History repeats itself in Seminary case
I wish to thank Kappara Administrative Committee chairman Frank Bartolo (The Sunday Times, March 13) for writing in support of Tal-Virtù residents who objected to the expansion of the Archbishop’s Seminary.
Dr Bartolo says that when Chiswick House School in Kappara was opened in the early 1990s, it was planned to take only about 50 students, yet it was subsequently allowed to expand, and it now has over 600 students.
Today, Kappara residents face daily traffic mayhem throughout the year when students are dropped off and picked up.
Despite all the hindsight of the past 20 years, in spite of the setting up of the Malta Environment and Planning Authority, the approval of the Structure Plan and the painstaking crafting of local plans, here we are with an almost identical situation to that of Kappara.
Tal-Virtù has about 275 households, or about 600 residents. The local plan approved in 2006 classified it as a residential priority area to protect it area from excessive development. In fact, the entire Rabat area is known to be archaeologically rich and environmentally sensitive.
The existing Seminary school, which moved to Tal-Virtù in 1978, today has 260 students. Access to it is already problematic, as the only way to reach it is through Tal-Virtù and the narrow residential streets of Rabat.
For all these reasons, the local plan declared that further development within the Seminary had to be severely limited to protect the amenity of the residential priority area.
And in recent months Mepa has on several occasions turned down development applications in order to protect residential areas from over-development.
Yet it has disregarded the local plan and approved the extension of the Seminary’s floor area by 230 per cent! The school population will shoot up to 710 students, outnumbering even Tal-Virtù residents.
All this will inevitably cause traffic chaos during school opening and closing times, not only in the residential streets of Tal-Virtù and Rabat, but also in the main artery, George Borg Olivier Road, which is already narrow and has even narrower pavements, and is subject to traffic jams.
All this will affect not only residents of Tal-Virtù, but many other residents in Rabat and Dingli, as besides the Seminary, St Agatha’s College will also be expanding. One must also take into consideration Savio College in Dingli and St Angela School at Tal-Virtù and, indeed, the government schools.
In giving the schools’ expansion the green light, Mepa and the Transport Malta have shown themselves to be very insensitive to all these residents, who will have to bear the same daily brunt Kappara residents face. History repeats itself and we never seem to learn.
What will these authorities do to remedy the situation?
Will George Borg Olivier Road be made one-way once again? Will streets in Tal-Virtù be made one-way or access restricted to school transport during school opening and closing hours, enforced by wardens?
Will the country lane leading past Tal-Virtù Castle up to the Seminary from the valley below be widened to alleviate the traffic flow?
Or will a completely new road linking Francesco Azopardi Street in Tal-Virtù to the Rabat Road via pristine countryside be developed?
10 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Christopher Farrugia
Mar 20th 2011, 17:13
Dear Mr Scicluna ed al,
The number of vocations has been consistently decreasing. I cannot forsee that with this development the numbers will suddenly increase. Regardless, there certainly is enough room for them in the existing building.
Mr Abela, other options are indeed available as laid down in the educational reform plan e.g. St . Aloysius used another church school. Savio College opted for the ballot system. With the decreasing number of births being born, as rightly pointed out by Mr Dingli, there is no real need for a new development to go up in an archeologically rich and environmentally sensitive area .The decision to build up was taken quickly without all the options being thoroughly explored
The principle at stake here is that there was no thorough planning in awarding the permit, including a Traffic Impact Assessment for the area. Alot of noise is being made because it is a Church school. The objections raised were not directed because of this fact, but because of the way MEPA is handling it. This development will not effect just residents of Tal-Virtù but also the surrounding areas, and traffic to Dingli...
Mario Borg
Mar 21st 2011, 08:24
No one objected the residents there when they built huge villas with pools back in the 70s/80s. Wasn't it a sensitive archaeological area back then? At least hundreds of square metres occupied by a school is far more beneficiary than a hideous villa occupied by an eldery couple. Besides schools are present in more conjested localities and tal virtu is the ideal setting to spend one's childhood.
Joseph M. Scicluna
Mar 20th 2011, 14:06
To All:-
Are you aware that through this development, there may be more vocations for priesthood?
So the suggested problem of traffic is quite trivial compared with the dire deed for modern
priests - or your religion comes after every material problem, naive as it may be? Today I am a pensioner but was lucky enough to attend the Archbishop's Seminary (those days in Floriana) where I can boast to be brought up with good moral values and self-disciplined.
Christian Sciberras
Mar 20th 2011, 17:07
Naive?
Naive is to believe priest can manage traffic by praying to god!
Paul Abela
Mar 20th 2011, 12:41
Mr.Farrugia, we are talking here of a school.Don't your children go to school? Maybe also you send them to some expensive school. Or are you all afraid that the price of your Villas will go down because there is a school nearby? With regards to the damage to the enviornment, tell us how many cars each Villa household have or now your cars do not dirt our enviornment. Also keep in mind that the soil on which your Villas were built was all agriculture land.
G Dingli
Mar 20th 2011, 13:54
A more useful comment is that the student population has been decreasing for years because of the low birth rate. There is no need for new schools at all.
Paul Agius
Mar 23rd 2011, 12:41
Mr. Abela not all the houses are owned by old rich people, in tal-Virtu' we have 5 religious homes and that altogether they house not more then 25 nuns. As far as we know they offer no services to anybody besides themself, typical. And yes they have cars too.
Dr Clive Aquilina Spagnol
Mar 20th 2011, 10:54
....and behind this abhorrable development there is the Church....no further comment.
Joseph Calleja
Mar 20th 2011, 13:31
Let's put it this way. Mepa+government= Church. Does that explain it all? The Archbishop's Seminary will get their permit to go ahead with their addition. Why? Because the church rules the government and the government rules Mepa. OIM
Mary Camilleri
Mar 20th 2011, 09:36
iILL TELL YOU WHAT THE AUTHORITIES WILL DO. They will bury their heads in the sand and do nothing, because that is what they are best at, it costs them nothing, and after all, no election is looming on the horizon (yet) so it is not that urgent.
After all the legal and procedural hoops we have jumped through, the cranes go up, the buildings rise, and the area gets destroyed.
Full Stop!