Advert

ADZ condemns bishop's claims that teaching students about contraception was abuse

Bishop Mario Grech's recent statements that the education system may be abusing students if it teaches them about contraceptionwas astounding, Alternattiva Zghazagh said.

It said in a statement that also astounding was the claim that teaching students about contraception in secondary schools encouraged them to give in to the “culture of pleasure”.

ADZ said it supported the clear and professional position of Dr Carabott from the GU Clinic who said “The role of an education programme should be to teach students to live their sexuality in a mature way. Sexuality is more than sex. There is no harm in teaching them about contraception but students should be given all the information: how safe, how unsafe and the health hazarards.”

It said it was irresponsible of Mgr Grech to accuse teachers, presumably of biology and PSD of abusing students for educating them on the theme of contraception.

"Malta is among the countries with the highest teenage pregnancy rate. This is only one side of the coin since sexually transmitted diseases among youth are also on the rise among youths in the Malta and Gozo. Clearly young people need more education, including about to use of contraception.

"It is the responsibility of the state to include the theme of sexuality in the educative system since sexual health is part of youth development."

Moreover, ADZ's Dirk Urpani insisted, to give the impression that sex education only included information about contraceptives was unfair and misleading since currently sex education included information on contraception as well as on other themes such STDs, self-respect, and other themes related to sexuality.

"Accusing teachers of abuse shows a lack of understanding of the positive educational experience in schools around Malta and Gozo," he said.

Advert

51 Comments

Post comment

Please see our new Comments Policy

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

For more details please see our Comments Policy

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Robert Callus

Nov 6th 2010, 11:04

My friend, I'm sure some or most of your fellow students share books or (more commonly) websites where there is much more than a diagram. Unfortunately, unlike your biology textbook, those are a combination of fact and fiction. Your biology textbooks on the other hand, show you the facts, the reality. Then after being inform make your own moral decisions.

The wrong education is easily available. This includes the 'porn world' , which if we are realistic, we must admit it is very available. There are many 'untruths' in that 'world' and they can only be countered by education.

http://robertcallus.wordpress.com/2010/06/10/make-love-not-porn/

Miguel Micallef

Nov 6th 2010, 11:56

You should indicate whether you are being serious or sarcastic, because honestly, it's very difficult to tell. Your words sound crazy, but I know there's more than enough crazy people in Malta. So you might be actually speaking seriously here, in which case, all I can say is, get some help man.

Justin Tabone

Nov 6th 2010, 15:43

I am assuming that you were not disgusted by the diagram of a contraceptive, but of the male sex organ instead....

A contraceptive is just a piece of latex and is nothing to be disgusted about, least of all apply morals to it. On the other hand the Roman Catholic Church also teaches that it is beneficial for its followers to marry and have children - so when you come to this point, ask yourself - will you still remain disgusted by not the diagram, but by the real thing?

Of course, I also take into account that you are still a secondary school student and have yet to mature in some areas of thought. But please understand that the Roman Catholic Church is maintained on Earth by people (supposedly guided by God), and those people are still prone to error, so not everything it teaches is absolute truth.

Mike F Abbot

Nov 6th 2010, 18:34

"I was even more disgusted when the 2007 O Level (Biology) asked a question about contraception including DIAGRAMS. IT WAS HORRIBLE."

you were *disgusted* by a question and a picture in you're biology exam about the contraceptives?

can i suggest you get a life?

michael

Nov 7th 2010, 15:08

then take accounts and economics mate....or study religion.. see how far in life that will take you.

David Bonello

Nov 5th 2010, 19:23

Agree. I was just giving a bit of comfort for dvella, hoping that by reading my reply, he would realize how illuded one can get, when thinking someone has some divine right for the Truth, and all others are mistaken.

Zachary Stewart

Nov 5th 2010, 21:38

Contraception education ALWAYS focuses on condoms over the pill. I've never heard of such a program that only teaches the pill. Of course, you don't even address condoms as a major factor in SAFER sex, because you have an unrealistic abstinence-only agenda.

J.Tonna

Nov 5th 2010, 17:42

@ Mr Pulis & Mr Zammit - Jidher li, jiena, fhimtu hazin lis-Sur Zammit. Naqbel ma dak li ktibt int.

Meta tistudja fuq haga ma tistax thallatha ma' hag'ohra. Per ezempju 'medicina mar-religjon'. Ghandna nitkellmu fuq kollox fil-kontest tieghu.

David Bonello

Nov 5th 2010, 14:25

God's teaching, which is by the way found only in church, is authentic and at the same time so simple!! All other church denominations and religions with their multitude of different gods and scriptures are not bad in themselves, but just unauthentic or false, and a bit complicated at times. We should not condemn them though because they are still much better than those who believe nothing. But it is like there are on their way to realize one day that our God's teaching, is only found in church, and is authentic and at the same time so simple!

Silvio Zammit

Nov 5th 2010, 14:08

Prosit J.Tonna....ghidilhom kemm hu hazin ikollok naqra knowledge hux, kemm hu isbah u iktar intelligenti timxi wara min jaf imexxi....Mela ma jafux li l-isqfijiet taghna tghallmu hafna fuq il komplessita tal-hajja sesswali mis seminarju, u ahna ma tantx nafu fuq ir-religjon taghna. Jekk ma jitkellmux huma fuq l-abbuz sesswali min tridu jitkellem?!

R.Camilleri

Nov 5th 2010, 14:34

Prosit sur.Tonna ilqat il-musmar fuq rasu. Dan kif illum issib hafna jridu jithadtu fuq religjon u x'suppost tghallem il-knisja u x'naf jien. Jien taf x'taghlimt li l- hobz ghandek ittih li min jaf jieklu. Ma' jridhux dawn it-taghlin jghalmu lil isqof/ isqfijiet x'ghandhom jghidu u jghallmu hux. Mela kif qed jghidu dawn, iz-zmien li hadu fl-istudji taghhom ma' jiswa ghalxejn. Jien taf x'nahseb li hafna minn dawn tilfu t-triq tal-verita - Lill Alla s-Sid tas-Sema u l-Art u li jghtina kull tahbita tal-qalb. Kunu sinciera maghkom infuskom.

J.Tonna

Nov 5th 2010, 14:42

Mr Zammit - Qed thallat il-hass mal-basal, is-suggett tal-lum hu differenti milli qed issemmi inti.

Patrick Harvey

Nov 5th 2010, 15:01

While I respect the ideas being expressed in these blogs, may I point out that the Bishop is not the only one who studied here. In these blogs there are comments made by people who are professionals, people who work with children on a daily basis, people who deal with social problems on a daily basis as part of their jobs, people who are talking from their daily experiences of their profession.

I believe that one has to make a distinction between religious values and the common good of the country. Let's face the facts: not everyone in Malta is a fervent catholic and thus a good part of the population will disregard the Bishop's argument. I am in favour that the church teaches moral values to society about sex and contraception, but then let the individuals choose their faith.

Let's be honest with ourselves... facts show that teenage pregnancy is on the rise and it is in the COMMON GOOD of the country that young persons are educated about their bodies! Hopefully in the long run we taxpayers will have less single mothers to maintain through social benefits!!!

Silvio Zammit

Nov 5th 2010, 15:10

U zgur....qatt mhu il mument it-tajjeb li nitkellmu fuq hekk hux. Ma jogobniex dak id-diskors!

Charlene Giordimaina

Nov 7th 2010, 12:46

Proset J.Tonna! Naqbel mieghek perfettament. Kemm sirna nisimghu bihom dawn.. nies li qatt ma qabdu bibbja f'idhom u minghalihom li jafu aktar mill-qassisin li jghamlu hajjithom kollha jistudjaw suggetti socjo-religjuzi.

R.Camilleri

Nov 5th 2010, 15:52

Of course Ms. Monica that sexuality is natural, but don't forget we are supposed to have minds and morals which the animals do not have . We should not act like animals, although some are taking more care of the animals than the human being. We are dressing up the animals and unveil ourselves. We need to scrutinize our conscience in order to speak sincerely and well.

David Caruana

Nov 5th 2010, 14:00

AMEN!

Ernest Vella

Nov 5th 2010, 11:15

kemm inti bravu!!!! kif qeghdin hemm naghmlu hotels b'xejn halli s-sess jaghmluh f'post nadif ukoll, b'mod privat....forsi nitfghu xi muzika romantika wkoll...u ddahhakx...mela uliedna hsibthom prostituti!!! Biex nghalqu halq il-Knisja naslu biex nghidu kollox...il-Knisja ghanda dritt tghid dak li thoss u mhux ser tigi int jew hadd li jiddetta l-Knisja x'ghanda taghmel u x'tghid.

Dwar il-Knisja thallas il-beneficcji socjali...int ma tisthix habib ehhh...kemm il-Knisja u l-istituzzjonijiet taghha jaghmlu xoghol volontarju u bla hlas ma ssemmihx...nahseb bil-flus li tatiha int il-Knisja jew l-ghaqdiet taghha jaghtu servizz mill-koxxa, lil uliedna fl-ghaqdiet, u lil min hu inqas ixxurtjat minnha. Isma minni ghalaq halqek int, u halli l-kulhadd juza l-liberta ta l-espressjoni...hija kontradizzjoni li nemmnu fil-principji tal-liberta...sakemm dawn jaqblu maghna.

Issa tigi ssemmi..."int nisrani?" biex tipprova taghlaqli halqi jew twaqqa kliemi...ghamel int...imma issa xbajna naraw attakki kontra l-Knisja meta din isemma lehinha.

l.theuma

Nov 5th 2010, 11:42

Miexjin lejn socjeta' iktar annimaleska milli umana!

J Farrugia

Nov 5th 2010, 09:58

Malta does not need any PSD teachers. Especially teachers with low rate of what is morality. This is all hogwash. This first education is the responsibility of the parents. Yes we have irresponsible parents who have abandoned this role and left it to the wolves. Unless their children are given all the care and education regards their sexual lives from their parents, all is lost. That's were sex education should start and continue with the growing up of their own children. In their own home, and by their own parents.

sciortino m

Nov 5th 2010, 10:48

@J Farrugia

I agree that parents should do more to educate their children. Given this situation, it is not the children's fault that they do what they do. They don't know any better.

What do you suggest that the state should do? Abandon these youngsters to disease or try and teach prevention so that at least they remain healthy?

Ms P.M Graham

Nov 5th 2010, 10:58

@Mr Farrugia:

You have hit the nail on the head. I have been saying this for years. It's NOT up to Priests or teachers to teach children sex ed. It should come as naturally as, potty training, eating with a knife a fork, manners, right and wrong.. It should start from a young age, with simple conversations regarding their bodies, hygeine and how their bodies can never be touched by anyone without their permission. To respect themselves, their uniqueness and encourage individuality.

Watching news shows together. Discussing as a family the World we live in, drugs, disease, famine.

Sex should not be a taboo subject. Your children should be able to talk to you about anything and receive an honest answer and if you don't, then yes, you are letting your children down.

David Caruana

Nov 5th 2010, 10:11

Every Politician, and actually every citizen, has not only the right but the duty to condemn anyone whose words can be of harm to our community.

What no politician or political party have the right to do is to CENSOR the Church's word, but we do not need to say that as CENSORSHIP is something which the State in collusion with the Church specialises in.

J Farrugia

Nov 5th 2010, 11:22

And that is what Malta needs right now. Absolute censorship against liberalism, perversity and vulgarity. Yes we do need discipline in our country.

David Caruana

Nov 5th 2010, 12:44

@ J Farrugia

Dream on!

Censorship will always fail... it failed under stricter regimes when people went to Sicily to be able to broadcast their message.

We will leave again if need be, and this time, internet and mobile telephony offer better platforms than radio did in those times.

P. Borg

Nov 5th 2010, 11:11

Hawn Joe Zammit iehor hawn!!!!!!!. Iehor brain washed siehbi.

Ahjar tghallimhom kif jipprotegu lilhom infushom milli thallihom ihawdu bex jispiccaw min tqil, min bl-AIDS u min jaf xiex. La ma nistax intih sikkina biex jiddefendi ruhu ghall-inqas nghidlu biex ma jersaqx lejn min jista jweggghu.

Mhawn hadd li jista jwaqqaf lil persuna ohra milli jkollha relazzjoni sesswali allura might as well nghallmuhom kif ma jkollhomx tfal. It-tfal qeghdin ghal min irid jibni familja mhux ghal xi hadd li ghadu mohh ir-rih. Dik hi il-maturita. Fil-passat kellna ezempji li min ma uzax kontraccettivi kellu tqala li ma kinitx mixtieqa u spicca halla tarbija go kaxxa taz-zraben, ramiha go xi skip bhal ma rajna l-italja jew qatilha b'xi daqqa ta sikkina. Ghandek bzonn ta aktar ezempji ghal xiex il-kontraccettivi huma importanti???? Hallik mill-isqof. Dak ghazel li jibqa single ghal ghomru halli ma jkollux problemi ta familja, fejn jaf x'jaghddu minnu in-nies biex irabbu it-tfal. Ikber siehbi. Il-knisja biex tpacpac tajba biss, il-bqija il-problemi ghal go wiccna

Ramon Casha

Nov 5th 2010, 11:43

"U dawn il-gallini min huma biex imieru lil min jaf iktar minnhom..."

U min jifhem l-iżjed dwar saħħa u kontraċezzjoni. tabib jew isqof?

PS: Jekk hemm tant tfajliet qed joħorġu tqal kmieni, l-abbuż huwa li tgħidilhom ma jużawx kontraċettivi.

martin saliba

Nov 5th 2010, 19:09

@ P. Borg. Kont insejtu u int fakartni fih. Tergax jekk jogbok.

Advert
Advert