Councillor asked to withdraw from motion
Sliema Nationalist councillor Edward Cuschieri has been asked by his party to withdraw his support for the motion he signed nominating him as deputy mayor instead of fellow PN council member Cyrus Engerer who, by law, is next in line.
The party did not say how it would deal with Mr Cuschieri, 82, if he persists in his support.
Mr Cuschieri has been avoiding the media since he and five other councillors (making up a majority) tabled the motion on Monday. “You don’t need to call here anymore,” a family member said yesterday when contacted at home.
Besides Mr Cuschieri, the motion has the support of the three Labour councillors and two others who recently resigned from the PN: former mayor Nikki Dimech and Sandra Camilleri.
When asked if the PN had effectively lost its comfortable majority in a traditional stronghold, a party spokesman said that was “gratuitous”.
“Mr Engerer has the full backing of the PN and, as always, the PN will act according to the spirit of the law,” the party said yesterday as it lambasted the Labour Party for supporting the “undemocratic” motion.
The PN accused the PL of supporting a person who it said solicited a bribe, in a reference to Mr Dimech, who was deposed soon after pleading not guilty in court to charges including bribery.
Mr Engerer, 29, has expressed surprise at seeing Mr Cuschieri’s signature on the motion, saying they always worked well together.
The motion says that Mr Engerer does not have enough maturity or experience for the job, a claim he challenged pointing out there were several mayors and deputy mayors younger than him and that he was also a graduate in politics.
Mr Engerer believes there are “other” reasons behind the motion, although he has not spelled them out.
A Facebook group has been set up mocking Mr Engerer for his homosexuality. When contacted, Mr Engerer said the group highlighted the level of intolerance in Malta, showing the need for more to be done in terms of gay rights.
“Seeing all this, I am proud to belong to a party that accepts diversity and does not discriminate when it comes to its membership and candidacy in elections on the basis of sexual orientation,” he said.
He said the motion against him showed Labour to be an “opportunistic” party only paying lip service to issues such as youth involvement and tolerance towards diversity.
The motion still needs to be approved by the Director of Local Government and is likely to be rejected because, according to law, Mr Engerer must be appointed and only then can a motion of no-confidence be tabled. This means signatures would have to be sought once more.
The PL said Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi should look into what was happening in his party, adding that, due to arrogance and threats, the party had lost its comfortable majority.
It added that “GonziPN” was in no position to give lessons on minority rights, especially because of its “disastrous record” on homophobia-related votes at the European Parliament.
When contacted, the PL denied the motion had anything to do with Mr Engerer’s sexual orientation, saying it was shameful for the PN to try to exploit it. It had nothing to do with Mr Engerer’s age either but, rather, the “disrespectful way he treats fellow council members”. The party did not give details.
Mr Engerer wondered why this new reason was not mentioned in the motion and challenged the party to give examples of when this happened, adding he did not recall any such instances.
During last year’s local election, Mr Engerer gained the third largest number of votes from the elected PN candidates and Mr Cuschieri got the least.
3 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
P. Montebello
Sep 15th 2010, 14:34
This saga makes interesting reading in that I can draw two conclusions.
1. If Mr Engerer is "young and immature" to deputy lead a local council, can I deduct that Dr Joe Muscat, leader of the opposition is "young and immature" to ever lead Malta? This is true according to the reasoning of the 3 labour members of the Sliema Council. Personally, other candidates had much more experience to be elected leader of the oppostion.
2. Regarding Paul Borg Olivier. Obviously he is doing his job. If Mr Cuschieri would still like to be connected and represent the PN, he must go with what the party says. PBO points out this fact. Obviously, if PBO does not point out this fact, than he is not doing his job. If for convenience, the Partit Laburista would like to call this "pressure" "or "threats" than so be it. Now it is for Mr Cuschieri to decide: either he is a pn representative always, or resign: but resign from the council and not only from the PN. Exactly what the other two councillors should have done: resign from the council, since at present, they are independent councillors by default.
Lawrence Cardona
Sep 15th 2010, 13:14
ATT Mr Engerer i can't belive you when you say that you are part of a party that is comfotable with you by being gay i think you are living in a dream my friend read the story and you will know who turned the laws in favour of gays in 1971-72 if you where cought on camera kissing your boyfriend before those days you would have been taken to court cause you would have comitted a crime so don't try to blame pl on what's beeing said and done let me remind you an other thing you where elected by votes some of them where 18 year olds an other thing that pl introduced those days voting at the age of 18 and gave rights to women to vote which i'm sure you had some to you know what Mr Engerer read the maltese story and then speak what kind of party your a member of not blaming PL now if you want you have the oprtunity to ask your party to introduce that 16 year olds can start voting in local council i'm sure you might gain some of those votes to G.LUCK
Robert Zammit
Sep 15th 2010, 10:09
With all due respect after all that has been going on especially in Sliema I think Paul Borg Olivier should call it a day and make way for some one more suited for the job. Also the fact that he's acting as accuser and judge with regards to Mr Dimech and even though there is a pending court case he is labelling guilty of having solicited a bribe shows his arrogance ! Is he going to treat Mr Cuschieri to the same treatment Sandra Cammilleri was subjected to at the Lady Di pub (this time in private) ? I hope Mr Cuschieri is strong and man enough to stand up to PBO and his arrogance and tell him where to get off ! Looks to me that the PN is using the dictatorial system in local councils it uses in government. Talk about calling the kettle black ! It seems we're back to the mintoffian days, only a bit more subtle, but still the same !!