Women ‘attacked police’ as football fan lay dying
Two female football fans grabbed a policewoman by the hair and punched and pushed her as she was trying to create some space for a man to breathe after he suffered a heart attack during a match, a court heard yesterday.
The two women, Darlene Borg, 22, and Angiolina Borg, 43, both from Valletta, were expressing outrage at the time it was taking for the man to get medical assistance, the policewoman, Constable Rodene Ghirxi, testified.
The man, Louis Micallef, 56, was watching the match between Valletta FC and Hibernians on September 25 last year when he collapsed at about 8.15 p.m. He later died.
WPC Ghirxi said she was told to move people away from the man to make way for the emergency services and to give him space to breathe. As she was doing so, she asked the accused to climb the stairs and away from the man.
However, the two fans started arguing with her because of the time it was taking for medical assistance to arrive, the constable said.
They then grabbed her by the hair, swearing and shouting, until other officers arrived to drag them off her.
Police Sergeant George Polidano told the court he called the ambulance twice during the incident and he was the person who dragged Darlene Borg screaming and kicking, off WPC Ghirxi.
She even kicked him between the legs after which she told him it was nothing personal but she had wanted to get at the policewoman.
Cross-examining the witness, defence lawyer Franco Debono asked how long it took for the ambulance to arrive, to which the sergeant replied five to 10 minutes.
When the lawyer suggested that it took much longer, and that it was more like 45 minutes, Sergeant Polidano said it was more like 10 to 15 minutes.
A few days after the incident, the president of the Malta Football Association, Norman Darmanin Demajo, rubbished claims that Mr Micallef died because he had no medical assistance. He said a doctor was at his side within five minutes of the man collapsing.
The case continues.
23 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Joseph Dimech
Feb 8th, 17:46
it-tort mhux tal-pulizija, mhux tal-ground managment, mhux tal-medical staff, mhux tan-nies li fit-triq jostakolaw ambulanza. it-tort hu ta l-mfa. hi l-mfa li torganizza il-kampjonat li jaqa fil-kategorija "avveniment tal-massa" u ghalhekk hija responsabbli li jkun hemm first aid stand u ambulanza stand by. almenu mhux hekk nahseb imma hekk NEMMEN!!!
DAN KOLLU BIR-RISPETT KOLLU LEJN L-MFA IS-SUR BJORN (insejt kunjomu) U DR. DARMANIN DEMAJO LI GABU QAWMIEN U LIVELL GDID FIL-LOGHBA DOMESTIKA.
Mr Ernest Vella
Feb 8th, 14:29
Damet kemm damet l-ambulanza, ghidlu lil Franco Debono, il-pulizija ma jahtux u kull vjolenza kontra l-pulizija taht l-ebda cirkostanza m'hi skuzabli. Ghax jien ma naqbilx li kien ha jwaqqa l-Gvern, b'hekk ma jfissirx li jiena ghandi dritt nerfa jdejha fuqu...anke jekk ma naqbilx mieghu. Kieku wegghu lil pulizija kien ikun hemm bzonn ta zewg ambulanzi u mhux ta wahda...logika hux
D. A . Agius
Feb 8th, 13:17
Policemen used to be given basic first aid (not certified), at least at entrance in the service and during refresher courses.
Judging that health professionals are not always present at mass activities, maybe the Police Force could afford to have a small percentage of its force trained by St. John's or Red Cross in further advanced first aid (with frequent refresher courses) so that at least when such cases happen, there is a greater chance of them being around.
A practical example could be to include this is NCO and officer training or have "special" constables, with at least one or two being specifically available for such mass gatherings. In that way, Police Officers themselves, and the General Public, would get better chances of informed and trained first aiders to be around.
In any case, if memory serves me right, in this case the major issue was that the ambulance itself could not make it to the ground as fast as possible due to illegally parked cars outside the stadium. That's something everyone can help in by simply get over our laziness and walk those extra 100 or 200m to the stadium.
Saviour M Garzia
Feb 8th, 13:16
Do the MFA have a health and safety officer present during football gtames? Isn't it normal to have an ambulance on standby at the stadium during a game,when a large number of supporters are present? What about the Chief Security officer in charge of the stadium? Clarification is expected after a man lost his life,learn from past mistakes.
Carmel Xuereb
Feb 8th, 11:43
Jehlu l-pulizija li alla hares ma jkunxu huma f'hafna kazijiet, jehlu ta l-ambulanaz, tinsiex li dawn iridu jigbru li-staff mediku qabel jitilqu mill-isptar. mill-isptar Mater Dei sa Ta' Qali zgur li ser iddum izjed minn 10 minuti biex tasal u trid issib it-triq sewwa mhux ikun hemm xi hadd li ma jhallix taghdi lill-ambulaza, l-istaff mediku jiehu z-zmien biex kif jasal l-istadium jilhaq il-pazjent, jigifieri tghaddi iktar min kwarta zgur u nafu fi zgur li kull staff mediku u l-pulizija jaghmlu minn kollox biex il-pazjent jibqa haj. Issa rigward l-imputati forsi dawn kienu jigu minnu u ma naghtihomx tors sa barra, imma jekk ma kienux jigu minnu dawn ghandhom ikunu kkastigati hafna iktar milli kieku kienu jigu minn dik il-persuna moribonda. Hawn Malta sirna qisna li kullhadd ghandu dritt ghal dak li jahseb jew irid imma sejrin zball u ghalhekk hemm bzonn ta' iktar dixxiplina specjalment fost iz-zaghzagh.
Paul Sammut
Feb 8th, 13:09
Quite right Mr. XUEREB The police and officers always do what is required in their capacity they can only clear the way for the ambulance they are not the once driving it. Why is it that that we always have to be against the Police force.
They WORK NIGHT AND DAY, public holidays, Xmas and New year while we are at home with our familys
and their familys have to be alone, in fact it is like even ther familys have joined the Police force.
Come on lets have some respect for the Police force.
Kurt Magro
Feb 8th, 11:25
Iddum ma tigi l Ambulanza u jehlu l Puluzija li kienu duty fil ground.... is- solitu... Maltese GEMGEM !
Jay Oatmon
Feb 8th, 11:12
@ Karl Abela
I would say that violence happens in many other countries - but that is no excuse.
Theft happens in all countries - but that is no excuse.
Murder happens in all countries - but that is no excuse.
What others do is not the problem - it is what we do that is the problem.
In my view the Malta courts do not give out proper deterrent sentences, so violence has become more 'the norm' than it should be in Malta.
adriana debono
Feb 8th, 11:09
tistghu pls iggibu quddiem ghajnejkom li il persuna li mietet fdin it tracedja halliet familja wara .. u jiddispjecini nghid li hawn certu kummenti mhumiex xierqa u li iweggaw. jekk joghgobkom oqodu attenti xtiktbu ghax ghalikom din hija just storja pero ghall hadd iehor din hi kapitlu minn hajtu li hi tragika u kera
Anne Farrugia
Feb 8th, 11:03
Jay Oatmon...who's calling the kettle black here??? Come on we read the newspapers and travel to the UK too and know what happens in GREAT BRITIAN! lol lol You're all good and obedient! As to ethics being taught at school....i wonder what your kids are being taught at home (1st 5 years at home with parent hooligans - some of them) prior to attending schools! Easy to put the blame on the schools because everyone spends a large number of years being educated, but no one realises that a lot of social education & ETHICS are learnt at home. So please Jay Oatmon I think you'd better go back to kindy and start all over again! Don't you think?
John Micallef
Feb 8th, 10:54
Those two women should kick themselves too and not only the police... if they really wanted a change and to help others they should have gotten a first aid course... and help would have been there within seconds.
Franco Abela
Feb 8th, 10:54
Jigifieri jekk ambulanza iddum (li mhux sewwa) jehel il Pulizija! Tajbaaaaaa!
Christopher Grech
Feb 8th, 10:43
That is because they have no fear of human laws. If they had they would not harm anyone, let alone the police.
Only God's Laws are the sane ones! Day by day this message should get through to some people.
http://jahtruth.net/godgovmt.htm
Joe Baldacchino
Feb 8th, 10:35
@Gauci
I agree with you, but who will be punished for a lost life? By law where mass crowd is present an ambulance should be on stand by and medical assistance or at least first aiders shoule available.
This issue is being kept silent so that everyone will forget about it and move on with life..
but for the family concerned this is totally unfair
Kurt Magro
Feb 8th, 10:33
u nerga nghid... alahares kienet bil- kontra l bicca ghax headline qeda !
R ferriggi
Feb 8th, 10:13
typical.
Karl Consiglio
Feb 8th, 23:17
of old people to die?
Joanna Gauci
Feb 8th, 10:10
Those two women must be punished for attacking a police constable who was carring out her duties diligently....
Mr Peter Barbara
Feb 8th, 10:47
...come on, they were just supporting their team !!
Matthew Alamango
Feb 8th, 10:48
even if they attacked anyone, no one has the right to attack any one, we are 'not' animals!
Mariella Caruana
Feb 9th, 19:43
and the punishment should be a course in first aid!
Jay Oatmon
Feb 8th, 09:25
Another case of wacko violence in Malta - but this time by women.
What sort of ethics are being taught in schools? and what affect do the courts feeble sentences for violence have, if women are ready to attack a police officer?
Karl Abela
Feb 8th, 10:17
Jay you are questioning about ethics in our schools.
So what we have to say about the same topic in the UK where teenagers kill each other. Did you forget about the famours English football hooligans?