Advert

Police catch bird trappers after CABS monitoring

Video footage provided by CABS - BirdLife Malta

Four cases of illegal trapping have been filmed since Saturday, and the subsequent police action resulted in the seizure of several large clap nets as well as nine live and two artificial bird decoys, the Committee Against Bird Slaughter (CABS) said today.

On Saturday morning a CABS team were alerted to a trapper in St. Thomas' Bay who was attempting to attract protected wader species by means of an illegal bird caller. The police were notified by the team and seized a 40 m long net. Legal proceedings had been launched.

On Monday morning the conservationists discovered an active trapping site near Bahrija, where a trapper was attempting to catch protected Dotterel (Birwina).He was using plastic decoys as well as an electronic device playing Dotterel calls. A video recorded the man trapping and a copy was handed over to the A.L.E. as evidence. The police subsequently searched the site and seized other items for evidence.

CABS said a real cops and robbers chase took place on Tuesday as police raided the site of a song bird trapper near Zurrieq. Following a tip-off from Birdlife Malta a CABS team had filmed the man for hours from a hide, and obtained footage of the man trapping protected larks and pipits.

The man saw the approaching police patrol and took to his heels, scrambling over a high stone wall to make his escape. His flight was however in vain as the police were later able to identify him easily from the CABS film.

A search of the trapping site discovered five live Short-toed Larks (Bilbla) and a Red-throated Pipit (Dizz Ahmar), all of which were seized and later released into the wild. Two of the birds had been caught a very short time before.

CABS praised the rapid reaction of the police but criticised their decision not to confiscate the nets or to search the man's premises for further protected bird species.

CABS spokesperson Axel Hirschfeld said: "Protected birds have been seized at this same trapping site three times already in the past 12 months. The fact that illegal trapping continues here, despite ongoing investigations, demonstrates just how fanatical these trappers are".

A further seizure of protected species was made yesterday afternoon near Ghadira San Raflu (Gozo), where a CABS team filmed a trapper catching waders over a number of hours. Officers from Victoria police station who were called to the scene found the trapper still in his hut and seized his nets as well as three live Dotterel.

The CABS videos will be available for viewing on Youtube in the course of the next days.

In addition to checks of trapping sites CABS teams have also observed and reported numerous cases of illegal hunting and have found several shot birds including a Kestrel (Spanjulett) and a Nightjar (Buqrajq). This morning the conservationists said they were appalled to witness the killing of two Honey Buzzards (Kuccarda) and a protected wader species being shot at south of Girgenti valley.

Advert

64 Comments

Post comment

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Johnny Xerri

Sep 18th 2010, 22:18

1. Hunters must have their seasons, not because an ancient tradition cannot be stopped overnight, but simply because hunters cannot be denied of their right to enjoy hunting like the rest of the EU and world-wide hunters.

2."(60% of hunters can't resist shooting anything, it's a fact!).." any statistics to back your 'scientific' claim??

3. "We birdwatchers and nature lovers must also be allowed to enjoy our pastime in peace." Well that is why there are over 30 nature reserves in tiny Malta, plus; 50m from roads, 200m from inhabitted areas, 50 meters from some beaches, all cemetries and public gardens.

4."Hunting is no longer a necessity, it's a sport, and killing God's creatures for some fuzzy little reason just doesn't even seem right...or sane!"

Hunting is neccessary more than ever in todays world. Have you ever been in a farm, with all the artificial feed, growth hormones & antibiotics that animals are given no wonder that some diseases have increased. Moreover, I wonder what is more humane, simply dispatching a game bird, or rearing an animal in extreem conditions (like small cages, arificial lights so that animals feed for 24 hrs +++).



Mario Tabone

Sep 19th 2010, 10:27

So finally Johnny Xerri admits that it is cruel keeping birds in little cages !!!!!!
So why do trappers persist in keeping songbirds in shoebox size cages , seen stacked on top of each other to use as bird callers in the video below.
This man, amongst one or two others champions the rights of hunters and is always quoting bits from EU laws and all sorts of different web pages, all to suit his arguments of course !!!
Now he is trying to tell us that hunters are doing us a favour by blasting birds out of the sky because of the artificial feeds and hormones etc etc used on farms.
Try pulling the other one Mr Xerri.
While hunting as you say cannot be banned altogether (at this moment) there are plenty of other restrictions that can be imposed . It all takes time and it takes courage from parliamentarians to do what is right. Trust me Mr Xerri, through your own (hunters) actions you have turned the majority of people against you . They have seen the hypocrisy and lies dished out by so called hunters on these islands.The noose gets tighter everyday !!!!

Johnny Xerri

Sep 19th 2010, 11:44

Mario so its ok to keep chicken feed with high fat and protein feed, given all sorts of suppliments, supplied with artificial light for 24hrs a day, transport them in cages in which they cannot stretch their wings, slaughter them and eat them? But its not ok to kill a birds that has lived free from this cruelty and eat them?

Moreover trappers do not keep all their birds in tiny cages, they are kept in aviaries just like pet birds such as canaries and buggies. They are only kept in cages during the trapping season. Trappers also do not take all their birds with them but a few decoy birds. The law also stipulates minimum sizes of these cages in which the bird must have enough space to strech its wings. Hunters do not keep any birds in cages.

I hunt frequently at least twice a year abroad, and have hunted in; Spain, UK, Italy, Egypt and Argentina, and I can assure you that Malta has much more regulations than warrented by the birds directive. For expample the; afternoon ban (on Sundays, Public Holidays and during September), size of lead pellets, number of huntable game species, hunting methods.

Cont....

Johnny Xerri

Sep 19th 2010, 11:50

cont...

They have seen the hypocrisy and lies dished out by so called hunters on these islands.
Yep just as much as the ECJ has seen through the lies dished out by BLM!!! The ECJ did not even have a look at their observations but relied on the data provided by hunters. The ECJ dod not even take note of the autumn alternative, but ruled that in principle Malta has a right to derogate since autumn as claimed by BLM is not an alternative.


The noose gets tighter everyday !!!!
Yep that's why the ECJ and EU Commission found no problem with this years spring hunting. Implying that at least we will start having a limited season and at most we will have the 3 weeks as suggested by Ornis Commitee Malta.

"While hunting as you say cannot be banned altogether (at this moment) there are plenty of other restrictions that can be imposed . It all takes time and it takes courage from parliamentarians to do what is right."

They can try, but they cannot do much since autumn/winter hunting cannot be banned as previously explain. Of course it takes courage...in order to break EU legislation regards minority groups.

Chris Grillo

Sep 19th 2010, 21:12

Thanks for replying....

1. Of course. Except you might have realised that not everyone is equal in the EU. Divorce is allowed in UK, but not in Malta. Don't put it in your head that you 'should have access to this err..sport'

2. It's not scientific. It is what I hear hunters talk about all the flipping time. Never had any desire to blast that stork to kingdom come? Can I not believe you? I have many friends and from all the hunters among them, 60% would happily take the chance.

3. Not too long ago, I brushed pellets from the roof of my car in an industrial estate. So ba**s!

4. I am afraid I can't say..you see, I am against that too mate.

What is most amazing is that you all do not realise that the poulation perception is well against the hunters. Practically all my uncles and both grandfathers are (were) hunters, addicts, going to any lengths...and all their (young)children are against them.

And the population's perception (not only me) is that most of the hunters would COMFORTABLY fit into the poacher bracket. As always, my own humble thoughts. Peace.

J. Borg

Sep 19th 2010, 21:58

& Johnny Xerri

1. Other countries can afford hunting simply because they are much larger – thus anyone can also enjoy the countryside in peace and safety (no like here)

2. Consider the % of your ilk that attack CABS and BLM, notwithstanding they are effectively seeking to control the illegalities, which for years have been denied and/or excused by FKNK.

3. How many reach the reserves? Some were even shot inside! ; And do you honestly believe that birds are going to stay within the supposedly safe distances, when gunshots blasts are audible close by?.

4. Simple….go organic and/or grow your own food – you’ll be making good use of the fields you currently use for hunting and lead showering stunts.

Lastly – pls note the subject matter was hunting abuses CLEARLY DOCUMENTED now…..it is respectfully naïve to strive to divert attention to CABS/BLM’s thankless initiatives and some hunters/trappers vice.....which FKNK and fellow supposedly law-abiding hunters turned blind eyes to for years on end!

Johnny Xerri

Sep 20th 2010, 21:31

@ Chris Grillo,

Re the divorce. UK & Malta.....I am sort to break the news to you but there is no comparism...since Malta never had divorce....whilst hunting has always been practiced...banning hunting would be taking something away from hunters...this would be illegal for reasons I have explained many times....I did not envisage or imagine this...I have confirmed documentaion from EU institutions who confirmed that although that spring hunting is subject to a well applied derogation...autumn and winter hunting can never ever be banned. If you forwad me your email I can send you this expert EU opinion (not my opinion, but an EU environment and an EU fundamental rights expert, who work in the EU commission)

Johnny Xerri

Sep 20th 2010, 21:33

@ J Borg since your comments have been previously answered I will not bothered...I am too busy...maybe I will reply at the end of January...untill then happy bla bla bla

JOE BRINCAT

Sep 19th 2010, 17:47

jalla jomplu jindahlu sa ma jinqered dan is-suppost delizzju qerried!!!! nahseb li ghadek ma indunajtx li id-dinja inbidlet minn meta f'Malta kellna dik il-kretina prima tal-ligi dwar l-indil barrani!!! WAKEY WAKEY

Johnny Xerri

Sep 18th 2010, 22:07

Please be informed that hunting or as you prefer 'bird killing' is allowed on game species (32 in autumn, 2 in spring, and one i.e. the rabbit as from 1st june till 31st Dec).

Only poaching is not allowed.

"And anyone who has a brain knows it anyway"

By the way joyriding and shoplifting are illegal, but warning of cameras have to be in place otherwise the filming or speedcamera shots cannot be used in court.

"I don't know why the gvern doesn't stopp the unnessesary bird hunting."

Simply because Maltese hunters have a right to hunt like all the hunters in the rest of the world. Or maybe you believe that hunting is practiced only in Malta? Again please inform yourself before posting comments, since hunting is allowed in all EU-27 member states and allover the world.

Mario Tabone

Sep 17th 2010, 21:38

Ooopssss....more evidence against the trappers and hunters who we are told never ever do anything against the law !!!!!
Johnny Xerri now tries to compare these criminals with joyriders and robbers !!!! Even though I don't agree with you Mr Xerri , I always thought you were a bit more sensible than to write such rubbish.
Why can't you just accept the fact that CABS and BIRDLIFE are doing a brilliant job and they have once again come up with evidence and discredited all the lies and hype that generally comes over these pages by pro hunters including your good self.
The sooner that laws are amended to include harsher penalties, confiscation of equipment and a total ban on this disgraceful pastime of yours the better.

M.cachia

Sep 17th 2010, 23:23

Err.... this very paper had an article about CABs and that they were coming. I think that is sufficient warning.

Timothy Cachia

Sep 18th 2010, 07:06

The speed cameras aren't just there to fine people, they're there so that people will drive slower and be safer in the process. They are normally put into problem areas such as large busy intersections, where people should be more careful because it's accident-prone. This is exactly what they want when they install these cameras, it's not just for ticketing/money purposes.

Bird trappers are usually found in non inhabited areas, and we surely cannot have monitoring cameras in every corner of the country. I praise CABS for voluntarily using their own free time to stop this sensless hunting and trapping.

There is surely nothing wrong in filiming people who break the law!!! There are no privelages here... if you are breaking the law... you have given up on any form of privelages!!!!

W Spencer

Sep 18th 2010, 11:30

Be reassured, that after reading all the comments, they have NOW been warned that THEY are being watched, the same as car drivers and shoppers ! Fair enough ?

M.Gatt

Sep 18th 2010, 15:00

''Good to hear that someone was caught. I can only express joy when a poacher is caught''
Two posts later you're telling us how unfair it is that poachers are not warned they're being filmed.

Johnny Xerri

Sep 18th 2010, 21:56

No I do not believe that it is unfair, but I believe that either the notices of speed cameras and CCTVs are removed or else notices must also be issued to paochers.

If I had a choice I would not warn the poachers, but I would also not warn the joydrivers and shop lifters.

All criminals should be treated the same...unless the law is biased.

@ Mario Tabone,

As I have previously explained total ban is a fantasy that cannot materialise for this would equate to presecution of a minority group, oppression of culture, discrimination of resource utilisation, since hunting is practiced world-wide and by all EU member states.

"Johnny Xerri now tries to compare these criminals with joyriders and robbers !!!! "

Yes that is what I compare them to since they are scum and do not belong with law abiding hunters. They are nothing better than criminals. Hunting is about preserving habitats, enticing or tracking game, dispatching the game humanely, preparing and cooking the game. Hunting is not about killing protected species and breaking the law, thats poaching.

Johnny Xerri

Sep 18th 2010, 22:00

M Gatt I do not think that it is unfair that poachers are filmed without warning, I believe that it is unfair that robbers and joydrivers are warned.

All criminals should be threated the same, either all should be warned or all should not be warned of cameras and CCTVs. I believe, that none should be warned. But what is unacceptable is that some criminals have the privilage of being warned whilst others do not. I believe that the law should be applied and enforced in the same manner, no matter the crime and the criminal involved.

And yes I will say it again, the more poachers we get rid of the better, not only for hunters but for everybody

Johnny Xerri

Sep 17th 2010, 18:23

Sorry to disappoint you but I have written confirmation from the EU (environment commission and institute for human rights) that hunting in Autumn and Winter cannot be banned, since it is practiced all over the EU and a ban would equal to persecution of a minority group, oppression of culture and denial of equal rights to the Eurpoean resources (since birds are hunted in all europe). As for collecting the shotguns, please be aware that shotguns are legally possessed, with import duty, registration, licences and everything in order, so unless used in a crime they cannot be collected as that would amount to stealing. Again something that is not allowed by UN conventions. Moreover, shotguns are also used for clay shooting, a sport that is amongst the few that brings medals to tiny Malta, a sport that many enjoy on a Sunday afternoon or during the closed season. Think before you write and do not write before you think, for your extrimist comments belong to the long lost dictatorship era, and are nothing but comic relief.

Timothy Cachia

Sep 18th 2010, 07:07

The problem is not hunting...but the actual hunting of protected species.

j.zammit

Sep 17th 2010, 15:04

Illegal is illegal... no mater how small the offence is.
With your kind of thinking one might decide to steal your car and the police can say hey... its only one in 300,000.
Joseph Stalin once said... "one death is a tragedy, a million is a statistic"
Are you a hard line communist?

M Mifsud

Sep 17th 2010, 16:06

Storks and raptors pass in their hundreds of thousands from the middle east. Does this tells you that we have to shoot them? Your comment is stupidity at its best. What is illegal is illegal and action has to be taken. Congrats to BLM, CABS and the police force. Keep it up!

Mario Borg

Sep 17th 2010, 16:11

Yes Mr Borg, and thanks to CABS and the police another 5 short-toed larks can rejoin the thriving global population. Keep up the good work guys!

Franco Farrugia

Sep 17th 2010, 19:41

I agree with you 100%. This should ideally be the work and the monitoring that we do. But since we don't have the guts or the will to do it, we have to accept outsiders to do it for us and quite rightly. And believe me, this is just the tip of the iceberg.

Johnny Xerri

Sep 19th 2010, 10:09

The tip of the iceberg?
Same as the tip of the iceberg shown by someone commenting that he would teach the warden a lesson without police or MUT intervention?

Same as the tip of the iceberg discovered when 3 teachers took sick leave in order to go abroad?

People in glass houses should not throw stones let alone boast that they would throw them. Just in case you forgot we still await an explaination of the thrown stone in you warden vs lsa comment. How would you have though the warden a lesson in good manners Mr. Farrugia? Do yourself and us a favour and refrain from commenting on other people before you comment on your own comment.

Franco Farrugia

Sep 19th 2010, 11:12

@ Johnny Xerri and another like-minded woman: You try, however pathetically, to damage my reputation and my integrity. But it is impossible because I, unlike many people, am impossible to damage! I write against hunting and trapping, and you, Johnny Xerri, and a few others, make it your life's ambition to ridicule me, to paint me in a way that makes out that I have something to hide. I know what your aims are. I know you speak about me. I know my name is mentioned in emails.But it is useless. I can throw as many stones as I want. You know why? Because I do not live in a glasshouse.

Johnny Xerri

Sep 19th 2010, 12:11

What emails, report me to the police and they can check through my ISP if I have ever written emails concerning you. Better still if you have those imaginary emails, hand them over to the police and they can check from where they originated.

Getting paranoid? OOhhh pleeeaaasee officer they are out there speakking about me in their emails...bla bla bla, get some evidence. Like I got, through your comment.

"But it is impossible because I, unlike many people, am impossible to damage! I write against hunting and trapping, and you, Johnny Xerri, and a few others, make it your life's ambition to ridicule me, to paint me in a way that makes out that I have something to hide."

You damaged & ridiculed your self with your statement..or you now deny that you wrote that you would have tackled the warden yourself?


In the mean time tell us how you would have sorted out the warden please, and stop avoiding the question

Franco Farrugia

Sep 19th 2010, 22:03

@ Johnny Xerri: I would have set down with that warden and educated him.

Johnny Xerri

Sep 20th 2010, 21:26

Thanks very credible...especially after having waited so long for an answer...I must say...a good old chat and everthing would be sorted, thank Good we have such eductaors...some of who busy themselves so much that they 'need' to travel abroad during their sick leave.

stefan26m@hotmail.com

Sep 17th 2010, 14:55

What many?4 illegal trappers and maybe 10 illegal hunters?As you saw its almost always the same persons that are cought and this is from 13000 hunters and 4000 trappers!

J Borg

Sep 17th 2010, 17:11

Stefan, if they are few, and 'always the same persons', as you say, is it possible that FKNK are NOT AWARE of them?????? How come, than, that FKNK who claim ZERO TOLERANCE does not report them itself, making it necessary for foreigners to do the job for us?

Michael Vella

Sep 17th 2010, 13:32

I agree with you 100%

r curmi

Sep 17th 2010, 14:15

agree with u and im an anti

CZARB

Sep 17th 2010, 13:21

I don't think that Xenophobia should stop CABs from doing the sterling job their doing.

Daniel Gordon

Sep 17th 2010, 13:27

Your comments are a no brainer.

Quote: " foreign intruders spying and pestering local people? They should be stopped immediately because they are instigating trouble."

Local people performing illeagal acts need to be "spied" on. If they did not perform such illeagal acts there would be no trouble, would there?

Do you really think that ALL members of these organisations are foreign?
Do you not understand that there are many many Maltese who are disgusted with the trapping and hunting (illeagal or not) that goes on?

What I do not understand, is what do these trappers do with the birds they catch? Are they simply killed? Eaten? Stuffed and mounted? kept in cages? Any info welcome.

And well done to all concerned.


J Simpson

Sep 17th 2010, 13:56

In lots of foreign countries these things happen a lot!!!!!!!! It is not spying, it is catching illegal activity!!! Have you ever saw the Italian programme "Le Iene"? And that is an imitation of a Spanish programme

C.bugeja

Sep 17th 2010, 14:00

well said,maybe the police prefer to give a verbal warning to hunters caught disobeying the law.however cabs have nothing to loose as no one knows them.

azahra

Sep 17th 2010, 14:46

jekk taf b xi haga rraporta siehbi. llum il gurnaqta tista tibqa anonimu cempel 112

Advert
Advert