borg Olivier could somehow think that Dr Muscat in his official capacity could leak such information on national TV days before the election. 

It would be better for Dr Borg Olivier to investigate who really leaked the information in 2008, somebody who was close to the prime minister, the PL said.

Advert

144 Comments

Post comment

Please see our new Comments Policy

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

For more details please see our Comments Policy

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Emanuel. Vella.

Jul 25th 2012, 10:51

proset ghal mitt elf darba,
@ vincent borg,to-day,10:32.

Philip Hili

Jul 25th 2012, 11:51

@ Vincent Borg

This is my opinion.

Since the PN was aware of HALF THE TRUTH when this person presented himself as a candidate in the last general election, Dr. Alfred Sant was correct in 2008. But while acknowledging Dr. Sant's intentions at that time, it does not mean that the PN was aware of the whole story. The whole story lied in Dr. Sant's hand at that time and it should have been Dr. Sant to reveal the whole story to the electorate two or three days prior to the General Elections.

Had Dr. Alfred Sant was sure of himself when he possessed an official document by which he could have hammered the PN few day before the general electins, Dr. Alfred Sant must have called JPO's bluff and answered his questions. Maybe today we have another story.

Vincent Borg

Jul 25th 2012, 12:35

@ Philip Hili

"It does not mean that the PN was aware of the whole story"

Do you believe this or this is just an alabi

Mario Camilleri

Jul 25th 2012, 13:22

@Philip Hili,

Why didn't JPO or rather was instructed not to go to the police and call for an investigation on the so called infamous allegations by Alfred Sant prior to the show of contract on the election eve?

Because their strategy was to keep away from any investigations and proclaim JPO as martyr thereby GonziPN knew all along about the Mistragate and JPO.

If PBO was wiser as a Sec Gen., he should have found a way to end this saga instead of adding further which in turn is resulting in more conflicts while jeopardizing the country's economy. Because of the GonziPN's internal affairs this country is at a standstill.

U il-kobba aktar titħabbel b'dettriment li aktar qed jitgħarraq GonziPN!

Philip Hili

Jul 25th 2012, 17:49

@ Mario Camilleri

Qieghed tara kemm ma taf XEJN!!!

Jekk kien hemm xi hadd li messu obbliga li dan ir-ragel li jmur ghand il-pulizija kien Dr. Alfred Sant, ghax Dr. Alfred Sant kellu l-informazzjoni ufficjali kollha f'idejh. Anzi, nazzarda nghid li Dr. Alfred Sant kien obbligat li jmur ghand il-pulizija u jirraporta dak li kellu f'idejh. Kif nista' jien nibghatek ghand il-pulizija meta jien ma naf xejn fuqek jew jekk naf, naf nofs verita'? Ghalhekk ghidtlek li Dr. Sant "must have called his bluff", halli wara li kien jikxef kollox u l-affarijiet ikunu moghod iehor imbaghd ikun il-kaz li tibghatu ghand il-pulizija, u mhux qabel il-kaz ikun mikxuf.

Izda bhal dejjem, Muscat's Labour Party dejjem jaqbad l-affarijiet minn sieqhom bil-konsegwenza li l-istorja ddur fuqu, jew kif jghid l-ingliz "fires back against him".


Konferma ohra kemm inti ma taf xejn, ghadhekk "beccun" irrizulta minn din is-sentenza li ktibt:- "Because their strategy was to keep away from any investigations and proclaim JPO as martyr - Ghala? Ghax jekk kif qieghed tghid int, l-istrategija tal-PN kienet li tevita kull investigazzjoni u Dr. Alfred Sant kellu l-evidenza kollha biex jimplika lill dan ir-ragel u lill-PN, KIEN IMISSU IZJED MAR GHAND IL-PULIZIJA U JIRRAPPORTA META JAF LI GHANDU L-FATTI KOLLHA UFFICJALI F'IDEJH!!!! Hallina Mannnn!!!

Issa jekk lanqas dan ma jwassal mohhok biex tifhem, allura, "no wonder" ghala is-sitwazzjoni hawwadtuha mill-bidu sat-tmiem.

Mario Camilleri

Jul 25th 2012, 19:07

@Philip Hili,

Alfred Sant qatt ma kellu għalfejn imur hu għand il-pulizija għaliex JPO ma kienx qiegħed jagħmel xi att kriminali. Kien sempliċiment qiegħed jagħmel "sagrileċċ" għaliex bħala l-persuna li kien ingħata l-'green award' favur l-ambjent u kien ikkonfronta nies biex saħansitra ma jagħmlux ħsara lill-ambjent, imbagħad kien involut f'dak li kien ser ikun tħassir fil-wied tal-Mistra.

Mela allura jekk kif dejjen stqarr hu li ma kienx vera dak li kien qed jgħid Alfred Sant fuqu, mela dan ifisser kif intqal kemm-il darba, li Sant kien qed jitfa t-tajn, u jekk allura l-allegazzjonijiet ta' Sant kienu nfami u nfondati u forsi foloz, kellu jkun JPO nnifsu li jmur għand il-pulizija. Agħar imma li kellu jkun il-PN li jħeġġu jmur għand il-pulizija għax b'dak li kien qed jagħmel Alfred Sant kien qiegħed jagħmel ħsara lill-PN, u minn dan kollu ma ġara xejn.
U tinsix kemm kien hemm nies u kowċis involuti biex jaraw kif ibażwruha ħalli joskuraw lil Alfred Sant. Imma bħal dejjem id-dnub ma jorqodx u ż-żejt dejjem jitla f'wiċċ l-ilma!!

U hawn jien għandi raġun daqs kemm kellu u għandu Alfred Sant u mhux intom, l'apoloġisti nazzjonalisti. Il-fatti huma li n-nazzjonalisti dejjem ħbew mill-poplu għal gwadan tagħhom, eżempju tipiku kienet is-€600 żieda fil-ġimgħa u l-poplu "min ħadha" ħa €1.16, x'kontrast!!

Hemm kliem il-għerf li jgħid "la tigdeb darba tibqa tigdeb biex tgħatti l-gidba ta' qabel".

Philip Hili

Jul 25th 2012, 10:15

@ Colin Camilleri

"How can you expect us to believe you ..." Sur Camilleri! when it is YOU and others like you who are saying that in yesterday's press conference Dr. Paul Borg Olivier referred to Dr. J. Muscat "as the Opposition Leader in 2008?!" It is your fantasy who is jumping to the conclusion that Dr. Paul Borg Olivier referred to JM as leader of opposition . If you go through the above extract of this paper, you will find nothing of this sort! It seems that you have a very short memory not to remember that after elected leader of the then Malta Labour Party today also known as Muscat's Labour Party, Dr. Muscat spent almost a year in Brussels with the post of Leader in the Muscat Labour Party vacant and his post was occupied by Dr. Charles Mangion!!!-- "Sakemm kien lest!!!", If you do not know the history of your party, please stop taking us for a ride - "minn ghalik" and respect our intelligence.

Philip Hili

Jul 25th 2012, 10:24

@ Eddy Privitera.

"realize that in this clip Dr. Muscat was already the leader of the PL ! "
IZDA JMEXXI MINN BRUSSELS!!!!

U hallina Eddy. Mela insejt li Dr. Charles Mangion ghamel kwazi sena jmexxi "Muscat Labour Party minnflok JM sakemm "il-leader" kien lest??

Qatt ma tghaddili minn mohhi li inti dan ma tafux! Izda ghal konvenjenza tieghek u biex tqarraq bil-qarreja ta' din il-gazzetta, ghogbok tikteb hekk. Nahseb li inti u minn jahsibha bhalek iridu "JGHADDU Z-ZMIEN U JQARRQU BIL-POPLU MALTI U GHAWDXI !!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Philip Hili

Jul 25th 2012, 10:41

@ Joseph Scerri.

Could you please respect our intelligence and when you quote somebody, don't quote him "OUT OF CONTEXT".

PBO said that it was "Dr. Muscat" who had given the PN indications in 2008. The reference for JM as leader of the opposition was only mention at the end of this clip in order to hammer that it was the opposition through it's today's leader that had passed on the information to the PN

Philip Hili

Jul 25th 2012, 10:49

@ Edmond Micallef.

Dear Mr. Micallef,

Have you reported " the numerous scandals and misdoings of their administration" to the authorities concerned because if you failed to do so, you share the same guilt as that of the administration "if found guilty" - "f'kelma wahda, inti tkun komplici jekk taf xi haga hazina u ma tirrappurtax!!"

A Trapani

Jul 25th 2012, 10:20

.... one question to you Colin, when are you going to stop nagging and complaining about everything the government does and be positive in life ? Probably the answer is when you will see Joseph as our Prime Minister. Then he will surely be able to answer all your questions and Malta will become heaven on Earth with the youngest PM smiling upon us.

Philip Hili

Jul 25th 2012, 11:03

@ Colin Camilleri

Another question for you Colin:-

When Muscat's Labour Party is going to give back the properties snatched illegally by means of the "requestion orders" of that time TO THEIR PROPER OWNERS???????

Antoine Psaila

Jul 25th 2012, 13:31

@PHILIP HILI

Ghax ma ghamilix il-gvern Nazzjonalista f'25 sena ????

Philip Hili

Jul 25th 2012, 18:00

@ Antoine Psaila

Il-gvern Nazzjonalista qatt ma ghamel dawn il-hnizrijiet!!!

Biex trodd lura dak li tkun hadt illegalment ma hemmx bzonn tkun fil-gvern. Jigifieri mill-bankijiet ta' l-oppozizzjoni, Muscat's Labour Party seta' iroddha lura din il-propjieta' IMMA MA RIDTX U GHADU MA JRIDTX irodd lura l-propjeta' li ha minn ghand il-publiku, liema propieta kien ghamel uzu minnha ghal kazini laburisti. Dik hi il-verita' u l-ebda argument ma ser ihassar din il-verita'.

Antoine Psaila

Jul 25th 2012, 19:55

@Philip Hili

Jien saqsejtek ghax ma qabdux u hadu azzjoni il-Gvern Nazzjonalista f'dawn il-25 sena jekk dak li qed tighd inti huwa minnhu.Insomma meta nisma argumenti bhal dawn ninduna kemma ma fadlilkhomx affarijiet ma xix taqbdu.

Philip Hili

Jul 27th 2012, 15:20

@ Antoine Psaila

" jekk dak li qed tighd inti huwa minnhu." hawn is-sur Antoine Psaila qieghed jirreferi ghal postijjiet li kienu gew rekwizizzjonati minn Muscat Labour Party biex jaghmlhom kazini laburisti rz. Santa Venera, Rabat - ex Police station, Lija - ex Police Station, u hafna ohrajn.

Issa dan is-sinjur qieghed jghid "jekk dak li qed tighd inti huwa minnhu.I"!!!!!

Dan irid idahhaq? Mela ma kienx jghix f'Malta, jew ghadu jiehu l-gazaza biex ma jaf li Muscat Labour Party kien ha propjieta privata minn ghand l-individwi biex jaghmilhom kazini laburisti???

Philip Hili

Jul 25th 2012, 11:13

@ Eddy Privitera.

Maa! how funny your comment is!!

If by your imagination you classify "funny GonziPN apologists have latched on to something which is irrelevant today in order to divert attention to WHAT HAS JUST HAPPENED JUST A FEW DAYS AGO - when JPO succeeded in highjacking the GonziPN government by forcing Lawrence Gonzi to accept his demands, namely, that Dr. Gonzi MUST consult Dr. JPO before certain Bills can be brought for debate in parliament !!!!", aren't you contributing with us when answering our comments and therefore you are as much funny as we are?

M Grima

Jul 24th 2012, 20:27

The message is quite clear and simple for those who do not use thick blue blinkers. The whole issue is how GonziPN camouflaged the Mistragate affair after it transpired that JPOS took them for a ride or else.

Who said the PN was crumbling? (with apologies to Gordon).

Franco Attard Trevisan

Jul 25th 2012, 09:59

that's because the 'messenger' gave a stupid message... Since when does the PN care so much about Alfred Sant being (allegedly) back stabbed?

Colin Camilleri

Jul 24th 2012, 19:52

Well, no ones needs to attack PBO. He is very good at shooting himself in the foot and playing second fiddle to GonziPN. If GonziPN tells us who has leaked the information about JPO to the PL would be better! Unless of course, you prefer that the PL shall name and shame the person!

Although, honestly, many have already a very accurate impression who this person is!

Since when have you Alfred Sant and the MLP at heart? Havent you forgot who has leaked the information about Sant's health to the media? The most deplorable action by any standards?

Is this all the proof GonziPN boasted so much about? I see RCC`s voice recordings much more damaging to the GonziPN image than anything else.... A PN mastermind criticizing (at the very least) people from HIS OWN PARTY!

S Scerri

Jul 24th 2012, 21:55

Mr. Cutajar, I bet you have one dvd, one cd and one radio and tv station. How boring to play the same tune all the time. You have to be heavily brainwashed to play mono in repetition

Philip Hili

Jul 25th 2012, 11:28

@ S Scerri

Dear Mr Scerri,

There is no need to have "one dvd, one cd and one radio and tv station" because WE lived those terrible days!! Maybe you are of a tender age in order not to remember the facts.

As regards brainwashing, it seems you are an expert in this subject because you are playing mono the repetition others are saying when you do not know the facts.

martin Padovani

Jul 24th 2012, 19:26

Simple...............to unmask Muscat's lies

Emanuel. Vella.

Jul 25th 2012, 11:00

fejn qatt fl-istorja ta l-elezzjonijiet generali ta pajjizzna,
ittawlet siegha biex in-nies ikomplu ivvutaw ?.
lanqas qatt fl-istorja ta pajjizzna,imma kif qal LG qabel
l-elezzjoni generali ta 2008,li gonzipn 'FLIMKIEN KOLLOX POSSIBLI',
u hekk hu.

A Camilleri

Jul 24th 2012, 20:18

Exactly. Part of Joe's long term plan to become the youngest prime minister.

S Scerri

Jul 24th 2012, 22:01

What a unique coach ! Capello , Fergie u ohrajn qed jibzu li jitilfu posthom !

Mr Joe Micallef

Jul 24th 2012, 17:27

These are facts that are disturbing for the PL. In opposition and AS goes at a tangent to his leader - not just on this case but also, and more seriously, during the parliament discussion on Euro and assistance to other Member States.

Literally translated the Maltese use a very apt saying "If you spit in the sky it will return to your face".

M Farrugia

Jul 24th 2012, 17:35

Habib jekk qieghed tistenna risposta minghand xi wihed mill-orakli tal-LP. li jiktbu hawnhekk ir-risposta hija jew mhux fl-interess tal-poplu li jkun jaf jew inkella nghidulek il-quddiem.

Franco Attard Trevisan

Jul 24th 2012, 17:37

why does he need to explain anything exactly??

Do you think anybody (apart from maybe the few remaining people with blue blinders) give a hoot to what happened back in 2008 especially with all this global and local turmoil???

The people are not deaf... just sick and tired of getting their intelligence insulted by these dirty politics (POLITRICKS!) and simply as I said before DO NOT CARE about the Mistra issue...

Recap of what happened :
JPO came out crying in public, Alfred Sant got humiliated, the PN won the election (I for one was very happy about it at that time!... stupid me!), eventually the truth surfaced (while the PN stood comfortably on the throne), the issue was put under the carpet because obviously didn't give the government much of a good image and now, four years down the line the PN wants to expose the 'blue truth'!!!

I ask again... WHY SHOULD ANYBODY CARE????

same goes for JM going on a three day holiday!

m. borg (slm)

Jul 24th 2012, 17:48

Neville if Dr Sant wanted to stir the water he could have done it any time but unlike gonzipn we are a close knit part that is setting up a movement for all those who have been hit hard or neglected by gonzipn even die hard NAZZJONALISTI.

The more the movement is made up of different points of view the less is the possibility of having cliques and oligarchies.

Mr M Spiteri

Jul 24th 2012, 20:12

tajba din

John B. Borg

Jul 24th 2012, 16:21

The PN ship with Lawrence Gonzi at the helm and PBO as First Mate isleaking from all sides and sinking fast.

m farrugia

Jul 24th 2012, 16:37

exactly and unfortunately gonzi is being being blamed for borg olivier's failure.

borg olivier's role is to run the party, pn parliamentary group etc. and gonzi should focus more on running the country. but borg olivier has failed miserably in his role and gonzi gets the blame.

borg olivier is turning out to be worse than jason micallef. pity for the pn.

and now jpo's story is over and does borg olivier think that we are still interested from where copy of contract was leaked etc, etc. better start working on some decent billboards such as a possilbe pl cabinet should pl be elected.

hope pn campaign will be somewhat better than mep campaign claiming that labour meps pressed wrong voting button in brussels. it is possible that pn could only come with such a poor idea when there was so much to criticise labour on hindering malta from joining the EU by even withdrawing EU membership application when joe muscat was very active in the party. did labour really deserve electing four meps when pn elected only two. it was clearly borg olivier's first failure, wrong strategy.

R. Balzan

Jul 24th 2012, 18:30

@ m. farrugia - which all goes to prove how right Gonzi was when he confided that he is surrounded by a bunch of incompetent good-for-nothings (not in so many words) both in his cabinet and in his parliamentary group. Now it turns out that the party secretary is the most incompetent of all.

Kevin Marks

Jul 24th 2012, 16:11

U fuq it 8000 impjieg ta smart city

J Busuttil

Jul 24th 2012, 16:40

@ X.Borg

Iva issa flogging a dead horse, as it is not music to your ears.

Franco Attard Trevisan

Jul 24th 2012, 19:11

Amen!

S Muscat

Jul 25th 2012, 09:08

Prosit. Nhgidlek jiena li hadd minnhom ma qieghed hemm ghal gid tal-pajjiz!! Min kien hekk ma irnexxiex fil-politika ghax tajruh il-barra!!!

Carmel Gatt

Jul 24th 2012, 15:47

Well said indeed.

J Degabriele

Jul 24th 2012, 16:31

This is what right-thinking people want!

Joe Vella

Jul 24th 2012, 17:35

How you can expect Joseph Muscat to give a team of people of the future? He has many people of the past like Leo Brincat Karmenu Vella George Vella Marie Louis Coleiro Anglu Farrugia.

R Axisa

Jul 24th 2012, 19:47

@Joe Vella - dejjem l-istess kantaliena. Zgur li mhux se nafda lil min se jhalli johrog ghall-elezzjoni lil dak li ha l-eluf kbar biex ghamel ir-rotot il-godda tal-Arriva u kienu vroma kbira. Litteralment ha l-flus ta' xejn. Mur afdah b'xi ministeru lil dan!

Malcolm Farrugia

Jul 24th 2012, 17:48

To me this smells too much of the usual pre-election GonziPn tantrums. They know that they failed miserably during the current legislature, and they sent PBO to be the party's sacrificial lamb in front of the media. After all PBO is well know for the erroneous "mistakes" he makes. He for one should try to speak less about leakages!

J. D. Farrugia

Jul 24th 2012, 15:20

... your para says all :)

Barney Camilleri

Jul 24th 2012, 15:24

As I keep saying. If the PN will not get out the professions (old party members) NL have a walk over.
It is not the jacket and a tie that win votes, it is how able you are to come down to where the people are and convince.
Stop trying to gain sympathy on something of so long ago. We are interested why the country in bankrupt and not what one said and the other answered, that we leave for street corner talk.

J Mangion

Jul 24th 2012, 15:27

Scerri..................I cannot agree with you more !!!!!!! well said !!!!!!!!!! what a donkey he is :)

G Schembri

Jul 24th 2012, 15:54

If this is the only thing they have on JM, they have nothing. Both parties used different strategies before the elections, so JM might have been given the task of letting the cat out of the bag, and JPO was given the task of crying in front of the cameras. Hopefully the Maltese electorate have matured enough to chose these silly things from the real issues.

Mr CHARLES TANTI

Jul 24th 2012, 15:47


Prosit Marco 100% Verrrrrrrrrrrrrru

Frank Massa

Jul 24th 2012, 15:44

Watch ONE News and direct the same question to the PL media and you will get your answer!!!!!!

Mr Joseph Carmel Chetcuti

Jul 25th 2012, 00:46

Attack is the best form of defence. A clear case of scraping the barrel. THE PN is truly imploding.

Mr Joe Micallef

Jul 24th 2012, 15:35

Who told you so?

The only fact is that the PL cannot even manage a deck of winning cards. The issue here (at least so far) was not one of corruption but one of someone trying to exploit his own belongings to the detriment of the environment for personal gain.

Had Sant made better use of this, the PN would not have been able to defend itself. But this was one of the countless misjudgements by Sant - in this case Muscat didn't help either, because being the amateur he is, he could help keeping his mouth shut.

Alex Falzon

Jul 24th 2012, 15:46

Kollu minnu... pero l-istqarrijiet tal-PL jindikaw li l-PN qatt ma kienu jafu bl-agir ta JPO...


U allura tahseb li jkun sew li partit (PL jew PN) jitlef elezzjoni a skapitu ta kandidat?

Advert
Advert