Advert

Outcome of leadership contest means PN is a united family - Gonzi; PL reacts

Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi said this evening that the outcome of the PN leadership election confirmed that the PN was one united family.

Speaking after he was confirmed leader with 96.5% of the vote in the contest where he was the only candidate, Dr Gonzi recalled how, when he was first elected eight years ago, he had declared his love for the country and all its people. He had promised to be of service to the country and the party.

He was pleased that the result had confirmed that the party was one family, united and determined to be of service to the country, Dr Gonzi said to applause.

This, he said, was the message he wanted to convey. Despite the criticism that was made, the PN was a family that was determined to work for the country.

The rules of democracy had been exercised, he said. This was a secret ballot where delegates were free to express themselves as they wished. He now hoped that this exercise would not go to waste, but rather, that it was seen as a golden opportunity from which they could all build for the future. After all, he said, they were all pulling at the same rope in the interests of the country.

PL SAYS PM SHOULD NOW TEST HIMSELF IN PARLIAMENT

Opposition leader Joseph Muscat in a first reaction, said that now that weeks had been wasted for the country, the least that Dr Gonzi could do was to test his position in Parliament. 

He said that the first thing Dr Gonzi should do is to bring for debate in the House next week the Opposition's private motion about the justice sector. 

Unless he did so, Dr Gonzi would be showing that the leadership contest was  just a waste of time, Dr Muscat said.

Advert

130 Comments

Post comment

Please see our new Comments Policy

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

For more details please see our Comments Policy

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Joe Fenech

Feb 28th 2012, 21:57

...time and space.

Edward Curmi

Feb 27th 2012, 09:14

Do you represent all the electorate??

pat muscat

Feb 26th 2012, 17:47

When the PL' s leader election was taking place, GonziPN was preaching to us all, that the PL elections were not democratic, cause the party members could not participate and vote. Compare this with closed shop PN re-election of their leader; not only were party members deprived of their votes, but the majority of the councilors( who could vote) were recommended by the Party leaders for this' free' election!

Giov DeMartino

Feb 26th 2012, 10:10

Qabel ma nikkomenta fuq il-kitba tieghek bil-Malta, naghmillek mistoqsija semplicissma, Biex int imwegga' b'dal-gvern ta' Gonzi. Jekk int ragel WIEGEB.

DAVID D. PACE

Feb 26th 2012, 10:14

jiena bhalek pero imxejt pass iehor ghax issa iddecidejt li nivvota P.L. ghax nemmen li pajjizna ghandu bzonn tmexxija/gvern differenti. Nemmen li issa biex il-partit nazzjonalista jimxi 'l quddiem, irid jitnehha GONZI.

R Axisa

Feb 26th 2012, 11:18

@Giov DeMartino - nghidlek jien biex inhu mwegggha l-poplu b'dan il-gvern - bil-korruzzjoni rampanti minn fuq nett u hadd ma jkun responsabbli, b'nies jieklu minn zewgt ihluq, biz-zieda la ha l-kabinett minn wara dahar kulhadd u l-poplu zdied bil-frak tal-hobz, b'sitwazzjonijiet fejn kumpaniji jkunu nvoluti fi frodi tal-VAT imbaghad ikun il-gvern stess li jerga jaghtihom il-kuntratti, etc etc. Lista li nassigurak li ma tispicca qatt. Dak li konna nghidu fil-passat ghall-gvern laburista, qieghed isir minn gvern nazzjonalista. Hemm bzonn li dal-gvern jaggorna ruhu u jekk se jibqa' jghid li ma tezistix il-korruzzjoni, se jiehu tisbita mill-kbar!

Giov DeMartino

Feb 27th 2012, 08:39

@ Mr Axisa..the proverbial fool rushing in....Il-qarrejja mhux paroli jridu, Sur Axisa FATTI. Semmi kazi specifici ta' korruzzjoni li l-awtoritajiet..IL-PULIZIA U L-QRATI mhux il-mninistri ma hadux passi. Il-helwa hi li min sabuh imcappas sab refugju fil-MLP> Int, Sur Axisa l-VAT dejjem hallastha? Jekk ikolloki cans tiekol b'zewgt ihluq ma tikolx? Dejjem iddikjarajt kull sold li taqla ghall-Income tax? Jekk jigik ic-cans taqbez xi naqra l-kju ma tithajjarx\? Ghirli LILEK f'hiex naqsek il-gvern, jew ahjar x'ridt u ma tawkx. Issa la zzattat fin-nofs kun ragel u parla.

Giov DeMartino

Feb 27th 2012, 15:06

Ghidilna Sur Pace fejn int imwegga' b'dal-gvern? X'qed tistenna?

Mr Michael Debono

Feb 26th 2012, 10:23

Have the votes been counted. The number of positive votes that count.Gonzi is happy that 98.5Voted but how much of them are positive or he is sure they voted Yes.

P. Ciantar

Feb 26th 2012, 10:15

did you do the same maths in 1981 heqq or in 1998 when mintoff with his 6000 votes was against sant should I name more ......

Paul Cassar

Feb 26th 2012, 10:42

@ P Ciantar...................as a true pn you are NOT comparing like with like................Sant's election majority was far beyond what you stated................Need I say more ?

m. borg (slm)

Feb 26th 2012, 10:57

Mr Ciantar if you had any decency you would have stated that with his 7000 majority votes Dr Sant should have had at least 3 seat majority and Mintoff would have been neutralised.

You can never compare like with like were Sant and Gonzi are concerned.

P. Ciantar

Feb 26th 2012, 11:21

to be correct MLP got 132494 against 124864 PN a mojority of 7500 for Sant and Mintoff had 7600 votes need I say more. Should I add the others namely Lino Spiteri Charles Mangion who resigned their posts or maria Camilleri AST who were not backing the govt on its treatment of Mintoff. This is history but the most indelible instance is the 1981 election in which MLP stayed 5 years and 5 months sal ahhar gurnata possibli with a minority of votes and the PN with the majority of votes. and by the way who is JFK ?

Alfred Vassallo

Feb 26th 2012, 10:13

Democratic!!! One SOLO Candidate????? More like an out-of-season Carnival !!!!! Not to mention the pressure that was piled up on the Councilors to vote since Friday 200 eligible voters did not collect their document.

Kenneth Williams

Feb 26th 2012, 10:27

HA HA HA HA HA HAJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ....Kemm ili ma nidhak daqha hekk...Staqsi lill BILL MILLAM nazzjonalist malti ta l Amerka kemm hu process demokratiku

pat muscat

Feb 26th 2012, 17:50

F'din il-farsa tfakkarni fil-loghba tal- karti tal-loghob jisima' 'bank ingliz' : jirbah dejjem min ikollu il-mazz f;idu!

Jos Vella

Feb 27th 2012, 21:24

and on his own!

Mr Adrian Zahra

Feb 26th 2012, 07:43

If we want to get our deficit back on track. There is undoubtedly a need to "nissiKKaw ic cintorin". Unless we want to make our country poor again by having the government default on it's bonds where many a person hold quite a good chunk of their savings.



Michael Grech

Feb 26th 2012, 08:12

'With the righteous ways of Christianity..." didn't the party turn liberal following the referendum divorce? Isn't government proposing laws recognising co-habiting couples, including gay/lesbian ones?

Giov DeMartino

Feb 26th 2012, 10:28

When an Englishman called Mntoff funny little man" he was taken to court and fined.

john muscat

Feb 26th 2012, 08:43

Dear Dr. Cutajar, how can anybody contest if there was no vacancy????

G Mangion

Feb 26th 2012, 10:08

john muscat:

Bil Malti sa nkelmmek. din l -Elezjoni interna fil Parit Nazzjonalista, Il Prim Ta Malta Kolla Dr L. Gonzi Ghamila

biex jikonderma li il Partit Zgur iridu Jibqa il KAP Tal - PN ! muhx tall Gab il - Fiducja Kolla Imma Qabes il -

96.5% Record iehor, U Kullhad seta Jikkontestah kemm Irid Muhx No Vacancy kek ghedt int issa tafu il par Idejn sodi Kemm huma fdati ! Ikalma Man Il - kbir ghadu gej !!!

G. Mangion,

Philip Hili

Feb 26th 2012, 10:18

@ john muscat

Sur Muscat, veru li l-kumment tieghek hu ta' sentenza wahda bhal ma kienet il-mozzjoni tal-vot ta' sfiducja ta' Dr. Emails f'Dr. Lawrence Gonzi u l-gvern li jmexxi.

Imma biex taghmel dak il-kumment veru mohhok "fqir", "meskin" u nhaseb li "bye bye" wkoll!, Ghala qieghed nghidlek hekk? Ghax taf li dan il-vot li talab Dr. Gonzi ma kienx vot biex jissodisfa l-kilba ta' Dr. Emails u tintela' l-vacanza ta' Prim Ministru bhal ma xtaqt int. Kien vot biex juri lil dawk id-deputati Nazzjonalist li huma zleali lejn il-partit, u lil dawk li jisserverw bil-kelma "Nazzjonalisti" u li XI DARBA KIENU JOKKUPAW XI KARIGA FIL-PARTIT NAZZJONALISTA, u dawn tafhom inti; li d-deputati honesti huma kollha wara Dr. Gonzi u l-gvern li jmexxi.

Sur muscat, issa oqghod isma l-qniepen idoqqu bhal ma qallek Joe Debono Grech meta qaghad ipeclaq il-Qawra. Kemm xtaqtu li jkun hemm vacanza!! Imma b'xiber imrieher bqajtu. Issa l-vacanza tinholoq fit-2013. Xu! Xu!! be quiet and tranquil now please up to 2013!!!!!!

Philip Hili

Feb 26th 2012, 10:20

@ michael scicluna

Dawn l-onorevoli li semmejt int ma ghadhomx parti mill-familja li semmejt int. Dan mhux jien qieghed nghidu izda Malta kollha.

Giov DeMartino

Feb 26th 2012, 10:27

Isemmu lil JPO. Tiftakrtu kif ippruvaw ISALLBUH erba' snin ilu?

Muliett: dak tal-pont, qeghdin tghidu.?

Dalli: dan "hu Bastjan"? Kemm intom ipokriti!

David Spiteri

Feb 26th 2012, 10:53

Proset Giov Demartino , l-ewwel xebaw isamrulhom imsiemer fi snin li ghaddew u issa qed ifahruhom :) . Tista tafda dan il-pajjiz f`partit li filli jmaqdar certu nies u f`daqqa wahda l-istess nies li kien ihammeg qed jilaqhom kollha !!! Jien nifimha li jekk kienu mahmugin (dejjem skond il-PL) jibqaw mahmugin ghal dejjem .

m. borg (slm)

Feb 26th 2012, 10:55

Ipokriti min keskes lil Mintoff u ried isalbu biex imbaghad capcaplu bhala eroj.

Sur Degiovanni dak li ghidna fuq JPO u Mugliette jibqa jghodd ma jfissierx ghaliex qed jiehduha kontra l-partit taghhom ser jinhafrulhom dnubiethom.

Jien personalment ghadni nistenna lil JPO jghamel li livbel lil Dr Sant u jsalbu kif kien qal fuq it-TV.

Li ghandek taghmel hu tinkwieta sew ghaliex meta MPs bhal JPO u Mugliette jibdew jaraw il-hazin fil-partit taghhom , meta tikkonsidra x'ghamli huma iffisser li gonzipn huwa jghamel ghar.

R Axisa

Feb 26th 2012, 11:45

That wasn't an election, it was a confirmation as you are stating! If you can't see the difference!

R Axisa

Feb 25th 2012, 22:19

May I remind you that JM was not the only contestant. And that is a big difference! If you to compare, do it like with like! Forget about the Amen!

Jos Vella

Feb 25th 2012, 23:31

that is because there were other contestant......Gonzi was competing on his own....where have the remaining 3.5% gone????

A men.....

Mr Joseph Carmel Chetcuti

Feb 26th 2012, 02:55

And what is your point? You seem to forget there were other contenders for the MLP leadership.

Ġ. Agius

Feb 26th 2012, 06:46

Yeah sure,but it was a race between 4.This was a race between...well er 1??!! You will arrive first....or last for that matter.

Joseph Agius

Martin Busuttil

Feb 26th 2012, 07:43

Sorry, but when Joseph Muscat was elected leader of the PL, there was an election between more than one person. In this case Gonzipn racing alone. So how things were, he should have got 100%. AMEN, AMEN ......

Joe Grech

Feb 25th 2012, 22:21

Raymond Scicluna - be honest: don't you just WISH that we had not joined the E.U.? I myself voted to join but how I lament the day! The E.U. is as inefficient as this present administration. And that's certainly something. How can Europe survive under such management?

P. Ciantar

Feb 25th 2012, 22:39

well said Raymond il paladini tad demokrazija insew il passat ricenti milli jidher

Jos Vella

Feb 25th 2012, 23:35

raymond you seem to be in a state of despair......blogging and blogging and blogging... in the PL there was always more than one contestant and 60+ % is a good result when there is competition. if i run on my own i can never become in 2nd place

michael scicluna

Feb 26th 2012, 00:55

you seem to forget that gonzi wasn't contested.......a 1 horse race..the same as Yemen earlier this week!

and for sant to be re-elected he actually resigned to create a vacation......not like gonzi lool

this is pn's saddest moment ever.......till now.

saviour marquette

Feb 26th 2012, 02:13

Mr. Scicluna you are forgetting one important aspect, how much percentage did the other candidates get?Of course none , Gonzi was the only candidate what a farce.

P. Ciantar

Feb 25th 2012, 22:38

I may be mistaken but the ma taghmlu xejn mal perit mintoff leadership confirmations were a one man race if I remember well and also KMB correct me if I am wrong. Further more Alfred Sant election was tinted with the allegations by Lino Spiteri and the bag of extra Votes. And by the way how did Joseph Muscat get elected to parliament in Malta and how many votes did he get !!!! I am mentioning the past as you brought it forward on the fact that Mr Mintoff divided the MLP twice Boffa li MOffa kif kien jghid Mintoff u Alfred Sant li tilef il boxla socjali

Oliver Grech

Feb 25th 2012, 23:09

Given that you are quoting some leader elections from the past....can you quote the one of Karmenu Mifsud Bonnici? And what about the just 65% of Joseph Muscat? Thanks

Mr Joseph Carmel Chetcuti

Feb 26th 2012, 02:54

It is a farce.

P. Ciantar

Feb 26th 2012, 09:15

Hugo Mizzi brought us the past . Does he remember the Boffa Mintoff contest well 250-250, and other labour leadership contests by Mintoff KMB and Aldfred sant where there is a claim by Lino Spiteri that a bag of votes was added for A Sant so Lino Spiteri will loose, and did you forget Muscat opponents writing a joint letter that they were not treated equally as Joseph.... the rest is history

Dennis Zammit

Feb 26th 2012, 07:07

Party leaders are elected by the Party delegates.

The Maltese voters elected the PN with Gonzi as leader to Govern for 5 years and THAT is what he is doing.

PL leader Joseph Muscat was NEVER elected in Parliament by the electoral but there he is.

J Busuttil

Feb 25th 2012, 23:23

@ Joseph Buhagar

" It is people like me that have a say and believe me, we are not convinced "

Do you want us to believe you?? You have to do better.

Mr Edward Caruana Galizia

Feb 25th 2012, 21:57

I don't see the point in comparing Ben Ali to Dr Gonzi. I don't see Dr Gonzi having people killed do you? So those who voted for him did so of their own volition.

Or are you going to insinuate that those who voted for him did so at gun point?

P. Ciantar

Feb 25th 2012, 22:01

that is why in Malta we have democracy may I remind you Alfred Sant leadership election and the alegations by Lino Spiteri ehh was it in 1994 hux

Joseph Camilleri

Feb 25th 2012, 22:10

...and yet Joseph Muscat is leader of the opposition without 1 single vote of the electorate!

Joe Grech

Feb 25th 2012, 22:26

@ Edward Caruana Galizia - Certainly Dr. Gonzi did not point a gun at the P.N. voters.....but he certainly gave them no other option but to vote for him. Had they voted him out they would have had to go for an election. Now that would have been just as horrific to them as staring a gun in the face....don't you think? So they kept him there..... self before national interests, that is!

michael scicluna

Feb 25th 2012, 22:30

FYI JOSEPH CAMILLERI....... Joseph muscat ikkontesta l elezjonijiet u b success tela b eluf ta voti.....fta l ewropa vera imma xorta jfisser li il poplu jridu jirraprezentah

min naha l ohra gonzi ghal darbtejn 1987 u 1992 baqa l art u li ma kien EFA ghamlu speaker ma kienx jarah il bieb tal parlament, min naha ta gewwa!!

ghal grazzja t alla ma tistax tqabbilom flimkien!! ;))

Jos Vella

Feb 25th 2012, 23:37

Joseph Camilleri...hopefully you will get a result for Joseph...and it wil be more than 1%.

ALBERT FENECH

Feb 26th 2012, 05:17

Yes Mr Brimmer, as Mr Edward Caruana Galizia rightly stated, you should not compare Lawrence Gonzi to Tunisia's Ben Ali - only. There are many, many more comparisons. For example, the Communist Party vote in the former Soviet Union rarely dipped below 95%, but then they were the only party contesting; Nasser, Sadat and Mubarak also never dipped below 95% but then they were the only presidential candidates. Abd-Rabbu Mansour Hadi has just been elected President of Yemen, but then he was the only contestant too. These are normally the results of one horse races. Now then Mr Caruana Galizia, I believe that parts of the Caruana Galizia "kilkka" have also been criticised by Dr Franco Debono and other PN representatives as being part of the GonziPN "klikka". Well Edward, the buffoonery carnival is over and Dr Lawrence Gonzi has been elected King Carnival as a result of votes cast by some 800 people. Now, how about letting the rest of the 330,00 or so legitimate electors also have a vote in a General Election to ascertain whether the GonziPN Carnival should continue dictating to Malta and Gozo - or would that smack too much of democracy?

ALBERT FENECH

ALBERT FENECH

Feb 26th 2012, 05:26

... and let's NOT forget to mention that TWO current PN Members of Parliament did NOT collect their document and did not vote whilst the vote of a third PN Member of Parliament almost certainly did not favour Dr Gonzi. Therefore, from a Parliamentary compliment of 35 MP's, the total has now shrunk to 32 representatives whilst the PL still has 34. If anything, this vote should confirm that Dr Gonzi should immediately resign and call a General Election.

ALBERT FENECH

robert pace

Feb 26th 2012, 07:07

Joseph camilleri sems to have forgotten that Joseph Muscat had thousands of votes for the European Parliament? Well maybe if i were you ask Gonzi to try the race now? We will see who gets the most?

m. borg (slm)

Feb 26th 2012, 09:17

@ECG
There more ways than one to make people do as you want not necessarily at gun point.

Jonathan Brimmer

Feb 26th 2012, 10:33

@ Mr. Albert Fenech: Noone is comparing Ben Ali to PM Gonzi. My God, can't people read?! I'm just saying that similar election results remind me of those totalitarian countries where the Leader holds rare general elections and he gets 97% of all votes cast!

Yesterday's leadership election where the incumbent was the only one in the race is a commedy, or a tragicomedy considering that the man is in power.

Jonathan Brimmer

Feb 26th 2012, 10:35

@ Mr. Joseph Camilleri: 36,958 - the amount of first count votes that Dr. Muscat got when he contested a nation-wide election to get a seat in the EP way back in 2004.

Advert
Advert