Cyprus sets sail through eye of financial storm
A minority Cypriot government must persuade a hostile opposition to approve unpopular tax hikes to close a widening budget deficit, and even then may still face the ignominy of going cap in hand to Brussels for a bailout.
As global markets panic over debt-ridden European and US economies, credit rating agencies have shown no mercy to a country that is struggling to overcome the political and financial turmoil caused by a deadly munitions blast on July 11 that wrecked economic growth prospects.
Standard & Poor's and Moody's had already downgraded Cyprus, when Fitch stepped in on Wednesday and did the same.
Fitch said Cyprus will probably be unable to meet financing requirements for the rest of this year and in early 2012, forcing it to seek a bailout.
The government argues that the austerity measures it has agreed upon will see it through this roughest of patches by reaching the EU's own fiscal deficit target next year, but doubters say the cuts aren't deep enough.
Averof Neophytou, the deputy leader of largest right-wing party, Disy, issued a statement following the Fitch blow blaming President Demetris Christofias for the country's woes.
"He has consciously chosen through the economic bankruptcy of Cyprus to obligingly lead us toward the support mechanism, destroying the economic fabric of Cyprus, which for decades has been built with the sweat and hard work of small businesses and workers."
Although Christofias has one of the toughest fights of his political career looming there are some economists who believe the fundamentals are strong.
"If you put all the indicators together Cyprus is one of the strongest performing economies in Europe; it's among the top 10. The credit agencies are using a simplistic argument with no relevance to the present situation," economist Costas Apostolides told AFP.
He said credit agencies like Fitch are driving interest rates up when they need to come down to stimulate growth.
"The Fitch narrative is wrong; there is no appreciation that the banks are strong and they did not need government assistance. This can be solved with a recovery but a recovery needs lower interest rates."
Fitch and the other ratings agencies have expressed serious concerns about the ability of Cypriot banks to withstand the pressures on their balance sheets of their heavy exposure to Greek bank debt.
Apostolides agreed the government measures were a step in the right direction but said there was nothing in the package about stimulating growth.
"It's a first step which should be encouraged even though it came late after a lot of incompetence and indecision."
The government has a minority in the 56-seat parliament, and must somehow achieve consensus, or the eurozone member is in for a very difficult ride.
Finance Minister Kikis Kazamias said Fitch's sombre outlook was "excessive" because it failed to take on board the efforts the government was taking to ensure the deficit was reduced to 2.5 percent of GDP in 2012.
The communist-led cabinet agreed to raise VAT, taxes on savings and income tax for top earners.
VAT would rise by two points to 17 percent, the tax on interest earned from bank deposits from 10 percent to 15 percent, for Cypriot residents only, and income tax from 30 percent to 35 percent for those earning more than 60,000 euros.
Instead of pay cuts, public sector unions have agreed to make a contribution from their salaries of three percent of gross income for the next three years, or more if needed.
This was presumably offered to avoid pension reform. Public sector workers contribute less and receive bigger pensions than people in the private sector.
Bit powerful trade unions warned on Wednesday that if politicians were hell-bent on attacking their rights they would strike.
The government has seemingly opted against taking the unions head on in favour of squeezing more concessions through a softly-softly approach.
It is committed to axing 5,000 jobs over the next five years, freezing new recruits and cutting overtime by 20 percent in efforts to trim the state payroll.
The minister said that without taking these proposed measures the deficit would reach closer to seven percent in 2011.
With only communist AKEL backing the government after the coalition collapsed last week, the package needs support from the opposition parties when it goes to a parliamentary vote on August 25 following a three-day debate.
And former coalition party centre-right Diko said the government had "surrendered" to powerful unions by not reforming the pension system that was draining finite public finances.
Christofias swore-in a new cabinet on Friday after a munitions blast killed 13 people and knocked out the island's biggest power plant on July 11, leading to rolling daily power cuts, economic disruption and public uproar.
Cyprus, which was already struggling to get its finances in order, was left reeling after the explosion, which all but crushed any hopes of economic growth this year.
6 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Stephen Koludrovic
Aug 11th 2011, 13:05
Crap. The Cypriots have beaten us to it.
Mark Galea
Aug 11th 2011, 12:39
We should send them Joseph from Arriva-PL - he will give them the much needed "new and efficient" method for managing a country. He used to tell us how much better the people of Cyprus live because of their government.
Mr Peter Murray
Aug 11th 2011, 10:23
Rolling daily power cuts,economic disruption and public uproar -now where I have heard that before as couldn't happen here could it??Are we next to go cap-in-hand to the EU?
Alan Cordina
Aug 11th 2011, 12:49
Mr Murray, instead of asking UNFOUNDED, and thus a stupid question, you should have, INSTEAD, wrote how incredibly proud we ALL (no politics sides) should feel, that we are, not only not going cap in hand to Brussels, but moreover, we loan money to these GIANT countries and economies, compared to our size !
Do we really never learn !!!????
Michael Seychell
Aug 11th 2011, 13:40
Mr. Murray - Yesterday you have already made a similar statement that Malta can be next in line to request a bail out. Despite this you did not succeed or dare mention one economic failure by our government, but had to mention only some power cuts, which happen from time to time in most advanced countries like Dubai as we read out today!
What you are forgetting is that the PN government has started to tighten the belt by introducing various measures and reforms even during tha previous lesitlature - a case in point was the pensions reform on which the Labour Party did not even made one suggestion when a White Paper was issued for consultation on the pension reform.
We have seen other reforms taking place including the Drydocks privatisation from where the nation saved millions in subsidies, and the transport reform which God willing will again be savings millionms to the tax payer - presumably including yourself.
Furthermore you may have not noticed, that government employment went down substantally, albeit there were additional employees in the public where it matters most, like the health and education sectors .
Despite all this, if the other countries bigger than malta not only in size, population, but also in their economy, will end up requesting bail outs, nobody should be surprised if, God forbid, Malta may arrive to that stage as well.
However if this were to happen, the reason for this will not be that our economy is not doing well at this point in time, or due to wrong decisions being taken by the PN government, but only due to the negative effects of more countries, amongst these Spain, Italy, and now even France is being mentioned, will leave on Malta's performance, epecially our production and services exports and tourism, to mention the main pillars of our economy.
Finally I do no look forward for this to happen, not even if we our country was run by a different political government, which is different from the impression you are giving me.
Michael Seychell
Tal-Pieta
Mr Peter Murray
Aug 11th 2011, 17:59
Mr Seychell,
I have no idea where you live in Malta but power cuts where I reside do not occur all the time but most of the time and in any event they occur with far too much frequent regularity here in Malta-and moreover,these power failures appear to on the increase and please don;t make futile comparisons -as with Dubai whilst the majority of the economic failures are yet to come Air Malta ,Enemalta,WSC , to name but a few and lest we forget the selling off of MID-MED,the MIA, Shipyards,Maltacom ecetera .
Dear Mr.Cordina,
You appear vexed which has prompted a dummy to be thrown from the perambulator and stupiid says as stupid does! Did we really have the money to give to Greece or did we borrow this and I maintain that given time we will be compelled to ask for a loan ?They said it could never happen to Cyprus and that the USA would never be subject to being relegated in credit ratings,and that the UK was the cradle of civilisation.Have patience and give it some time .