Advert

Government to tighten laws against hate crime

Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi said today that he had instructed Justice Minister Chris Said to embark on a consultation process to see whether the laws to prevent hate crime could be strengthened.

In a statement this afternoon, Dr Gonzi said he was speaking because there had been two incidents over the past three weeks which could have been motivated by homophobia.

The two cases, he said, were still being investigated and subject to court proceedings, but if homophobia was proved, this would be very worrying.

The country had to respect the dignity of all people, independently of one's colour, belief or orientation.

He said society should not judge individual persons and the laws had to be enforced.

The two cases referred to by the prime minister was an assault on two girls in Hamrun and, last Friday, an incident on a bus in Floriana.

Advert

80 Comments

Post comment

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Mike Hunt

Feb 9th, 12:08

By the same token, some imams teach on how to properly beat your wife in pious islamic states. A lot of religious teachings are deviant and if political correctness is guilty of one mortal sin (pun intended), it's of being apologetic to the inhumanity of religious teaching.

Mario Mamo

Feb 7th, 21:26

For a very simple reason. Angels like STAR return hate and torture with LOVE and DEVOTION. Homo sapiens returns love with TREACHERY, MURDER, ROBBERY, ENSLAVEMENT and all other vile actions that he is capable of. Actions that would be impossible to list.

Luke Lanzon

Feb 7th, 23:15

humans have a voice animals don't.......(at least a voice that we don't understand), but you seem worried!! the more things become equal to humans as a species and the less religious it gets, the more it shows in your comments.

Karl Consiglio

Feb 8th, 23:54

"The non introduction of gay "marriage" is not a hate crime!"

Imagine not being allowed to marry the one you love.

Jo Grima

Feb 8th, 01:35

very well said !! prosit valerie

Jo Grima

Feb 8th, 01:37

I agree 1000000%

Mr F J Brincat

Feb 7th, 18:38

Not everyone that attended the gay rights demonstrations is gay - in case you have trouble understanding; you don't need to be gay to abhore and condemn violence. And young people have a right to protest as well you know. And the use of brain matter is not exclusive to your goodself.




Mr Joseph Carmel Chetcuti

Feb 7th, 21:16

V Cauchi should understand that even minors are homosexual. Attend a pride march as was held last weekend in Melbourne and you will soon realise how many young poeople are either gay or lesbian. Minors do not need to be protected from homosexuality. They need to be protected from abuse and assault (sexual or otherwise) and from ignorance and the brainwashing into heterosexuality that you exemplify so well.

Mark Zerafa

Feb 7th, 18:50

Hateful as they may be, attacks on senior citizens are never an end in themselves. When senior citizens are attacked, the perpetrator is (usually) after their belongings. What makes homophobic attacks particularly horrific is that they are motivated by sheer hate - the victims are beaten up simply for being the persons they are. Legislation against mugging and robbery is already in place. Spot the difference?

J. J. Borg

Feb 7th, 18:01

There probably isn't but if you feel so strongly about it and think you have a case, why don't you do something? Mhux tistenna l-bajtra taqa f'halqek, kif nghidu bil-Malti.

Emma Xerri

Feb 7th, 19:09

@D. Galea

That is right, it is open season if you happen to be White and Christians or Atheist, living in your own country. And this unfortunate trend is going on all in previously majortiy White Christain nations. We have become second-class citizens, always at the whim of others, that we might insult some religion or other or harbour realistic thoughts that happen not to be politically correct. It is amazing how our leaders all attend the same 'Conferences' where they all get the 'memo',then go back to their respective countries and unfurl the plan. From Sweden to Malta to Canada etc, they are all on the same page, if you know what I mean.

Ramon Casha

Feb 7th, 20:09

If there are consistent, targeted attacks on any of the groups you mentioned for no other reason than the fact that they belong to those groups, then yes, they should set up a group and I would support them. However I don't believe there is such a phenomenon.

Ms. P.M Graham

Feb 7th, 16:25

Ms Vella, Have you ever been physically attacked BECAUSE of your sexuality or because of the color of your skin?

Joseph Aquilina

Feb 7th, 16:42

@Ms. P.M Graham
A few years ago my uncle was beaten in the village feast because there was a little animosity between his family and the family of the aggressor. Having a law which distinguishes between an attack on a person and an attack on a homosexual would AUTOMATICALLY IMPLY that my uncle (his case is long closed now) is discriminated against because of his sexual orientation. Now is that fair? Wouldn’t it be better if we had a LAW FOR EVERYONE?

Ms.D. Galea

Feb 7th, 17:03

@Mr Graham, I got verbally abused a number of times for being a practicing Roman Catholic. Will I qualify for sympathy from such as your good self?

Colin Stanley

Feb 7th, 17:15

Yes , this is what happens with PC. If he hit them he should be charged, as if he had hit anyone else. and by the way, on the recording,some woman called him names.

carlos ellul

Feb 7th, 17:31

Yepp that what it means.

Jo Grima

Feb 7th, 17:39

if i were the government i would also start fining people €1000 who pass comments like yours Ms Maria Vella. so your question has been answered !!

carlos ellul

Feb 7th, 17:44

Does it really matter Mr Graham? Isn't a punch a punch irrespective of the victim's sex, colour of his skin and religion?

Ms. P.M Graham

Feb 7th, 18:17

To J Aquilina, et al

In an ideal world one Law for everyone, where everyone was equal in the eyes of the Law would be perfect, but you only have to read some of the comments any time Gays are mentioned here to know that equal we are not. Some talk about Gays as if they are second class citizens, so it's actually people like them with that superiority complex that have brought about this situation. Not just here in Malta, but in every other country World wide that have had to introduce Laws such as these.

and Ms Galea, get back to me when you actually feel the teeth in your mouth break, your eyes swell and your nose break. I am talking PHYSICAL abuse.


and your comment, "Will I qualify for sympathy from such as your good self? " hmmmmm you truly don't understand do you, or may I suggest, want to understand, which from your own statement, in your post, "being a practicing Roman Catholic". is surprising ?

and it's MS!!

Mr Ellul, in an ideal World, in an ideal World.

carlos ellul

Feb 7th, 19:04

I presume that in an ideal world there will be no violence. Anyway imagine a scene were two persons got beaten up. One is an heterosexual and the other one is homosexual. How are you going to justify to the former victim that he is a lesser victim then the latter.

Joseph Aquilina

Feb 7th, 19:10

@Ms. P.M Graham
"but you only have to read some of the comments any time Gays are mentioned here to know that equal we are not"

- Call it a strange hobby, but I read the majority of the comments and apart from one or two the majority condemns the violent act but still wish to have a law which is equal for everyone. The first people who’ll suffer from a law which does not consider everyone as equal will be those same people the law is trying to protect, since in the eyes of the law those people would be considered as different, something, which if I’m not wrong, gay people are completely against (being considered different)!


Emma Xerri

Feb 7th, 19:16

@Jo Grima

So you are all for muzzling people and taking away their rights of free expression? Then tell me that you are not a Fascist. A classic example of using minority rights to do away with the rights of the majority.

Ms. P.M Graham

Feb 7th, 20:43

To Mr J Aquilina; I actually agree with your post in its entirety. It's so sad that it has come to this, and can I just say, thank you. I have enjoyed our correspondence :)

Ms. P.M Graham

Feb 7th, 16:39

But isn't this why the Law is required because we are NOT all equal?

Maria Camilleri

Feb 7th, 16:54


Claire Bonello got the reasoning behind hate crimes all wrong in that article.

It is the punishment of random acts of violence on a group of people due to certain inherent characteristics (such as gender, sexual orientation, religion, race). The mens rea would be hate towards a group of people and such hate being expressed in violence which should be criminalised.

It would be childish to think that the inclusion of the above crimes would somehow belittle any other crime or increase discrimination on the discriminated.

Charles W. Sammut

Feb 7th, 15:52

So we should allow animals to be tortured to death in the name of political correctness, multiculturalism and diversity.

Even The Netherlands, probably the most tolerant country in Europe has banned halal and Kosher slaughter of animals. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-15610142

Joseph Aquilina

Feb 7th, 15:56

What’s a shame is a fellow Maltese who prefers to throw mud at his own country rather than provide POSITIVE criticism in order to help his country move forward. The TRUTH is that in general the Maltese are far from being homophobic or racist and throughout history have always been known to give a helping hand where needed.

D Muscat

Feb 7th, 16:18

Good thing you are Maltese. Saying such a sweeping statement as "you are intolerant " to a whole group in this case of Maltese would be considered a racist statement had you not been Maltese.

Darren Portelli

Feb 7th, 16:32

Charles,
You're ignoring eveyr other slaughterhouse on the island. Most other western nations allow halal and kosher practises.

Joseph you're living in a bubble. Maltese may give a helping hand to people of other faiths but they see them as foreigners and will never see them as equals.

Joseph Aquilina

Feb 7th, 16:53

@Darren Portelli
During my stay in the UK I never had problems with the people I used to work with – actually they were all great people and coming from different background too. Once I went out on my own and was immediately bullied; I was told that it is because the locals do not like foreigners!! The entire world is like that! Malta is a better because someone in need will usually always find a helping hand!!

Ms.D. Galea

Feb 7th, 17:07

Would you defend me if I get verbally abused for being a practicing Roman Catholic, or is bashing non- muslims free speech as far as you are concerned?

Darren Portelli

Feb 7th, 18:50

Ms.D. Galea

If you look at my comment then you'll see I already did just that by referencing religious states like Saudi Arabia.
You are simply deflecting the comment by using a red herring. And the odds of you being discriminated in Malta for being a catholic are probably slimmer than the odds of you winning the lotto the lotto the same day you get hit by lightning

Ramon Casha

Feb 7th, 20:12

The laws against animal cruelty are not there to target Muslims or Jews. They are there to prevent cruelty to animals and apply to everyone.

Charles W. Sammut

Feb 7th, 15:48

Dear Carlos, you are the wrong colour, wrong gender and wrong sexual orientation. Expect that anything you say, do or even think, will be held against you. You are not entitled to an opinion and if you criticise, you will be accused of 'hatred'. But remember, even if you are not allowed to 'hate', you can love some more than others ;-)

Valerie Borg

Feb 7th, 16:19

Can you tell me of an incident when a heterosexual couple was assaulted because of their public display of affection? I am very interested in your answer? If yes then tell me was the thug arrested straight away?

Both incidents are clearly because of the sexual orientation of the victims. We are all human and we all deserve and have the right to feel safe in our own country. Now if we don't feel safe in our own streets cause of our sexuality because of the ignorance of others then yes a different law is well deserved. Don't judge before you walk a mile in other peoples shoes. Now it would be great if everyone was treated equally however in these cases the police didn't take action against the thugs until there was public outroar! If the law covered everyone equally these thugs would've been arrested for assault straight away.

carlos ellul

Feb 7th, 17:30

I have actually experienced incidents were heterosexual couples were harassed for their public display of affection. You may not notice but the world is filled with idiots and puritans. There were many reasons why it didn't degenerate into a full blown fight. Sometimes the BF was strong enough to ward them off. In other occasions, the BF had friends who stepped in and there were cases when the couple were mature enough to just leave the place and let the idiot take his 'win'. In the first case I was involved in persona.

I agree that the driver should be punished. I refuse to accept any type of abuse whether its physical or verbal. What I disagree on is in discriminating violence. If I punch you I should be punished as fiercely as if you punched me.

Steve M. Engerer

Feb 7th, 15:31

Oh yes George... we are so lucky to have the PL & Joseph to give the government instructions!!!

Get a life!!


George Azzopardi

Feb 7th, 16:21

Yr welcome gbin .. hehehehe ;)

Jo Grima

Feb 7th, 17:45

LOL !! sad, very sad !! yes you George !!

George Azzopardi

Feb 7th, 19:41

@Steve M. Engerer ... I will get a life when GonziPN steps down .. and this will be pretty soon!!

M Schranz

Feb 7th, 15:34

Mr Agius,
There is such a thing called separation of powers, thankfully. What you are suggesting is in itself tantamount to homophobia.

Karl Mercieca

Feb 7th, 15:35

What is god's way, Mr.Agius?

Frank Attard

Feb 7th, 15:47

@G. Agius: I hope I am mistaken, but I have a feeling that you wanted to say "homosexual" rather than "homophobic" in your comment above. If that is the case, I think you should go live in an extreme religious controlling state where "sinners" would be sentenced to death by stoning. But please do not take us back to the dark middle-ages with you!

Maria Camilleri

Feb 7th, 15:48


and maybe we should make sodomy a crime again... !

Michael Attard

Feb 7th, 15:51

God told you that? mann he told me something else... Sucks to be right now...

What you are saying is since stealing is illegal, granted but then you are saying the act being done in non-public area and/or not seen makes it ok? lol why would gay couples have to hide that within their own home..

Valerie Borg

Feb 7th, 16:04

if it disgusts you Mr Agius don't look. Does that mean if a gay person sees a heterosexual couple kissing in public, (happens all the time) do you see them being assaulted for doing it? Deal with it, homosexuals were around before god was even born!!!

Thomas Vella

Feb 7th, 16:04

Which god you referring too cause everyone has a different god, especially in Malta ?!

Franco Attard Trevisan

Feb 7th, 16:08

'a bit over the top'???????? are you kidding??? Apart from being homophobic that guy challenged two girls to fight!!!!!! and actually attacked them!!!

everyone has a right to walk our streets without being judged or even worse attacked....

Tell us more about 'God's way' but please make sure you present a document signed by god himself!

Kevin Camilleri

Feb 7th, 16:12

My God told me to Love and Respect everybody Mr. Agius! And I think that my GOD is the one that you are referring too... so please do not cause further harm to our Religion, because comments like yours increase hate not love.

Grazia Borg

Feb 7th, 16:23

Flopinjoni tieghi mghadniex nghidu xnahsbu li hu 'God's way' u bdin ic certezza. Li nahseb hu li Alla halaq lil kulhadd bimhabba kbira anki lil dawk li jistghu jidru differenti mill maggoranza tas socjeta.Anzi jien nemmen li ghal minoritajiet Alla ghandu mhabba specjali, ovjament din hi t-twemmien tieghi u mhux bilfors taqblu mieghi.

Ġ. Agius

Feb 7th, 17:01

the heterosexual way is the normal way, it's the natural way, it's god's way!!

After all he didn't send the holy spirit to a man, but to a woman, so yes, I do think that homosexual (I apologize for the earlier lapsus, yes it should have been homosexual not homophobic, obviously) acts in public should be legal. The unison between man and woman (after marriage, of course) is sanctimonious and approved by God Himself, the unison between man and man or woman and woman is the work of the devil and it pains me to see the morals of our Catholic country in the drains!

Luke Lanzon

Feb 7th, 19:47

It is people like you G Aguis that make me happy I left relligion for good.

Mario Mamo

Feb 7th, 21:01

Dear theologist, please be gracious to allow me a minute of your time. Is not everyone God's creation? And if you really believe that we were created on God's image you must have a problem here because our brothers and sisters who are being discussed here can't help being how they are. It is the excessive demonstration of love - or lust if you wish - that can be scandalous to kids. 'Saintly' grown ups can just look the other way and pray for the 'sinners'. Did not our Lord Jesus Christ preach about love to everyone? Did he exclude anyone? I am sure that if He were here with us today He would be the prime promoter of stiff laws against ALL hate crimes. Do not come to Me before you make peace with your brother. Acceptance is the ONLY way to be at peace with your neighbour. Tolerance and compassion are divine virtues. Do you have any of these? My impression is that you don't.

Mario Mamo

Feb 7th, 21:15

By the way. Any comments on this? http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20120207/world/catholic-leaders-ask-forgiveness-for-child-abuse.405777
Something tells me that you consider this more forgivable than a person BORN a little different from me or you. I can assure you that being the way I am does not make me feel superior in any way. I am very much afraid to play God and condemn ANYONE.

Advert
Advert