Advert

Updated: Muscat demands timeframe for confidence debate

Opposition's confirms its arrogance - government

Video: Paul Spiteri Lucas

(Adds government, PN statement)

Opposition leader Joseph Muscat this afternoon urged the government to agree a timeframe with the opposition for the conclusion of the no-confidence debate in Parliament.

Speaking at a press conference, Dr Muscat reiterated the Opposition's charge that the government is delaying the debate.

He said that the fact that the government at the House Business Committee yesterday had refused to set a timeframe for the conclusion of the debate was shameful and harmful to the country.

"This country cannot afford a situation where such a debate could drag on for a month or even two months," Dr Muscat said.

He said the Opposition wanted the debate to start this week. If it was to start on Monday evening, at least it should continue in the subsequent sittings without interruption, he said.

The Opposition was not against every MP speaking for an hour. The prime minister could speak for more, he said, but there had to be a timeframe within which the debate would be concluded.

Last November, when a confidence debate was held in the shortest possible time, the prime minister had insisted that the people deserved to know where the government stood, Dr Muscat said. The same argument applied now.

Dr Muscat criticised new Leader of the House Carm Mifsud Bonnici and said his failures in the sectors of justice and home affairs were now being carried over to his management of House business.

The government's delaying tactics, Dr Muscat said, were only serving to further raise instability, which was detrimental to the country.

He hoped that agreement would be reached at the House Business Committee meeting, which has been called for tomorrow afternoon by the Speaker. 

Respect for the institution of parliament did not come from the building of a new Parliament House, but taking the proper decisions, Dr Muscat said.

COURT ACTION TO STRIKE PEOPLE OFF ELECTORAL REGISTER

When replying to questions, Dr Muscat confirmed that the Labour Party has filed court action for some 100 people to be struck off the electoral register because they are not qualified to have a vote.

Dr Muscat said these were clear-cut cases and people who had nothing to hide should not fear such applications.

MUSCAT'S BEHAVIOUR DISRESPECTFUL - GOVERNMENT

In a statement, the government reiterated that it wanted a debate on the no confidence motion moved by PL deputy leader Anglu Farrugia.

But the Opposition's haste to limit debate on such a serious and important matter again confirmed its arrogance.

Through his behaviour, Dr Muscat was being disrespectful to MPs and Parliament, the government said.

MUSCAT PERSISTS IN ARROGANCE - PN

In spite of the government's will to debate the no confidence motion presented by the Opposition, the Labour leader was still trying to block the debate on the motion by limiting the debate time for government MPs, the Nationalist Party said in a statement.

It said that the Labour leader was also trying to deny voters their right to vote through court action to strike off names from the electoral register.

All this confirmed that the PL, led by Dr Muscat, was persisting in arrogance.

Advert

161 Comments

Post comment

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

John Scerri

Jan 18th, 11:08

Ghar rigward ta teknologija zgur mhux bhal ma sabu l-PN wara l-gvern ta KMB fl-1987

Peter Borg

Jan 18th, 09:04

Spot on Rizzo. You are absolutely correct and I suspect part of a not insubstantial chunk of the electorate. Gonzi PN is a very far cry from the party that was elected in 87 and quietly revolutionised Malta. Cronyism and arrogance are the order of the day and the name itself ( GonziPN ) is symptomatic of the level of arrogance and inflated ego which rules the party today.Can you imagine the Tories reffering to their party as the Cameron conservatives ? Cameron would be kicked out faster than you can say jackrabbit !

Dennis Zammit

Jan 18th, 08:34

Typical Labour . . . ashamed of themselves. Addio it-torca u il-warda . . . Its also been some time since they had a Warda Kanta.

They even made Anglu Farrugia shave his mustache. He is even worse without it!!

Alistair Busuttil

Jan 18th, 09:30

attakki personali habib,ghara x ghandu x jaqsam il-kulur ta l-ingravata u l-mustacci ta anglu farrugia?unbelievable

Joe E Galea

Jan 18th, 08:00

Amen

Joe E Galea

Jan 18th, 07:57

I am sure you are referring to GonziPN.

Lawrence Fenech

Jan 18th, 09:04

@Galea.

Prosit. well said.

Jack Attard

Jan 18th, 08:25

We want to make sure PN doesn't steel the election again.

George Azzopardi

Jan 18th, 08:10

Election is called by PM and so timing is in his sole hands!!

Joe Cordina

Jan 18th, 08:17

Have you been to gogo land? Every democratic government needs a majority to govern

Rita Smith

Jan 18th, 08:42

Mela ghax ma rajtx il-programm fl-istess hin fuq One TV. Kien hemm erba laburisti kontra Nazzjonalist MPu Dr. George Vella u kien hemm mara ma waqfux jinterrompu lin-Nazzjonalist. Tghidlix x'kien jismu il-programm ghax by chance sibtu. Mela you have blinkers. Jien dawk qazzuni ghax xejn ma kellhom prudenza dejjem jaqbzu fuqu bill-prezentatur ukoll u hallina Sur Andre Buhagiar

Rita Smith

C. Borg

Jan 18th, 09:00

Rita...I don't watch a lot of local TV, but I expect more impartiality from PBS rather than One and Net. One and Net have an agenda, both of them, but PBS should be equal to all.

G Mangion

Jan 18th, 09:37

C. Borg:

Jigifieri kif kellhom l'mlp meta kienu jiditarjaw Malta hux sur borg !

G.Mangion

edward seychell

Jan 18th, 11:25

mela ma tarax ta joe grima dak li dar l istazzjonijiet kolla issa rega gie accettat

Victor Vella

Jan 17th, 22:44

If the GWU, the ALPA and the Union of Cabin Crew have the decency to show their solidarity with those employees who were threaten by GonziPN that if they do not leave he`ll shut down the company boycott all those flights that Air Malta will operate just to bring people for 10€ or something more. Or if they operate such flights the cabin crew will offer any service and the ground handling will not load/unload any bags. If Air Malta shed 500+ of its employees because they have touched the bottom and the company is like the Concordia, operate such aircraft at a loss will continue to bring Air Malta like the relic of that of the Titanic.

Mr Joseph Carmel Chetcuti

Jan 18th, 00:40

It would be the height of impropriety for the President to act in any way that could be interpreted as partisan - notwithstanding the fact that I would want to see a change of government as a matter of utmosty urgency. Even a presidential call for unity in these circumstances may be seen as partisan as it would be seen as supporting the status quo. The president, a former PL politician, was appointed by the PM, a PN politician, and he must not be seen to have been bought by the PM. Nor must he be seen undermining the current leader of the opposition who, after all, defeated him in the contest for the PL leadership.

Rita Smith

Jan 18th, 08:47

Veru il-pajjiz qieghed "in a miserable State". Jahasra ahna il-Maltin m'ghandniex flus. Mela min fejn gew dawk il-flus li n-nies hargu ghall-Partiti, L-istrina U d-Dar tal-Providenza. Jonqos nghatu x'mkien iehor ghax jahasra ahna l-Maltin broke. Inti milli jidher trid tara lil Joseph Muscat fil-Gvern. pacenzja ftit. Veru li jien "I lost count when Labour was in Government" izda min m'ghandux pacenzja bhal Dr. Franco Debono jigrilu.

Rita Smith

Manuel Camilleri

Jan 17th, 22:31

So you still believe that citizens who are away from Malta, working for their families, studying etc, should be denied the right to vote? This is your idea of a democracy. Countries are not made up of thousands or millions, but of individuals with rights and one those rights is the right to vote even if they are away for some time because of different situations and reasons. It does not make them Maltese of a lesser category. It does not mean that they have lost interest in local politics or Maltese life for that matter. Your Party claims to be moderate and progressive. What is so moderate and progressive in denying people their right to vote? It reflects also the attitude Dr. Muscat has towards parliamentary sittings: he wants a time frame, 90 minutes for each side, of which he will probably take 90 % himself! Same thing happened with the divorce affair. No internal PL debate, just instructions from the PL leader.

Paul Giordimaina

Jan 18th, 06:38

Jaqaw qedin tibzghu .You always mentioning 1500 votes better than running the country for 5 years with a minority so shut up.

Paul Giordimaina

Jan 18th, 08:50

Thanks Times of Malta you are showing real Democracy.These PL supporters are using the paper to promote PL after they burnt the place and I saw it happened under the Prime Minister office and this one was part of that government who still talk about democracy,what a face you got a two inch thick skin.

sharon farrugia

Jan 18th, 07:26

Jake ahjar titwikka bit-tfal u bin nanniet, milli titwika bi klikka ta nies li hakmu lill prim ministru minn mniehru, skond Franco Debono u ohrajn fl istess partit.

Joe E Galea

Jan 18th, 07:56

We have been stuck by a bunch of fat pigs for 25 years sucking on our pockets and getting mediocrity in return.

C. Borg

Jan 18th, 08:59

Jake, I think you should check some of the new candidates LP will be proposing for the coming election.

Victor Laiviera

Jan 17th, 21:03

It is possible, Mr Chetcuti - but the PL is reluctant to take that path. It is still hoping that the PN will see reason.

Mr Joseph Carmel Chetcuti

Jan 17th, 21:15

Good to know that it is possible and I hope the PL does just that. I see no possibility or probability that the PN will behave reasonably. It is not in its interest.

R Psaila

Jan 17th, 21:34

Qiskom skoprejtu frazi, hux?!? Sewwa jghidu li s-sinjura milli jkollha ttik.

Vince Piscopo

Jan 18th, 06:46

X kilba missek ghidt! U zgur 500 fil gimgha sbieh u ahna inhallsu t taxxi u jitolbuna s-sagrificcu! Misshom jisthu!!

Joe E Galea

Jan 18th, 08:00

Tinsewx li Austin Gatt qal lil Gonzi biex l-elezzjoni ssir f'Settembru ha jrebbahielu. Mela ma tridx tkun gharef li tal-PN se jibqghu ikaxkru sakemm jaqbel lilhom. Ma jimpurtahomx mill-pajjiz izda jimpurtahom biss minn buthom u mill-partit taghhom.

A Micallef

Jan 17th, 22:31

tantx timla rasek sihbi, ghax nghid ghalija certi nies jaffaxinawni

T Gauci

Jan 18th, 00:56

Who told you Malta's economy is one of the best in Europe i am sure it was GonziPN, Don't you read the news do you know S&P downgraded our rating and Tonio Fenech came up with an excuse.

Rita Smith

Jan 18th, 08:55

U T.Gauci u r-ratings ta min ma nizlux? Tighd Joseph Muscat Ha jtella r-ratings dritt kif jitla? u Hallina kemm tohlom

Rita Smith

Manuel Camilleri

Jan 17th, 20:48

Precisely

Manuel Camilleri

Jan 17th, 20:52

U ajma! Pajjizi demokratici ta' veru ma jaqtghux lic-cittadini taghhom minn dritt li jivvutaw, anki jekk jghixu barra! Min qed jahdem jew jistudja barra minn Malta, ma baqax Malti jaqaw? M'ahniex nitkellmu fuq dawk li emigraw ghal kollox, imma fuq nies li jahdmu fl-Ewropa (l-iktar). Qisek ma tafhiex il-ligi Mr. (jew Dr?) Brincat!

Victor Laiviera

Jan 18th, 07:43

Dik il-liġi kif inhi bħalissa, Sur Camilleri.

Jekk mhix demokratika, għaliex il-PN ma bidilhiex f'25 sena?

Manuel Camilleri

Jan 18th, 08:26

Mr Laviera, check your sources. The PN tried to change law but it was always blocked by the opposition. Ask Dr. Sant!

Paul Giordimaina

Jan 18th, 09:29

ser jigrilek like xi hadd mux ha taghqta

Rita Smith

Jan 18th, 08:59

Sewwa qed tghid. Bezghu fil-prova.

Rita Smith

Tonio Bone

Jan 17th, 18:43

Your comparison is inspiring! Were you alive between 1980 and 1987? Why do you guys find the need to provoke my rationale this way?

M. Attard

Jan 17th, 19:18

well said

Alfred Cassar

Jan 17th, 21:37

The PN government has been voted in for 5 years after 5 years by the People. What a difference from Assad Ghaddafi etc!!

m. borg (slm)

Jan 17th, 18:47

That is your interpretation. Not neccessarily correct but you have a right to misguided perceptions.

mark borg

Jan 17th, 19:32

At least Muscat is eager for power(which is basically the whole point why someone follows a career in politics) So next time you write any moronic comments,try to be a bit more different then other pathetic bloggers.
Could you perhaps now enlighten us why the PAR IDEJN SODI (ta bla maggoranza u dittatur) wants to remain against his own people's wish as a PM ???? ONLY FOR POWER HUX CHANTELLE !!!!!!

J Busuttil

Jan 17th, 18:49

MHUX OVVJA

mark borg

Jan 17th, 19:33

Do not know...but rest assured they are definately not all Labour !

Manuel Camilleri

Jan 17th, 20:54

Iva, nazzjonalisti biss hemm jahdmu barra minn Malta! U halluna!

Mr saviour magro

Jan 17th, 20:32

Hu cuc l-ghadna priministru qed jarmieh.

Tonio Bone

Jan 17th, 17:37

It does not make much sense though from an objective standpoint! If the polls say Labour has a 5% lead in votes (which equates to roughly 15,000) how can they even be bothered with a 100 votes here and there? Food for thought or being clinical? My take is that it is all up for grabs and not as cast in stone as it seems!

R Abela

Jan 17th, 19:45

Our country is the laughing stock of the EU becuase we have the MOST undemocratic goverment of all times.

Tonio Bone

Jan 17th, 17:17

Yes Frans I agree about it being the best quote. Dr Muscat will be constantly reminded of this the moment he gets in the driver's seat!

Wilfred Camilleri

Jan 17th, 17:33

Not a self-serving quote at all! lol

J.C. Borg

Jan 17th, 17:18

Disqualifications of voters - Some 20 years ago the MLP tried to disqualify a lady from voting as she went for a WEEK's holiday in Catania. Let's hope they are not trying to do the same now.

Andrew Siad

Jan 17th, 18:48

@J.C. Borg

taf min ta d dritt lin nisa jivutaw awn malta jew bil mars biss qalulek!!?

Jimmy Magro

Jan 17th, 19:25

@JC Borg
some 40 years ago dead people went to vote in favour of the PN. How is that for democracy? I believe you know very little about the electroal process, since if a person is challenged in court to be deleted from the register, and the appeal is rejected by the court, the person remains as a registered voter.

This is the same like when the prosectution (police) take someone to court and then is found not guilty. But one cannot tell the police not to take anyone to court because there is the possibility that the case is not proven. some years back, the Labour Party used to win 70 to 80 % of the cases and this shows that the process is valid, fair and transparent.


To be undemocratic means is to abuse the law. But electoral appeals are part of the electoral process and there nothing undemcratic about using this legal process to correct the electoral register.

Victor Laiviera

Jan 17th, 17:04

Who said they are trying to stop anybody from speaking? What they are against is an open -ended debate which can go on forever.

Lawrence Fenech

Jan 17th, 17:12

@Camilleri.

It's the delaying tactic by Gonzi that is denying all MP's to a decent debate.

A.J. Schembri

Jan 17th, 17:20

The PL did accept what you said ......"The Opposition was not against every MP speaking for an hour. The prime minister could speak for more, he said, but there had to be a timeframe within which the debate would be concluded."

Tony Borg

Jan 17th, 17:31

Labour is not finding it hard to accept that ALL NP MPs have the right to speak for an hour each. If they want to do that then the NP can propose a 12 hours non stop parliament sittings for Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday. Like that all of the NP MPs would have their hour and the vote is taken next week.

Manuel Camilleri

Jan 17th, 18:31

Really? Then tell me, why all this rush from the PL leader? It is so obvious why he is in a rush! Maybe he is afraid Debono will change his mind after all! Laughing stock of the EU? Wow, that is huge! Please give us the links to the websites that you might have so we can check and read your affirmations.

Tonio Bone

Jan 17th, 17:00

Malta 'is the laughing stock of the EU' based on what? 'The most democratic government in the EU': are you saying this as an observer, a citizen or a Labour supporter? Vince you should substantiate your comments! From what I read Malta is quite highly regarded in the EU on many fronts and unless you have different information of you live in a bubble the government, albeit by a 1500+/- majority, is still legitimate. It's not like this government has governed for five years with the minority of votes as was the case in the early eighties!
I really make an effort to write objective comments on here because I really enjoy the debate, but sometimes such totally partisan comments leave me bewildered and provoke my rationale to retaliate!

Aaron Cremona

Jan 17th, 17:21

Before one should talk, it would be much more better if they get the statistics straight.
Were has Malta ever been the laughing stock of the EU ?
First of all, how can Malta be laughed at when it played a major role in the Libya Crisis ? Didn't the One Television showed you how every country thanked Malta on it's behalf ?
Oh yeah, One TV cuts the truth and puts on garbage.
Gonzi partit negattiv ?
Oh so Muscat is an angel falling from the skies who is the saviour of Malta huh ? -.-''

Andrew Siad

Jan 17th, 18:50

@ Tonio Bone

totally agree with you Ton because your comments are highly partisan as well!!

Tonio Bone

Jan 17th, 22:46

Andrew do not mistake objective for partisan!

Jo Grima

Jan 17th, 16:55

lol

HENRY FENECH AZZOPARDI

Jan 17th, 17:13

I have recorded what Dr. Joe Muscat said to his assembly over the weekend. He mentioned so many fringes and benefits that it is impossible to list, and all this without mentioning one single tax to make good for the giving.

However I noticed that there was no mention for the trappers and the hunters maybe I overlooked it can some one tell me whether he did mention the same old hunting and trapping seasons that were written off by the present administration.

Frans Aguis

Jan 17th, 16:59

" I can sense strong background lobbying at play here......!" please elaborate

Tonio Bone

Jan 17th, 17:33

I would not be allowed to elaborate Mr Agius.'Chi vuole capire: capisca!'

L Ancilleri

Jan 17th, 16:59

They kept on dragging and never asked for a non-confidence vote so the PN take political advantage and gain votes from at that time a sinking labour. Unlike the PN, JM is not taking political advantage as him self reiterated several times.

john muscat

Jan 17th, 17:03

Jigifieri jekk hemm xi hadd li mhux suppost jivvota int tridu jigi u jivvota, ikun ma min ikun??? Mela ha nergghu nigu bhal mitt sena ilu? Hallina Sur Portelli.

Victor Laiviera

Jan 17th, 17:13

Jekk trid tfakkar il-passat, fakkru kollu u b'mod korrett. Il-PN ma kienx ressaq vot ta' sfiduċja għax Mintoff fl-ebda ħin ma qal li sejjer jovvota kontra l-=Gvern. Anki fl-aħħar vot, sa ftit qabel kien qed jgħid li sejjer jastjeni.

Tonio Bone

Jan 17th, 17:16

@ L.Ancilleri. Not taking political advantage? Seriously? Are you telling that PL have a very good chance to jump to power 18 months prior to the end of the legislature, out of the blue, and they are not taking political advantage? Dr Muscat is in full electoral campaign and is playing mind games by making these claims and by labeling his party as underdogs! Can you blame him? I don't, cause I would probably do exactly the same thing. Ehhhh these red shades......!

Aaron Cremona

Jan 17th, 17:23

Il Partit Laburista lest li jiccelebra izda muwiex lest biex jigverna - Chris Said.
Typical stuff that the labour has to offer in it's history.

A Cachia

Jan 17th, 16:54

Nahseb il-problema jiena mhux il-PL. LI huwa tad-dahq (jew tal-biki) fil-pajjiz kif l-ufficju li jiehu hsieb dan ir-registru full time jaghti dritt tal-vot lil 100 persuna u il-PL (part-time) jirnexxilu jsib dawn il 100 persuna...

Frans Aguis

Jan 17th, 17:03

Because GonziPN have long messed about with the electoral register!A lot of GonziPN voters who were not 18, 6 months before the last election but were at the time of the election still got their vote.But the MLP supporters of the same age did not get their vote.Who knew it would be enough to turn an election.
Please so before you start accusing people of messing with the electoral register see the injustice that has been done under Gonzi

Victor Laiviera

Jan 17th, 17:07

Il-liġi hija l-liġi u trid tiġi obduta minn kulħadd. Jekk taħseb li din il-liġi mhix tajba, staqsi għala l-PN, f'25 sena, ma bidilhiex.

Lawrence Fenech

Jan 17th, 17:18

@Borg.

Kien Gonzi li cahhad 2,000 student li ghalqu it-18 il-sena milli jivvotaw fir referendm ghad-divorzju ghax haseb li ser igiba zewg imma baqa' f'wiccu.

J. Mizzi

Jan 17th, 17:08

...and someone doesn't want to let go of it

Andrew Siad

Jan 17th, 17:21

remove the 'quickly' and you can apply the 'lollipop'(take it as you like) to gonzi!!

Alfred Vassallo

Jan 17th, 17:37

As much so that someone wants to keeping sucking on an empty stick (of a lollipop)

Advert
Advert