Advert

Halloween exposes people to ‘sadism, sexual violence, torture’

You may think it’s simply a spot of trick-or-treating but according to the Church’s Theological Commission, Halloween “runs contrary to the central belief of Christian eschatology”.

As a Church, we are warning parents of Halloween’s serious dangers

If you’re a Balzan resident, it is even worse. A note distributed to households by this parish warns parents that Halloween, celebrated on October 31, exposes people to “sadism, sexual violence, satanism, torture, mutilation and strange killing”.

The note, which parish priest Fr Kalċidon Vassallo confirmed was the parish’s doing, comes replete with a hand-drawn skull and pumpkin and warns readers that Halloween “celebrates a culture of death” and “attacks that which is holy”.

In boxed, bolded text, it says: “As a Church, we are warning parents of Halloween’s serious dangers. This feast is a dangerous celebration of fear and the macabre.”

It concludes with a motley list of “other things which draw children towards the occult”. The list includes heavy metal music, negative and fantastical role-playing, sadistic pornography and reading about the occult and Satan.

The note has gone viral on social networks such as Facebook, even provoking hilarity and sarcasm.

A Curia spokesman said when contacted it was unaware of the note and did not know where it came from although The Times subsequently confirmed it was drafted, printed and distributed by the Balzan parish.

Although the Curia avoided any direct reference to the note, it reiterated the note’s central tenets.

“Halloween is a neo-pagan feast that finds its origins in old pagan cults all over Europe. Halloween, in a most subtle way, focuses on death, the occult and evil spirits,” Fr Hector Scerri, president of the Church’s Theological Commission, said.

Fr Scerri contrasted the Church’s theology, which, he said, was based on light, eternal life and the beauty and goodness of God, with Halloween, which focused on darkness and the occult, evil spirits and “a macabre presentation of skeletons and bones”.

Fr Vassallo defended his parish note, saying it was based on a 2005 press release issued by the Archdiocese’s Commission on the Occult and Satanism. “The Commission stated it loud and clear: it would be better if Halloween were not celebrated.”

He insisted it was not overly alarmist. “It’s just stating the facts,” Fr Vassallo said. References to sexual violence, torture and sadism were there as warnings on what dabbling in the occult could lead to, he explained.

“Children dressing up or trick-or-treating do so innocently. But it’s good for parents to know that doing so might lead to these things,” Fr Vassallo said.

Despite its unorthodox language and imagery, Fr Vassallo’s note would appear to have the Vatican’s blessing. In 2009, an article in the Vatican newspaper L’Osservatore Romano quoted a liturgical expert saying: “Halloween has an undercurrent of occultism and is absolutely anti-Christian.” The article went on to warn parents to “be aware of this and try to direct the meaning of the feast towards wholesomeness and beauty rather than terror, fear and death”.

Advert

368 Comments

Post comment

Please see our new Comments Policy

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

For more details please see our Comments Policy

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Mr Marco Debattista

Nov 1st 2011, 06:56

And those who adhere to the official religion of the Republic of Malta should ask themselves what they can do more to contribute to the rest of society in the 21st twenty first century rather than play victim, wallow in self-pity and cry wolf every single time their petty sentiments are "offended".

Since you're going to justify your intolerance towards this pre-Christian era tradition with every excuse up your sleeve, let's pick one of the more hypocritical which was that these celebrations are anti-social. Well, the exact same part of your argument can be said for the grotesque behaviour that takes place during those idol worshipping village feasts.

Carmen Hopkins

Nov 1st 2011, 20:01

my my what a speech. Too bad you did not mention anything about Carnival. They wear masks too but the church allows that because lent starts right after so all your sins are forgtiven.
This is an American Holiday and I was surprised how much Malta is copying everything from America. Then when they do they find they can't deal with it and start making a big thing out of a holiday that is mainly for children to enjoy.
I have been living in the USA for almost 49 years and always made the costumes for my 3 children just like my mother did for me for "Carnival". They enjoyed this holiday almost as much as xmas, in fact I think they enjoyed Halloween more because they did not have to go to midnight mass and get all dressed up, and wearing a tie. They liked this holiday because they get to eat a lot of candy, something I did not allow them to have because sugar is bad for the teeth. Maybe thats why they all have such nice good teeth.
I wonder how Fr.Vassallo would feel if he knew that most Catholic churches and Catholic schools have Halloween parties for kids and dances for teenagers.
Happy Halloween

Carmen Hopkins

Nov 1st 2011, 20:12

Francis,
I think you need an attitude alignment. This is an American holiday to begin with so why are they celebrating it in Malta. What next, will they be celebrating Memorial day [in May] 4th of July, Labor day [in Sept} and Thanksgiving day [in Nov.] You all watch American TV and want to be and have what the Americans have.
As for the kids knocking on doors and shouting "Trick or Treat" well... what is wrong with that. Don't you like to see kids happy.
You people in Malta want to advance but you still have the minds of a 3rd world country.
Did you forget about the "Carnival" in Malta. Or is that ok since after carnival ends lent begins.
Let me tell you something. My parish church {Roman Catholic} had a halloween party for the kids and then at night they had a dance for the teenagers. Sure you find some teenagers getting wild and smash the pumpkins you so cherishly curved but that is to be expected from teenagers. I think Fr.Vassallo should go to Paceville to see what goes on there and scare the parents with that because it is very scary. I was in Malta only last month and could not believe how these parents allow their 13 and 14 year old children to go there. Also the way they dress only hookers dress like that in the USA. That is what Malta needs to talk about not Halloween
Happy Halloween

D Castillo

Oct 28th 2011, 13:06

...an ye harm none, do what ye will ;)

Jo Meli

Oct 27th 2011, 20:01

P A R T Y !!!

Chris Grillo

Oct 27th 2011, 18:29

No, mostly lies!

Victor Pulis

Oct 27th 2011, 16:20

I will pray for all of the angry people for I am absolutely no one to judge
Ron Huber

You have judged us Ron and concluded that we are angry!

Rob Huber

Oct 27th 2011, 20:04

No Victor. I'm not judging. I'm stating a fact because that's what you're expressing. But i won't argue.

Paul Portelli

Oct 27th 2011, 14:44

What is there in the bible has always been done.what has Jesus Christ said has always been fulfilled.The church and Catholicism WILL NEVER DIE.SEE YOU AT THAT TIME MARCAS.

Anthony Galea

Oct 27th 2011, 17:34

LOL I needed a laugh! Jesus said that NOT EVEN THE GATES OF HELL could prevail against His Church. If the Roman arenas and torture could not quell the spirit of love and belief amongst Christians, what makes you think a bunch of uncertain atheists will upend it :) ?

Jo Meli

Oct 27th 2011, 20:06

Secular Malta will celebrate Halloween 2011 with the EMANCIPATED Irish.

Let's Halloween Party Ireland !

R Bartolo

Oct 27th 2011, 20:58

@Anthony Galea

No "bunch of atheists" are trying to do anything of the sort.

It is only the believers who are trying to make others believe.

In future, the number of non-believers (a.k.a. atheists) will simply increase.

Atheism is not a choice, unlike belief. Atheism is simply not choosing to believe, because one is not convinced of there being any truth in anything religious.

Without any wiffle-waffle which is all we get from religion, feel free to convince me, i.e. give me solid proof of what you believe in (not the vacuous arguments substantiated by similarly vacuous statements that is all I have ever heard) and if you succeed, then I will most certainly believe, because I believe in absolutely everything that is logical and proven.

Atheism is not a state of choice, to be defended. Only religion puts up great defence, exclusively comprising of illogical statements, now why would that be?

A Bonett

Oct 28th 2011, 08:49

Marcas, wake up from your beauty sleep !! Catholicism is here to stay. Just look at the previous dark ages.. they where far more problematic than today's !

Rob Huber

Oct 27th 2011, 15:14

Our Lord is telling you "My child. I love you can't you hear me?"

Christina Pace

Oct 28th 2011, 08:16

And my reply is, I have heard you and I have heard your church and I no longer wanna hear what your church has to say. Especially when it comes out with hypocrisy like the note mentioned above. I remember attending Halloween parties in my teens organised by the parish. Conveniently then no one had issued notes against it as the parish was making a profit on these parties and they were keeping us youngsters from meeting in the village square unsupervised.

While you say the lord is saying my child i love ytou can't you hear me, the church is saying i hate what you are you must change if you want my love. There! FYI it was the church that rejected me and my identity.

Mary Ann

Oct 27th 2011, 10:52

just a correction, not an argument.

Pawlu gie Malta. (Ma jfissirx li kkonverta pajjiz imma) Just, gie.
Acts 28 : 1-2

Il- Knissja Kattolika Rumana, hija filfatt Rumana b' bazi pagana.
Qabel, tant kien aw Kristjani u Pagani mhalltin li Kostantinu prova jintogob ma kulhadd, ha naqa kristjanezmu u naqa paganizmu u bdiet did denominazzjoni..

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 27th 2011, 12:04

@ Mary Ann (Halloween)

Roman Catholicism is "Roman" because its centre was Rome as far back as the time of St Peter - it has no connection with the Roman Emperors who in fact tried to destroy it - so Roman Catholicism does not have any pagan base. It traces its origins directly to Christ and beyond that to Judaism, not paganism.

Constantine was a Roman Emperor who tried to establish a balance and a modus vivendi between the different religions and sects prevalent at his time. He himself did not formulate the doctrine of the Roman Catholic Religion. He did convene the first Council of Nicea to unify Christian doctrine not to effect a compromise with paganism.

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 27th 2011, 12:06

@ Mary Ann

Roman Catholicism is "Roman" because its centre was Rome as far back as the time of St Peter - it has no connection with the Roman Emperors who in fact tried to destroy it - so Roman Catholicism does not have any pagan base. It traces its origins directly to Christ and beyond that to Judaism, not paganism.

Constantine was a Roman Emperor who tried to establish a balance and a modus vivendi between the different religions and sects prevalent at his time. He himself did not formulate the doctrine of the Roman Catholic Religion. He did convene the first Council of Nicea to unify Christian doctrine not to effect a compromise with paganism.

Christina Pace

Oct 27th 2011, 13:18

Correction to all:

St Paul may or may not have come to Malta.
There is evidence that points to a different island and evidence that he was here. Obviously some of it is made up so no one knows for sure where he shipwrecked.

Roman Catholicism does have some roots in Pagan religions, in its mycticism, even more so than in Judaism. Common patterns observed in religious beliefs in antiquities (Kemetic, Hellenic and Latin) made it down to the gospels hand picked my the Council of Nicea. Gospels that would not prove popular with existing Roman Empire colonies were discarded. Were it not for their discovery not too long ago we would be completely ignorant of other scriptures that were conveniently left out.

Mr C Busuttil

Oct 27th 2011, 13:29

mela minn kienu dawn il-mexxejja Rumani ? ejja ohrog il-fatti storici fejn giet imposta l-fidi kattolika fuq il-Maltin, fatti u dokumenti storici pls mhux bla bla bla bla

Mr C Busuttil

Oct 27th 2011, 13:38

@ Mary Ann

Constantine at no point in time did shape or transform Christianity, neither did he make it the official religion of the empire as some think. He simply gave freedom to Christians and built some churchs. In his legislation there is hardly any influence of christianity. He was emperor of both christians and pagans and made them live peacefully. Christianity was not imposed on the pagans, it would have been a folly to impose a religion on 90% of the population of the Empire. In Constantine's time Christianity was just a mere 10% of the entire population with adherents to be found mainly among the poor and slaves. Therefore no Roman Emperor would have risked so much by going against the great majority, previous emperors had been killed for much less.
The rituals and celebrations of Christianity do not date from Constantine's days but evolved much later. Constantine's own idea of Christianity was very basic, it was a gradual conversion.

N. Galea

Oct 27th 2011, 14:06

Gie jew ma giex ma tantx tghamel differenza kulhadd ghandu jithalla fil liberta li jiehu daqxejn pjecir! Qisa qedin nghixu fil medjuevu ma dawn in nies! NO MORE imma ta! ghax haduha ir rispsota

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 27th 2011, 17:29

@ Christina Pace

Before presuming to “correct all” try to check and get your facts straight.

The apocryphal gospels are not recent “discoveries”, most have been known since antiquity and new ones keep cropping up. There are scores of them and the list differs from one religion to another. Quite simply they are not considered as “canonical”.

The Council of Nicea did not have anything to do with any handpicking of the gospels and it did not “discard gospels that were not popular with the Roman Empire - it dealt with the heresy of Arianism and related disputes.

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 27th 2011, 08:51

@ James Camilleri.

Evidently, replacing pagan feasts by Christian celebrations is NOT "paying homage" to the displaced pagan deity, it is not NOT witch hunting and it is NOT a return to the violent practices prevalent throught society during the Middle Ages (not just the Inquisition).

Today's Halloween celebrations ARE a retrograde step to pagan customs that had been discontinued.

James Camilleri

Oct 27th 2011, 22:31

@But it is Francis Saliba. It is. The church in all the countries it managed to convert christianised many of their rites, traditions and feasts. That is how it survived. And yes such a message is reminscent of the Inquistion. Most children enjoy Halloween because they can dress up as they do at Carnival. It is a fun time for them and in their innocence they are as far away from the black tinge the church wants to give this celebration as the church is from its origins. It is messages like the above that will poison childen's minds with thoughts of devils and all the ugly things mentioned in the said letters.

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 27th 2011, 11:16

You do not even know what "occult" practices are! There are no such secret, hidden practices in the Catholic church.

You do not know history either. Roman Catholicism has withstood competition successfully for two millennia actually and is still going strong, as Christ promised.

W Cassar

Oct 27th 2011, 12:51

@ Francis


One word... Opus Dei

angelo cilia

Oct 27th 2011, 17:21

@ Francis Saliba,

For a roman catholic church apologist and a supposed educated person you know very little about the roman church and its ties to the occult powers. For starters, the plaza at the Vatican, also known as St. Peter’s square with the Papal palace is on the right edge has a large eight rayed sun wheel design symbolic of Ishtar is immediately noticeable. In the center of the wheel there is an obelisk, a genuine Egyptian obelisk shipped from Heliopolis to Rome ." The obelisk is of course a phallic symbol but it also was used in sun worship. It is claimed that the word obelisk literally means Baal’s shaft or Baal’s organ of reproduction." Source: Masonic and Occult Symbols by Cathy Burns.
Two thousand years is nothing in the scheme of things when even Hinduism is over five thousand years old and even by judging from Malta alone, roman catholicism is a spent force with nowhere to go but down in the number of its adherents as compared to the Malta of 60 years ago. The more people get informed, the more they shun this pagan Babylonian system of worship disguised as Christianity.This paganism is certainly NOT what Christ promised.

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 27th 2011, 20:40

@ W Cassar.

Apart from being the name of a Catholic society "Opus dei" means "the work of God". That is why Christianity will continue to outlast the perennially recurring prophets of its imminent end.

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 27th 2011, 11:25

@ Marco Debattists

Halloween does not "preclude" the presence of Christianity in Europe. Do not use polysyllabic words without checking their meaning first.

Mr Marco Debattista

Nov 1st 2011, 06:41

@Francis Saliba.

Oh i'm sorry, did a tiny grammatical mistake give you a linguistic seizure? At least response to the rest of my comment instead playing the language teacher.

John Cassar

Oct 26th 2011, 22:02

If what you state is correct Gerry, all the church wishes are blind bats devoid of personal reasoning that they refuse to see the point.

Personally thanks to this eye opener from the church I have come to the conclusion that the macabre processions of good Friday and the references to torture and death associated with Easter are more harmful to children than Halloween.

From now on the best place for children around Easter time is abroad from this madness.

David Caruana

Oct 27th 2011, 07:46

I think you cannot see the point Gerry.

These papers have been thrown in everyone's mail box - catholics and non-catholics.

These papers contain false information and insults towards Wiccans.

As I said earlier, since such things (insulting other beliefs and annoying people with spam mail) are protected by the law, no one can stop me from starting my own leaflet sharing, door-to-door. I have some juicy and very real info about the roman catholic church in Malta which I have wished to share with the rest of the population for a long time. Thanks to Kalcidon, now I know that I am allowed to do so. Thanks again Kalcidon!

Victor Pulis

Oct 27th 2011, 08:35

References to the past and the inquisition etc etc etc are meaninless attempts to pour scorn on the guidance offered by the Church to the faithful.
Gerry Cowie

Are we to understand that you are in favour of the inquisition and of what it did in the past?

Elaine Sultana

Oct 27th 2011, 16:16

Luke Bonnici:

Please define absurd or tell me what you were referring to.

Dave Alan Caruana

Oct 27th 2011, 07:06

nobody expects the spanish inquisition.

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 26th 2011, 20:16

@ Robert Agius et al.

If you knew anything about Christ and Christianity you would know that to a true Christian the crucified Christ is a symbol of God's infinite love towards man. That is the lesson transmitted to the young by true Christians. The crucifix is a symbol of "terror, fear and death" only to the unbeliever.

The costumes worn for Halloween are ugly and not wholesome nor beautiful. They are deliberately intended to scare and to frighten. But since that is a pagan rite, not a Christian rite, you and your ilk do not object to it even if neighbours complain about the associated disturbance, provocations and vandalism.

Sue De Nym

Oct 26th 2011, 20:42

You really hit the nail on the head....... I remember as a child, how terrified I used to be looking at the huge cross in church with a man nailed to it. Why should *that* part of Jesus's life be glorified? Why does being religious has to be centered around SUFFERING? I'm sure whoever created us wanted us to be HAPPY.....not running scared and full of guilt for enjoying things which make us happy!

Maaaa x'biza, gej il-babaw!

Harry Livesey

Oct 26th 2011, 20:58

it still beats bloodthirsty religion

Steve Zammit

Oct 26th 2011, 23:51

good for you

Sue De Nym

Oct 26th 2011, 20:55

Yes indeed.......how about the famous Chapel of BONES?!! What can be more macabre than that!?

http://www.flickr.com/photos/mmira/5021391903/

Maria Vella

Oct 26th 2011, 17:39

You couldn't have said it any better ! :) BRAVO!

Luke Bonnici

Oct 26th 2011, 19:00

you rule!!!

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 26th 2011, 16:59

@ Guido calleja.

Bully for your son and those similar to him. They are not representative of the louts It is my misfortune to encounter.

David Caruana

Oct 26th 2011, 20:00

Apologies Dott. I always tend to forget how cranky one gets with old age.

These youth should be silenced. They should be home saying their hail maries instead of being out having fun. How impertinent of them!

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 27th 2011, 00:14

@ David Caruana.

I am so sorry to learn that you "always tend to forget" - even now, so early in your life and before your cranky old age. I fear to imagine your situation then. May I suggest a few Hail Marys now before you forget how to pray?

Mr James Caruana

Oct 26th 2011, 16:21

too right mate!

Francis Saliba M.D.

Oct 26th 2011, 17:23

You are advocating the suppression of the expression of opinion dicriminatively and restricted only to priests belonging to the Ctholic diocese of Malta, and perhaps Gozo! I do not think that you are so brash as to advocate the same censorship in any other organisation - that would be too ridiculous by any standard, even yours. But where the Catholic religion of the republic is concerned you would make an exception!

John Cassar

Oct 26th 2011, 22:14

@Francis Saliba

You are very economical with the truth. The church does suppress its priests when it does not like their message. Remember Fr. Mark Montebello???? Weren't his opinions suppressed (even though he was right about most of them) because he did not tow the line.

As for the religion of the republic, I suggest you don't shout too loud. If a referendum were held now on whether the church should remain the official religion of Malta, the result will be a resounding NO!!

A Bonett

Oct 27th 2011, 10:28

@Francis Saliba.

My comments where not to limit anyone on his/her personal opinion or to limit the freedom of expression. On the contrary. However, like all organisations, the Church has commom policies, strategies etc. Therefore, one cannot speak in the name of an organisation without getting the approval of the superiors ! I would like to see anyone belonging to any organisation, speak in the name of this organisation, without getting a slap on the wrist for talking too much. In this case, although Fr. Vassallo tried to do a good deed by advising the Balzan residents, this propoganda should have been done by the Curia for all the Maltese - because what's good for the goose is good for the gander !

Edward Mallia Milanes

Oct 26th 2011, 19:22

Gianluca Falzon - well done, a very well written comment, I completely agree with you.

JOSEPH ZAMMIT

Oct 26th 2011, 16:04

LOL---just an opportunity for the benefit of the business community.

A. Gouder, what about Christmas?

Halloween was changed by the Christian Church into All souls' day by which the faithful would give money to the priests for masses for the repose of the souls.
So much for hypocrisy!!!

Matthew Grima

Oct 26th 2011, 16:43

Hypocrisy and Church have become synonyms.

Matthew Grima

Oct 26th 2011, 16:43

LOL

Manquareiel De Caveden

Oct 26th 2011, 18:17

HAHAHA!!

R. Gauci

Oct 26th 2011, 14:35

Well said! Mhux anke l-karnival speci ta` Halloween specjalment dak li jsir fin-Nadur.

Glenn Collins

Oct 26th 2011, 14:45

Ma nafx ghalfejn qieghed izzeffen il-festi fin-nofs..maghna qabdu ukoll, meta ahna ma naghmlu xejn hazin.

Dan il-pajjiz hekk ha jibqa? Fafna paroli fil-vojt fuq kollox?

Mhux ahjar inhallu lil haddiehor kwiet jekk mhux itina fastidju..

N. Galea

Oct 26th 2011, 15:36

Remember everything they say is Holy and right........ shhhhh!

P.S they will also find an excuse for everything....

Manquareiel De Caveden

Oct 26th 2011, 15:36

Exactly, no no no sadism there no no.
No masochism in those who go walking barefoot in chains or on their knees in the Our Lady of Sorrows processions no no... pfff!

M Abdilla

Oct 26th 2011, 14:00

Crusaders used to butcher people and eat them...both Christians and Muslims. Just goes to show you all the contradictions in the Church's teachings.

Chris Gatt

Oct 26th 2011, 14:38

"many kids that are attracted to the occult start off innocently enough.." Really? perhaps he could give us some figures, and facts.

This is not about the Church speaking its mind, its about talking utter rubbish.

I have yet to see how kids go from Jack o'Lantern to Beelzebub or from the witch in Snow White to Lucifer.

Horror is an essential part of childhood. The church knew this as, as a kid we were constantly regaled with images of angels and devils.

to be honest I am not too worried about Halloween, I am more worried about a priest who can make the leap from childish pranks like Halloween to sadism and torture. Shudder!

frank grech

Oct 26th 2011, 14:18

Prosit. You could not have said it better!

Mr C Galea

Oct 26th 2011, 14:55

make sure you send me an invitation please.

Satine Christian

Oct 26th 2011, 13:28

Good one!

Christina Pace

Oct 26th 2011, 12:11

I would add "We will teach them facts, like the story of creation, that have long been disproved and tell them of parents who were told by God to kill there children, for the sake of keeping them ignorant and submissive"

David Caruana

Oct 26th 2011, 11:50

"Ipswich Christmas Day murder: Two men guilty

Two men have been found guilty of the murder of a 45-year-old man whose body was found in a flat in Suffolk on Christmas Day last year. "

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-suffolk-15401114

**********

"Easter Sunday Murder Suspect Identified
Warrant Filed After Columbus Man Fatally Shot On East Whittier

A Columbus man dies in the street Easter Sunday, and Columbus detectives file a warrant for a suspect's arrest."

http://www2.nbc4i.com/news/2011/apr/25/4/cpd-homeless-man-named-suspect-easter-homicide-ar-465115/

*************

Now you got yourself into a blind corner dear Joseph. If you suspect a connection between a celebration and murder, then you need to explain the above occurences.

Come on, go ahead you clever man!

Joshua G Giordimaina

Oct 26th 2011, 13:48

you might have stumbled upon something here sir ... i myself sometimes had inclinations of killing that annoying easter bunny!!!

Charmaine Marmara'

Oct 26th 2011, 12:45

same to you :)) having a party on saturday actually LOL

Jianni Grima

Oct 26th 2011, 13:44

You've obviously never been abroad.

Halloween in North America is celebrated with little kids dressing up as witches, vampires, or their favorite super hero and visiting their neighbors for candy. Teenagers use Halloween to party just like any other holiday, such as beginning of summer, end of exams, etc. I have absolutely no idea where you got the basis that a holiday as innocent as Halloween can be a 'launching pad for irrationality, evil , drugs, and young girls danceing half naked.'

I'm sure many people laughed at your comment as I did. If you were sarcastic, well played!

Ms Donna Degaetano

Oct 26th 2011, 13:51

Excuse me for pointing out that drugs, irrationality and young girls dancing half naked can be found all year round...it doesn't take Halloween to get them out of the woodwork!!!! And I can't see the connection between them and Halloween either! Halloween is just like Carnival just less colourful. What's wrong with dressing up as a witch, a vampire or a pumpkin? Why don't we let kids be kids and have fun instead of filling their innocent minds with all this stupidity!!! This year I'll be dressing up my 3 kids and taking them trick and treating at least it will give them something to do in the mid term holidays that will be fun!!
And another thing...the Archbishop Cremona doesn't have a say in Halloween....it's the people's business what they do with their time so please stop trying to control everything!!! It's pitiful and nauseating!!!!!!!

Mr Ernest Vella

Oct 26th 2011, 12:20

A Catholic does not follow his own morals...because thats relativism...A Catholic is one who loves and obeys the Gospel, and follows Christ teaching's in the Gospel and the teachings of the Holy Catholic Church

Matthew Bugeja

Oct 26th 2011, 12:51

Actually you are wrong.. I'd suggest doing some research before calling others ignorant..

Mark Shaw

Oct 26th 2011, 11:41

Macabre?.... forgive my ignorance but i believe it dates back to a pagan ritual whereby the spirits of the ancestors would mingle with the living?..a day/night for families to remember there loved ones...., how is this evil?..do you not go to church to pray for your loved ones that have passed?...where is the fear?..except for that which has been twisted and eulogised by the church?!

Perverts need no excuse to do their thing...of that i am certain,

No offence intended Sir, but im afraid you have bought into the millenia old propaganda of control and subjugation!..

ps i am not anti christian either, i'm just against ignorance which the church uses to control its flock!, my God is in my heart, not a building, nor voiced from the lips of others but between myself and He!

David Caruana

Oct 26th 2011, 11:42

John,

I would like to keep my children away from death too but on Good Friday I have to lock them inside so they are not exposed to the gorey images of a butchered man and masked men in chains. They can't even go to a public school because in class they have to be exposed to a battered half-naked man nailed to a cross.

They weren't too happy either when I told them that people who go to mass join together to drink the blood and eat the flesh of a 2,000 year old ghost.

Talking about macabre!

michael sammut

Oct 26th 2011, 12:14

why dont we ban movies dealing on macabre and horror then, why not adopt the sharia law and cut artists' hands for depicting death and skulls and occult. Oh yeah, and burn book stores as well. If you want to abide by the laws of the church, nobody is telling you not to, but then, don't interfere in other people's business.
Shall we ban cartoons such as SCOOBY DOO.....full of monsters and death and cemetries!!!!
Dear Curia, take a stand will you....if you wish to carry on with your medieval mentality, go ahead, Im immune to your pathetic opinions!! For your information, heavy metal is music, thus an art...an expression. So according to you, the producer of 'The Exorcist' is a satanist, Anthony Hopkins is really Hannibal Lecter in real life!!! ....how many metal bands have played for charity? LOADS OF THEM!! Are you aware that Christian bands exist in the Metal Scene even in Malta. So you re saying that I, have been listening to metal for 25 years, am a satanist?? HAHAH Satanists should thank the church for keeping such stupidity alive.

Joseph Aquilina

Oct 26th 2011, 11:05

The Church does not treat you like a stupid idiot, you can celebrate what you wish or like, but the Church is duty bound to inform you what she feels is good or wrong. There is no problem If you do not agree with what the Church tells you. It's teaching are only meant for those who feel part of it.

J.C. Borg

Oct 26th 2011, 11:29

Well said Mr Aquilina.

@ Ms Frendo - If you are so sure that nothing will happen to your children you may leave them to go where they like. I have told my children of the perils they may meet and they are intelligent enough to heed my words. Let's hope we will not hear anything about your children in the news, the day after.

Joseph Aquilina

Oct 26th 2011, 11:08

Which in other words means you did not understand a thing from what the Church is saying. Christmas originated from a pagan feast but on Christmas day, Christians celebrate the birth of Jesus Christ and not as used before some pagan idol. On Halloween, people would be celebrating death which goes against the teachings of the Church. There would absolutely no problem if on Halloween children and adults celebrated life!! But death!? In short, what is important is not the date, but what is being celebrated!

Heather Rivett

Oct 26th 2011, 11:27

Well said Keith but it is celebrated here in all its glory !!

John Meli

Oct 26th 2011, 12:46

Although Christmas actually started as a pagan festival. Nobody knows what day or month Christ was born, but it was very cold like December time. Some people see Santa as a God which is wrong. In the Bible other gods (false) were condemned. There are many good gifts, but there are also many that are not useful and take over people's lives. So presents at Christmas times is to remind us of the three maggi that offered their gifts to the new born child (Jesus).

The believers in God in the Bible certainly did not go to the people with pagan gods, and turn their festival into a partly Christian festival while allowing pagan activities to continue. Pagan activities were totally removed from the living or worshiping presence of the believers. In the Old Testament we have many examples of where God was angry if they did not totally remove the pagan idols. One of which was during Moses times, which he destroyed it for them when he came down from receiving the ten commandments.

Matthew Grima

Oct 26th 2011, 14:57

No John, if there ever was a Jesus, it is said that he was born in summer. Although there are no records showing his existence. Even though the bible says that a census was done at the time of his birth.

Please stop using the bible to correct anyone. The oldest edition of the bible came round about 400 years after "the birth of christ", and you want to believe every word written in it.

The 25th of December is birth date of another god, born to a virgin, the son of yet another god. The whole story is then repeated for Jesus. You chose to believe the latter, or better yet, you were born into a family that believed the latter.

Joseph Aquilina

Oct 26th 2011, 11:11

and indeed the Church is doing its best to reduce the pagan element in our feast.

Joseph Aquilina

Oct 26th 2011, 11:12

The aim of the Church is to have the Marc ta' filghodu (which in some localities started even before mass had finished on Sunday, very bad) to be stopped.

Joseph Aquilina

Oct 26th 2011, 11:15

Shows how little you know about Catholicism.

l vella

Oct 26th 2011, 12:45

@ Joseph Aquilina

You mean the church never tortured anyone ?

(I will leave the sex part out......)

Matthew Grima

Oct 26th 2011, 12:57

Joseph I think that should be said about you. If you only think that CATHOCLISM (not Christianity) is all about god and love then you must loosen your blinkers.

D Castillo

Oct 26th 2011, 10:54

the church should learn a thing or two about the wiccan rede

Maria Brincat

Oct 26th 2011, 11:21

x'ghandu x'jaqsam?????

Kurt Mifsud

Oct 26th 2011, 10:14

X'ghandu x'jaqsam? Mela ejja nahbu s-skieken, igru igru!!! Li ma jmurx xi hadd jiddeciedi li joqtol bihom...

Christina Pace

Oct 26th 2011, 10:15

One incident does not make a rule. Just like one person choking on cereal should not stop other from having breakfast. Shall we stop celebrating weedings because a few turn into a riot?

l vella

Oct 26th 2011, 10:31

So if there is a spate of murders on christmas day we should abolish christmas ?

What happens on a particular day is not the fault of the day but a product of twisted minds.

lets not start with the bogeyman saga please

Justin Azzopardi

Oct 26th 2011, 10:35

How many years back? 5,10,20
Village feast or Halloween feast?
A little more info would help...

Victor Laiviera

Oct 26th 2011, 10:55

Why don't you tell us? It's just the right time for horror stories ....

j dough

Oct 26th 2011, 11:07

so what happened in zejtun?? are we really expected to inundate the parents (!) school head and parish priest with phone calls to satisfy our curiosity?
i suspect that whatever happened would have been avoided with adequate adult supervision and may easily have taken place at any other party regardless of the occasion.

Kurt Mifsud

Oct 26th 2011, 10:14

Thumbs up!

S Cachia

Oct 26th 2011, 10:14

very well said. i've been saying it all my life... the church is just brainwashing people and trying to induce fear and terror so that it keeps its head above the water. If it were for the church we would still be in the middle ages. So yeah, good riddance to a corrupt and hateful institution that is the church

l vella

Oct 26th 2011, 10:41

What is paganism ? Anyone whose belief isnt Monotheistic ?
so all the Chinese, Japanese, Indians etc. etc. are pagans ?

S. Mula

Oct 26th 2011, 10:08

Of course Mr Grech because when the church finds something that challenge it.....it will quickly classfify it as satanic so that catjolics will be scared and its sins remain hidden to most of them!!

Pia Attard

Oct 26th 2011, 10:00

As opposed to Santa maria, where Maltese people flock to discos and farmhouses in Gozo for no reason other than to pray in Rabat.

David Caruana

Oct 26th 2011, 10:00

Running around with a statue isn't stupid then?

Christian Sciberras

Nov 2nd 2011, 20:27

"Stupid" is in the eye of the beholder.

On the other hand, if you are really into it, it will lead to bad consequences, be it Halloween or not.

In fact, it isn't the first time fights broke up between villagers because of parish feasts.
Get this, fighting between people of the exact same religion.

Mr A Grech

Oct 26th 2011, 09:51

including chants from the church's PA system to brainwash the whole village

W Cassar

Oct 26th 2011, 10:26

"chants from the church's PA system"

Is that not noise pollution, but I guess its ok cause its the church!

Luke Lanzon

Oct 26th 2011, 09:53

I'd love his life then

D Castillo

Oct 26th 2011, 09:57

indeed!!!

Pia Attard

Oct 26th 2011, 09:58

All Hallow's Eve. Hallow is an old word for "saint". All Saint's Eve. That is what the word "Halloween" means!

It is AS Christian as Easter and Christmas. It is most definitely a Christian feast, just like Christmas and Easter, with pagan origins.

Do I need to remind peopel about Horus, the Egyptian god born on 25 December from a Virgin? Or the word "Easter", originating from Ostara/Oestre, the pagan feast of Spring?

I'm sure San Martin with its nuts, oranges and spices as gifts is a VERY Christian feast, with no pagan origins whatsoever.

Yeah right.

Christian Sciberras

Oct 26th 2011, 09:45

Funnily enough, some parents in the US have tried to lobby against Harry Potter books in school libraries. Ironically, such libraries contained "worse" content and these parents' motives were simply based on the fact that those books were popular.

Christian Sciberras

Oct 26th 2011, 09:48

While at it, you should consider the origins of Christmas day, also known as the Day of the Sun.

Yes, it is/was a pagan feast celebrating the sun. No, I don't think the Church is trying to make us believe our God lives/is the sun... Also, historically, the birth of Christ is known to be on a different specific date. Why this mistake wasn't ever rectified is beyond me.

Joseph Aquilina

Oct 26th 2011, 11:03

@Christian Sciberras
Christmas day - 25th of December - has its origin from a paga feast yes, however in the Christian world we celebrate the birth of Jesus Christ. On the Contrary, on Halloween the people would be celebrating death, while Christians should be celebrating life!! In short, what is important is not the date but what is being celebrated.

Christian Sciberras

Nov 2nd 2011, 20:24

Joseph Aquilina - Oh, I thought Christmas was all about Santa Claus, chimneys and presents! I must be wrong!

While I don't see the point behind celebrating either death or life, I'm sure one cannot see these two processes as a "good one and a bad one". Death is the natural way to keep life growing. Stopping death means a grinding halt in our progress, leading to chaos.

I'm not suggesting that people suddenly people begin celebrating demons or anything of the sort, but rather to see things from a higher perspective.

E Schembri

Oct 26th 2011, 09:52

@ W Cassar.

The church is far from dying a slow death. It is simply a time of transition from an era based on culture-ism when everyone was assumed to be Catholic, but in reality was not, to a new era of fewer but true followers. Simply look at the near 2million youths that attended the WYD in Spain.

This transition is a good thing, as Catholics are now identified through their actions and life styles, and not simply because they are Maltese or because they attend the village feast, which I agree with you is completely pagan.

The hypocrites are those people who continuously criticize the church to show how forward minded they are, but at the same time want to get married in a church, baptize their kids and also ensure they receive their first holy communion. It is these pseudo Catholics that dent the churches image and must be weeded out.

As with regards to the pedophiles, this is a bit old now, they have been found guilty and will be punished. The absolute majority of pedophiles are family relatives and friends, so attacking the church with the same issue over and over simply proves that your only interest is destructive criticism.

Rocco Camilleri

Oct 26th 2011, 09:44

Yani, something wrong does not make the other good. No one is being forced to live the Christian way, God gave everyone his liberty, but what is wrong can't be called right and finally every one has to make up for his doings after this short loaned period by our creator. Adults have the responsibility to give examples especially in schools by teachers and certainly not less the parents themselves.

yani ellul

Oct 26th 2011, 10:24

couldnt agree with you 100% rocco.... but what i cant understand is, what is wrong by children dressing up in costumes and knocking on people's doors asking for sweets??.... the church shuoldnt generalise... i am sure there are certain people who take advantage of this feast to do all sorts... but the church cant generalise and paint a grim picture, making it sound like these children are cursed because they dress up in costumes... they are children, it is purely innocent fun, and yes it is up to us adults to make sure it remains that way. but scaring parents that their kids are going to become god knows what if they let them trick or treat is wrong. explain by all means,make parents aware, but dont scare... also dont generalise.. as if we start generalising, then should we generalise and assume that all priests are bad because of the unfortunate events that have happened? there are ways and means to get information across.. unfortunately this in my opinion was a bad excercise which has backfired...

David Caruana

Oct 26th 2011, 09:34

The crucifix is hung in EVERY public space - spaces which provide for both catholics and non-catholics. Places which are run by non-catholics' tax money too.

Halloween, on the other hand is not slapped in the face of everyone - if you don't like it, you won't take part in it.

Veru ma tisthix Dott. Tassew ma tisthix.

Anthony Galea

Oct 26th 2011, 09:33

Halloween is the feast of Samhain Eve-when the dead walk this earth for one night, leaving the Otherworld. Pagan folk would leave food so the dead would leave them alone, and celebrate death by dressing as the dead. Pagan priests would, on such occasions, offer animal sacrifices (normally through burning alive).

I think it's obvious that Halloween is not a Christian festival; although today it is merely a secular festival with pre-Christian roots.

I don't agree with this article at all-but, seeing as this feast directly opposes the Church, I see nothing wrong with the Church opposing it (after all, Malta is a democratic country).

N. Galea

Oct 26th 2011, 09:23

Just don’t participate and that’s it.. but its none of your business what other people do.. and by the way Halloween is NOT new.. for Malta its new... because we are always 30yrs behind!

Kenneth Cassar

Oct 26th 2011, 09:24

I wonder...were you ever a child, or are you perhaps still one?

Let children be children. They have enough time to worry about stuff when they grow up.

Marius Magrius

Oct 26th 2011, 09:28

'concentrating on more serious things like making cribs out of paper-mache' - get a life mate

Rocco Camilleri

Oct 26th 2011, 09:30

Well said Paul. The generations don't look so bright, and this could be due to the ones who should have gave examples or see that bad habits do not grow due to lenient actions or doesn't careless of what youngsters do.

Mr R.E. Saliba

Oct 26th 2011, 09:30

Tajba Pawlu... ta' l-ismijiet veru. Kultant sirt nisma ismijiet imhawdin wahda nobis. Basta jkun originali m'hawnx iehor bhalu. Min jaf x'passata jghaddu tar-registru ta' l-ismijiet!

Kyle Boffa

Oct 26th 2011, 09:37

sure sure.. and the assumption of listening to heavy metal leads to the occult is not something which falls under the criteria of "PROUD TO BE AN IDIOT"

Mr JOSEPH FSADNI

Oct 26th 2011, 09:38

J.Fsadni
Well siad Mr Aguis,
J.F

Steve Zammit

Oct 26th 2011, 14:56

Well said Pawlu

Kenneth Cassar

Oct 26th 2011, 09:26

Values don't diminish...they evolve. For instance, we no longer believe women or black people are inferiors, and we no longer keep slaves...even if the "Old Testament" approves of both.

Christian Sciberras

Oct 26th 2011, 09:51

Rocco, what the heck are you talking about? I find it easier to describe a child the motives behind Halloween than the filth that is our clubs, pubs and bars.

W Cassar

Oct 26th 2011, 09:10

Prosit!

David Caruana

Oct 26th 2011, 09:10

Thank you indeed D.Castillo!

I had to argue with many people saying that this paper was not distributed by the church.

Thanks to Bertrand Borg, I have been proved right.

Mr R.E. Saliba

Oct 26th 2011, 09:17

Your second comment makes one think you want youths to be attracted by the church.

But if that were the case, you'd have called the Kurja about the note rather than distributed a scan on Facebook to make obvious mockery of it.

What game are you playing?

S. Mula

Oct 26th 2011, 09:20

Good job!!! =)

Mr R.E. Saliba

Oct 26th 2011, 09:24

N. Galea, I take Halloween at face value, as you do - so I will celebrate it the same way you do.
The church refers to those who celebrate this 'feast' at a deeper level.
The drama of Fr. Vassallo aside, the message is sensible.

If you don't bother going to church or listening to church, you will never know this. I'm not the most reverent of church goers, or even a regular one, but at least I listen to both sides properly before making my decisions.

l vella

Oct 26th 2011, 10:25

Mr. Saliba there is no deeper level in halloween............look at the words, the eve of all hallows.

Its a 'pagan' feast to honour the dead, which tradition is found in various cultures from Asia to the Americas.

Just look at catholic Mexico......................

N. Galea

Oct 26th 2011, 15:34

Mr R.E Saliba... I have been listening to the same stuff for 22 years and I have listened to them and it has been more than enough to take a decision.... They are too dramatic yes.. for them everything is negative.. Surely God is NOT the same as them! its impossible! If ONE HALELULJAH DAY they will change and start living in the 21st century I will give them a chance, they should have taken in consideration that people are changing from the divorce referendum as I stated in other comments.

Mr R.E. Saliba

Dec 10th 2011, 20:43

@ N. Galea
Thanks for explaining a little better. I agree that the church needs a facelift and should avoid taking extremist positions yet if the church won't advise against wrong, what will?

Mr R.E. Saliba

Oct 26th 2011, 09:25

Hopefully yes, nowadays we know that the black death doesn't come from air. And we also know that we should evaluate messages from all sources before discarding them.

Mr R.E. Saliba

Oct 26th 2011, 09:26

Agreed.
The church's PR needs a massive redo.

Jimmy John M Vella

Oct 26th 2011, 09:10

Well said!

Chris Grech

Oct 26th 2011, 08:59

Well said!

Mr A Grech

Oct 26th 2011, 09:06

hahaha nice one. oh and don't forget being put to the stake for blasphemy @ "strange killing”

Andrea Portelli

Oct 26th 2011, 09:06

oh yeah and I was listening to some Arch Enemy and Helloween this morning whilst I was reading this article..... they're metal bands, and I'm 100% normal :D hurrah to me

N. Galea

Oct 26th 2011, 09:06

religious people - funny lot ....TOTALLY!

David Caruana

Oct 26th 2011, 09:07

So what if it is pagan?! Can you please explain to us what's wrong with Paganism?

Ryan Bugeja

Oct 26th 2011, 09:08

Christmas - pagan.

You - Close minded.

Why? Because halloween is a celebration just like carnival, only not as colourful. The children even get candy. What's so wrong with that? And who said they only wear grusome/scary/"demonic" costumes.

Mr A Grech

Oct 26th 2011, 09:13

why would Jesus take 25% of your wage every month? grow up

D Castillo

Oct 26th 2011, 09:10

i couldn't have said it better myself justin ;)

Charles Grima

Oct 26th 2011, 13:32

Ghaziz habib Rocker u Metalhead..... :-)

LONG LIVE ROCK N ROLL !!!!!!!

N. Galea

Oct 26th 2011, 09:12

They think society in Malta hasn’t changed... I guess they believe that we will do what ever they say and believe what they want us to believe! but they are soooooo wrong! They have no idea! I ended up ignoring them completely :) .. they should have realized this after the divorce referendum...

mario micallef

Oct 26th 2011, 09:13

Well said Mr. Collins! Before preaching at us normal, law abiding citizens, the Church should start some internal discipline and really start practising what it preaches.

Advert
Advert