Malta sees sharpest EU drop in government debt
Malta recorded the sharpest drop in government debt in the EU during the third quarter of last year, Eurostat figures issued today show.
Eurostat said that at the end of the third quarter of 2011, the government debt to GDP ratio in the euro area (EA17) stood at 87.4%, down compared with 87.7% at the end of the second quarter of 2011. In the EU27 the ratio increased from 81.7% to 82.2%. Compared with the third quarter of 2010, the government debt to GDP ratio rose in both the euro area (from 83.2% to 87.4%) and the EU27 (from 78.5% to 82.2%).
The highest ratios of government debt to GDP at the end of the third quarter of 2011 were recorded in Greece (159.1%), Italy (119.6%), Portugal (110.1%) and Ireland (104.9%), and the lowest in Estonia (6.1%), Bulgaria (15.0%) and Luxembourg (18.5%).
Compared with the second quarter of 2011, fourteen Member States registered an increase in their debt to GDP ratio at the end of the third quarter of 2011, and thirteen a decrease. The highest increases in the ratio were recorded in Hungary (+4.8 percentage points - pp), Greece (+4.4 pp) and Portugal (+3.6 pp), and the largest decreases in Italy and Malta (both -1.6 pp) and Romania (-1.0 pp).
Compared with the third quarter of 2010, twenty Member States registered an increase in their debt to GDP ratio at the end of the third quarter of 2011, and seven a decrease. The highest increases in the ratio were recorded in Greece (+20.3 pp), Portugal (+18.9 pp) and Ireland (+16.5 pp), and the largest decreases in Sweden (-1.6 pp), Luxembourg (-1.4 pp) and Bulgaria (-0.9 pp).
See full statement and graphs by clicking on the pdf below.
67 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Joseph Grech Attard
Feb 6th, 18:20
Election time is near and, hence, pro GonziPN media shall start playing about with figures! The truth is that in a few years of joining the Eurozone, we are heading for a disaster, like the rest of Europe. When we joined the problems were already there. They did not happen overnight. Yet, GonziPN betrayed us by showing us a false picture. Alfred Sant was right in shelving malta's application. Time has proved him right. 3 months do not mean that things are going to be better. Predictions say that thing shall worsen. Blowing trumpets at this stage does more harm than good!
Mr Joe Borg
Feb 6th, 18:52
Are you serious!??
Just try to imagine us not in the EU and out of the euro zone, and without the funding we got from the EU. We would still look like we're still in the stone age.
Alfred Sant kien l-ahar leader li-dan il-pajjiz qatt kellu, u huwa ix-xempju ta kif politiku ikun ikkakmat mas-sigu tal-poter wara li tilef tlett elezjonijiet u referendum. Hammar wicc il-partit laburista.
Kemm int maqtuh mir-rejalta siehbi.
Edward Curmi
Feb 7th, 15:19
Yes in fact if we didnt join the EU we would be "the third world country of Europe" I am sure you enjoy driving through new roads all constructed with EU funds or walking past a restored monument thanks to Eu funds!!
Emma Xerri
Feb 6th, 18:18
it seems to me that in this age, governments are being run by accoutants. The social aspect and increase in poverty is never calculated when considering debt etc. Austerity measures are being enforced from above, never mind that the other side of autserity is economic stagnation. It is about time we get back to government run for the people and not a government run to balance the books - certain things you cannot put a price on. However, this trend of running a country as one would run a corporation is leadubg to the creation of a permanently poor underclass.
pat muscat
Feb 6th, 17:19
And may I ask, which political party is responsible for the rest of our massive 87.4% of debt? By the way the European Community says that every country should have a debt of less than 60% to GDP ratio. Can anybody translate this debt reduction from 87.4% to 60% in terms of sacrifices and hardships needed? The truth is that GonziPn instead of making hay whilst the sun was shining, (ghaqal) it went on an uncontrolled spending spree that is 'hala'!
Hossam Helwani
Feb 6th, 17:35
@ pat muscat
once you squeel like a parrot , you need to sit down and jot some figures.
Lejber left office in 1987 with a 7000 worker employed irregularly overnight as a pre election twist.
The Nationalist Government had to burden these irregular workers and placing them not to cause any unnecessary hardships.
When the Nationalist Government started to Govern They found a dockyars sucking off revenue without paying of taxes and national contributions.
We had no power station, we had no proper colleges to educate nurses doctors engineers Mcast housing, Hospital , single mothers schemes,
The Nationalist Government inheritied a country without any infrastructure , everything on bulk buying, we had no telephone systems, everything was bought second hand from third world countries,
Now our quality of life is 100000000000000% better than in 1987 and if one had to compare why there is debt in the country just ask the countles of fabriki parastatali that the Government had to out phase to stop the workforce from doing nothing.
Today Malta is employed with one of the least unemployment rate within the EU and lejber cant admit the fact that we eat well we live well and our standard of living is outstanding .
So before you squeel you need to get your facts right.
David Buttigieg
Feb 6th, 18:42
Yes dear pat muscat,
Do you know of any country that manages without taking loans? Do you know what type of country we would be reduced to?
The utter shambles we were in during the 70's and 80's under KMB and Mintoff, that's what!
But then again I know your kind would prefer that, who cares as long as nobody else is allowed to improve their lot!
pat muscat
Feb 7th, 14:46
@ Mr Helwani. You must have lived all your life abroad because everybody knows -except you- that the Delimara Power Station is not paid yet, the Medical School of Malta is one of the oldest Medical Schools in Europe-let alone inaugurated in 1989, whilst free health was introduced by the Labour Party whilst the PN voted against!
Ronny Ingvar Breivik
Feb 6th, 16:15
Malta has done really well in the crisis. When the discussion gets hot in Northern Europe we always voice Malta as a financial centre and a quality economy. We at www.howtobet.net will be scouting the financial bookmakers for bets where we can bet on Malta to fare better on pretty much every key indicator compared to other European countries. Especially Cyprus. Well done Malta, you got quality! Keep up the good work.
Carmel Cilia
Feb 6th, 15:46
Manafx jien izda din il-gimgha il-gvern hareg stock ghal 300 miljun u mhux 150 miljun kif kien indikat fil-bidu. Tghid qieghed jaghmel bhad Deficit jitfa kollox taht it-tapit fl-ahhar kwart biex imbaghad jaghbbi kollox fis sena ta wara. Bil haqq lil Agenti tal medicini qieghed jinghad li ilgvern ghandu jtighom mal 20 milljun ewro. Akka certifikat sabih dan.
Angus Black
Feb 6th, 15:39
Just wait until Joseph reduces our W&E tariffs, without raising taxes.
Wait until unemployment explodes under his leadership, ably aided by his outdated egomaniacs from three decades ago.
Eurostat will have to implement a new graph capable of containing the soaring trend.
Guido Farrugia
Feb 6th, 18:55
At least you managed to convince yourself. Dr. Muscat is defintely convincing. Well Done Mr/Mrs Angus.
pat muscat
Feb 7th, 16:37
Angus Black reminds me of Andrew Borg Cardona always PL bashing, always!
J Craig
Feb 6th, 15:27
this is the real stability...not Joseph and co!!
Mr James Rizzo
Feb 6th, 15:01
taf x'qed nghid..li lill Dr Muscat qed jigrilu bhal Dr Sant...mhux qed tigih wahda tajba!!
Dan certifikat ta veru ghal pajjizna...u dawn il bloggers li jhobbu jgibu id-dinja fit-tarf spiccaw bla raguni ghalfejn igorru.
m. borg (slm)
Feb 6th, 16:06
Dan semma kwart tas-sena u mhux is-sena kollha, ghaliex ma tarax l-ewwel zewgt kwarti u l-ahhar kwart ukoll f'daqqa? Vera qiskom boloh tifierhu bix-xejn meta tafu li l-ekonomija hija fi krizi u d-dejn nazzjonalil qabez il-hames biljun ewro u gonzipn falliet bhala sistema.
U mela ma giebx id-dinja fit-tarf, taf min ma jghamielx hekk, min qed ipappija tajjeb, tghid int wiehed minnhom Sur Rizzo.
Mr A. Cassar
Feb 6th, 14:52
Listen all of you. This debt business by all countries on this planet has gone too far out of hand now. I wonder how this plague has gone so rampant so all the world over that it now went out of control. Shame on all the world leaders (sic !) that brought about all this disgusting situation all the world over with all the big problems to one and all.
Brian Gatt
Feb 6th, 14:26
As far as i know the Eurostat works on the figures supplied by each country, I wonder if the goverment is ever Audited would we achive the same results !!
Mr Andrea Borg
Feb 6th, 14:38
Sour grapes Mr. Gatt!
Brian Gatt
Feb 6th, 16:06
No Mr Borg
I really wish that those figure are true, honestly I wish that Malta had no debts but from what I know there was never an Audit by the EU, my worries Mr Borg (which shuold also be your worries) are that the EU will send over an Audit, they find the figures screwed up and they issue sanctions on us, sanctions that will inevitably be shouldered by us.......
Umbad tell me if these are sour grapes
GEORGE CUTAJAR
Feb 6th, 14:15
Does anyone see any reason to go for an election and change Government? I don't.
And all this from a Government who some wise nut claims to be in crisis and one compared to a sinking ship.
Steady as she goes Dr. Gonzi!!!!!!!
James McIntosh
Feb 6th, 14:13
There are three kimds of Lies:- True Lies, Damned Lies and Statistics.
Nowhere does it state that Malta owes a specific amount of Euros as a real figure of national debt
The figure would astonish you as to how many years it will take a State of approximately 400,000 people to repay. This will probably result in a tax paying population of aroud 150,000, divide that into the netional debt and see how many Euros each of you owe before you get clear of this Executive Governmental "largoise".
I note that there is a lot of camoflage figures thrown in to muddy the clear picture. This is a favourite ploy of politicians of all colour in an attempt to confound and confuse the real picture.
Believe nothing except that which can be independently verified in plain mathematics,
Its easy to tell when a politician is lying you know, his lips will be moving.
Trust no-one except yourself.
Karl Abela
Feb 6th, 14:28
And neither to we trust you. thank you.
C Sant
Feb 6th, 15:48
That is why it is compared to GDP - basically it is a level playing field, and one can compare like with like - what is more, Malta's debt is with the Maltese population and not with foreign banks - this is a major difference with the rest of the World.
Hossam Helwani
Feb 6th, 17:37
why bother answering
d. attard
Feb 6th, 14:02
Heading suggests that Government has acctually reduced its debt amount which, of course, is not the case. At debt levels of 87.4% of GDP we should be shivvering in our tangas. Look at the low generation of our economy that employs the lowest population percentage in Europe, and add to it the millions that have to be cut from expenditure because we need to, constitutionally, balance the books, and then we start talking. I am sorry to say that headlines such as this in the given context do not lead to credible analysis by whoever penned the piece.
m. borg (slm)
Feb 6th, 13:59
"Malta recorded the sharpest drop in government debt in the EU during the third quarter of last year, Eurostat figures issued today show."
.
So how about the first two quarters and the last (4th) quarter. Half a truth, in this case a quarter of a truth, is worse than a lie.
R. Abela
Feb 6th, 13:25
Eurostat said that at the end of the third quarter of 2011, the government debt to GDP ratio in the euro area (EA17) stood at 87.4%, down compared with 87.7% at the end of the second quarter of 2011. In the EU27 the ratio increased from 81.7% to 82.2%. Compared with the third quarter of 2010, the government debt to GDP ratio rose in both the euro area (from 83.2% to 87.4%) and the EU27 (from 78.5% to 82.2%).
If these figures means that the Goverment of Malta is performing well in just only 3 months of a year, so how much better performed Labour Govermennt between 1971>1987 where the GDP was hold at 23%?. This figures are all pre election bubble soap. EU democratic 'dictators' wants PN Gov in power, like they choosed for Italy & Greece, their 'YES MEN Puppits on a string.
John Zammit
Feb 6th, 13:31
Choosed? Puppits? Download spell check!
Anthony Castillo
Feb 6th, 14:02
Everybody knows how we was living in those years, we could easily be compared to a third world country and the only word we could hear is to TIE UP THE BELT AS MUCH POSSIBLE THAT WE COULD my friend, it could be that you was to young to remember.
Alfred Dimech
Feb 6th, 14:34
"If these figures means that the Goverment of Malta is performing well in just only 3 months of a year, so how much better performed Labour Govermennt between 1971>1987 where the GDP was hold at 23%?"
No, because the government debt today was achieved while permitting citizens to have a first world standard of living, which considering Malta's lack of resources, is admirable. Moreover, unlike 1971 this was achieved without having to align ourselves with the likes of Ceausescu's Romania, Gaddafi's Libya, and Kim Sung Il's North Korea for gifts.
Of course, the government debt must be reduced, it is far from ideal, and it is no secret that the government haemorrhages money, but I still disagree with your argument.
Yes, Mario Monti was unelected, and is probably a yes-man. However, if he does manage to save Italy from itself and doesn't stay longer than his mandate then I think we should accept that.
John Zammit
Feb 6th, 13:25
Grande Gonzi! 5th lowest unemployment rate in the EU and now this! The stats again speak for themselves!
R. Abela
Feb 6th, 14:15
In Spain there 64% of population have some sort of Job and another 20% unemployed, in Malta 56% of our population have some sort of Job 'or modern slavery' while another 6% unemployed. To boost our economy and to reach the least worse country in the unemployed figure we need 8% in employed people. Can some magician explains where the other 8% gone?
B Grech
Feb 6th, 13:02
On another note it looks like Eurostat included the government bodies debt (such as Enemalta) in the calculation of the national debt, the figure of about 68% of the national GDP which the government so loudly boasts about at every opportunity has been shown to be more like 88%. PL will probably have a field day with this story.
Amante Reale
Feb 6th, 12:41
I am not surprised considering the constant increase in taxes and utility bills. Of course our debt has decreased, but at what expense? There's just no money in people's hands to move the economy.
B Grech
Feb 6th, 13:59
Debt did not decrease, GDP increased during that period to an extent where the GDP to debt ratio decreased.
J Busuttil
Feb 6th, 14:47
@Amante
I await your reply which taxes increased Single or Married ?
Michelle Pirotta
Feb 6th, 15:10
Amante, which tax increase in the past four years?
Income tax came down three times in last four years.
Business tax came down (micro-invest)
tax for parents came down
tax for parents sending children to private schools came down
tax for parents using child care facilities went down
tv licence tax removed
depature tax removed
new car vehicle registration tax heavily decreased (but increased for old cars)
0% vat rate on food and medicine maintained despite eu agreement to increase
Paul Pace
Feb 6th, 12:38
I bet this will be the headlines in today's news on NET TV......and I bet as well that this will not be so important to ONE TV. They prefer to mention the increase of prices in gas and fuel not to mention the water and electricity bills!
Antoine Psaila
Feb 6th, 12:36
Il Eurostat qed tikkonferma li l partit Nazzjonalista ghamel hafna dejn permezz ta l ammont ta taxxi enormi irnexxilu jnaqqas ftit. Mela ghalhekk il kontijiet tad dawl u l ilma biex forsi naqsu ftit mid-dejn mhux vera ghax ghola z-zejt !!! Ma jipretendix il prosit hux GonziPN ???
Edward Curmi
Feb 6th, 16:06
Ghalhekk taht Pl l-artiklu jkun bill kontra ghax biex JM jghamel il weghdiet kolla ta qabel l-elezzjoni id dejn jisplodi jrid...
Liam Gauci
Feb 6th, 12:22
I profess a certain amount of ignorance on the subject too but I clearly remember that till last year we were still patting ourselves on the back for only having debts in the 60%-70% region. Now, all of a sudden, we find ourselves being consoled by the fact that our debt is "only" at 87.4%? What happened to our debt stats all of a sudden? Has no-one else notice this huge descrepancy? Because, one way or another there is some bad journalism involved as it's either a case of statistics being reported inaccurately or being explained badly if there is some form of re-adjustment involved.
In case you don't remember, here is a case in point of a Times article which is only 5 months old reporting a 68% debt projection by the end of 2011: http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20110913/local/Malta-told-to-cut-public-debt.384561
M Farrugia
Feb 6th, 12:18
Matthew dawn huma figuri ufficjali tal-Eurostat u mhux tal-Gvern Malti. INsmma dejjem ikun hemm xi hadd li jrid jara kif joskura l-verita.
Peter Murray
Feb 6th, 12:10
Here we go again.Who is Euorstat employed by and who supplies Eurostat with these figures to declare such statements?In the case of Malta it would appear that this third quarter drop in government debt was achieved without any austerity measures -so what measures exactly caused this recorded (and recorded by whom?) "sharp drop"?
J. Debono
Feb 6th, 12:57
Here we go again!! Peter 'anti-GonziPN for whatever the reason' Murray.
Erin Ciantar
Feb 6th, 16:21
You just can't give credit where it's due can you?
Matthew Galea Debono
Feb 6th, 12:03
I hate to nitpick, but this article is rather difficult to navigate. Either it's because my knowledge of statistical maths stops at O-level or because the author has given loads of numbers but has rather inconveniently not taken the time to explain the Maltese situation to the statistically challenged. I could just be a lamb and go with the 'I'll take your word for it' approach but that's probably not the most prudent stance a citizen ought to take in reading the news. If anyone could clarify these figures, I (and I'm sure many others) would be very grateful :)
Ġ. Agius
Feb 6th, 12:11
It basically means that Dr. Lawrence Gonzi and his brilliant government are doing a brilliant job, something which should by now be expected as the norm from a Nationalist government!!
Philip Hili
Feb 6th, 12:28
While being tempted to agree with what you have stated, I see no point to do this because the gist of this report says:- "Malta recorded the sharpest DROP in government debt in the EU during the third quarter of last year, Eurostat figures issued today show."
ALBERT FENECH
Feb 6th, 12:30
With so much "brilliance" around - according to G. Agius - let's have a snap General Election in March and put this "brilliance" to the test. A refusal to hold an immediate GE is tantamount to saying "we are a brilliant football team but we never consider playing any matches because we are so brilliant"....and Mr Galea Debono is correct, a lot of statistics and matheical jargon, always sure to fool and baffle almost anybody. The real proof of statistics and jargon is how much money do people have in their pockets, how much do they owe and the balance of their bank account.
ALBERT FENECH
Peter Murray
Feb 6th, 12:34
You should be earning a living as a comedian and hanks for bringing laughter into my dull day.For , as with Gonzi ,people are laughing at you-but not for long!
Leonard Brincat
Feb 6th, 12:46
Mr Agius,
Brilliant ghax idejjen 4.5 Biljuni. Mela qed titlef habib.
@ Sur Galea
Ghandek ragun habib hawwadni ha nhawdek
DamianPaul Cassar
Feb 6th, 12:51
This ratio is the amount of government debt to the GDP of the countries (how much a country produces). This information confirms that although we still finished the third quarter of 2011 with a deficit (as confirmed by both eurostat and nso) we still managed to decrease the debt ratio to GDP, indicating that the economy (GDP) grew at a better rate than debt.
Lawrence Fenech
Feb 6th, 12:59
@Agius.
You should ask Gonzi where the money came from and how much came out of the maltese pockets.
Wenzu Vella
Feb 6th, 13:04
Ha ha ha jekk nidhku aktar ihossna hazing dear G
Robert Agius
Feb 6th, 13:29
@ G agius
or someone was not doing their job well until someone slapped their wrists. But you know, Jesus walked on water and stuff...
Ġ. Agius
Feb 6th, 13:54
I think you can easily read the budget reports to know the things you're asking.
All I know is that Malta is not suffering as much as the rest of Europe, and it was ALL thanks to the great PN government that we're not in a recession and begging for alms!
Philip Hili
Feb 6th, 15:53
@ ALBERT FENECH
Fadallek ftit x'tittewwep Bert!!!
William Calleja
Feb 6th, 12:01
End result? we are still broke.
Philip Hili
Feb 6th, 12:22
@ William Calleja
Not as much as other Greek, Italians, Spaniards Portuguese fellows.
Maybe you are living in Mars and not on a planet called EARTH!!!!
Edward Curmi
Feb 6th, 12:35
End result with PL in power "Malta sees sharpest EU increase in government debt
"
Alfred E. Zahra
Feb 6th, 12:48
Yes and we are still better off than the irish, The ``lativians, the greeks, the italians, the Hungarians ( whose national airline has just gone bust), the cypriots, the Spannish, the portugese, the British and a host of other people. Not bad at all for a serial failure as PM.
m. borg (slm)
Feb 6th, 14:05
@Philip Hili, why do you keep looking at those worse off instead oflooking up and aspire to become like those who are doing well.
.
You gonzipn apologists are like people who have venereal disease and instead of taking medicine to cure themselves they say "look he's got cancer".
Philip Hili
Feb 6th, 15:59
@ m. borg (slm)
Because we are already doing VERY WELL and no one expects our GOZIPN to be better than others well off!!!
FRANS H SAID
Feb 6th, 11:55
What about the hidden millions ion the Piano debacle? Are they not committments by the govt? What is the EU doing by not mentioning this underhand method of spending millions in grandiose projects?
Edward Curmi
Feb 6th, 15:13
no room for excuses please admit that were not doing so bad after all....or as a Pl supporter you only see "doom and gloom"???
R. Balzan
Feb 6th, 11:44
As long as this is not the result of some creative accounting. Some input from non-political experts is called for.