Advert

Live: Major Brazilian company relocating to Malta - PM

Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi and Opposition leader Joseph Muscat are this morning discussing the political upheaval in the country in a Times to Debate conference.

The debate, being reported live here, is part of a series organised by The Times, The Sunday Times and timesofmalta.com and hosted by Intercontinental Hotel in St Julian’s. It is being chaired by The Sunday Times deputy editor Herman Grech.

Live coverage: Leaders' debate

The event has now ended, here is a transcript of the live coverage.
  1. People are gathering at the Cettina Decesare Hall of the Intercontinental Hotel in St Julian's for a live debate between Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi and Opposition leader Joseph Muscat.
    The event, which is part of the Times to Debate series,  is also being streamed live on this website.

    08:35 amRosanne Zammit
  2. Dr Gonzi and Dr Muscat are having breakfast with some of the directors of Allied Newspapers.

    08:41 am
  3. Debate is about to start.

    08:46 am
  4. Herman is introducing the Prime Minister and the Opposition leader.

    08:46 am
  5. He asks whether the political crisis is now over and whether an early election should be held. A short video is now being shown.

    08:47 am
  6. The video is about the events which led to the current situation.

    08:47 am
  7. Herman asks the Prime Minister whether the political crisis is over.

    08:50 am
  8. The Prime Minister says he sees challenges and not crises. Such was the Libya situation, for example. He says he addressed the problem using all party structures and is continuing to address it. An early election, he says, is not in the country's interest. The most important thing is the creation of jobs.

    08:51 am
  9. Dr Gonzi says we should continue doing our duty whatever the situation. Internal conflicts take place within all parties but are more evident within the party in government.

    08:52 am
  10. He says that Malta is among the most successful countries in the EU. Jobs are retained and new ones are created.

    08:54 am
  11. Herman asks about the majority in Parliament. Dr Gonzi continues to speak about the government's successes in the economy, education. Herman asks if he believes such success can continue in the current situation. Dr Gonzi says he does.

    08:55 am
  12. Dr Gonzi refers to the forthcoming secret vote within the PN. He hopes the result will be the answer the country needs. Says his priority remains the creation of jobs.

    08:56 am
  13. Herman asks Dr Muscat whether he will continue to say there is a crisis if Franco Debono comes to some form of agreement with the government. Dr Muscat says that whatever the PM says, the country lacks stability. A solution, he says, has to be found in Parliament and not within a political party.

    08:57 am
  14. Dr Muscat says proof of this lack of stability is the fact that since the vote on the no confidence motion in the government was taken, no other vote has been taken in Parliament. There will be stability when Parliamentary work continues in a regular manner and votes are taken.

    08:58 am
  15. Dr Muscat says that when Dr Gonzi referred to former Prime Minister Alfred Sant saying there were policies within his party he did not agree with, Dr Gonzi did not say that Dr Sant, contrary to Dr Debono, did not abstain but voted with his party.

    08:59 am
  16. Dr Muscat says the government does not want to go to the test. But without stability there cannot be sustainable economic growth.

    08:59 am
  17. Dr Muscat speaks about the economic figures and says that the government is failing in its debt targets.

    09:00 am
  18. He says that a fourth of the country's debt was made in the past seven years, under the premiership of Lawrence Gonzi.

    09:02 am
  19. Dr Gonzi accuses Dr Muscat of analysing the figures in a very superficial manner. As businessmen borrow money to invest, the government also has to borrow to create investment. The country's debt is being invested in infrastructure such as drainage treatment plants.

    09:02 am
  20. The EU placed at Malta's disposal millions of euros to invest. But the country also has to fork out part of the costs.
    Malta has the fifth lowest unemployment rate in Europe.

    09:04 am
  21. Dr Gonzi says that Malta is playing in the Premier League and it is in the fifth place out of 27.

    09:04 am
  22. Dr Gonzi accuses the opposition of still being anchored to the times before Malta joined the EU. The EU gave Malta a thousand billion euros but if it did not spend this within a period of time it will lose the money.
    Between 2004 and 2006 Malta spent all its money and also benefitted from other funds other countries did not utilise.

    09:07 am
  23. Herman asks Dr Muscat if he is disappointed at having reached the peak without an election being called.
    Dr Muscat says he has been hearing that the PL has peaked for the past three-and-a-half years.

    09:08 am
  24. He says that if the PM looks at the debt issue just as a means of job creation, he has a problem with the fiscal pact which has just been agreed upon because this saw debt as a problem.
    Debt has to be paid and this needs economic growth. But economic growth is only possible if there is a stable government.

    09:10 am
  25. Dr Muscat speaks about his party's policies in energy, saying the PL wants to opt for gas as soon as possible. The government, on the other hand, opted for heavy fuel oil.

    09:11 am
  26. The cost of energy, bureaucracy and service charge are killing industry, Dr Muscat says.

    09:11 am
  27. Dr Muscat refers to the assistance which had been given to industry and says that the fundamental problems of the country's competitiveness should be addressed.

    09:12 am
  28. He says the Prime Minister did not want to know Labour's policy objectives. It wanted to know its electoral problem. He asks about Sargas, what action had the government taken about the project.

    09:14 am
  29. Dr Gonzi says Sargas is only one of many proposals. Another proposal, for example, is for the building of a large photovoltaic farm.

    09:14 am
  30. He reiterates that while the EU gave Malta the best certificate, the Opposition leader did the opposite. What the country needs in the field of energy is to not remain dependent on one source of fuel.

    09:15 am
  31. Malta, the PM says, will be in a position to buy fuel at the best possible rates through the interconnector with Sicily and the power station extension will cover Malta's needs for the next 10 to 15 years.

    09:17 am
  32. On Sargas, he says the government will study the proposal but it will study it well. The Opposition leader was promising that he will reduce water and electricity rates. This is not possible. Dr Muscat interjects that together everything is possible.

    09:18 am
  33. Dr Gonzi says that as long as the country has a deficit, it will have debt as it has to make up the difference through borrowing.

    09:19 am
  34. Malta does not have the financial credibility problem of other countries and for the 150 million euros it needed to borrow, it had offers for 247 million.

    09:20 am
  35. Dr Gonzi speaks about the country's success in aviation. He says that a major Brazilian company which learnt about Malta during the Libyan crisis will soon be relocating to Malta. Herman asks in which sector. The Prime Minister says he will say at a later stage.

    09:22 am
  36. Dr Gonzi says he agrees with the obligations of the fiscal pact to keep deficit at a low level.

    09:24 am
  37. Herman asks Dr Muscat what he would have done had he been in Dr Gonzi's position.
    Dr Muscat says that the problem is that Dr Gonzi is showing instability as normality. This is not the case. He says that while everyone has a problem, he does not believe the Prime Minister is tackling his problem in the right way.

    09:26 am
  38. Dr Muscat says that the PM's only solution is to gain time. Although this may be beneficial for him, it is not beneficial for the country.

    09:26 am
  39. In 2006, Dr Gonzi presided Cabinet meeting which decided that any new extension to Delimara had to operate on gas, this is now being extended to operate on the most polluting fuel in the world.

    09:27 am
  40. Dr Muscat criticises the government's projections. He also refers to Trellerborg and says the company's CEO had noted that the cost of energy in Malta is double that of other countries.

    09:29 am
  41. Dr Muscat says there is in Malta a struggling middle class and people who are falling below the poverty line. There are the working poor who cannot keep up with the cost of living in spite of having a job or a pension.

    09:30 am
  42. Herman refers to the PM's offer to the Nationalist Party to resign and asks Dr Muscat what he would do in a similar situation. Dr Muscat says he will face reality and take the steps which need to be taken in Parliament and not within his party.

    09:31 am
  43. Questions from the floor now being taken.

    09:32 am
  44. Ryan Callus asks Dr Muscat about his education, economic and health policies. Says not much about these had been heard in the past years. Asks if this will put the Labour Party at a disadvantage.

    09:34 am
  45. Dr Muscat says a substantial number of proposals were made by Labour in the past four years. These were completely ignored by the government. The PL's policy guidelines on education are to reduce as much as possible the number of students who stop their education on reaching the age of 16.
    On economy and finance, the PL believes in the two issues being tackled separately.
    Dr Muscat refers to Rent Laws and says that because of the agreement reached between the two sides and the PL's collaboration, at a risk to for itself, the people knew that the current Rent Laws are there to stay.

    09:37 am
  46. Dr Muscat refers to the fiscal consolidation laws and says the Opposition is giving its word about this matter.

    09:38 am
  47. Arnold Cassola says the uncertainty in the country is felt among the people. He asks both speakers if they are willing to change the electoral system so as to have all votes proportionally represented and to accept coalitions between different parties.
    Joseph Zrinzo says he is angry that the PM looked down at Labourites. He asks both speakers how can a balanced budget be reached, seeing this had never been the case.

    09:40 am
  48. Dr Gonzi says Malta is a democratic country and elections are respected. The constitution had been amended to bring proportionality closer to reality. Malta's system had an indirect threshold which is high, compared to other countries. The parties had tried to change this but there was no agreement so far. There can be situations of internal conflict within a party which necessitate internal debates. These are part of the democratic rules. It is true there is a difficulty, an issue at the moment which entails the party in government to work for a solution. This is what it has done, what it will continue to do. The PN bows to democratic rules and if the electorate chooses to elect a third party it will bow its head to that.

    09:46 am
  49. Dr Gonzi says that everyone has a role to play. He had proposed a man who had contested the Labour leadership election for President. This was one of the most historically difficult steps ever taken. It is true that some people are resorting to insults and this can be seen daily in l-Orizzont. There are people who resorted to insults even within the PN and whenever he got to know about such instances he tried to stop them. Dr Gonzi  praiss Dr Muscat for the way he criticised and says he tries to do the same but there are are certain people, including columnists, who go over the limit.

    09:47 am
  50. Dr Gonzi says that when he took over as Prime Minister, the country's deficit was six, seven per cent because the country had just taken on the shipyard's debts. What is Labour's position about this? Malta set targets because it wanted to become part of the Euro, it reached these aims and the target had been to balance this by 2010, 2011, had the situation not changed.

    09:48 am
  51. Dr Muscat says that Spain, Portugal and Greece, among others, had passed the same Eurozone tests as Malta showing these had been nothing but 'crash diets'.
    The fiscal pact will change fundamentally the way the country is administered. The only way to meet targets will be to go for many more public private partnerships in many sectors, starting from health and going on to environment. PPPs will become crucial and bureaucracies created over time will have to be fought.

    09:51 am
  52. On coalitions, Dr Muscat says these had never worked in Malta but the people are supreme. The Constitution and its changes should not remain a prerogative of the two parties but should be the result of debate involving civil society.

    09:53 am
  53. Has the time come to change the concept of the Broadcasting Authority, for example, for this not to remain in the hold of a political party, Dr Muscat asks.
    On personal attacks, he says that he and the Prime Minister had always shown reciprocal respect while criticising each other. There are people who have crossed the line and society has to give a sign that it does not want to go in this direction.

    09:55 am
  54. Dr Gonzi says it is true that bureaucracy is a problem but what does removing bureaucracy mean? Is Mepa bureaucracy?
    Dr Muscat tells Dr Gonzi he ignored Mepa in the case of the power station.
    Dr Gonzi says he had not asked about the power station but about the private sector, what does the removal of bureaucracy in this instance mean, that certain projects can ignore environmental considerations?
    Dr Muscat says that what he means is being clear with investors. Transparency has to remain but the Prime Minister is confusing transparency with bureaucracy. Such was the case of the White Rocks.

    09:58 am
  55. There are also the small businessmen who ended up in prison because they had been victims of bureaucracy.
    Bureaucracy has destroyed economic growth. The permanent residents' scheme, he says, had been working, it needed to be replaced but certainly not in the way the new scheme had been introduced.

    10:00 am
  56. Dr Gonzi asks Dr Muscat what will his policy be? He says he had his own answers to all the questions he asked Dr Muscat, his policy is clear and transparent to all but what about Dr Muscat’s. It is not fair to use the election as an excuse.
    Dr Muscat says the issue is that the Prime Minister undervalues the strength of the private sector in Malta. He does not appreciate the fact that there is money in Malta but there is not enough courage for one to invest.
    Dr Muscat asks about the government policy on pensions. The so-called reform had not led anywhere and another reform is now needed.
    Labour agrees with incentives for the introduction of a third pillar pension. We are looking at having such incentives. The Prime Minister has been saying this for eight years but no action has been taken.

    10:07 am
  57. Tony Zahra says the private sector feels like a spectator in a situation it has nothing to do with. The private sector wants a clear picture to be able to invest with its minds at rest.
    The country’s leaders have to project their vision for the next 10 to 15 years. The private sector can create the wealth but it is not convinced that the wealth it is creating is being spent wisely.

    10:15 am
  58. Paul Abela says businessmen have the responsibility to invest and expand the economy. A politician has the duty to ensure stability. We expect an election to be held as scheduled in 2013 and no MP has the right to blackmail a democratically elected government.

    10:15 am
  59. Reinee Laivera says there are 100,000 inactive women in Malta. Half of them say they do not work because they have family responsibility. Only some 6,000 are registered as unemployed. No entity is looking at the 50,000 women who would like to work but say they cannot. The government is coming up with piecemeal initiatives which are bearing results but these are too few.

    10:16 am
  60. Herman quotes Franco Debono telling timesofmalta.com that the crisis in the country was created by the establishment of the oligarchy. "I had made it clear that I would support the prime minister, as I had always done, but not one who was held hostage by a clique. This statement was made before the reshuffle, I stress, before the reshuffle, or whatever it was," Dr Debono said. Herman tells Dr Gonzi, it is clear that Dr Debono wants resignations. Will there be any, he asks.

    10:17 am
  61. Dr Gonzi refers to his opening the contest for PN leadership and says that Dr Debono appreciated that this was a positive step and he hoped it will pave the way for more collaborative work in future.

    10:18 am
  62. Herman asks if he had personally contacted Dr Debono. Dr Gonzi says he personally did not, but Dr Debono was contacted  through others. He says it is always important to listen to criticism as this will only be beneficial. He says it is not the first time that he acknowledged that criticism made by Dr Debono and others and others had been justified. Asked if he is willing to contemplate the resignations Dr Debono needs, Dr Gonzi says he is always open to discuss. What has to be considered first and foremost is what is in the country's best interest.

    10:20 am
  63. Dr Gonzi speaks about the records achieved in tourism saying these could be achieved through an investment of some 35 million euros.

    10:23 am
  64. Dr Gonzi says that a major achievement in the past seven years is that Malta had the highest increase in the EU in the number of women entering the job market. Malta has also reached the European average of women in employment among women aged 35 and younger.

    10:24 am
  65. Dr Muscat quotes Dr Fenech Adami saying that only stable governments can bring economic prosperity. He says that declarations made during this debate had confirmed that stability is lacking and solutions have to be found in Parliament. The Prime Minister, he says, is only playing for time.

    10:26 am
  66. Dr Muscat acknowledges that tourism has grown but says it has grown at about 50 per cent what it has grown in other countries, such as Greece.

    10:28 am
  67. On Air Malta he says, it is easy to make this profitable. This challenge is to make such growth compatible with the needs of local tourism. The government had introduced VAT on tourism behind the operators' back. They had also not benefitted from any schemes the government said it had introduced.

    10:30 am
  68. Dr Gonzi says it is not true that VAT had been introduced behind their back and tourism operators had benefitted substantially from the schemes the government had introduced. One has to keep in mind that the unemployment situation in Malta isamong the best in the EU but the Opposition only presented doomsday scenarios.

    10:32 am
  69. Dr Gonzi refers to Labour MEP Edward Scicluna saying that what he is saying now that he is in politics is a lot different to what he used to say before he entered the political scene. Dr Muscat accuses him of rhetoric and he answers with figures, Dr Gonzi says.

    10:34 am
  70. Dr Muscat says that Dr Gonzi reduced stipends for university students in October 2005. He also reduced the smart card grant. His commitment to retain stipends, Dr Muscat says, is clear. MEP Edward Scicluna questioned the wisdom of stipends in a personal document. This government has a problem of instability which is being felt over the country and from which families and businesses will suffer.

    10:37 am
  71. Dr Muscat refers to funds being wasted on unnecessary projects such as the bridge the nowhere to the detriment of other projects for which there is a greater need.

    10:39 am
  72. Dr Gonzi says that in 10 years Malta has to be a centre of excellence in a number of sectors, offering value added.
    He says that 10 years ago only 43 per cent of students continued with their studies after secondary education. This percentage has been increased to 75 per cent.
    It isnot true that his government had reduced stipends but it had shifted them to reflect the country's needs.

    10:42 am
  73. Victor Carachi says that while figures give a certain picture, the real situation seems otherwise. How many decent jobs are being created? Certain government agencies are the creators of precarious work, he says.

    10:45 am
  74. A young woman asks how will the country meet the challenges ahead considering the waves looming ahead.

    10:47 am
  75. Deborah Schembri says that a person who works for a month, loses social services for six. Statistics, she says, do not reflect quality, which seems to be suffering. She refers to the election within the Nationalist Party and said that in a similar race, where she was the sole competitor, she would win the 100 metre sprint.

    10:50 am
  76. Dr Muscat says he judges people not by their political allegiance but from the direction they wished to take. The university rector, for example, has a difficulty with stipends when the Prime Minister says his policy is that these should be retained.

    10:53 am
  77. Dr Gonzi said that even in this legislature, money bills are not always voted against by the Opposition. He says he agrees there are major issues in Malta in certain sectors which have to be controlled. He acknowledges there is abuse in certain areas but says that the Opposition always believed all that is bad about Malta but nothing that is positive. Deborah Schembri is seen shaking her head on the big screen.

    10:57 am
  78. On the election for party leader, Dr Gonzi says the vote will be a secret one and he believes this is the correct decision.

    10:58 am
  79. Herman asks Dr Muscat about his statement that a Labour government will be a safe government. Who does the PL represent. Dr Muscat answers that the PL has become a movement. It has gone through the realisation that wealth has to be created before it can be distributed. And wealth is created by the private sector. The movement unites businesses and the self-employed with the workers. He says he enjoyed the debate and notes that there is a lot to unite the people and many areas on which there can be consensus. Dr Muscat says it is not enough to say where one has to to get but how. Without a stable government there cannot be stable economic growth.

    11:04 am
  80. Herman asks the Prime Minister about the forthcoming local elections. Dr Gonzi says these had always been important but they were never a measure of what the situation on a national level can be.
    He asks in whose interest would an early election be - that of the country or of the Labour Party, which is currently 10 points ahead of the PN? It will be irresponsible of him to act in such a manner. The Opposition leader's bubble burst when he presented a motion of no confidence in the government which he lost. The Prime Minister acknowledges there are issues in the country but says that results have been achieved in the past years showing that the economic policy is bearing results. He points out that he came to the debate not knowing what Labour's policy is, and will be leaving it none the wiser.

    11:10 am
  81. Debate has been concluded. Herman thanks the speakers and the Intercontinental Hotel.

    11:10 am
Advert

96 Comments

Post comment

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

S. Zammit

Feb 9th, 10:07

Can you please tell us what JM's actions would be as I haven't heard a single one. Thanks.

Mr Andrew Camilleri

Feb 9th, 12:43

Sur Zammit, mela tafx taqra? Erga aqra ir-rapport fuq u aqrah minghajr nuccjali blu din id-darba.

kevin farrugia

Feb 8th, 19:05

gonzi = kmb!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

IC CAJTA TAS SEKLU

Anthony Caruana

Feb 8th, 16:50

I think nowadays a billion is 1000 million and a trillion is a 1000 times a billion, i.e. a thousand billion is 1,000,000,000,000. The old billion was one million times a million. The american billion is a thousand million. Nonethe the less I agree with you a hundred percent. Where has the money been spent? How could this money have been spent in three years? I am sure the prime minister has either been mis quoted or made a slip of the tongue. Some slip??

m. borg (slm)

Feb 8th, 16:25

Best comparison of Dr Gonzi's solo leadership race was given by Deborah Schembri, of her winning the 100meter sprint if she raced alone.
Lovely Deborah, couldn't have been explained better, you put a lot of apologists to shame.

Edward Curmi

Feb 8th, 16:21

Dear Mr.camilleri if they relocate for tax purposes or any other reason , they are always contrinuting to our economy , so let them come !

Paul Cassar

Feb 8th, 14:09

George................at least, when you mention the recent past, be truthful,. for the rest keep on your blue glasses, they help you not to miss the gravy train.

Edward Curmi

Feb 8th, 15:45

Yes i agree but there is no alternative to GONZI PN unfortunately so better the devil you know !

Francis Coquelin

Feb 8th, 16:03

Paul Cassar: I challenge you to write a sentence that does not include "blue" and "gravy".

Paul Cassar

Feb 8th, 18:24

Francis.....................I cannot separate blue and gravy.................they are sooooooooooooooo related.

Edward Curmi

Feb 8th, 15:47

Serrah rasek li jekk is Smart City mas sehx kif jixtiequ tal lejper xorta l-art terga taqa ghandil gvern , u dejjem ahjar mil mizbla li kien hemm qabel habib!!

Peter Zahra

Feb 8th, 15:01


Minkejja l gheluq tat tarzna, xorta wahda il percentag tal qghad f Malta huwa relativament baxx hafna meta komperat ma kumplement ta pajjizi f Europa. In nies li hargu mit tarzna hadu l flus bhala kumpens u hafna minnhom sabu impjieg produttiv mhux ma xi korp tal izra u rabbi....

X' ridtu jibqa jghamel l Gvern, li jkompli jipumpja il liri mit taxxi tieghi u tieghek sabiex din tibqa miftuha ?? Hafna mill problemi tat tarzna kienu kawzati minn min inqeda bil haddiema taghha ghal avanz politiku tieghu fejn sahansitra kien jehdded li johrog in nies tat tarzna fit toroq !! Saqsi lil min kien jahdem it tarzna u jghidlek kemm kienu johorgu (trid u ma tridx) ghal meetings tal labour u ghad dimostrazzjonijiet waqt il hinijiet tax xoghol biex imbghat jidhlu overtime (dejjem ghal dawk li jkunu min tal qalba).....!!

Angus Black

Feb 8th, 13:43

Mr Zammit, the last person the Prime Minister should consult with and obtain advice from, is Joseph Muscat.

Joseph Muscat has been (and probably still is) skeptical regarding the EU, having advised Iceland not to join. They took his advice and now find themselves in deep trouble.

As a journalist with the Labour media, he produced a programme specifically against joining the EU leading to a referendum the results of which thwarted his efforts and his party thankfully lost.

He mounted a campaign against joining the euro-zone, and lost again.

Three years after he became leader of the Mintoff/Muscat Labour Party, he stated that 'in hindsight' joining the EU was beneficial.

Now he wants to become Prime Minister without revealing what his policies are, what his vision is, until after being elected.

With these traits, who will blame the Prime Minister for not listening to an inexperienced 'leader' of a Party without policies, and worse, without principles and with a rotten track record?

Kevin Marks

Feb 8th, 13:14

And still there s a margin of 8 to 13% between the parties and the prime is loosing his popularity too what a pity!

M Grima

Feb 8th, 13:23

I agree that the differenece in the leadership style of the two leaders is getting more evident. On one hand we have Dr. Gonzi who has lost the plot and has even lost control over his cabinet and backbenchers. This notwithstanding his war cry of 'par idejn sodi'. He and his 'limited' cabinet have messed anything they touched during the past 4 years and to cap it all he gave himself and his bunch of croniesa weekly €500 payrise when the rest of us immortals were presented with a paultyry €1.16 weekly rise to cover the cost of living. What a joker?

On the other hand we have the fresh Dr. Muscat full of energy and ever so consistent. He has been able to unite the PL into a movement which is credible and which is not tainted with corruption. His track record can be judged by his performance in the EU when he was the PL representative. Otherwise, he was never a prime minister with all the power of incumbancy and its advantages like Dr. Gonzi had. As to his concrete proposals, you have to wait a little bit when your PM comes to his senses and calls an election.

If people are voting for a change they at least know that this country will rid itself of corruption, arrogance, clique of evil, blue eyed boys who have gobbled all there is to gobble and mediocre PN politicians if they vote for the PL.

J.C. Borg

Feb 8th, 14:46

From what I read here Dr Muscat offered childish replies to Dr Gonzi's questions. The PM of the future????

J Busuttil

Feb 8th, 15:53

@ M.Grima

Do you live on a remote island on your own. It seems that you do not speak to the people out there especially the business man / women who are terrorised of a Labour Government.

Peter Zahra

Feb 8th, 15:16


The proof of the pudding is in the eating !!! - Trid ikollok wiccek mcappas b.....

Could you please tell us what Alfred Sant did when the electorate gave him the chance to prove all his heaven on earth electoral promises bit tmexxija moderna u trasparenti ?? If not mistaken, the labour party is today running on the same lines as in 96, promising reduction of electricty bills etc ..as Alfred Sant had done with the Vat. The problem is that today the labour party is still composed of the same old faces going back since the 1980's !!!!!!!

S. Zammit

Feb 8th, 11:58

Dawk il progetti li semmejt kollha mil privat. Smart City ghada qed tinbena. U xghandu xjaqsam it taxpayer ma dawn il progetti? Nahseb li tisma il VERY PAROLI tas "SUPER NONE" biss int. U min qallek li il poplu deciz li ser jehles minn Gonzi. Inti u tal MUSCATPL forsi, ghax iddejjaqtu f'l-oppozizzjoni. Imma min hu intelligenti jara madwaru u jaf x'ghandu jghazel. Specjalment mnn din lintervista ghax JM ma qal assolutament xejn.

John L Galea

Feb 8th, 13:50

@S. Zammit: Smart City ha ddum biex tinbena mela ghax ilhom ghaddejin! Kieku il-Gappun fl-istess zmien jilhqu jibnu pajjiz. BTW Gonzi stess qal li l-PL qieghe 10 punti percentwali minn quddiem, mela hemm maggoranza kbira ta' nies li ddejqu minn Gonzi.

A. MICALLEF

Feb 8th, 14:13

S.ZAMMIT- Tajjeb tkun taf li l-art ta Smart City kienet propjeta tal-Poplu Malti u nghatat bis-soldi.
Sewwa li tkuntaf li l-famuza COGHM, il-famuza Brand Malta u hafnaaktar frejjec tal-PN kollha
imhallsa mit-taxpayer Malti. Forsi qieghed tahseb li dawn iffinanzjhom il-kuntratturi tal-famuza
JS LIST li tghamel parti mill-KLIKKAGONZIPN. Imma kullhadd jghaf li tal-JS tfffinanzja lil KLIKKAGONZIPN biss. Dawk li jridu li tispicca il-KLIKKAGONZIPN huma in-nazzjonlisti stess li ma jiffurmhawx parti minn
din il-klikka. Jos. Muscat ma jidholx fiha din il-kwistjoni. Jekk int inteligenti ghamel ftit kont u
ghasal ghal-figura ta kemm seta zid jew naqqas voti fuq l-1500 vot flahhar elezjoni li rebah
l-elezzjoni bihom. Zgur li ser tkun VERY, VERY DISSAPOINTED u tlesti ghal-funeral tal-PN.

S. Zammit

Feb 8th, 15:42

@John Galea. Il 10 punti huma sa issa. L-ahhar elezjoni konna listess u xorta rebah il PN

@A.Micallef. nerga nghidlek li jekk tibqa tisma u tara is SUPER NONE mintix ser timxu il quddiem. Ghax Alla jbierek kollox hazin hawn fil pajjiz u li JM ser ikun is salvatur ta Malta. Imma JM ma qal xejn, u sr jibqa ma jghid xejn ta sugu. Il problemi li hawn mad dinja kollha anke ahna kelna nghaddu minnha imma
GonziPN fit tmun, irnexxielna nghelbu il mewg, u ta dan inthom KOLLHA mahruqin ghax Malta ma gherqitx bhal pajjizi ohrajn u allura ma stajtux tippuntaw subghajkhom lejn il PN. Issa oqghod hemm u tpaxxa bil progress li gab il PN.

Edward Curmi

Feb 8th, 11:06

Some few projects??? Did the roads get better?? Are u living in malta??

Frans Aguis

Feb 8th, 11:12

I'm sure that's a mistake, meant to say thousand million euros since we joined probably.Thousand billion is a Trillion which would help solve the current crisis if we return:)

John L Galea

Feb 8th, 11:43

@Curmi: Yes I am living in Malta. The roads are still a disaster. I think you don't live in Malta. No alternative energy measures or investment. And I agree that the word billions is mistyped or it is a lie.

Edward Curmi

Feb 8th, 12:24

No alternative energy measures..what about the GOVT grant for solar panels or solar water heaters...investiment?? ghalfejn bi hsibkom tifthu xi fabbrika tal kappar??hallina ahmar biss tara habib...j'alla jitla JM ha naraw kemm tibqghu tikkritikaw ghax kollox tajjeb taraw..iktar nissawtu iktar tiehdu gost!!!

vincent busuttil

Feb 8th, 13:28

@Edward Curmi: Jekk dawn in-nies qeghdin jaraw ahmar int xejn anqas minnhom ghax hlief blu ma tarax.

Edward Curmi

Feb 8th, 15:50

@ John L Galea. Smart City miexja bil mod inhabba il krizi fid dinja kolla u mux wieqfa...u kif ga spjejjajt jekk din mas sehx kif jixtiequ tas Super None l-art zviluppata terga taqa ghand il Gvern u dejjem aghar mill mizbla li kien hemm qabel!!

Alfred E. Zahra

Feb 8th, 14:56

Sliema is now the prime shopping area in Malta where the sales persons do not have to wait outside for customers. From your post it is very obvious that you do not live in Sliema.

Pierre Mangion

Feb 8th, 10:09

@ Matthew

I agree fully that Dr Abela. what i'd like to add is that the post of president should carry more weight on the overall governance of the country.

Edward Curmi

Feb 8th, 10:12

It is thanks toDr.Gonzi who had the brilliant idea to propose Dr.George Abela and not propose someone within the PN. It is true Dr.George Abela has proved himself by using his influence for the better of the country.

Karl Abela

Feb 8th, 10:12

Mathew,

Your hatred towards the prime minister are not helping you see things as they really are. Be informed before you speak.

It was Gonzi who chose George Abela to be President and noone else.

Mr Joe Micallef

Feb 8th, 10:34

Matthew your stupidity shines! Like it or not YES it was Dr. Gonzi who proposed Dr.Abela.

AS Spiteri

Feb 8th, 13:46

Ghandkhom zball mhux Dr Gonzi ghamel lil Dr Abela president imma il magna ta Gonzipn ghamlitu president ghal skop li l istupidi biss ma jarawhx u dan kullhadd jaf ghaliex ghax b'din il mossa il magna pruvat tbied lil Dr Abela mil PL ghax jafu xi jfisser imma gharralhom ghax helsu min wiehed bil pulit u hargu tnejn ohra minnu , ibnu u il mara tat tifel tieghu . issa ghajduli min hu l istupidu, jiena zgur illi huma stupidi u jleqqu ukoll bhal ma qalu certu bravi min jahseb li gonzipn ghamel lil Dr Abela president ghax haqrituy qalbu

Karl Abela

Feb 8th, 10:10

Tony you should be ashamed of speaking with this attitiude towards a prime minister who has guaranteed that you can wake up in the morning because you have a job you have to go to.

Millions of people around Europe are staying at home because they have no job to go to.

Stop being arrogant about petty things.

Edward Curmi

Feb 8th, 10:13

If the road has potholes we grumble ..if there are roadworks to build better roads ..which i am sure you will use we grumble....vera qatt m'ahna kuntenti

W Cassar

Feb 8th, 10:20

What Tony Abela is talking about is quality of life and he is right. Transport planning in Malta is a joke and someone should have resigned LONG AGO!

@ Karl Abela

What about the jobs jobs jobs? We are the lowest paid in Europe of course we will have jobs lol Wake Up!

George Azzopardi

Feb 8th, 11:23

@Karl Abela .. you make me sick .. how patetic

tony abela

Feb 8th, 12:46

Dear Karl Abela

Why should be ashamed? For your information I have worked hard probably well before you was born to help building Malta over the past 50 years. I worked hard, contributed to my country with my capabilities and taxes so that people like you SHOULD NOT be obliged towards anybody for having a job. A job is a right not a favour. We live in 2012.

My point is the insensitivity of our PM for hardships the average citizen is experiencing due to inefficient administration.

If you feel grateful towards the Public Transport reform and the mismanagement in TM regarding the traffic management and road repairs planning, I can assure you that there are many others who disagree with your opinion, and i must say that you are surely on the minority side.

Mr Andrew Camilleri

Feb 8th, 15:55

Karl Abela: you have fallen victim to the GonziPN spin machine. They are always comparing us to countries that are worse of, and the result is statements like yours - grateful to have a job. We should instead compare ourselves to countries that have a better standard of living and complain that we have not yet achieved that level. Your kind of attitude just breeds mediocrity because you do not aim at a higher level but are happy to wallow in the mud just because someone else is worse off than you.

S. Zammit

Feb 8th, 16:15

@ Mr. Abela, Thanks for your contribution towards Malta, honestly.

on the other hand ,I do hope that Dear Dr.Muscat gets a motorino if and when he is PM.

Andre Cilia

Feb 8th, 09:45

Dur dawra r-restaurants ta' Bugibba... ara tarahomx mimlijin... f'gurnata li mhix festa, weekend, imma gurnata xoghol komuni... mur ara qabel titkellem

Karl Abela

Feb 8th, 10:05

I can bet you that there are many EU heads of state who wish to be in Gonzi's position. Gonzi is one of the few PM's who can boast about his country, and Kevin you should be proud of this irrespective of what political orientation you have.

Those days are gone li ghax int ahmar kollox huwa hazin. Li huwa tajjeb huwa tajjeb. FULLSTOP.

Or maybe you are living in Greece. In Malta whenever I go out to eat in a restaurant without a pre booking I always end up without a table.

Edward Curmi

Feb 8th, 10:15

Ghaziz Sur marks sa fejn naf jien fil weekend kulhadd fully booked jkun...ippruvajt nibbukja ghal nhar il hadd restaurant go tax xbiex u qaltli ilhom fully booked mil hadd li ghadda!!!

John L Galea

Feb 8th, 11:48

@ Andre Cilia: Jekk ddur Bugibba fix-xitwa qisha cimiterju. Kemm ilhom hemm il-PN fil-gvern din il-lokalita giet minsija ghal kollox.

Din tar-restaurant hu argument falz. Tridu taraw dawk li jmorru r-restaurants xi kwalita ta' hajja qed jghixu. Mhux kull ma jleqq hu deheb :)

Henry Spiteri

Feb 8th, 20:26

@ John L Galea

Bugibba huwa post tas-sajf u ma tistenniex li jkun hemm hafna nies fil-hwienet, specjalment f'dan il-maltemp li qieghed jaghmel. Wara kollox ghadna kemm ic-celebrajna l-festi tal-Milied ftit gimghat ilu tista' tghid.

Advert
Advert