Jobs listened to vinyl, says rocker
Rocker Neil Young took his campaign for higher-fidelity digital sound to the stage of a technology conference, saying a giant of the industry was on his side - the late Steve Jobs.
Young said the Apple co-founder was such a fan of music that he did not use his iPod and its digitally compressed files at home. Instead, he used a physical format well-known to have better sound.
"Steve Jobs was a pioneer of digital music. His legacy is tremendous," Young said. "But when he went home, he listened to vinyl (albums)."
Young told the D: Dive Into Media conference in California that he spoke to Mr Jobs about creating a format that had 20 times the fidelity of files in the most current digital formats, including MP3.
Such a format, he said, would contain 100% of the data of music as it is created in a studio, as opposed to 5% in compressed formats including Apple's AAC. Each song would be huge, and a new storage and playback device might only hold 30 albums. Each song would take about 30 minutes to download, which is fine if you leave your device on overnight, he said.
"Sleep well. Wake up in the morning. Play some real music and listen to the joy of 100% of the sound of music," he said.
Although Young did not have a practical plan for developing such a format - saying it was for "rich people" to decide - he said Mr Jobs was on board with the idea before he died from cancer at 56 in October.
"I talked to Steve about it. We were working on it," Young said. "You've got to believe if he lived long enough he would eventually try to do what I'm trying to do."
Young's opinion of Jobs was confirmed by interviewer Walt Mossberg, a journalist with News Corp's All Things D website, which hosted Mr Jobs at its conferences.
Mossberg said Mr Jobs expressed surprise that "people traded quality, to the extent they had, for convenience or price".
An Apple spokesman declined to comment.
Singer-songwriter Young, 66, was full of other surprising opinions, including his defence of recording labels such as his own Reprise Records, a unit of Warner Music Group, as being a nurturer of artists, even as he said recording companies had botched the transition to digital music.
Young also said that "piracy is the new radio", suggesting that illegally copying low-quality songs was an acceptable way for fans to sample music before buying higher-quality versions.
4 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Cecil Herbert Jones
Feb 1st, 22:15
http://www.stereophile.com/features/308mp3cd
Stereophile's report mp3 vs AAC vs FLAC
Stefan Saliba
Feb 1st, 21:18
You are right Daniel, but unfortunately it's not main stream to purchase original records in FLAC format. The purist might even argue that FLAC format is still sampled music, which by definition is lossy. People are so used to MP3 sound nowadays that they seem to have forgotten how proper music should sound. I personally nowadays play vinyl records on a regular basis, and would not trade their warm sound to CD or SACD.
The last three years has seen a strong revival of vinyl records, while the CD sales are all the time decreasing. People though seem to trade quality for price and not just in music.
Daniel Zahra
Feb 2nd, 17:02
It is possible to buy 24bit 192kHz FLAC files which are studio quality. After all, studios master in the digital domain so it is useless to have vinyl if you can the studio version itself. Having said that, I too prefer vinyl over low quality mp3's. The difference is unmistakable.
Daniel Zahra
Feb 1st, 12:23
Such a format already exists. It's called FLAC. It also supports studio quality 24bit 192kHZ.