Advert

AD hits out at objections to fireworks moratorium

A group of firemen at the scene of the accident last Monday. Photo: Matthew Mirabelli

A group of firemen at the scene of the accident last Monday. Photo: Matthew Mirabelli

Alternattiva Demokratika has hit out at the main political parties after they dismissed calls for a moratorium on fireworks until the causes of the recent explosions are established.

The Times reported today that halting fireworks production until a board of inquiry can identify ways to improve the situation was unacceptable to both main political parties, while the Church said it was open to discussion.

AD Secretary General Ralph Cassar said that certain situations called for difficult and strong measures.

"The fact the both the PL and the PN are ruling out a moratorium on firework production until the reason for the huge number of accidents is identified shows the sheer lack of respect that these parties have towards people, not only those who manufacture fireworks but also those who happen to live close to fireworks factories.

"The accidents point towards something which is repeatedly going wrong. In other industries where human life is affected, such as food production and medicine manufacturing authorities and even manufacturers go as far as recalling their products on the slightest suspicion of defective products, but it seems that since the PL and PN are only interested in getting one vote more than each other in the case of fireworks anything goes. This attitude is disgusting."

He said that AD was backing the calls for a moratorium on the manufacture of fireworks.

"The safety and wellbeing of people is much more important than PN's and Labour's votes. Their alliance of death shows that we have really scraped the bottom in this country", Mr Cassar said.

In the past 12 months, there have been eight fireworks explosions and since the beginning of this year at least nine people have died, prompting passionate calls from the public for drastic action to be taken.

The latest explosion on Sunday, which wiped out almost an entire extended family from Gozo, happened three weeks after a young man died in Mosta.

A board of inquiry was set up after the latest explosion.

Asked by The Times for its stand including the possibility of a moratorium on fireworks manufacture – which The Times mentioned in an editorial yesterday, the Nationalist Party said it did not agree with such a move.

“What we need is for all concerned to engage in a thorough and constructive analysis on how we can continuously improve the standards and safety of the highly technical skill that is part of our national heritage.”

The Labour Party said it welcomed the government’s move to appoint a board of inquiry and investigate the materials used in the production of fireworks. However, it did not back the idea of a moratorium in the winter months, saying this could drive production underground.

“There are other decisions which can be taken,” a Labour spokesman said.

The Church authorities were less forceful, saying that, while the proposal could be “discussed”, it was not prudent to take a stand without proper consultation and discussion.

The Church spokesman said that everyone was aware of the serious consequences and misery caused by the “now so frequent” incidents caused by fireworks.

On the other hand, the Ministry of Justice and Home Affairs avoided answering the question, saying, instead, that, over the past few years, several measures to heighten the levels of security in the industry were introduced and this process was ongoing.

“This inquiry aims to establish if these latest accidents were the result of an unfortunate coincidence, negligence or if there was some other root cause... We need to know the truth because people’s lives are important.”

A ministry spokesman said such findings would help to continue the efforts to control the industry and make it safer for those working in it and the public, while preserving its traditional element.

Advert

58 Comments

Post comment

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

M. Debono

Sep 8th 2010, 18:49

Presumably you are the "real" expert then?

Raymond Camilleri

Sep 8th 2010, 20:15

u hallina tridx C Busuttil... f'pajjizi serji KULL STADJU jigi mistharreg qabel l-affarijiet ikomplu qiesu qatt ma kien xejn.... hallina, turi kemm tigi taqa' u tqum mis serjeta...

C.Busuttil

Sep 8th 2010, 22:02

@Raymond Camilleri

Fil-fatt l-awtoritajiet ha jibghatu samples tal-materjal barra biex jitnehha kull dubju imma l-logika tghidlek li kieku l-materjal kien hazin waqt it-tahlita l-aktar mument krujcali fil-hidma tan-nar li kien ikun hawn spluzjoni wara l-ohra u mhux wara lin-nar kollu jkun inhadem. Murtal ma jiehux wahdu murtal ma jqumx filghodu u jghid il-lejla jew wara nofsinhar intir. Murtal biex jiehu jew taharqu jew tipprova tifthu wara li jkun tlesta, sakemm ma tkunx mignun u itieh bis-sieq. La darba n-nar kien lest mhux mil-materjal. Haga elementari. Jien is-serjeta inhobba biss ma naghmilx bhalek gudizju fuq xejn bla ma nkun naf xejn fuq is-suggett.

@M. Debono
I am no expert however I use logic and through my experience, I don't rush to conclusions that it was the material or that the accident was related to transportation as some have written. If it was due to transportation with the state of our roads the explosion would have occured much before not when parked. The material can be ruled out since we would have had a dozen more explosions. For Heaven's sake people should reflect before rushing to conclusions on a subject they have no knowledge about, just to open their mouths.

Dirk Urpani

Sep 8th 2010, 17:52

Mela issa ma naghmlu xejn laqqas nohorgu mid dar ghax anke tohrog fit triq tista tmut mela id dar noqoghdu id dar .....

M. Debono

Sep 8th 2010, 18:21

Tony Muscat: AD is making a political issue out of this because that's exactly what it is. Nearly ten people have died this year while manufacturing fireworks yet the government of the day refuses to take the only sensible decision and the opposition remains curiously silent as well. A halt to the manufacture and use of fireworks is exactly what is needed until the causes of these multiple accidents have been determined. But both main parties know that such a decision may cost them votes, which is exactly why they prefer to beat about the bush.

albert leone ganado

Sep 8th 2010, 18:48

I fully agree with you .
One of the risk assessment measures in dangerous production processes is full traceability of the whole production process.
Chemicals should be chemically analysed and a sample kept before starting any production.
The production process and any hardware used must be fully documented and each person working on it must record exactly time, place and temperature plus other critical data and sign off.
Finished product should be stamped with appropriate marks , barcoded and details of production details attached. Details of any person who handles finished product must be documented until the time the fireworks are let off.
Any incident in production however small must be recorded.
Such an approach which is normal in any quality standard will ensure the ability to trace back any incident. Without such information I honestly doubt how the inquiry team can confidently trace back the source of the current spate of mishaps.

peter agius

Sep 8th 2010, 17:01

Kemmuna was never used for target practice. FILFLA was. Get your facts right before you comment.

S Diaconos

Sep 8th 2010, 16:06

L-istess haga ghal - PL ..... m'hemmx differenza ta' xejn

sscerri

Sep 8th 2010, 15:03

"AD you are sensible and right on yet another issue. " Do you really think so????? If it were it would have spoken up on the first tragic event not wait till now when other lives were lost. AD is using this tragity to poke its rival parties and maybe earna few votes, and this behaviour makes them not much better than the rest. GonziPN set up an inquiry to establish what is going on and the PL showed its approval on this. AD did not ............ AD only adherted to a suggession ( not even its own) to hold production for a year. So then what ????? All of us should contribute to see that fire works are produced, stored, transported and let off in the safest way possible. If the Authorities heed to AD's suggessions we will have to live with people (proffesionals or not) producing fireworks God only knows where. A thing that already happened and had tragic ends.

Mario Stellini

Sep 8th 2010, 14:16

...... and meanwhile people continue to die!!

We have been through these boards of inquiry countless times before. The strict regulations they are supposed to introduce are just a waste of paper and ink. Nothing ever really gets done.


Jesmond Micallef

Sep 8th 2010, 16:50

I agree that these tragic events have literally thrown the Maltese Fireworks Industry into a very shady corner. I for one, was completely shocked when I read just the headlines here on Sunday afternooon, and thought, NO NO NOT AGAIN. !! People are asking serious questions and want answers and concrete follow up action which is perfectly normal and understandable, considering all the recent history. I still choose to remain positive and confident in the Board of Enquiry investigations. Maltese Fireworks are a traditional passion, works of art and spectacle but also a showcase of Maltese technical ingenuity. I fully support the Maltese craftspeople that make all that possible and ask them to be very professional and to cooperate fully with the Authorities so that much is learnt from all this. Their passion is shared by those who appreciate their skills but, I for one, expect them to be "perfect" within all the work that goes on in this volatile environment.

I have previously contributed here at the timesofmalta.com towards the safety of fireworks in general. I cannot say much more now and wish my sincere best to all those involved; the productive, the legislative and the regulative.

Raymond Camilleri

Sep 8th 2010, 13:43

oh..so AD should follow the ignorant masses? (if they exist)..oh how principled and serious! There are already the PL and PN who do that

Raymond Camilleri

Sep 8th 2010, 13:42

go and tell that to the Popular Party whose leaders introduced abortion laws into ALL EU countries...go and tell that to Angela Merkel, and do not forget to include all socialists and liberals too...

Ivan Vassallo

Sep 8th 2010, 12:25

Totally well said Mr. Hobson

John Betts

Sep 8th 2010, 12:08

What happened?

Joseph Dingli

Sep 8th 2010, 12:12

Haha, indeed!

Patrick Sacco

Sep 8th 2010, 12:12

You are a very intelligent man, Mr. Galea!

What AD is proposing (as usual) is much more dangerous than the present situation we are in!

Bravo Mr. Galea.

Pierre G

Sep 9th 2010, 08:15

Dont try and politicize this more Mr Sacco. What AD is proposing is what the two major parties should have done. There are people's life at stake here. Forget the votes, forget the politics. I agree with AD.

Marie Mifsud

Sep 8th 2010, 13:06

Well said!! They just want votes!

J Farrugia

Sep 8th 2010, 14:33

Everyone knows that 2010 is the annus orribilis for the fireworks' factories. No need to go to statistics. It's there in front of us all.

Tony Bishop

Sep 8th 2010, 12:20

It Is amazing that those who work in these fireworks factories are called "delitanti tan nar ".So in other words all engineers technicians working with Airmalta are "delitanti tal-ajruplani "

Advert
Advert