Update 2: PBS says Labour's attack has to do with audiences
Labour's concerted attack on popular TVM presenters Peppi Azzopardi, Lou Bondi and TVM news has nothing to do with balance in broadcasting but with audiences, PBS said this evening.
It was replying to points raised during a news conference given by the Labour Party this afternoon, in which the PL demanded action by the Broadcasting Authority to rein in PBS which, it said, was breaking the Broadcasting Act with regard to the actions of some of its presenters and reporters.
Party spokesman Gino Cauchi, speaking at a press conference, said a legal notice issued in terms of the Broadcasting Act (clause 19) laid down that reporters and presenters of news and current affairs programmes on the state broadcaster should not reveal their political views or involve themselves in political activities.
The legal notice says: "Those known to the public primarily as presenters of, or reporters on, news programmes or programmes of current affairs broadcast on the Public Service broadcaster must be seen to be impartial. It is important that no off-air activity, including writing, the giving of interviews, or the making of speeches, leads to any doubts about their objectivity on air.
"If such presenters or reporters publicly express personal views off air on controversial issues, then their on-air role may be severely compromised.
"It is crucial that in both their work with the Public Service broadcaster and in other non-public service broadcasting activities such as wring, speaking, or giving interviews, they do not:
"1. state how they vote or express support for any political party;
"2. Express views for or against any policy which is a matter of current party political debate.
"3. Advocate any particular position on an issue of current public controversy or debate;
"4. Exhort a change in high profile public policy".
Two weeks ago, Mr Cauchi said, the PL wrote to the chairman of PBS enclosing articles written by presenter Lou Bondi which showed his clear political bias in favour of the PN. More recently, Mr Bondi said, in a Net TV interview, that he would not hesitate in voting PN at the next general election.
Mr Bondi' had every right to write whatever he wished, Mr Cauchi said, but he could not break the law which governed broadcasting. His actions disqualified him from presenting news and current affairs programmes on PBS.
The situation worsened yesterday when it was revealed in court that Xarabank presenter Peppi Azzopardi had coached Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando before a televised press conference less than a week before the 2008 general election.
Mr Cauchi said Mr Azzopardi, through his coaching, had participated in the electoral campaign of the Nationalist Party in a decisive stage of the campaign. Yet this man had even presented debates between the party leaders. Did anyone know if he had actually also coached Dr Gonzi?
This situation was simply unacceptable, Mr Cauchi said. The PL was demanding nothing more than a level playing field on the public broadcasting station.
Mr Cauchi said that personally, he did not expect PBS to rectify the situation. After all, the PBS CEO was Anton Attard, who in March 2008 had been in the PN team which went to the PBS studio for the press conference.
However the PL expected effective action from the Broadcasting Authority as the regulator of broadcasting.
The BA could no longer be passive in this situation but needed to take effective action, Mr Cauchi said.
He did not rule out legal action by the PL.
However, informed sources pointed out to timesofmalta.com that the legal notice quoted by Mr Cauchi provides that clauses 18 and 19 "are not enforceable by the Broadcasting Authority but may be applied by the public service broadcaster."
Mr Cauchi said that this was a self-regulatory measure but the Broadcasting Authority could bring it to the attention of PBS.
PBS said in its statement that Mr Cauchi was probably not aware that things at PBS changed drastically from the time he used to form part of the newsroom.
Mr Cauchi seemed to conveniently ignore the fact that Mr Azzopardi's services have been used by several epople including the leader of the opposition, who used him to draw up the Labour Party Code of Ethics for the media as well as to give seminars to One News journalists on how to convey the message in a more professional way, PBS said.
Moreover, PBS said, the section of the law quoted by Mr Cauchi was not enforceable by the BA.
Yet TVM enforced it when there was some kind of election.
"It is ironic that when Lou Bondi said he was in favour o divorce, the PL sadi nothing because Lou Bondi's position was congruent with Labour."
It said that TVM has continued to improve its audience share in the local broadcasting scnee because it was attracting better quality productions.
These had a negative impact on competing TV stations which lost audiences as well as advertising revenue, which PBS believed was the real reason behind "the harsh orchestrated campaign" against it.
185 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Adrian Camilleri
Apr 10th, 06:33
While I have no love for either Lou or Peppi, the notion that they cannot express an opinion on any matter of political relevance in any setting at any time for whatever reason is lunacy. Yes, yes, some will say that they are free to express any opinion they like but they cannot do so if they expect to work at PBS. But is that really what we're talking about here? I think not. This is politics.
Paul Micallef
Oct 18th 2011, 17:27
Excuse me, i watched the programe, and the most attacks came from,JPO, Dalli the minister,and some guy that was so annoyed at PEPPI that he went a bit over board, but i have seen him on the one station, but surly he is not a PL supporter, i stand corrected. So the ATTACKS as the BPS states come from, NAZZJONALISTI.
As for coaching, i dont think that JPO needs it any more as of yesterday he will be giving it to someone else.
Gordon Scicluna
Oct 13th 2011, 10:38
Why can't we have 2 or 3 TVM's like RAI. Each station's news room will be then biased towards a particular party. Then it's up to the people to choose which news to follow. Then it's up to the Political parties to decide if to go ahead with their private stations.
Mr Mario Bonnici
Oct 13th 2011, 09:17
Jissemma' hafna Xandir Malta fis-snin tmenin pero qatt ma jissemma' l-PBS bejn l-1996 u l-1998. Kull min kien jahdem il-PBS jghidlek li dak kien zmien, taht Albert Marshall, kulhadd kien jahdem f'armonija. Biex ma nsemmux prezentaturi maghrufin ghat-twemmin nazzjonalista li kellhom programmi ewlenin bhal Pjazza 3, Sellili, Bongu Sinjura Borg, Xarabank,...
Hekk ikun verament xandir nazzjonali.
Mr C Camilleri
Oct 13th 2011, 09:11
Dan il-pajjiz mhux fit-2011 qed jghix imma fl'80s u 70s ghax dejjem dawk iz zminijiet insemmu. Ara naqra x'injoranza ! 30 jew 40 sena ilu nuzawhom zkuza biex niggieldu. Flok ma nipprovaw inharsu l-quddiem biex nirrangaw pajjiz fil-bzonn qed inharsu lura u nintrabtu ma zminijiet TOTALMENT DIFFERENTI sempliciment biex nitghajru b'xulxin. Meta se titghallmu ghid ??
Mr Joseph Sammut
Oct 12th 2011, 14:25
The statement from PBS clearly shows the "management's" political inclinations.
Paul Camilleri
Oct 12th 2011, 12:43
insejtu meta dardartuna bil-logo tal-labour u run rabbit run ghax skond ministru laburista ried jghamel miz-zghazagh generazzjoni socjalista
George Azzopardi
Oct 12th 2011, 13:44
You seem to be living in a stonage world .. so be it if you really think that this is the right strategy to win next election!!! You really think that new generation will really believe that two wrongs can make a right? You're on the way down! Your problem will be how deep down you intend to go so that when you get rid of Dr.Gonzi, you'd manage to get up straight again!!
PL had the same problem in the 80's. There were 2 people, who tried to open eyes but at the time they were seen to be as desrters and doing party damage. They were dismissed from the party back then. These 2 people came back within the party and were finally accepted back. One of whom is now deputy leader, Tony Abela! The same will happen to PN with JPO, John Dalli and many others. He's opening your eyes but you're too blind to accept the truth!
R. Gauci
Oct 12th 2011, 12:21
Min ghandu ragun? Bizzejjed naghmlu analizi ta` nies li qeghdin mal-PBS. Lou Bondi - Attivist Nazzjonalist Claudette Pace - Nazzjonalista ddikjarata Ron - Nazzjonalist u ex-NET Pierre Portelli - Attivista Nazzjonalist Peppi - Jghid li bla kuluri imma l-PN dejjem sabu warajh specjalment fi zmien ir-referendum.U minbarra hekk min jispicca minn ma PBS jispicca fuq NET u vice versa, qieshom ta' 'Min ipartat u min ibiegh'.
Joseph Camilleri
Oct 12th 2011, 21:12
What about the people who are labour activists and are on PBS!? I dont know the names as I only know them by face! I remember in the 80's and 70's no PN person was allowes into the Building! Kemm ninsew fejn rridu hux?
R. Gauci
Oct 13th 2011, 00:35
L-uniku wiehed li hemm hu Dr. Joe Mifsud, ifli l-iskeda sewwa u tara kemm hemm Laburisti. Anqas fl-80s ghax kien hemm aktar Nazzjonalisti ma TVM, Charles Saliba per ezempju u dak iz-zmien tuzzana kienu mhux mijiet bhal-lum.
Mariano Camilleri
Oct 12th 2011, 12:15
I am pn supporter and i like to go ahead with my life. labour done bad things. ok so what we are catholics and we forget. the important thing is they change and dont do the same mistakes again. i look forward in my life not backwards. i beleive that pl is right here whatever happened million years ago because its time to change the maltese attitude because i suppport one party then the other party is never right. to be honest altough i am pn supporter i had enough of pn scaring us of what happened in the past so they stay in power. this is still abuse on us maltese when they verbally threaten you that if labour comes in power we are goin to be threated likein the era of dinosaurs.we are in 2011 and these things cannot happen again. sant was men enough that when people werent happy he called for elections im sure this never happened before so things change. aswell pbs is ripping off maltese people tv license for its broadcasting then it fills the time with all the adverts so it makes more money. other national tv stations in other contries the best example is bbc uk about 5 bbc channels you never see 1 single advert in any bcc channel because they get their money from tv licence. so why maltese people accept this? we are used to these adverts so remove the licence then.stop stealing our money...
Ms D Galea
Oct 13th 2011, 10:19
@Mr Azzopardi and Mr Gatt;
I was simply asking a question that cropped up naturally as a result of what got said earlier by Mr Laiviera.
All that I expected was a simple YES or a NO answer , not a boring encyclical apologizing for the golden Mintoff era.
Thank you.
Mr Ronald Cauchi
Oct 12th 2011, 10:43
What kind of National Television Station is it that gets into mud slinging matches with a political party naturally one that is in opposition? While its quite expected for the two Parties to call each other for everything, it shows very little dignity and balance when "the Station of the Nation" feels the need to go hitting out at the Party in opposition. Id like to see it doing that to the government. I guess as regards Xandir Malta, PBS or what ever nothing ever changes except the colour of the flag they wave.
Mr Victor Laiviera
Oct 12th 2011, 09:44
The reply from PBS only shows how right the LP is to complain. It is the reply of someone who clearly feels that his loyalty is to a party (the PN) and not to the national institution that should be above party politics and is is subsidised from the taxes of all the population - not just half of it.
No country which uses public broadcasting to push the agenda of the regime can call itself democratic.
Ms D Galea
Oct 12th 2011, 10:54
Was Malta a democracy in the golden Dardir-Malta Mintoff-era of the 70s and 80s?
Mr Joseph Aquilina
Oct 12th 2011, 11:31
"It is ironic that when Lou Bondi said he was in favour o divorce, the PL sadi nothing because Lou Bondi's position was congruent with Labour."
Have anything to say about that? PL and PN are one and the same!?
Mr Victor Laiviera
Oct 12th 2011, 11:47
As I have already told you, if you want to find at least some of the people responsible for that you would have to look for them in Herbert Ganado Street, not Mile End Street.
George Azzopardi
Oct 12th 2011, 11:58
@Ms D Galea
so if it was not so democaratic at the time you mentioned (70' and 80's) .. then it's ok to continue with this PN biased TVM? Well ok so why not continue going back to the 60's or maybe the 50's?
Come on, we're living in 2011 you're going back 30 and 40 years!!! If you're honest enough you'd simply say that these 2 presenters (one more than the other) are politically biased. The problem is that they think that us normal citizens are so naive as not to realize this!!!
But the real reason is that they already know that their end with TVM is very near and so don't really care in continue to damage TVM's reputation!
Ms Lynn Zahra
Oct 12th 2011, 14:36
Mr.Joseph Aquilina:
Peppi and Lou Bondi have always been for divorce so they couldn't take a stand against it and be credible , now could they?
Brian Gatt
Oct 12th 2011, 16:11
@Ms D Galea,
Ms Galea, is Malta a democracy in this Par Idejn Sodi - tmexxija ghaqlija - Gonzi - Gatt -era??
The answer is yes if you compare it to the Mao Tse Tung - Stalin eras, compared the rest of the EU countries ......but you know the answer to this one yourself
P.S. no-one answered my comment further below. Well I guess i hit the nail on the head and and the PN supporters have to check in with however is coaching them to see what kind of answer they should wrtite down!!!! And who may that be????
Brian Gatt
Oct 12th 2011, 09:41
Looks like all the PN supportes are going all out to protect their Stalwarths on the National TV, this also proves the point that the PL are saying the truth. All the PN supporters writing below are not saying that these incidents never happened and that the National Station is not biased in favor of the PN, instead they are trying to cover up with the excuse of the PL is getting a taste of his own medicine .....basically a pay back of whay used to happen on the national station in the 80's, so I put out these questions to my fellow bloggers below:
Do TWO wrongs ever make a right?
So by not condemming the actions of the National TV station now does this mean that the MLP back in the 80's did the right thing to use the National TV as his political weapon (or so it is being written below)?
So are you saying the the PN is using the 80's political strategy used by the old MLP?
I would like to hear from the supposedly unbiased bloggers writing below.
Patrick Pace
Oct 12th 2011, 08:49
Ha tibqghu issemmu snin 80, nistghu nibqghu morru lura bhal hamsinijiet u sittinijiet ghax tkun kulur ahmar dejjem taqla fuq wiccek, qisa l-istorja politika hawn malta fit-80 bdiet. Tahsbu li l-poplu se jibqa injorant u ma jindunax fi zmijiet tal llum xhinu jigri.
Patrick Pace
Oct 12th 2011, 08:49
Ha tibqghu issemmu snin 80, nistghu nibqghu morru lura bhal hamsinijiet u sittinijiet ghax tkun kulur ahmar dejjem taqla fuq wiccek, qisa l-istorja politika hawn malta fit-80 bdiet. Tahsbu li l-poplu se jibqa injorant u ma jindunax fi zmijiet tal llum xhinu jigri.
j brincat
Oct 12th 2011, 08:28
What do you expect PBS to say?
Shouldn't this matter be decided upon by MBA?
(jb)
Mr Carmel Garcia
Oct 12th 2011, 08:00
Insih zmienu dan meta kien max-xandir (Dardir) Malta u isem il-kap tal-Partit Nazzjonalista ma kienx jissemma b'ismu? Jiena m'inhiex xi fan ta dawn iz-zewg prezentaturi li ma jtukx cans tirrispondi d-domanda li jaghmlulek jew dak li trid tghid. Ghalhekk jien ma narahomx il-programmi taghhom ghax taghhom biss irid jghaddi. Imma ahjar jara x'sar fi zmien meta hu kien max-xandir malta fi zmien gvern socjalista. Anke l-arma tal-labour kien tidher fuq l-iskrin flok l-arma ta' l-istazzjon. Ara sewwa jghidu li l-izpizjar milli jkollu jtik.
Patrick Pace
Oct 12th 2011, 08:40
Ghandek ragun imma llum isiru affarijiet ohra. AKTAR BIL-PULIT. Daqqa man-Net TV daqqa mal-PBS, jerghu man-Net u terga tarhom mal-PBS. Nahseb int intelligenti bizzejjed biex tinduna, jekk ghandek tikkritika ikritika lil kulhadd.
Mr Carmel Garcia
Oct 12th 2011, 12:08
Patrick Pace, Naqbel perfettament mieghek dwar Net - PBS - Net etc. Il-gvern taghna naghmlu li rridu u dan qed nghidu ghal kull gvern li jkun fil-poter.
Mr M Spiteri
Oct 12th 2011, 07:25
This is all about money and power and money again. Peppi and Lou make thousands from PBS funded from our coffers whilst at the same time make thgeir best to keep GONZI PN in government through these so called indipendent programs.
Mr Ludwig Flask
Oct 12th 2011, 07:13
This is just a matter of opinion not ethics when it pleases us its ok when not then it’s wrong!
lilly vella
Oct 12th 2011, 06:48
Ha Ha haj !!! Joke of the century !!! Lou Bondi and Peppi Azzopardi impartial !!! Ha Ha haj !!!
Kenneth Galea
Oct 12th 2011, 06:04
Well Labour is getting a taste of its own medicine of the 70's and 80's era, though the situation is certainly very different on PBS these days. Gino Cauchi is orchestrating all this because Super One are losing audiences en masse. Do we remember when Alfred Sant launched a fierce campaign against Peppi Azzopardi and Lou Bondi? It did not go down well with the public but it was the downfall of the PL and consequently they lost one election after the other. Continue with this non sense and you will lose another election in 2013. It is utter desperation to govern, that's what it is. Biex tiskongra trid tkun pur!!!
Joseph Borg
Oct 18th 2011, 17:43
Well Labour is getting a taste of its own medicine of the 70's and 80's era????? so Two wrongs make one right???/ are you saying so? Do you think that in 2003 MLP lost th election because tehy boycotted Peppi and Lou?? I thought in 2003 MLP lost the election because of their stand about teh entry of Malta in the EU???
stupid me!!! ....mela after all it was because of thatboycott , that the maltese electorate decided to vote PN!
u hallina!
charles tabone
Oct 12th 2011, 01:59
Why is PBS shielding these two media personalities when all and sundry know full well their political agendas? Furthermore there need be no further prof after their declarations. PBS should safeguard the citizens' right to fair and balanced programmes and news items.
Mr Victor Laiviera
Oct 11th 2011, 23:50
This comment by PBS is further proof - if any was needed - of how justified the LP's complaint is.
It is not the statement of a public entity defending its position - it is a highly partisan statement defending a party. It is clear that the heads at PBS see their loyalty is to the PN not to te public who is paying their salary.
Mr Rodnick Abdilla
Oct 11th 2011, 23:35
Ghandom dritt jesprimu l opinjoni taghom. pero femni ftit umbad kif tista umbad fuq programm tkun imparzjali ? issa inhoss li tefaw il gebla fuq saqajom, in nies issa anke semplici mistoqsija ser ikunu qed jidubittaw hux geniwina.
David Cutajar
Oct 11th 2011, 23:26
Firstly i've been told a couple of times that the money, some are still forking out for the tv licences are not goinh to pbs as opposed to the impression of many. A Labour Delegate who works at PBS & who happens to be my friend, explained that though its the state tv, the state is forwarding very limited financial assistants. Most of the revenue seems to becoming from the adverts. I'm not a Peppi fan.bit the giy has a natural talent inside him. He produces quality progs that attract record audiences. Labour have Super One and rightly so are main rivals. PL is trying to destroy peppi and xarabank. They instructed Bundy to emulate Peppi bit the formula is not working! I would love to get this...why peppi was good to educate the PL journalists, reform the media ethics of the labour media but yet cant provide some tips to JPO? Kindly enlighten me cos am lost...
Mr Alfred Cassar
Oct 11th 2011, 23:05
I say remove Clause 19, it's simply ridiculous. Labour spokesmen are behaving like small kids
silvio loporto
Oct 12th 2011, 09:25
The law is there for everybody.
It is not fair that some should feeel to be above the law.
I don't see why you find clause 19" ridiculous" it is there to protect you and me.
Mr m farrugia
Oct 11th 2011, 23:04
mark piscopo ibqa fi zgur li jtellfu u ma jtellfux azzopardi u bondi bhalissa jitlifha elezzjoni il PL
il poplu mhux iblah u qed jirrealizza li bid difetti kollha, allahares ma kellniex il PN u prim kapaci bhalissa biex niffaccjaw krizi finanzjarja mad dinja kollha u il krizi tal libya. Nibza nahseb kif kien jiffaccja il krizi tal libya il PL, forsi kien iqabbad xi espert mill gvern tal 80s bhala medjatur u nidhlu b'xi froga. Jew kien jaffaccja il krizi finanzjarja bill irahhas il kontinijiet ta l-ilma u mbaghad idahhal ic CET u ifalli pajjiz.
sfortunatament il PL sejjer lura bhal granc, anki nies ta l-80s li sant kien prova iwarrab bil mod, jew ahjar mintoffjani, muscat qed jiehu pjacir jerga jaghtihom prominenza a skapitu ta nies ohra zghar kapaci.
Mr michael catania
Oct 11th 2011, 21:52
Personally I do not give a ***** about thes two so called unbiassed presenters, what I resent is that with a gun to my head I have to pay a licence which lines the pockets of these so called unbaissed presenters. I f they want to to be on TV they have their paymasters' TV station the NET but then they propably will not be able to have an audience as that station's rating is so low. What came out in the open has long been known to people with some brains and I'm sure that if they are like me would not even look in at TVM. Those that harp to the 70's and 80's and accuse mlp of similar behavior I say to you that you must be talking from the part of your body that most civilised normally sit on.
Joseph Camilleri
Oct 11th 2011, 21:51
Maaaaa!! What cheeck! Tal lejber insew il BAN tal PN fuq il PBS fi zmien ir renju taghhom!? Issa qed jitkellmu bil act u mhux act! Ara veru il q@£&a milli jkollha ttik ta! Gino kompli aqa ghaz zufjet! Ghafgu kemm tistghu! Heh! Insejt Gin li fi zmienek meta INTI kont il PBS ma kontx isemmi isem Eddie Fenech Adami? Insejt li il PBS kien jkollu xjandar minn sqalijja ghax kien projbit il PN li jsemmi il vizzjonijiet tieghu ghal pajjizna!?
Isthu jekk tafu tal lejber... Ghadda iz zmien, izda ninsa qatt minn xiex ghaddiet Malta taht il lejber!
Mr Henry Mifsud
Oct 11th 2011, 21:50
I think that Mr. Anthony Tabone and the BA board members have some head-scratching to do. Each member must shed his/her political allegiance and stand to be counted. It is pointless to continue this farcical act by simply looking at things from a blinkered point of view with the excuse that this was being practiced since time immemorial. Two wrongs never make a right. Unless we mature and start calling a spade a spade, we shall continue to be the laughing stock of our neighbouring 'civilized' EU countries. It is pointless to take a common front in parliament as was done yesterday by passing a motion on a unanimous vote which concern an international affair (the Greece bailout) but then fail miserably when it comes to dealing with domestic situations. We constantly hear our politicians, especially those on the government benches, preaching as to how many laws are being enacted and amended year in year out. But dare I ask: what is the point of having legislation in place when this is hardly ever being enforced? Laws are blatantly being broken as definitely is the case of Peppi Azzopardi and Lou Bondi’. Why two weights and two measures? It's about time that our legal and constitutional (watch dog) bodies such as the Broadcasting Authority, show that they are truly performing and delivering. Otherwise what is the point of having such Authorities in the first place? And please BA, do not come with some ruling by beating round the bush like the recent classical PBS example as otherwise you would only continue to lose your credibility with all those who are level-headed.
Quo Vadis Malta?
Alfred Grech
Oct 11th 2011, 21:42
Il-Laburisti u n-Nazzjonalisti jiggieldu qishom klieb u qtates.
Hafna huma ntelligentissimi pero' fejn tidhol il-politika jaqghu ghall-istupitagni. Grow up big kids!!!
Joseph Camilleri
Oct 11th 2011, 21:36
History repeats itself. When RTK was the competition for Labour media, the party worked hard to destroy it...and Curia was docile and afraid. Now PBS is threatening Labour media, also, as RTK before it in the past, giving the correct facts in context and letting people decide. Of course Labour media does not like that. The only freedom the PL media accepts is the freedom to be like them.
Carmel Xuereb
Oct 11th 2011, 21:20
U la l-PBS qed jghidilna li qed idahhalha sew mir-riklami mela ghalfejn is-Sur Gvern qieghed iqaxxrilna l-flus tal-licenzja tat-TV u jaghtiha lil PBS biss. Ahna suppost ma nhalsux licenzja tat-TV bhal ma suppost ma konniex inhalsu l-licenzja tat-dixx imma s-Sur Gvern ghogbu jibda jigborhom sa kemm tal-l-EU qalulu daqshekk u l-istess se jigri ghal din il-licenzja. Issa fuq din il-kwistjoni kullhadd jaf li din hi l-hajja jew il-mewt tal-PBS, Peppi u Bondi+. ghalhekk nistenna li dawn ser iqajmu l-irwiefen kollha u jekk hemm bzonn anke l-mejtin mill-qabar imma llum l-poplu m'ghadux bahnan u kulljum qieghed jinduna li dawn qed isiru sinjuri minn fuq il-fidili bhal ma kont jien. imma llum ftaht ghajnejja u programmi ta' Peppi, Bondi+ u PBS ma narax ghax dak qampiena wahda biss idoqqu, ghalhekk qlibt ghad-dixx u nara kollox barra ta' Malta.
Mr M camilleri
Oct 11th 2011, 21:19
il bicca tax xoghol hekk tahdem aw malta meta ikun hemm partit fil gvern igawdu niesu issa hemm tal pn u igawdu darbohra ikun hemm il pl u peppi u bondi jispicaw fuq net flokhom indahlu xi hadd min tal pl..lftah ghajnejk CIKKU IL POPLU tibqax tarfa it trofy umbad isib xi pasta imwehla fil qih u taqa fwiccek.
maria curmi
Oct 11th 2011, 21:17
Peppi being a great coach why not try to coach MFA national team maybe we will make it to the word cup
J.C. Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 20:53
Kif irridu nsibu z-zejt hawn Malta, lanqas f'wicc certi nies ma fadal!
T Gauci
Oct 11th 2011, 20:38
Haha as if nobody knew that pepi and bondi are gonzipn enthusiasts, i can't believe how people still watch TVM, they must have never heard of a satellite TV.
John Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 20:38
Was Gino Cauchi a labourite when he was working at PBS newsroom for 15 years? or did he became a labourite when he left PBS to go to head One news?
What about Edward Scicluna, whom the BA used to appoint to chair its its conferences before the election. Did he become a labourite afterwards or was the broadcasting authority choosing a labourite?
Those living in the glass houses should stop throwing stones. Gino Cauchi may try to look smart but we remember who Gino Cauchi was when he was at TVM. Today TVM is a real public Service Broadcaster, not in Gino Cauchi's time.
Mr Hans Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 20:38
We all know that the PN will always stoop to the lowest levels to scrim through another election !
James Catania
Oct 11th 2011, 20:14
It is ironic that when Lou Bondi said he was in favour o divorce, the PL sadi nothing because Lou Bondi's position was congruent with Labour."
It was never PL's position of being in favour of the DIVORCE legislation it was only Dr. Joseph Muscat personally who was in favour of the Divorce Legislation. Do these people actually think we're stupid ?.
PL could say or not say anything about this matter since it was nothing to do with politics but a social issue were everyone had his / her own opinion.
Mario Schembri
Oct 11th 2011, 20:08
Will someone please tell me what has changed within the Labour Party?
Sorry, I forgot, they have a new emblem.
The rest remains the same, maybe even worse!
Mr Jeffrey Mallia
Oct 11th 2011, 19:57
Imma possibli li hawn xi pesuna onesta go dan il pajjiz, li tisa tejd li il PBS huwa imparzjali ???? Hafna kummenti banali ta 25 sena ilu , u xgara dawk iz zminijiet, u hafna paroli fil vojt.............il lum fit 2011 ergajna gejna l;istess mela !! Pajjiz tat tribuijiet u tan nies morda mentalment.
Noel Abela
Oct 11th 2011, 19:50
People people, let us not forget that PBS is funded by public funds, and public funds come out of our pockets no matter if you are a Labour or Nationalist supporter. So PBS should keep its distance fromn party politics. But how can this be the case when it is being managed by people close to Pieta
Mr Joe Vella
Oct 11th 2011, 21:55
Noel Abela, so why the people from mile high in Hamrun invite Peppe to participate in PL sponsored activities.
John Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 19:31
Gino Cauchi waqa ghac cajt... komplu ikfu l-maskri tal-PBS. tibzghux mill-intimidazzjoni tal-lejber
Mr Victor Laiviera
Oct 11th 2011, 23:40
"komplu ikfu l-maskri tal-PBS." .... you said it!
Kemm għandek raġun!
Mr Matthew Psaila
Oct 12th 2011, 01:36
maybe you're too biased
Edward Gatt
Oct 11th 2011, 19:23
It seems that the problem is not what political views does Lou Bondi and Peppi Azzopardi have but that they (or at least Lou Bondi did) express them publicly.
But whatis the best: having someone who declares upfront his views so that when you are seeing his programs you would know how to judge or someone who pretends that he is neutral but who would have very strong political opinion.
Remeber Edward SCicluna being presented as a neutral person during election time on the national broadcasting station? Was he really neatral at those times or simply he did not declare his bias!
jjose pace
Oct 11th 2011, 19:16
hi jiena personali ex nazjonalist ma naqbilx ma min joqod jilaba ta xi indipendenti phal dawn specjalment fuq ix-xandir ta istat ghax jiena inhalas licenzja biex veru ikun ta comunita u mux biex nisma min jiprova jaweg il-fatti jew jahbi xi agenda. Qatt ma kont nopsor li f'malta ghadom jezistu dawn it-tip ta afarijit imma issa la hareg kolox fil-berah nemen u najt grazzi min qalb lil pulicino orlando ghax veru onest u gentili .grazi u tibzax min verita phal dejjem . programi phal dawn daqsek rajtom ex PN .
P Cassar
Oct 11th 2011, 19:13
"Yet TVM enforced it when there was some kind of election"
Were Lou Bondi and Peppi Azzopardi stopped from producing any Political programm prior to the last election? Of course not, on the contrary they produced political debates and if I remember correctly one Xarabank also discussed JPO.
More important will WE be stopped from producing any political program come next electiion, although they are already working very hard to subtly convince people that PN is a better choice than PL. I admit this is a very difficult task, but they have two long years to succeed.
Mr Henry Mifsud
Oct 11th 2011, 19:07
I think that Mr. Anthony Tabone and the BA board members have some head-scratching to do. Each member must shed his/her political allegiance and stand to be counted. It is pointless to continue this farcical act by simply looking at things from a blinkered point of view with the excuse that this was being practiced since time immemorial. Two wrongs never make a right. Unless we mature and start calling a spade a spade, we shall continue to be the laughing stock of our neighbouring 'civilized' EU countries. It is pointless to take a common front in parliament as was done yesterday by passing a motion on a unanimous vote which concern an international affair (the Greece bailout) but then fail miserably when it comes to dealing with domestic situations. We constantly hear our politicians, especially those on the government benches, preaching as to how many laws are being enacted and amended year in year out. But dare I ask: what is the point of having legislation in place when this is hardly ever being enforced? Laws are blatantly being broken as definitely is the case of Peppi Azzopardi and Lou Bondi’. Why two weights and two measures? It's about time that our legal and constitutional (watch dog) bodies such as the Broadcasting Authority, show that they are truly performing and delivering. Otherwise what is the point of having such Authorities in the first place? And please BA, do not come with some ruling by beating round the bush like the recent classical PBS example as otherwise you would only continue to lose your credibility with all those who are level-headed.
Quo Vadis Malta?
francis caruana
Oct 11th 2011, 19:05
do as most of us do and use the same weapon these people used in the past....................boycot the state tv . they dont deserve much better
Mariano Camilleri
Oct 12th 2011, 12:38
yes every maltese pl and pn normal hard working people should join forces into one and not turn tvm on this will teach pbs who is in charge.its us the viewers and not pl or pn or any other one that is in pbs. it should teach pbs to respect the viewer more
Maria Cassar
Oct 11th 2011, 18:53
A journalist should never be precluded from making his voting intentions known to all and sundry, let alone kicked out of PBS.
Mark Piscopo
Oct 11th 2011, 18:52
Iz-Zejt tela f'wicc l-ilma fil-Qorti u Peppi Azzopard ammetta li ta "coaching" lil Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando lejliet elezzjoni Generali biex jaffronta lil ex mexxej laburista Dr Sant.Peppi u Lou Bondi qeghdin jghamlu min kollox biex jtellfu l-elezzjoni lil PL izda illum harget il verita. Hadt pjacir hafna lil PL ha stand iebsa fuq dan il kaz ghax ma jistax jkun li nhallu nies jiksru il-ligi sfaccatament u ma jigri xejn.
Noel Mifsud
Oct 11th 2011, 23:22
Peppii Azzopardi ahjar jibdel ismu u jsemmih San Peppi, iva jien ghalija jistya jsir San, jibqa Peppi ujew isir Sur Joe ghax kemm jista jkun ma narahx. Ghax apparti li jdejjqni, narah li tieghu biss tajjeb. LIl Alfred Sant ma kien jahmlu u bil fors lil PN ihbbhom hux, ghax sqewh, temawh u kiel minghandhom.
Paul Giordimaina
Oct 12th 2011, 06:54
Mr Piscopo you are living in another world there was nothing wrong and here everyone say what he is big deal.Remember in the 80s the PN had to transmit offshore .
Tony Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 18:52
"PBS said in its statement that Mr Cauchi was probably not aware that things at PBS changed drastically from the time he used to form part of the newsroom"
This statement is unbelievable. How can the national station issue a statement with such a political loading?
Imagine if the BBC was to issue such a statement how many heads would roll not just at the station but also on a political level.
Mr Hans Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 21:09
@ Tony Borg
Well said.
Saviour Sam Agius
Oct 11th 2011, 22:08
Hekk qed ngħid jien ukoll. Tweġiba mimlija botti politiċi, meta dan suppost qed jippruvalna li l-PBS imparzjali. Mhux biss il-politikanti qegħdin jitkellmu bħat-tfal u bħall-boloh, imma anki x-xandir pubbliku issa.
Mr G Mangion
Oct 11th 2011, 18:41
The truth hurts that is why gino cauchi is trying to take a Political advantge on Bondi+ and Mr Peppi
Regarding Floating Voters : They do watch all local t.v staions and they dont have to go to the universaty
to see the in Maltese ( Moqsezati ) and the mlp has a long way to go to Convince them !!!
Why not, Complained about Disset too ?
G. Mangion.
Mr Antoine Vella
Oct 11th 2011, 18:40
They thought they could challenge Xarabank with Affari Tagħna but it turned out to be a no contest.
Mr Mark Farrugia
Oct 11th 2011, 20:25
Spot on !!!!! Agree with you 100% ... PL think that they can control everything and everyone even from the Opposition ... they are trying very hard to gain audience on their station in order to influence a greater share of the population with their political agenda, especially now that the election is nearing. They know that xarabank and bondi + are simply too good for them to challenge, so they revert to such things in order to put peppi's and lou's programmes in a bad light ... agree with this comment if you share my thought !!
Mrs Joe Felice-Pace
Oct 11th 2011, 18:32
In the 70's a call for applications for a broadcaster in the news and features department of Xandir Malta was advertised. There were several applicants who were interviewed by a politically balanced 5-men board. it so happened that first (by far) on the list was no labourite. When the decision was presented to the minister he took up his pen and cancelled the name. The same with the second, and so forth till he came to the labourite favourite. No need for further comment.
Joe Felice Pace
Anthony Grech
Oct 11th 2011, 21:30
Dear Joe, while at it, why mentiom only the 70's. What about the 60's ? Did your pn ever cancelled a name from a list of a labour applicant for a SIMPLE job?,Do you by any chance have a ststistic of how many MLP supporters had to emigrate because of this? I was one of them.
Mr Victor Laiviera
Oct 11th 2011, 23:51
Have you any proof of that?
Mr A Vella
Oct 11th 2011, 18:28
So much for the new Labour Party
Mr Joseph Brincat
Oct 11th 2011, 18:25
LIKE THEY SAY !!!!!
IT TAKES TWO TO TANGLE ????
Ms D Galea
Oct 12th 2011, 01:22
TANGLE what?
Talk about getting one's knickers in a TWIST.
:)
M. Degiorgio
Oct 11th 2011, 18:24
The law is absurd in a small nation like Malta where everybody knows everybody. It is impossible to put in practice.
Mr joseph saliba
Oct 11th 2011, 18:18
Like in this case their inferiority syndrome still manifests itself in an obsession to silence the 'other opinion'.
victor caruana
Oct 11th 2011, 18:11
There should not be any problem for the PL to ridicule both programmes if those PL representatives taking part in such progammes make fun of both presenters association with the PN.
A. Cachia
Oct 11th 2011, 18:02
....u bhas-soltu tal-PN ghandhom ragun........
Mr Joseph Calleja
Oct 11th 2011, 18:40
If a Show host wants to express his personal political opinion then he/she should go on a Political sponsored station and not on Public Sponsored Television.
Andre Cilia
Oct 11th 2011, 18:53
ghaliex? tal-PL ghandom ragun?
Fabien Calleja
Oct 11th 2011, 19:42
Kollha ghejra ghax diga qed tibzaw li ha titlfu elezzjoni ohra!
A. Cachia
Oct 11th 2011, 21:50
le stenna tal-PL ghandhom ragun.......
j brincat
Oct 11th 2011, 18:01
It was to be expected for the PN's apologists to swoop in droves and adulate whatever GonziPN does by mentioning ancient history.
What they conveniently try to forget is the fact that Labour was in government in more recent time (albeit for a short time) in 1996 and Dr Sant ruled in a very fair manner.
(jb)
A. Cachia
Oct 11th 2011, 18:07
...too fair for certain people
John J. Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 18:13
Presumably you meant to say Sant "governed" rather than "ruled" (interesting insight into a Labour mindset there). Which raises the question of why Sant was so quickly dumped by the electorate if he was indeed "ruling" so fairly.
Andre Cilia
Oct 11th 2011, 18:54
pity that 'fair' didn't let him govern for the whole five years... + he didn't win another election since...
S. Vella
Oct 11th 2011, 21:57
Ruled? Who was this - King Alfred and the PL Knights of Mile End?
anthony bartolo
Oct 11th 2011, 23:07
Tell it to the mariines.
Paul Giordimaina
Oct 12th 2011, 06:58
How can you talk like that Mr J you never stop mentioning the quarrel with the church if you got glass back dont trow stones.
J. Schembri
Oct 11th 2011, 18:00
"The situation worsened yesterday when it was revealed in court that Xarabank presenter Peppi Azzopardi had coached Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando before a televised press conference less than a week before the 2008 general election.”
But may I ask , isn’t Peppi the same Peppi who headed Joseph’s PL media board or whatever name it was given, just right after Joseph was elected? When it comes to media ,Peppi helps everybody, even Alternattiva Demokratika.
In my humble opinion Lou Bondi should stop writing his blog but also Saviour Balzan should stop being a TV presenter or editor of the anti Gonzi Paper Malta Today.
Fabien Calleja
Oct 11th 2011, 19:43
Proset well written!
Tony Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 17:59
The PN's apologists are not stating that what Gino Cauchi is not true. They know that Lou and Peppi are biased towards the PN and their position is untenable.
They are justifying what is happenning by referring to the 80s.
These apologists do not know that two wrongs don't make a right.
Andre Cilia
Oct 11th 2011, 18:55
I was born in 1990 and clearly remember Gino Cauchi reading the PBS news... how the 80's came into this only you know...
Mr Joseph E Briffa
Oct 11th 2011, 17:46
I don't agree that being balanced means being neutral. One might as well go the whole hog and suggest that TVM should not make any mention of any political Maltese figure or report any of their statements.. Wouldn't such a proposal be absurd? The same goes for giving the same importance to say some news of value made by the prime minister or a minister and something trivial uttered by the leader of the opposition or worse still by a an opposition deputy leader or indeed by one of its backbenchers. It's not the first time that this has happened on TVM ina vain attempt to ensure that the same time is alloted to both the government and the opposition. The time window is not important, but the way the news items are transmitted; particularly whether there are any qualifications by the broadcaster. Biased reporting can be done in various ways, like leaving out a salient part of what was said or adding comments by the broadcaster, or by the broadcaster adding his own or the station's interpretation, or by quotations out of context. The time window is immaterial, one can misinterpret or give a different twist to a statement in a longer time window, while reporting faithfully a statement in a shorter time window. The first one is biased reporting despite being of longer duration, the latter is faithful reporting though of shorter duration. .People want to hear what our politicians are saying provided it has news value independently of the source; it's the substance that counts. People should be let to carry out their own analysis; they are not interested in a broadcaster's qualifications or interpretations. This apart, it would be ludicrous to compare the style of today's TVM reportage with that of Xandir Malta. There is no comparison at all. Even the style of reporting on today's Super One is mild by comparison with that on Xandir Malta which one could compare with Radio Tirana and other stations behind the Iron Curtain.
Giovann Demartino
Oct 11th 2011, 17:39
Afli jrid ikollok wiccek xi haga aghar, hafna aghar mil-ghatba tal-qorti biex tkun lejburist u tiskandalizza ruhek bl-"imparzjalita" tax-xandir.' Mela dawn insew meta r-regim kien ha l-istazzjon KOMPLETAMENT f'idejh u anqas l-isem tal-kap ta' l-oppozizzjoni b'maqggoranza assoluta ta' voti ma seta jixxandar!! Dawn jafu jew ma jafux jisthu?
Mr Michael Debono
Oct 11th 2011, 17:55
Mr Giovanni Demartino: you are still asleep after 25 years. What a sleep longer by years of the Bear sleep.
It is doubtfull whether Mr. Giovanni Demartino, what a nice Italian name, is still ruminating the past.
Mr Paul Micallef
Oct 11th 2011, 17:58
Hemm hu, lehhen il PN, ilek ma tarah ix-xandir li issemmi??? mela BONDI,U PEPPI, mhux xarabank issa ghax ha biddel issu,, ARRIVEDERCI. Are taht ALFRED SANT hemm baqaw hemm jerdaw, u by the way jien nippreferi nara xi program fuq HITLER ghax ihhob juzah BONDI. Sur editur jekk dan is-sinjur jattaka bil pinna hallina han wigbuh. Smajt li daqt tigi, bit 20 EURO minn fuq DAHRI, tal PL.
M. Bezzina
Oct 11th 2011, 18:01
GIOVANN qas nistennija minnek andkom il PBS u in net f idejkom hi!!zewg stazzjonijiet bhall dawk!!
G Schembri
Oct 11th 2011, 18:21
Dejjem isemi x'gara 30 sena ilu, dak iz-zmien in -nies ivvutaw biex ibiddlu l-gvern, ghax il-PN kien wieghed Demokrazija, mhux Regim Faxxista. Il-poplu Malti ma vvutax biex ixxandir minn Mouthpeice ta Regime isir mouthpiece ta Regime iehor avvolja aktar sottili. Jien nippreferi kif kien dak iz-zmien ghax ghal-inqas konna nafu li dawk kienu favur l-MLP. Imma dawn jilaghbuha tal-paladini tad-Demokrazija imbaghad minn wara jkunu qed jikowcjaw lil tal-PN biex fuq it-TV jidhru ahjar mil-PL. Allura wiehed jista jahseb li qabel xi Xarabank debate tal-PN ikunu jafu x'se jigu miststoqsija u tal-PL le. Jien nipreferi nara NET u ONE ghax ghalinqas tkun taf x'inhi l-political agenda wara l-program. Imma programmi tal-WE ghandhom hidden agenda. Jien daqshekk rajthom.
Zack Piccinino
Oct 11th 2011, 18:35
Why is it every time I read a comment by Mr. Demartino it's always the same old story - he's stuck in the rut of days gone by.
You're stuck in a moment mate.... a moment long gone !
Mr Ray Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 18:48
Mr. Demartino if you want to go back why don't you start from were the Labour party news paper il- Helsien, could not enter in governmental departments, you tend to forget that was PN freedom press.
Saviour Sam Agius
Oct 11th 2011, 22:11
Jiġifieri tajjeb li ma jkunx imparzjali allura? Tajjeb li nibqgħu hekk? X'jimporta min qed jgħid il-ħaġa? X'jimporta x'kien jagħmel qabel? Li jimporta huwa l-messaġġ. Illum qegħdin ngħixu u l-problemi tal-bieraħ ma nistgħux insolvuhom illum, mela tal-anqas insolvu tal-lum!
A Cuschieri
Oct 11th 2011, 17:38
People in glass houses shouldn't throw stones (pun intended)
Gino Cauchi worked at the Broadcasting Authority till 2000 (when he joined ONE). During that stint, from 1995-1998 he was Pembroke Mayor. He contested the election as and independent candidate but everyone (with some sense) knows that in thar phase of Local Council elections Indipendent meant MLP.
John J. Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 17:52
Well-said.
Mr ADRIAN GRECH
Oct 11th 2011, 17:37
Is this the way the PL acts agains people who get in their way?
Indeed new labour
John J. Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 17:35
This is rich coming from a party that once had Toni Pellegrini in charge at Dar ix-Xandir. If Bondi and Azzoppardi broke Broadcasting Authority rules let them pay the consequences but the MLP is hardly in a position to take the moral high ground. We were not all born after 1980.
Mr Julian Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 17:28
Go on folks- vote for the PL - the only truly democratic party in Malta - advocating freedom of speech! The PL have a station that spouts vile half truths and spin to create (and they have succeeded) a 'feel bad' factor. They have managed to convince many that it is time for change and that the country is in a disastrous state. And yet when cornered to cite examples they say 'electricity tariffs' and '€500 pay increase'.
The first the Govt has no control over - the second has been retracted because it was ill-timed and ill-judged - and the PN admitted as much.
Now we have yet another example - if any was needed - that the PL is against freedom of expression. On the one hand they eulogised Abela Garrett as the heroine symbolizing freedom of speech (and the PN did NOTHING to muzzle her; on the contrary - they agreed with her right to express herself). and on the other they try to silence anyone that has a different point of view to the PL one.
This is a party full of spin and PR and we will bear the consequences of gullibility!
Mr Victor Laiviera
Oct 11th 2011, 17:36
It won't wash, Mr Borg.
You cannot escape the fact that Peppi Azzopardi is paid from PUBLIC FUNDS (unlike ONE or NET) to produce balanced current affairs programs which he is not delivering.
Mr Paul Micallef
Oct 11th 2011, 17:52
You think that the PN are Democratic???
Let me hope that the Editor posts this. I had a good job with the BOV, i was a handy man, you know what the PN did when they come to POWER, throw me out, and sent me to HALFAR naqta il haxix.
Democracy??? 500 Euro wage increase for the boys when and all the perks that come with the job??? You my friend maybe living the high life, but not us.PL supporters are treated like crap, so when you say that the PL is not a truly DEMOCRATIC PARTY you dont know what you are on about. LOOK at Alfred sant THE DEMON, what did he do??? He left all as is, no transfers and so on, he knew that he was going to lose the election, but still had the guts to do it. We are against Freedom of expresion??? Look at our statsion full of PN supporters, PBS and NET, not over there dead body that a PL supporter passes true.
I am not a gullibile person,had mu ha jixtrili il-VOT jew ittini fridge.
JOSEPH is a true maltese he attakes the regime not the people, and he uses words.
As one great man said the pen is Mightier then the sword.
-
Godfrey Camilleri
Oct 11th 2011, 17:09
Such antics as Mr Cauchi is here promulgating are not conducive to floating voters to be convinced that they can trust the PL with their vote!
Michael Magri
Oct 11th 2011, 17:52
Sur Godfrey.. I can assure you that floating voters know exactly what they want / and don`t want to see in this Country, as come next general election, they will surely make their presence felt....!!
For example.. They want our national broadcasting to be ABLE to be balanced and newtral... Tipo BBC of London. They want to have all broadcasters to administer Political Impartiality.. They want to see that the state funding of TVM does not go into the hands and pockets of broadcasters, producers / presenters and top management individuals with a HIDDEN Agenda.. They also do not want to see and, or hear, party political arrogance galore.. and so on and so forth......
That`s exactly what they want Mr. Camilleri..
John Mifsud
Oct 11th 2011, 17:58
The floating voter is made up of a better and different stuff than to what you are tying to insinuate. This is the 21st century Mr Camilleri. Zmien il-babaw ilu li spicca, nispera li indunajt........
Today's floating voter and the electorate in general, can very well read between the lines. The floating voter has learned many lessons, to his/her expense.
I am sure that what I'm writing will be reflected in the next general election.
G Schembri
Oct 11th 2011, 18:32
Mr Camilleri the floating voters will vote AD or PL. Now both AD and PL are after the PN voters - those who have had enough of this Regime and its subtle manouvers. Next time round PN will lose many voters, the question is which party will get them AD or PL. Will we have a PL government or a coalition between AD and one of the major parties?
Mr Joseph Fava
Oct 11th 2011, 19:28
Such a bleeding heart for the good of the PL. Don't worry the utility bills, GonziPN's arrogance, his self-given pay hike of 500 euro a week have already convinced the folating voters where their interests lie. Don't cry for us dear Godfrey. Cry for your disintegrating party.
Mr Joseph Azzopardi
Oct 11th 2011, 17:03
Dik il-liberta li semmew tal-PL wara l-outburst ta' l-istudenta fl-universita ?
Mr Paul Micallef
Oct 11th 2011, 17:07
DIK MHUX PL IMMA PN, and by the way, daqs kheem u passtas A.G ha naqra doza mil medicina tighu stess.
Mr Hans Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 16:57
Il-maskla tal-paladini ta' l-imparzjalita' qed taqa' bicciet.
j brincat
Oct 11th 2011, 16:51
@Christian Ellul
"so we are now in a state where a PBS presenter CANNOT say publicly his voting intentions???? Are we serious??"
What you may have purposely forgotten is the fact that PBS is financed through our taxes!
(jb)
silvio loporto
Oct 11th 2011, 17:52
You might be right ,all PBB presenters have the right to say publicly their voting itentions,BUT NOT WHEN THEY ARE BEING PAID BY All OF US.
If they want they can go and say what they want on the other two Political stations,but not on TVM.which is a national station not a political one.
Mr Joseph Calleja
Oct 11th 2011, 18:36
Thank you Mr Loporto.
@Mr Brincat. "the fact that PBS is financed through our taxes!" Good one. It is not paid for by any political party but paid for by by the PN , PL and independent voter Tax Payer. Get it? Focus Mr Brincat. There is a lot wrong when a PBS presenter expresses his personal political opinion when this station is financed by the Tax Payer.
Mr Joseph Calleja
Oct 11th 2011, 16:47
One question. Why are these shows allowed on Public TV in the first place? These shows are profitable organizations. Since they are on Public TV they have and must remain neutral but this is Malta, there is no such thing. Why is the general public, Tax Payer sponsoring such shows? If there is any preferences that promote certain political parties, then the show is breaking the airwave laws. Public TV is and must remain a Neutral TV.
Mr Victor Laiviera
Oct 11th 2011, 16:45
There is the letter of the law and then there is the spirit of the law. The second is definitly being breached.
Even if the BA cannot enforce proper conduct by PBS, it can certainly use its moral authority to show that the situation is not acceptable in a democratic country.
Mr Joseph Aquilina
Oct 11th 2011, 16:42
The Broadcasting Authority should have long ago woke up and shut down TV stations like NetTV and OneTV which propaganda efforts makes Nazi propaganda look like nothing. I mean; you watch OneNews and you start wonder if you're in hell, then go on NetNews, and up in heaven we all go!! It is obvious that no one at One and Net know what journalisim is about, they know the meaning of licking, humilation, and stupidity beyond every human known limit, but not the meaning of journalisim and as such The Broadcasting Authority should take actions against these TV stations, close them, and hope something better comes along!!
Joe Camilleri
Oct 11th 2011, 17:11
The situation at these two stations is more or less as you describe it. It's a pity that both parties are wasting their resources on fruitless propaganda.
Christian Ellul
Oct 11th 2011, 16:38
so we are now in a state where a PBS presenter CANNOT say publicly his voting intentions???? Are we serious??
Not so much for a FREE country were everyone can advocate his opinion!!!
Mr Victor Laiviera
Oct 11th 2011, 16:46
Not while he or she is being paid from PUBLIC FUNDS to present balanced current affairs programs, no.
Mr Rodnick Abdilla
Oct 11th 2011, 16:47
u zgur li le jekk qed tghamel programmi politici li tista tinfluwenza bil pozizzjoni tieghek ,la hemm regola dwara
Ray Gatt
Oct 11th 2011, 19:39
@ Victor Laiviera - and in the 70ies and 80ies, was it not the public funds who paid? Where were you then?
What about a level playing field then? Remember in those days we had one TV station, the public one Has Gino Cauchi forgotten how things were done in those days. If there's any bias today, which there is not, then what did we have then. Do these gentlemen remember that the leader of the opposition's name, Dr. Eddie Fenech Adami was not to be mentioned on TV or radio.
Kendrick Bondin
Oct 11th 2011, 16:34
If only the board of the Broadcasting Authority was formed by other members; members from NGOs or any other group that isn't political. I think if we had such members having a neutral television station would be possible.
Mr Lawrence Fenech
Oct 11th 2011, 16:33
Is-soltu, froga tal-PN u jzeffnu il-PL.
Mr Paul Micallef
Oct 11th 2011, 16:33
It was about time that the PL made its voice heard against the continuous bias by PBS. Those who make reference to what happened during the PL in government will not score points because two wrongs do not make a right. Moreover, when people voted for change they wanted change even in public broadcasting and not more of the same. Political bias in favour of the party in government is taking place on all of PBS news, current affairs and even morning programmes on both radio and TV. Hopefully the BA will take action to ensure impartiality in public broadcasting especially in the run up to the elections.
Ms D Galea
Oct 11th 2011, 16:30
Is the PL taking up arms against the same person, ie Mr Peppi Azzopardi, who they themselves appointed on their ethics board not so long ago when the new leader Dr .Joseph Muscat took over the said PL?
Mr Victor Laiviera
Oct 11th 2011, 16:48
Yes, Ms Galea - sometimes one can be too trusting. After all, Jesus chose Judas as one of his disciples.
Mark Piscopo
Oct 11th 2011, 16:28
Xarabank presenter Peppi Azzopardi has admitted coaching Nationalist MP Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando in how to face former Labour leader Alfred Sant during the 2008 election’s BA press conference!!! Hope now that the Broadcasting Authority will do their obigation and follow the law. "The legislation states that those known to the public primarily as presenters of current affairs programmes on PBS must be seen to be impartial. “It is important that no off-air activity, including writing, the giving of interviews or the making of speeches, leads to any doubt about their objectivity on-air. If such presenters or reporters publicly express personal views off-air on controversial issues, then their on-air role may be severely compromised!!
David Cutajar
Oct 11th 2011, 16:27
Inkredibbli! Mid-Deputati kollha tal-Lejber, min jitkaza b'Peppi.... is-Sur Gino Cauchi li kien propogandist Laburista fuq Xandir Malta fi zmien meta isem Eddie Fenech Adami ma setax jissemma fuq struzzjonijiet tal-ex Kap tal-Ahbarijiet ta' Xandir Malta, Charles Flores. Kemm hawn min jinsa malajr! Gino ahjar joqghod attent mill-kunflitt ta' interess li ghandu bil-kariga li qed jassumi fi hdan il-Partit Laburista milli jipprova jiehu ftit propoganda minn fuq l-ex post tax-xoghol tieghu! Qed inxomm li l-Lejber se jerga jaghmel bawxata ala Alfred Sant u jattakka lil WE biex minghalih jirbah ftit voti....kemm sejjer zball!
Mr ALBERT FENECH
Oct 11th 2011, 17:13
Mr Cutajar - why are you surprised? Perhaps you are too young, or maybe just not old enough to remember that in the 1950s a leading Maltese newspaper had instructions from its owner/s NOT to mention Dom Mintoff by name but merely to refer to him as the Leader of the MLP. On the counter-balance, the names of Dr Giorgio Borg Olivier and Archbishop Gonzi were ALWAYS to be given great prominence. This was a time when there was no radio (except the BBC World Service) and no television because they had not yet appeared in Malta. What goes round comes around. Unfortunately some people only remember the history that is convenient for them to remember.
ALBERT FENECH
Qawra
Andrew Azzopardi
Oct 11th 2011, 16:23
I have my own take on this one: http://andrewazzopardi.wordpress.com/2011/10/11/ok-now-lets-lynch-peppi/
Charles J. Buttigieg
Oct 11th 2011, 17:02
Andrew, I read your lauding bit in your blog just now and I would not deny that Peppi Azzopardi has his strong virtues too, after all we all have our strengths and weaknesses, however our weaknesses can’t be justified by our strengths. Without by all means draw parallels, I ask you- are you aware that Al Capone, the infamous American Gangster was also a very kind hearted and a very generous person when it came to charitable help to the sick and the poor? But was that a justification for killing the police and his opposing gangsters?
Joseph Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 16:21
is sabiha hi li l apologisti tal PN tahsbu li l passat hazin tal PL jigustifika il hazin li jsir issa. veru bla sens!
Mr Anthony Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 17:35
A comment with a lot of sense Mr.Borg!
In my eyes, the PN is more guilty than the MLP! At least, you knew where you stood with the latter.
With the PN of today, they pose as the protectors of righteousness and integrity, but they too are rotten, through and through.
This is the perception that seeps down to the roots.
Come election time and you will hear the discordant note of how we must be nearer to our people.
Philip Hili
Oct 11th 2011, 16:20
@ Fenech MD
Veru lima kienx ghadu hare ghall-politika, imma nahsbe li L-QALB HEMM KIENET!!!!!!
Lucienne Camilleri
Oct 11th 2011, 16:19
Insewh iz-zmien meta jekk tkun nazzjonalist mghandekx cans li tidher fuq Xandir Malta? Qisna issa ezatt!!!
L. Camilleri
Mr Rodnick Abdilla
Oct 11th 2011, 16:35
ghallura jekk qabel sar hazin nirepetuh ? dak li kin hazin ghandu jigi kundanat mhux imsahhah
Mr Paul Micallef
Oct 11th 2011, 17:09
MONKEY SEE MONKEY DO?????
john muscat
Oct 11th 2011, 17:21
Insejtu iz-zmien meta jekk tkun laburist ikollok salib ahmar ma ismek u ma ssibx job? Jew il- gurament falz ta Terinu?
jesmond zammit
Oct 11th 2011, 16:19
stazzjon nazzjonali mahtuf mill pn .
Christian Ellul
Oct 11th 2011, 16:40
jien nahseb bqajt f' 80's int. Nemmen li kulhadd ghandu dritt jghid li jrid dament li ma jwegga lil hadt. F' zmien il-Labour mhux talli ma stajt tghid xejn, imma isem il-Kap tal-PN ma' setax jixxandar fuq Xandir Malta. Messkom jisthu!
jesmond zammit
Oct 11th 2011, 17:55
nahseb int insejt kemm newwahtu fit 80 ijiet .
Mr ALBERT FENECH
Oct 11th 2011, 16:16
Hey, don't hold your breath anybody because there will not be any reaction from the Broadcasting Authority to these demands. As I write, cloaked figures are huddling behind closed doors trying to spin up a battery of excuses to deny what everybody has seen and heard with their own eyes for years and years. Expect a battery of foddilised blog riposts harking back to 30 years and what used to happen in 1981. These dinosaurs will try to maintain that what happened in 1981 etc is still applicable today because 2011 has never really materialised for them.
ALBERT FENECH
Qawra
Mr Steve Zammit
Oct 11th 2011, 16:15
"Mr Cauchi said Mr Azzopardi, through his coaching, had participated in the electoral campaign of the Nationalist Party in a decisive stage of the campaign".
So Gino is saying that Peppi should stop working during elections.....iddahhaknix Gino....!!!! Find something better to entertain you!!
Mr Ivan Cutajar
Oct 11th 2011, 18:08
Mr. Steve Zammit it you how should not make us laugh and find something better to entertain yourself !! This show how the PBS was and is running under the PN. When Alfred Sant fell to the provocation which was organised by the PN and with the corroboration of the PBS. You can ask if they will tell you the true people who worked in the PBS station in a very good position.
Christina Pace
Oct 11th 2011, 16:15
Ever heard of buplic relations consultance PL? That's all Peppi did.
As for Lou Bondi...does PL expect all those presenting on TVM to be floaters? Just because one doesn't broadcast their political view doesn't mean they don't have one, and a strong one at that. Or is the sum offence because no one came out and said they will have no hesitation voting PL come next election? We wonder
John Borg
Oct 11th 2011, 16:15
The problem with labour is the truth. If you are on the side of labour, you can say what you like. if you are not on labour's side, you either say what they want you to say or they will try to shut you up. Labour are against Peppi and Lou because they have a following and One news have a dismal audience at that time. This is not about politics but about loss of audiences and revenue from advertising.
Of all people Gino Cauchi, a firmer PBS journalist who was active at a time we'd rather forget, speaks about broadcasting. New labour my left foot!
Mark Anthony Vassallo
Oct 11th 2011, 16:33
Issa lqat il-musmar fuq rasu. Minn tant nies Gino Cauchi gie jitkellem fuq l-imparzjalita tax-xandir. Il-vera ghandu memorja qasira biex nesa zmienu
john muscat
Oct 11th 2011, 17:07
So, are we going back 20 years,Mr. Borg? Live the present or are we doing the same as it was way back? One bad thing does not justify another, and PBS is paid from PN and PL supporters taxes, therefore it should not be one sided .
Mr D Galea
Oct 11th 2011, 16:08
Mela Gino Cauchi nesieh żmienhom, iż-żmien meta tiftaħ l-istazzjoni nazzjonali u ssib ma' wiċċek l-arma tal-partit? Issa qed titkaża Sur Cauchi?
Kendrick Bondin
Oct 11th 2011, 16:32
Allura ghandna nibqaw hekk? Minghajr stazzjon li jkun newtrali?!
Mr Rodnick Abdilla
Oct 11th 2011, 16:41
so jekk sar zball nigustifikawh b iehor ?
Mr Victor Laiviera
Oct 11th 2011, 16:50
Ms Galea taf fejn qegħdin il-persuni responsabbli minn dik l-arma tal-partit? Mur fittixhom Herbert Ganado Street, mhux Mile End Street.
Daniel Felice
Oct 11th 2011, 16:03
http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20081101/local/code-of-ethics-for-labour-s-media-presented-to-joseph-muscat.231391
Mr Victor Laiviera
Oct 11th 2011, 16:51
Jesus chose Judas as one of his disciples.
Mr Joe Micallef
Oct 11th 2011, 15:55
Apart from any other debatable issues. such a press release coming from Gino Cauchi must qualify as the best form of hypocrisy!
A case study indeed, that is, Mr.Cauchi.
Matthew Galea
Oct 11th 2011, 15:49
During this morning's program of TVAM were Mr. Azzopardi was called in line with the allegations about JPO, Peppi admitted that he had also coached labour party figures as they had requested. So throw such accusations at a person who does his job in which he is professional about....
FRANS H SAID
Oct 11th 2011, 16:09
Two wrongs do not make a right. He should never have been involved in politics. Now when people view "xarabank" they will know that they are being taken for a ride.
Philip Hili
Oct 11th 2011, 16:18
@ Frans H Said
Therefore stop watching this soap-opera in order not to be taken for a ride.
Mr Henry Spiteri
Oct 11th 2011, 16:21
@ FRANS H SAID
PL Leader Joseph Muscat invited Peppi Azzopardi to participate in an Ethics Commitee for the PL media.
Mr Andrew Cauchi
Oct 11th 2011, 16:32
@FRANS H SAID
When you go on a Xarabank you demand to be taken for a ride.
Mr Joe Micallef
Oct 11th 2011, 17:09
Henry, in fact I have feeling that is why Joey did nothing with the findings? Not only he went the exact opposite way and reached new abysmal lows. He must have thought that the findings where a PN booby trap.
Henry S. Pace
Oct 11th 2011, 15:47
'Whoever has no sin throws the stone'
Once their respective proffession is Public Speaking there is nothing wrong to train others in public speaking. Once they get paid for it. I am sure that they got well paid for it. After all it is their living income.
So What Hon Cauchi -- 'O tempora O mores. (those where the manners and the times)
FRANS H SAID
Oct 11th 2011, 15:44
You must be kidding. WE and the whole clan are untouchable!
Period!
A Cuschieri
Oct 11th 2011, 15:40
Ma qalahhiex meta kien jaqra l-ahbarijiet din Gino Cauchi?
Fenech MD
Oct 11th 2011, 16:11
Meta Mr Cauchi kien jaqra l-ahbarijiet ma kienx ghadu hareg ghall-politika.
Philip Hili
Oct 11th 2011, 16:16
@ Gino Cauchi
Imbierka s-Sapjienza t'Alla!!!. Issa stembah dan? Fejn kien meta kien impjegat ta' Xandir Malta li wara ftit kellu jibdel ismu u jibda' jissejjah "Dardir Malta". Kien f'sensieh dan jew? Nesa' il-hnizrijiet li kienu jsiru fuq ix-xandir ta' l-istat meta hu kien impjegat ta' dan l-istazzjoni. Nesa s-Sur Cauchi meta isem l-Ecc. Tieghu Dr. Fenech Adami ma kienx jissemma fuq ordni tal-PL'? Nesa meta siehu, Jason Micallef kien ukoll impjegat tax-xandir u kien itella' programm dawr il-granet importanti ta' ma tul is-sena pero' meta kien jasal ghal 21ta' Settembru, is-sur Micallef taqbdu "id-dimensja" u jinsa li fil-21ta' Settembru ta' kull sena jigi ccelebrat jum l-Indipendenza pero' dik id-data ma kieitx tissemma, tinqabez. Qieghed insemmi din ghax kont insegwi dak il-programm.
Gino, nahseb jekk qabel tparla ghal gallarija biex forsi darb'ohra takkwista siggu iehor fil-parlament, taqta' figura ahjar.
A Cuschieri
Oct 11th 2011, 16:47
@ Fenech MD
Informa ruhek qabel tasal ghal konkluzjonijiet.
Gino Cauchi dahal mal-ONE Productions fit-2000. Qabel dan kien mal-Broadcasting Authority sa fejn naf jien. Minn 1995 san-1998 kien Sindku ta' Pembroke.
Rodrick Grech
Oct 11th 2011, 16:48
@ Philip Hili
Jien ma nafx kif tipretendu li xi darba nigu il quddiem fdan il-pajjiz meta minflok tghidu iva dan il-bnidem ghandu ragun, le nipprovaw naraw xha nsibu fuq dan il-bnidem, biex inehhu l-attenzjoni fuq li qal hu (tajjeb kemm hu tajjeb). Gara x gara fil-passat, illum qedghin 2011 u dalwaqt jekk alla jrid dehlin 2012 u jekk ha nibqaw nahdmu bil mentalita li ghax qabel gara hekk minn partit A allura partit B mghandomx jitkellmu u vici versa, mela allura missna ma nghamlu xejn qatt u noqghodu niggildu l-hin kollhu. Bhal meta jkun hemm problema bejn koppja mizzewga u biex kulhadd jghatti tieghu jibqaw jaraw xi jkun ghamel l-persuna lohra fil passat, hekk vera nimxu l'quddiem.
Ejja nqumu mi raqda l-ahwa ghax matul iz-zminiejiet iz-zewg partiti kellhom taghhom il-labour mod, u l-pn u l-hbieb tal-knisja mod iehor. Ghaldaqstant biex nimxu l quddiem mghandniex triq ohra hlief nippruvaw nirrangaw dak li hu hazin mhux billi naraw xha naqilaw mill-hama.
Gino u nies b vizjoni bhal tieghu ghandna bzonnom fi zewg partiti forsi xi darba nieqfu nitkellmu l-politika ta zmien in-nanniet u l-buznanniet u kulhadd jahdem bl-ghan wihed li nmexxu dan il-pajjiz l quddiem. Sinjal tajjeb hu li in-nies godda fi zewg partiti diga qed jghamlu dawn l-affarijiet u iktar kemm ma nibnu politika fuq xha nghamlu ghada milla xgara mis-sittinijiet sal-llum iktar nkomplu nigu l quddiem. Dawn l-affarijiet li l-partiti ta Malta qishom 2 timijiet kbar tal-futbol u kulhadd johrog it-tazzi u jahbi ir-relegations iridu jispiccaw, u la mghandniex iktar timiejiet, ejjew almenu nahdmu ilkoll biex l-ahjar team hu min hu jirbah it-tazza li jmiss, u jgawdi pajjizna.
Philip Hili
Oct 12th 2011, 00:44
@ Rodrick Grech
Rodrick, jaqaw inti iehor li meta tisma' l-passat moqziez tax-xandir taht gvern Laborista titwerwer?
Jekk kont twelidt:-,
tiftakar xandir malta, mhasses mis-suldati?,
tiftakar li kul fil-ghodu l-istazzjon jiftah bl-arma tal-PL b'akkumpanjament ta' "in-nazzjonalisti kollha fniek"?
tiftakar li isem Dr. Eddie Fenech Adami ma setax jissema b'ordni tal-PL?
tiftakar l-insluti li t-telespettaturi nazzjonalisti kienu jaqilghu?
tiftakar rappurtagg kontroversjali bhal meta waqt il-hruq tat-Times, l-istazzjon xandar ahbar li ma kienetx
minna - li kienet li n-nazzjonalisti kienu qeghdin jahirqu il-kazin laborista ta' Birkirkara?
Jekk ma tiftakarx dan, ghalxejn tparla u tilghabha ta' xi qaddis!!
Rodrick Grech
Oct 13th 2011, 09:01
@ Philip Hili
Mhux kull partit ghamel affarijiet li mghandux ghalfejn jkun kburi bijom habib? Jien li qed nsaqsik ghalxiex tahsbu li ghax fil passat saru affarijiet hziena allura illum u ghada ghandna nibqaw nigustifikaw affarijiet hziena?
Le ma tghamilx sens siehbi, qed nghixu illum u illum iridu nirispettaw lil kull min qieghed hemm fil-parlament jahdem biex jbiddel il-present u l-futur ta wliedna. Il-hazin nuzawh biex nitghallmu minnu u ma jirrepetix ruhu iva, imma nuzawh targa kontra min qed jigbed l-attenzjoni fuq xi haga hazina le.
Nawgura li jkollna hafna aktar nies/politikanti b'vizjoni moderna bhal ta Gino fi zewg partiti.
Please choose the reason of your report below: