Ornis Committee has become a rubberstamp - BirdLife
BirdLife Malta has rebutted a government statement yesterday that its decision not to attend this week's Ornis Committee meeting ran counter to a joint statement BirdLife International had issued with the Federation of Associations for Hunting and Conservation.
The statement the government referred to had been issued on the eve of the European Court of Justice judgement in 2009 and the two organizations had said that “we will respect the ruling of the court and we call upon all parties and individuals to do the same.”
In its statement today, BirdLife said the government this month published two legal notices on spring hunting, each one day before the Ornis Committee meeting.
In both cases, the Ornis Committee was not aware that the legal notices were on the table. The legislation was presented to the Ornis Committee as a fait accompli.
This sidestepping of the committee clearly showed that the government does not wish to consult its advisory body on this matter.
The meeting last Tuesday discussed spring hunting legislation, however, since all decisions had already been taken the meeting was pointless, which was why BirdLife did not attend.
The organisation reminded the government that the ECJ ruling obliged it to ensure that the populations of the species concerned were maintained at a satisfactory level, and that this was a pre-requisite to any derogation.
The government needed to take into account the European Conservation Status prior to opening a spring hunting season, as was also expected by the Commission.
“The Ornis Committee is currently being used for nothing more than rubberstamping government’s decision to re-open the spring hunting season,” BirdLife said.
12 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
n.bugeja
Mar 31st 2011, 17:13
No doubt it will be an empty Autumn sky, I get the feeling hunters next Sept will be out shooting at birds they never saw while their books get filled by educated ghosts. It's in the bag.
Henry Fenech Azzopardi
Mar 31st 2011, 19:04
you remInd me of NOSTRADAMUS. Why did you not come up with this prophecy before the last autumn season? It would have given us an opportunity to regularise our position and maybethe figures would have been within the limits to have a maximum bag limit this spring. For your information since 2002 the autumn figures were under 5000 pieces for turtle doves and quails except 2008 where we had a surprise increase migration that reflected in the figures for quail for that particlar year only. The pattern was standard and for your information the sky was the same as it was last autumn. However, for some reason last autumn the figures showed a vast increase which is unexplainable since it was a very bad migration for both turtle doves and quails. You did not complain then, Why? Apparently now you want to imply that if the figures return to the normal pattern the hunters would have manipulated the figures. I assure you that unless we shall witness a good migration the figures are bound to go back to the normality of the previous years. If the figures were correct in 2002/3/4/5/6/7/8/9 they should be credible for 2011.
Andrew Gatt
Mar 31st 2011, 16:15
Sore losers, that's all you are. After years of crying to mummy at the EU led by your now-resigned foreign executives, instigating Court Cases against Malta in spite of pre-Accession promises and having the same court cases fail.
Now that the EU has accepted that limited Spring Hunting CAN take place (the same Spring Huning you claimed was illegal), what do you do? Sulk in a corner like spoilt babies and mumble more banalities.
C Mallia
Mar 31st 2011, 21:11
@Andrew Gatt
What is your problem? If BLM does not attend the Ornis Comittee, then FKNK and the rest can have a field day with the decisions concerning hunting and they can do what they like? right? All this hate and name calling? If BLM attends ...its one thing, if not its another? BLM can never win with you?
John Matthews
Mar 31st 2011, 15:38
@ BLM and Supporters
This has got to be the worst case of "sour grapes" I have ever experienced.
Your organisation has lost all credibility, why not just leave it at that.
M.caruana
Mar 31st 2011, 16:33
Sorry but now It's down to one bird each, not a feather more, beyond that it's game over.It dosn't get better than this.
Andrew Gatt
Mar 31st 2011, 17:03
Indeed, that one bird, M. Caruana! Because that one bird makes a mockery of all Birdlife has been saying, doing and agitating against for years. All the statements, threats, report to the EU, networking and agitation, cosying up to CABS and those infamous T-shirts..........nothing but hot air, untruths and exaggerations. All exposed for what they are by that one bird in Spring, M. Caruana. LEGALLY CAUGHT in Spring during a LEGAL SPRING HUNTING season.
Henry Fenech Azzopardi
Mar 31st 2011, 17:51
@M. Caruana This year at least we have one bird each. These last three years we had nothing and maybe next year we shall have one bird and a half. The whole concept is that SPRING HUNTING IS LEGAL contrary to what all those prominent people who wore the T SHIRTS saying illegal spring hunting. you can never understand our frustration in the past three years. The fact that we wake up early in the morning prepare some sandwiches, some broad beans and a flask of coffee together with our dog companion is already something. That one single bird is the iceing on the cake. Perhaps you will now try to understand and maybe realise what we were missing. Most of the days it is just social gathering and it could be a week before we aim at a dove or quail. Part of the excitment for instance is the sound of the shots getting closer and closer hoping that it will get close enough to aim and catch my single dove/quail. Everyone has a passtime otherwise it is not worth living. There are people who ruin the health smoking cigarettes, others drink, others playing cards and so on.
J Farrugia
Mar 31st 2011, 14:15
birdlife you have lost your case. Now be gentlemen enough to admit defeat. and if yuo truly have the birds' itnerest at heart, if you really have them at heart, you will take part in this Ornis committee and give your positive feedback. And stop all this incitement. otherwise there is only one way for you... disband and lose your foreign financing.
V Falzon
Mar 31st 2011, 15:07
"If you truly the birds' interest at heart, etc."
That's rich! If you are one of those who look at birds down the barrel of a shotgun, i suggest you do not pontificate too much about how to have birds at heart.
Disband? You wish!
Henry Fenech Azzopardi
Mar 31st 2011, 13:23
Birdlife can you tell me which one is correct, because some two days ago you called ORNIS to which I am a member, SMOKE SCREEN, now today you called it RUBBER STAMP. May I remind the public that last year the ORNIS recommended a Spring Hunting season for all hunters but the government opened a season for one week for 2500 hunters which was rejected by FKNK.
It seems that if ORNIS does not respond to BIRDLIFE propositions the Committee is not trust worthy. Birdlife had the oportunity to air their views epecially when it came to bag limits which the Autumn season has a bearing on the bag limits for Spring. The BIRDS have been very badly let down by their protest and we managed to conclude the agenda in time for the season to open.
At least confidentiality was not at risk and the recomendations put to the government are still confidential. May I remind the public that last year details of the meeting were already in the news before I reached home.
john borg
Mar 31st 2011, 13:23
and when it closed the season completely, what was ornis ...the ink pad !!!
REMEMBER that just before the ECJ decision both birdlife and fknk agreed to respect its decision. it is very little to what hunters had and were promised ...but its better than nothing.
birdlife should do the same ..looking at all the restrictions imposed i would be more than happy. IS THIS SO HARD TO ACCEPT ????