Pullicino Orlando sticks to his guns...but will not publish the messages from other fellow Nationalist MPs
Nationalist backbencher Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando yesterday stood by his claim that another eight government MPs wished to vote for the Richard Cachia Caruana motion.
The backbencher insisted he had mobile phone messages and witnesses to back his case but refrained from producing the proof.
“They were private conversations and I will not divulge the names or what was said but this morning (yesterday) a friend of mine reminded me of an instance when one of these MPs spoke openly about his wish to support the motion in front of me and two friends,” Dr Pullicino Orlando said.
During the parliamentary debate on Monday, Dr Pullicino Orlando said 10 MPs on the government side had expressed a wish to vote with the opposition to oust Mr Cachia Caruana, Malta’s EU envoy.
The MPs included Dr Pullicino Orlando, who voted with the opposition, and Jesmond Mugliett, who abstained.
On Thursday evening, the Nationalist Party rebutted Dr Pullicino Orlando’s claim with a declaration signed by 33 MPs saying they had no intention to vote for the opposition’s motion calling for Mr Cachia Caruana’s resignation. Missing from the list were Dr Pullicino Orlando and Mr Mugliett.
The PN even challenged the rebel MP to substantiate his claim.
“The MPs told me they wished to do it. It did not mean they were going to vote with the Labour Party and my vote was not determined by what they had told me,” Dr Pullicino Orlando said in reaction yesterday.
When asked whether he felt betrayed by the MPs’ decision to sign the PN declaration, Dr Pullicino Orlando said he would not judge them.
The PN executive on Wednesday condemned three of its MPs – Dr Pullicino Orlando, Mr Mugliett and Franco Debono – for the way they voted in Parliament on two Labour motions calling for the resignations of Mr Cachia Caruana and former Home Affairs Minister Carm Mifsud Bonnici.
13 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Fredo Zahra
Jun 26th 2012, 15:00
I think that JPO should put out or shut up
Henry S Pace
Jun 23rd 2012, 18:38
; Pullicino Orlando sticks to his guns...but will not publish the messages from other fellow Nationalist MPs '
It is quite obvious that some of those 33 MPs are on the alert to grapple the first opportunity to sabotage Lawrence Gonzi.
Such people have gone out of their allegiance to the party and to the government.
Soon after the election there were MPs who cerulated petitions among the constituents requesting Dr Gonzi
to appoint them Ministers in the Cabinet. However the only promotion that they got was an appointment as
Parliamentary Assistants. I consider these appointments as Clerk-typist in the Ministries
Jpo is the PN primadonna. 'The end jkustifies the means '.
Sarah Grech (Zebbug)
Jun 23rd 2012, 14:21
If your mobile phone gets lost or stolen, all the said messages will be made public before you know it and your point made.
You can try leaving it in open view.....
Charles Massa
Jun 23rd 2012, 13:42
Komplu pacpcu l inkwiet taghkom fil berah, halli tpaxxuna
Peter Pace O'Shea
Jun 23rd 2012, 12:02
Let me attempt to predict the future. Our Prime Minister will continue to continue business as usual even though a number of PN MPs continuously express disagreement. We will come to summer recess and Dr. Lawrence Gonzi will announce election date. This will give the PN a summer of marketing its party and its past achievements and all that is negative with the PL. As I have grown older I have realised that we must have a system that guarantees that the same political leadership does not last more than, maximum 10 years.
It is unhealthy for the same party to remain in government and the change in the electoral system should be designed in such a way as to protect those who blindfoldedly vote for the same party becaue they claim it is in their blood.
Edward Camilleri
Jun 23rd 2012, 11:17
What JPO and Franco Debono did is what happens in every democtratic country. When MPs are in parliament they are not answerable to their party but to us citizens.
If all MPs start following suite, things will start changing in a positive way, not according to the party that is instigating the change.
j dough
Jun 23rd 2012, 11:09
YAWN - we don't care...so one politician will be replaced with another....
Francis Saliba M.D.
Jun 23rd 2012, 11:05
Whether he publishes any SMS's or not, no one Nationalist or Labourite, would be so stupidly credulous as to believe again the tearful author of the deceitful charade known as Mistragate.
Mr J Xerri
Jun 23rd 2012, 10:57
JPO claimed "another eight government MPs wished to vote for the Richard Cachia Caruana motion." The Nationalist Party stated"a declaration signed by 33 MPs saying they had no intention to vote for the opposition’s motion" So while JPO uses the word "wished" , the PN declaration uses "no intention" and there is a big difference between "wishing" and "intending."
Edmond Micallef
Jun 23rd 2012, 14:02
Very good legalistic observation there. That is exactly how the Pn operated. Legally correct but morally defective and politically deceitful.
John Zammit
Jun 23rd 2012, 10:22
Why all this fuss it's an open secret that many MP don't like the leadership for one reason or another.
Joseph Cauchi Senior
Jun 23rd 2012, 09:59
Why all this fuss of JPO’s assertion that 10 other MPs were prepared to vote for the motion but didn’t?
The fact of the matter is that when push comes to shove, those 10 MPs just toed the party line and voted against the motion (unlike JPO and Mugliett)!
JPO must be living in a parallel world and must realize that he has to come down to the real world!
It’s not what you say that counts, but what you do!
JC.
J Pisani
Jun 23rd 2012, 12:03
PROSITSUR CACHIA. WELL SAID AND EXACTLY SO !!
Please choose the reason of your report below: