Advert

JPO, Caruana Galizia, make counter-claims in court confrontation

JPO says he was 'coached' by Peppi Azzopardi

Nationalist MP Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando said in court today that (Xarabank presenter) Peppi Azzopardi had coached him prior to his participation as a journalist in a televised press conference given by Alfred Sant in the run-up to the 2008 general election.

Dr Pullicino Orlando was replying to questions by defence counsel Toni Abela in a libel case instituted by Richard Cachia Caruana against MediaToday managing editor Saviour Balzan.

Pullicino Orlando last week admitted in a media interview that he was coached by the PN about how to react to Sant's accusations over his plans to set up an open-air disco at Mistra Bay.

Dr Pullicino Orlando said he was not told what to say, but how to tell the truth. He had also followed the instructions given to him by (then) General Secretary Joe Saliba and Cachia Caruana to the letter, because he had the party's interest at heart.

In his evidence, Pullicino Orlando said that he spoke to Caruana Galizia and had also been approached by Vanessa MacDonld over the Mistra case. The latter told him she had been asked by MPs from both sides to attack him but she did not give any names. This was said in the presence of other persons.

Caruana  Galizia had told him after the elections she had been approached by PN officials to attack him on this issue.

Pullicino Orlando said there had been a drive by some people to make it seem like he had  lied to the prime minister, and to make him resign, but he had never lied, and the prime minister had confirmed this.

Caruana Galizia had supported him at first, and he had shown his appreciation. Recently she seemed to have changed her mind about him.

Pullicino Orlando said that in a private conversation, Caruana Galizia admitted to him that it was Cachia Caruana who had asked her to attack him.

He knew that Cachia Caruana and Caruana Galizia were friends, and therefore, when she had backed him initially on Mistra, he thought that Cachia Caruana was also backing him.

Today, Pullicino Orlando said, there was mutual respect between him and Cachia Caruana.

On the coaching he was given prior to the televised press conference, Dr Pullicino Orlando said he was not told what to say, but how to tell the truth. He had followed the instructions given to him by (then) General Secretary Joe Saliba and Cachia Caruana to the letter, because he had the party's interest at heart.

CARUANA GALIZIA DENIAL

Daphne Caruana Galizia in a confrontation with Pullicino Orlando, denied that Cachia Caruana or MPs had asked her to attack him.

She said she had insisted on defending Pullicino Orlando after the elections amid calls for his resignations.

Nobody told her what to write, Mrs Caruana Galizia said.

Had Cachia Caruana pressured her to attack Pullicino Orlando, she would surely not have told Pullicino Orlando about it.

Caruana Galizia said she used to believe Pullicino Orlando. But  JPO had lied to her and lied to the prime minister and now she did not speak to him any more. Pullicino Orlando had created a victim scenario through MaltaToday and the Labour Party and had created problems for the PN.

Reacting, Pullicino Orlando said he never trapped the PN or anyone and he had won the election for the PN 2008. He said he stood by his comments about what Caruana Galizia told him. During a phone call Caruana Galizia told him the shocking news and told him she would deny it if he ever spoke about it.

Advert

115 Comments

Post comment

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Philip Hili

Oct 11th 2011, 11:42

@ Daniel Dimech

Daniel, if Dr. Sant "was so Right", why didn't he called his bluff and stayed there to answer the questions which this person was going to make in front of the camera?

George Azzopardi

Oct 12th 2011, 11:49

@Mr.Hili .. as usual, you're so blue minded that you seem to forgot what actually happened later on when Mr.Sant confronted Dr.Gonzi .. and keep racing on .. you're better off in the racing track . so hold your horses ;).

Answer to your question is very simple. Mr.Sant did not want to confront JPO at the time because it was not the right place and time. Dr.Sant was wise enough not to fall to PN strategy of the usual provocation tactics. On the contrary Dr.Sant wanted to reveal thinks later on when things were appropriate, as it did happen!

Paul Micallef

Oct 11th 2011, 09:03

Imma biex jigi avzat u jintuza mill PN biex irebbhu elezzjoni mitlufa mhux hazin ghalik milli jidher sur Zammit. Milli jidher kellu ragun Alfred Sant, bhal ma kellu ragun f' hafna affarijiet ohra!

Antoine Zammit

Oct 11th 2011, 11:59

@ Mr. Paul Micallef,


Nista nassigurak Sur. Micallef, li daqsek kont dizappuntat dakinhar li l-elezzjoni ntilfet għal-nitfa. U daqshek nixtieq nara bidla. But at what cost. Partit qaħħabnieh! Tlifna ruħna u naċċettaw ir-renegades tan-naħa l-oħra... Le le, jien għad għandi prinċipju u għad għandi unur. U kieku jkolli ngħid li jien Laburist, ngħidha b'wiċċi lejn l-art bħalissa għax tal-mistħija.


Rigward Peppi. Jien tajtu tgħajjira hawn, u mhux talli ma kellix tweġiba. Talli t-ToM stess iċċensurawni.. għax is-Sur Azzopardi sagru sar! Aħjar imur jagħmel eżami tal-kuxjenza dak.


One last phrase.. BOYCOTT XARABANK, BOYCOTT WHERE'S EVERYBODY & BOYCOTT THE COMPANIES WHICH ADVERTISE.. to ALL NATIONALISTS AND LABOURITES.

George Azzopardi

Oct 12th 2011, 13:57

Antoine Zammit .. ma jitaghlem qatt. Hawn Malta, jekk inti tghid kontra partit ghalura bil-fors li int ma nahha l-ohra .. tghid x'tghid hadd mhu se jemnek gbin!! .. :)

Francis Attard

Oct 11th 2011, 20:18

Mr Mallia, is the building of a disco at Mistra illegal?

George Azzopardi

Oct 12th 2011, 12:31

@Francis Attard
I applied to close off one of the balconies of my appartment in a very commercial street and this was refused by MEPA!! Similar balconies have been closed off a coupl od blocks off!!

The area involved in this case was a Euro 2000 protected zone!!! Does this sound legal to you? Of course knowing the right persons and being one of the 'Hbieb tal-Hbieb' everything becomess legal!!

Paul Giordimaina

Oct 11th 2011, 09:01

Iz zejt illu li tela F wicc l-ilma Joseph minn meta il poplu ma riedkomx iktar.

Ms Rudi Mcbeal

Oct 10th 2011, 21:05

I don't think they do actually, Mr Borg. They're just seeing him and his outbursts as a ray of hope which may be beneficial (they think) to win the PL the next elections.

Noel Mifsud

Oct 10th 2011, 23:27

jien ili li ghamiltlu boycott, ghax naf li il prezentatur mhux indipendenti, u iz zejt jitla f wicc l ilma. INsomma ghalhekk dejjem imorru tjb hux ghax hbieb ta hbieb. Issa naraw id dokumentarji li se jamlu fuq l isptar jekk hux b kumbiunazzjoni jirbhu l kuntratt il WE. thx

j brincat

Oct 10th 2011, 19:22

Yeah - that would be very interesting!

(jb)

M. Borg

Oct 10th 2011, 23:28

hahaha!

Tony Borg

Oct 10th 2011, 18:20

"Why are Labour so annoyed that JPO was coached to tell the truth?"

It seems that within Gonzipn truth is a scarce "commodity" so much so that people have to be coached to say the truth.

Mr John Borg....truth should come naturally and no coaching is necessary.

John Borg

Oct 10th 2011, 18:03

Qed titkellem mill-esperjenza donnok Bert!

David Magro

Oct 10th 2011, 18:31

Le Dear Henry Pace....iz-zejt tiela f`wicc l-ilma u s-sewwa qed iwwegga n-nies. Jekk ghandhom il-hila il-PN ikeccuh lil JPO jew jissospenduh kif il-Labour ghamel lil Lorry Sant u Wenzu Mintoff....don`t tell me you don`t remember.

Mr Stephen Borg

Oct 10th 2011, 23:06

Henry Pace.

I am amazed that in 2011 there are still people with your same reasoning. At this point I would rather believe Jeffery Pullicino Orlando rather then believing the other side of the coin because we all know how the people on the other side of the coin are glued to the political term of Power. Unfortunately the Nationalist party has become a broken family for those who really adhere to true Nationalist believes.

Noel Mifsud

Oct 10th 2011, 23:30

IMissu ha l parir tieghek JPO u ivvota kontra l power station, iz zieda tal 500 euro u konna nehilsu minn dal gvern bla sinsla

Philip Hili

Oct 10th 2011, 23:52

@ David Magro

David, trid iddahhaq? Meta gie sospiz Lorry Sant? Forsi Wenzu Mintoff biex ma jikxifx xi ritratti li kienu qeghdin jghidu li ghandu Lorry Sant, jew kif kienet imhawda l-borma. Imma Lorry Sant ma giex sospiz. Il-PN ikkeccieh biex jaghmluh aktar vittma milli qieghed jilghabha!!
Kieku kont inkeccieh hekk kif beda jibbuzullottja mhux issa, wara li ghamel mill-partit kummidja.

Mr Victor Laiviera

Oct 10th 2011, 17:45

Naturally, you take what they say as Gospel Truth, right?

Maria Cassar

Oct 10th 2011, 18:15

Their analysis was spot on. The PN won the election and the JPO episode left the PN with a reduced majority.

Do you have any proof to the contrary?

Mr Victor Laiviera

Oct 10th 2011, 20:24

@ M Maria Cassar

Analysis after the event is ALWAYS spot-on.. It's called hindsight. Or, as we say in Maltese "wara kulħadd bravu".

A Dimech

Oct 10th 2011, 21:28

Nobody could predict an election so close. it was up in the air until the very last minute.

Mr Angus Black

Oct 11th 2011, 00:24

Mr Laiviera, Cachia Caruana and Lawrence Zammit's calculation was much more accurate than Jason Micallef's prediction of the MLP winning by 12,000 vote majority.

We rather take Cachia Caruana's statements as Gospel Truth than take any Labour Party spokesperson's since their statements are always either unfounded allegations or downright lies.

David Magro

Oct 10th 2011, 18:33

Joseph...its now black on white....Peppi cannot be trusted and his programs are to censoured just like the PN used to do in the 80`s to program on Xandir Malta...Peppi has a political agenda together with his dear friend the cousin of Wenzu Gatt...Mr.No Problem....Mr.Lou Bonit

Wilfred Camilleri

Oct 10th 2011, 19:10

Don't kid yourself M. Borg. Back stabbing happen in every party and in every country. It's part of politics. It's not the forte of any particular party. If you believe otherwise, you either don't understand politics or you are so partisan that you actually believe such nonsense.

Roderick Camilleri

Oct 10th 2011, 16:48

We will get a denial as early as tonight on PBS, where we will get a full twisting story. Who is managing our country? haha, someone who lives in the silent city......

Mr Angus Black

Oct 10th 2011, 20:55

What's the title of your next tale Charles?

May I suggest 'Wishful thinking' or perhaps 'Hallucinations"?

R. Gauci

Oct 10th 2011, 16:32

Sur Borg (suppost) il-fatt li marru ghand bniedem bhal Peppi ghal parir f'mument hekk delikat ghall-pajjiz diga hi prova bizzejjed li hu bniedem ta` fiducja tal-PN u nieqaf hemm, ghandu kull dritt imma ghala din il-qdusija u tmashin meta jghidulu li hu jahdem ghal-PN??. Fuq Bondi, Daphne, RCC u bella kumpanijja hadd ma jista jghid xejn ghax huma Nazzjonalisti, anzi anti-PL, iddikjarati.

Mr Marcel Dingli

Oct 10th 2011, 16:49

Sur Gauci, il veri Nazzjonalisti gew eziljati, ghalkemm hemm min li internament hu favur l eziljati u ghadu jzomm il principji fondamentali ( dawk li ffirmajna ghalihom meta dhalna tesserati) bhala sagrosanti. Li huma anti PL huwa veru, imma min hu verament Nazzjonalist tal konvizjoni u l principju, ma hu anti hadd li jista jservi ta gid ghal Patria u l poplu Malti, inkluz il partit laburista. Dejjem ghidtha jien, li jien Nazzjonalist ta konvinzjoni mhux moghza tal partit. Min hu bhali ma jistghax jivvota pn qabel ma jerga il partit isib ruhu.

Mr Jeremy J Camilleri

Oct 10th 2011, 17:14

Does anyone need coaching to tell the truth?

G Schembri

Oct 10th 2011, 17:55

He was coached to say the truth and omit the bad things. Whenever I watch Xaraban and Bondi +, I realise that is what they are doing. The PN are experts at doing this, remember when balaustrates where thrown on MLP supporters in Zebbug, PN officials said that they had fallen, of course that was the truth, half the truth actually. They omitted to say that the balaustates had fallen because they were pushed. That is the type of truth JPO was trained in saying. Saying a truth and omitting the bad side of the truth.

John Borg

Oct 10th 2011, 18:03

mela nsejtu kemm beka JPO... jien qatt m'emmintu u lanqas qatt nemmnu... gab hafna nies fl-inkwiet ghalxejn, ghax ried jikri bicca art u gietu hazin...

anthony farrugia

Oct 10th 2011, 16:26

Wishful thinking. Peppi Azzopardi was selected by Joseph Muscat for Labour Etichs Committee when he was elected leader.

m. borg

Oct 10th 2011, 17:01

@anthony farrugia
That was a good move bring in Peppi so that Joseph would not be criticized that he put on LP supporters on the committee, so what's your point.

Mr L Zammit

Oct 10th 2011, 17:32

Kemm tohlom car, Silv.

Alfred Vassallo

Oct 10th 2011, 19:54

No Mr. Cauchi PN credibility is KAPUT. Finished. Annihilated.

Mr Joseph Calleja

Oct 10th 2011, 15:24

Agree

John Borg

Oct 10th 2011, 15:58

I agree, but the alternative has to be something better, not a concoction of has beens alongside power hungry non starters

R. Gauci

Oct 10th 2011, 16:14

Mr Borg, better being ruled by beginners who want to perform rather than by arrogant people who think they know it all but know nothing. The way our national media is being managed reflects the way our country is managed, power to the few and they put it in your face and you can do nothing about it, same as in 1985!!

Mr W Cassar

Oct 10th 2011, 15:55

...people in the Media especially... independent TV producers know that when they want to use PBS they have to speak to W.E. Its a known fact that Peppi gets certain privileges how else do you think he makes his money.

I for one will be glad to see the back of Bondi and Peppi once PN loses the next election!

John Vella

Oct 10th 2011, 15:26

What makes you think anyone should be impartial in any discussion? An intelligent argument require oppose views. It is stupid for a politician or a journalist to think interviews should be bias. If I was a politician I would prefer hard question and an intelligent answer. Political bias or neutrality shows inability of journalist to report and works against the person interviewed.

Mr Pat Hobson

Oct 10th 2011, 15:48

Is the sense of fair play fair enough? That's what I expect from an interviewer, something which is sorely lacking in Mr. Peppi Azzopardi. The 2008 March elections were evidence enough.

Mr Patrik Larsson

Oct 10th 2011, 14:53

I don't like to put words in your mouth, but what you seem to be saying is that Malta would be better off if TV programmes were banned and EU membership was resisted. I just want to be clear what you mean, as such thoughts seems absolutely ludicrous to me.

Mr Vincent Cassar

Oct 10th 2011, 14:47

Mhux hekk Sur Buhagiar...hekk tixtieq. Jekk JPO hu non-entity, mela min hu entity? DCG jew??

Advert
Advert