Advert

UPDATED - Franco Debono: crisis will be solved when the oligarchy goes; PM optimistic solution could be found

MP insists on urgent Constitutional and justice reforms

Franco Debono reacted to a Times debate today and said that the current political crisis will only be solved when the oligarchy within the government goes.

The Times debate, held at the InterContinental, asked the question - Is the political crisis over?.

Asked for his comments by timesofmalta.com, Dr Debono said: "The crisis was created  by the establishment of the oligarchy. I had made it clear that I would support the prime minister, as I had always done, but not one who was held hostage by a clique. This statement was made before the reshuffle, I stress, before the reshuffle, or whatever it was."

Last November during the PN general council Dr Debono had already hinted at this theme by saying that a political party could expand to a political movement or restrict itself to a clique.

"The crisis will only be over when the oligarchy is dismantled, the elitist rule of 'planet clique' comes down to earth and democracy is strengthened. Even certain quarters of the business community have been complaining for some time about this clique mentality."

Dr Debono, a prominent criminal lawyer who has been campaigning for Constitutional reforms, said that after the French revolution one of Napoleon's greatest conquests was not military in nature. It was the establishment of meritocracy where careers were open to talent. It was the call to dismantle privileges enjoyed by the nobility and the oligarchy. Meritocracy was even more important in a small country like Malta, he said. "These are the foundation of our European culture and identity."

Dr Debono, insisted, passionately  that Malta needed to commit to urgent constitutional and justice reforms. "We have taken years debating the honoraria lack of teamwork issue, the highly polluting power station extension, the public transport reform fiasco and the disappearance of primary health reform, when we should have dedicated this time to the strengthening of democracy and constitutional reforms." It was wrong decisions and bad implementation which caused instability," he  said, and not legitimate calls for matters to be done correctly and in a transparent manner.

Asked about reports that he had not been communication with the prime minister since the no confidence vote, Dr Debono said he would not comment. 

Dr Debono said he acknowledged and appreciated recent delcarations by the prime minister.

However he hoped that the PN leadership issue would also focus attention primarily and in great detail on party financing and the state of party finances - an area where he has been calling for major reform. The leadership vote, he pointed out, had come about after the prime minister, following his comments, had admitted that mistakes were made and assumed responsibility. In other countries, he said, party funding laws were one of the ways to prevent the formation of oligarchies. Councillors, he said should also focus on the role and performance of Paul Borg Olivier as General Secretary.

Dr Debono stressed that he is not a rebel but a reformer from the backbench, despite the limited resources available to him.

He pointed out how he has for years been calling for reforms meant to raise the dignity of parliament and improve its efficiency. He had been influential  in the creation of the role of parliamentary assistants. He also managed to convince the government to introduce the right to legal assistance for arrested persons.

Dr Debono was also been behind the setting up of the parliamentary law consolidation committee, which he chairs. The committee is discussing fundamental justice reforms. He also pointed out that he managed to put the environment and infrastructural deficit of the south on the national agenda. He also managed to convince the prime minister to split the justice and home affairs portfolios, something which would become entrenched in the Maltese system. He also drafted a Bill on political party funding and presented it as a private member's motion - along with a 22 point motion on justice reforms.

PM REACTS TO DEBONO'S COMMENTS

In a reaction to Dr Debono's comments, Dr Gonzi said the fact that he had put his leadership to the scrutiny of the PN councillors was the strongest reaction he could give to the current reality and Dr Debono had acknowledged this. He hoped that they would be able to reach agreement and he hoped all those who held democratic rules at heart would move in this direction. 

Dr Gonzi said he had not had personal contacts with Dr Debono but there had been contacts through another person and he was always optimistic that problems could be resolved. He said he always heeded criticism since one could learn from it.

Asked if there should be resignations, Dr Gonzi said solutions should be in the national interest.

Advert

147 Comments

Post comment

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Sandro Pace

Feb 9th, 09:25

And Prospero. He patiently waited till 86 to get a promotion, no matter how much he thought he merited it.

Robert Camilleri

Feb 9th, 13:03

@sandro pace
billi franco jrid promotion ma qedt jitlob xejn hazin !! in nazzjonalisti mdorrija jihdu promotions fuq il postijiet tax xoghol taghhom ta!!!!!! specjalment li jahdmu mal gvern jew parastatali

Alfred Falzon

Feb 9th, 15:42

@ albert galea

Better still...

Kneel down before the power-hungry PL and apologize for refraining from voting in favour of the no confidence motion!

Or better still...

Do just like some turncoats and join the bandwagon in the hope of picking up the few crumbs left by the power- eaters!

Will Dr Franco Debono fall for that tripe?

He should know better! And I have a feeling that he is not all that naive!

He will not bring down the temple warts and all just for the pleasure of it!

Alfred A. Falzon

Anthony Agius

Feb 8th, 19:51

forsi ghandu jdejh marbutin? hokkli dahri biex inhokklok tieghak.........

Andy Farrugia

Feb 8th, 20:27

U inti tahseb li l-President , jew l-Unjoni Ewropeja, ghandu/hom il-hin jaghtu kaz id-dellirju, ukoll jekk imsieheb u sostnut b'hafna punteggjatura u b'ittri kapitali?

John Schembri

Feb 9th, 05:54

Il-President fil-hin li staqsejt int kien qieghed jippartecipa fic-celebrazzjoni ta’ Patri gharef u umli li se jsir Kardinal.
Qatt ma ghajjat u qatt ma sabbat saqajh biex isir isqof jew Kardinal.
La l-president u l-anqas l-unjoni Ewropeja m’ghandom x’jaqsmu , issa jekk ghandu l-istonku Franco jmur japplika ghal-mexxej tal-partit ,la hu daqshekk konvint li hemm Mafia tahdem kontra l-poplu!
Franco dejjaq lin-Nazzjonalisti u lil-Laburisti , it-tnejn lesti biex jarmuh ‘il barra mix-xena politika.

George Azzopardi

Feb 9th, 15:04

@John Schembri

propjament lil GonziPN dejjaq .. tkellem ghalik gbin .. :)

mario piscopo

Feb 8th, 21:16

l-mod ta kif tkellem llum qed juri kemm ghandu daru ma l-hajt....diskors mil-iktar partigjan! U mbaghad nibqghu nsostnu li ngibu l-interess ta' pajjizna l-ewwel!

Vincent Farrugia

Feb 8th, 19:52

As far as I know, Neil Armstrong and his fellow 2 American astronauts returned safely to Earth after their mission to the moon... that's why it was deemed successful. So no, Armstrong is not on the moon at the moment.

Andy Farrugia

Feb 8th, 17:11

Prosit, hej, kemm taf taghmilhom is-somom int! Ghandi nahseb kont iggib rizultati favoluzi fil-matematika, u mhux biss fil-Form 2!

Joseph Grech Attard

Feb 8th, 17:28

@Andy Farrugia. Jealousy gets you nowhere!

Andy Farrugia

Feb 8th, 17:55

"Jealousy"? You probably mean "envy". Even then, me envious of this self-aggrandising maverick? In your dreams!

Lino Busuttil

Feb 8th, 17:00

I am sure some unelected enlighted consultants are part of the clique, it is useless mentioning names to those who do not want to listen eh? A REFORMER NEEDS A GOOD AUDIENCE TO BE HERD and guts to plunge forward. Big changes are not automatically earned but done with lots of input and controversy. Abstaining not voting in favour of the Opposition motion gave Franco the tools and time to finish his job. I sense some sort of win win situation coming, politics is the art of compromise or is it not?

Joseph Calleja

Feb 8th, 17:35

Lino, is the glass half full or half empty?

Joseph Grech Attard

Feb 8th, 16:42

Two wrongs NEVER make a right!

Joseph Calleja

Feb 8th, 15:51

Mr Debono, you hit the nail on the head. When Franco Debono "ABSTAINED" he committed political suicide. You cannot trust someone that does not have enough guts and stamina to carry out his threats. You play with fire, you get burned and I think Franco Debono will get burned because he is no match to Dr Gonzi.

Joseph Grech Attard

Feb 8th, 16:49

i would ask Gonzi to stop the farce as well! Or it is an anticipation of Carnival?


mario piscopo

Feb 8th, 21:18

The PM can finish this farce instead he is opting for more extra time!

George Azzopardi

Feb 9th, 15:15

I believe that Dr.Debono made it obvious who some of the clique are ... these are those ending with names like Mifsud Bonnici, Gonzi, Fenech Adami, Borg Olivier etc .. you can also include in the list Austin Gatt, Pulicino. Giovanna Debono. Isn't this so obvious!!!

Joseph Calleja

Feb 8th, 15:58

It seems like Franco Debono is one good defense lawyer but he is not a good politician. He has demonstrated that he is no match to Dr Gonzi. Twice he had the chance to challenge Dr Gonzi and twice he decided to 'ABSTAIN" on the vote. Franco Debono has to learn that if you do the talk, you must do the walk. Maybe the third time is a charm, how about it Franco Debono?

Wenzu Vella

Feb 9th, 07:45

Joseph I expected you to comment on the other bits but you chose not to because I am spot on about the stale and corrupt PN government. Tell us I am wrong and you win a price.

Manuel Scicluna

Feb 8th, 20:40

"Gonzipn that had giving us jobs and guaranteed them" WHAT JOBS ??? with 3 months contract jobs, part time jobs, minimum wage jobs.... do you call them jobs??? ...and how about the conditions of such jobs eh???

Joseph Calleja

Feb 8th, 16:00

I believe that the Italians have the right phrase. " Paroli si, fatti no". That is a perfect description.

M.Dolores Vassallo

Feb 8th, 13:26

Well said. I would like even to add or ask more likely Dr.Debono did you resign or still in the PN?
Because if you are I am sorry to say that you have approved everything even the evil Clique, that you mentioned yourself.

Joseph Portelli

Feb 8th, 13:33

target date biex tara l-elezzjoni sur lapira: latest August 2013 :) - not before March 2013

joseph saliba

Feb 8th, 14:04

R they?!?

Guido Farrugia

Feb 8th, 13:58

Skuzi ta, staqsi lil Dr. Debono ghal tal-klikka ghax huwa qed isemmihom u mhux Noel.Parir, mur stahba kif ghamel Angus Black malli Astrid qaltlu/qalitila li hija Daphne CG.Nerga nighdlek, ghal darb'ohra, kemm int ghajjien fl-argumenti. Din sieheb id-dahla glorjuza tal Belt Valletta.

Joe Farrugia

Feb 8th, 12:55

nahseb lilek dejjaq ghax qedin imdendlin u bla poter fil parlament

godwin difesa

Feb 8th, 13:22

Yes PM will listen he will do election but in a year time.Why are you so inpatient or you are going to be one of TAL Kilkka of PL if one day will be in power.Take it easy be patient 25 years had past wait 1 more year but only for the race to start then we see after what will be the result may be like 2008 photo finish.

S. Bonello

Feb 8th, 12:34

DOUBLE YAWN UKOLL

Joseph Portelli

Feb 8th, 12:37

minn meta joseph brincat jitkellem f'isem il-maggoranza?

Tony Agius

Feb 8th, 13:37

HEY HEY , witch majority are you shouting about ? , who gave you the right to call your self majority ? , and witch GOD are you referring to as your GOD ?

Darren Muscat

Feb 8th, 12:10

Very well said!

Robert Zammit

Feb 8th, 12:16

To me it just seems that Franco is just seeking attention. He seems comfused and unreliable as some one who says he resigned from PN should at least should sit in the middle of the house as he does not form part of the PN goverment any more but maybe has become now just an independent MP supporting the government where he sees fit.Untill he does that he will never be taken seriously now I think. Having said that , we don't know what he's been told could happen to him if he rocks the boat any more than he's done already !

S. Bonello

Feb 8th, 12:38

U tghid mhux ser jirrepjah (wrap) u jibaghtu lÁlaska !!!

Ghajjejtna Dr. Gonzi !!!

godwin difesa

Feb 8th, 12:56

Yesterday the PL and the Maltese people had the answer of the instability that the PL are saying there is.
Where there is instability no person or Companies will even think to invest but thank God this country and most of all the Government have the best certificate of trust.If i am not wrong there was almost double demand for the Government Bonds.Franco had the cans and the freedom to say what he believe in public about the political party he belongs too,in democracy that how it should be but only from the PN party we can expect his deputy's criticizes there own party.About cliques there are there in bought party s and will remain there for ever in politics.I do not understand how PL want to talk about cliques or you already forget after the election of 2008 it was only 4 years ago.Franco is free to say what he wants and any where he wants because he is still part of PN family as the PM sad because he wants that PN will win the next election ,if he wished to see PN in the opposition he could ha stayed quiet even not attend the parliament like others do for this few months left and see PN drawn,but he is giving PN the warning so they will be on alert before it will be to late as there is not to much left.

A Trapani

Feb 8th, 13:43

mario... int taf x'qed tghid? you want another vote of confidence in parliament ? we just had one few days ago and the PN won.

A Tonna

Feb 8th, 13:17

A Game of Seats !

M camilleri

Feb 8th, 12:38

mur ghamel siegha xoghol sur Hili forsi idahal lira il pajjiez min fuqek :)

Philip Hili

Feb 8th, 13:06

@ M Camilleri,

Sur Camilleri,

Mohhi mistrieh, zaqqi mimlija, hemm inti tahdem ghalija!!!!

U grazzi.

Philip Hili

Feb 8th, 11:49

@ Jo Meli

Taf kemm tibqa' "Proud VERY Proud of you Franco."? Sakemm taqla xi wahda "below the belt" ghax ma jkunx ghogbok!! Dan l-ezempju diga' gara!!

Imbaghad nahseb li tghid li mhux ragel dan!!!!!

Hawn Maaann!!!! - ghad fadlilha l-elezzjoni!!!

Mario Bonnici

Feb 8th, 12:09

@ Philip Hili
L-iktar li fadlilha l-elezzjoni sena ohra. Jigifieri hemm qieghdin. Bdejna l-countdown.

Jo Meli

Feb 8th, 11:20

Blame it on Lawrence Gonzi's MANAGEMENT style !

It is NOT just Franco Debono who is stating these accusations so but the ORDINARY man and woman in the street who have eyes to see.

The ONLY way out is a General Election which Lawrence Gonzi is delaying so that what he, Lawrence Gonzi, and his minions took BEHIND the Parliament's back and and the Tax-payer's (YOU and the rest of the People of Malta and Gozo) is rectified and rendered as "approved".

Philip Hili

Feb 8th, 11:31

@ VINCENT WILLIAMS

Are you joking Mr. Williams?

Can you explain to the readers your meaning of "The ongoing instability of the country "?

But don't forget to take into consideration the " INSTABILITY"!!!! SHOWN BY THE MALTESE PEOPLE YESTERDAY - when the government stocks were launched!!

U Hallina Maaannnn!! Lanqas daqshekk ma taraw????? Nehhu l-ghamad politiku u mbaghad kunu ppreparati biex forsi, forsi, u forsi xi darba tiggvernaw lil dan in-Nazzjon!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

May be Franco Debono can help you to define the meaning of your nonsense!!

Philip Hili

Feb 8th, 11:36

@ Vince Williams

"Besides our country will not continue to be the laughing stock of the EU. "

Hawn Maaaaaannnnnnnn!! ahna ahna jew m'ahniex?? Kif skirt ghal poter!!! Jekk tista' tikkritika fuq kollox zgur ma tistax tghid li ahna "our country will not continue to be the laughing stock of the EU".

Inkunu "the laughing stock of the EU", jekk Alla jikkastigana u Dr. Emails (remember Sabrina Agius???) jahtaf il-poter.

Hemm xi Email ohra jew?

Philip Hili

Feb 8th, 11:41

@ Jo Meli

U dan il-"mismanagement" gie fdat bid-doppju ta' fondi li ried!!!

Mela kieku!!!! kellu "management style" ahjar u forsi kif tixtieq int, kemm kien jafdah aktar IL-POPLU MALTI?!!!!!!!!!

Zepp, qabel tikteb ara l-affarijiet sew.

A Tonna

Feb 8th, 13:11

Who dares contest Dr Gonzi !

Frans Aguis

Feb 8th, 10:43

No you can't stand him BEING in the news at all.

m. borg (slm)

Feb 8th, 11:17

Wrong Mr Micallef, reform at times has been achieved even through violence and wars brush up your history.
.
""We have taken years debating the honoraria lack of teamwork issue, the highly polluting power station extension, the public transport reform fiasco and the disappearance of primary health reform, when we should have dedicated this time to the strengthening of democracy and constitutional reforms." It was wrong decisions and bad implementation which caused instability," have you read this part Mr Micallef.

Mr Joe Micallef

Feb 8th, 11:45

when was sustainabe reform achieved through violence? maybe in the 80s

m. borg (slm)

Feb 8th, 13:02

Don't be puerile Mr Micallef. Keep to the argument you sound so hollow I will not enter into anargument about the past not there is any shame in it but I prefer to look foward in mending the damage this government managed to bring to the country.

Mr Joe Micallef

Feb 8th, 14:00

borg reply

when was sustainabe reform achieved through violence?

Michael Seychell

Feb 8th, 10:46

Your own Comment shows that you are talking nonsense, so much so that Dr. L. Gonzi is the first Member of Parliament with this surname - albeit his uncle Mons M. Gonzi served in the Senate as an M.L.P. representative.

One may also mention Dr. P Borg Olivier who although he is the general secretary of the P.N. he was never a member of Parliament, and in all probability there will not be another Borg Olivier M.P. for a long number of years.
.

Finally I can mention Dr.F. Zammit Dimech, who is the only M.P. ever with that surname, and in his case he served as a Minister in previous P.N. goverments. I may add that despite the fact that is now serving the country as a back bancher, he is one of the front liners of the P.N. always putting forward and explaining the Goverments programme, not only in the House but also on various media.

Michael Seychell
Tal-Pieta

Jo Meli

Feb 8th, 11:02

GAFFE by the Great Michael Seychell :)


Sir Michael Gonzi was the BROTHER of Lawrence Gonzi's GRAND FATHER !!

Mr Andrew Camilleri

Feb 8th, 15:30

And another gaffe: there was no M.L.P. at the time Mons. Gonzi served as senator.

Edward Curmi

Feb 8th, 10:18

Ghaziz Sur debono...tibqax tghamel b'satten fir roti u halli lill min imexxi jghamel xoghlu.

Nispera li tiehu risposta wara l-elezzjoni ta kap tal partit li qed tiggieled wahdek!!

Joseph E Briffa

Feb 8th, 10:28

Ma nistax nifhem certu kummenti. Min huma il-klikka, Mr Mifsud? Jaqaw il-membri tal-kabinett saru jissejhu 'klikka'? Jekk dan huwa l-kaz mela il-gvernijiet kollha imexxu bil-klikka. Il-kabinett irid jiehu d-decizjonijiet kollha fl-ahhar mill-ahhar. Kull membru parlamentari jista' jwassal l-idejat tieghu kemm fill-parlament fil-miftuh, jew inkella billi jibghad memorandum sigriet lill-kabinett u jressaq il-proposti tieghu. Xi membri parlamentari jippreferu mod u ohrajn jippreferu mod iehor. Jiddependi xi jkun jaqbel lilhom personalment. Jekk membru parlamentari jhoss li ghandu pont jew kaz li ser izidlu l-popolarita' u l-voti, juza' il-parlament, jekk il-proposta ma tkunx wahda popolari, allura jaghzel li jibghat memo sigriet.

Charles J. Buttigieg

Feb 8th, 10:37

Franco is stating the obvious and preaching to the converted. He's been trying to disestablish the unrepentant establishment to change its ways to no avail. What is he going to do about it ? Isn't it high time for him now to move from talk to solid actions?

Mr Joseph Carmel Chetcuti

Feb 8th, 10:54

I agree with Charles a 100%. You cannot be taken seriously if you say you will vote against a motion of confidence and then you abstain. You are either a man of your word or not!

Michael Seychell

Feb 8th, 10:55

Ms. Muscat - just a short reminder. There was a time that a Labour Goverment had two Mintoffs and two - if not three Sants since I am not certain whether Dr. Alfred Sant was already an M.P at the time Lorry and Salvu Sant were M.Ps.


Michael Seychell
Tal-Pieta

pat muscat

Feb 8th, 13:31

@Seychell: There were two Mintoffs ...'.were' not 'are! For the PN who who's, look nowhere except in the family tree: minghandu il-busnannu li kien Ministru, min ghandu li missieru li kien Prim Ministru, min ghandu lil zijuh li kien tal-qalba, min ghandu lil kuginuh li kien speaker; imsomma' Its all in the family' u nies bhalek, Mr Seychell, tajbin biss biex tibqa 'foot soldiers' jigiefieri TOBDU dak li jghidulkom tal-family tree!

Advert
Advert