Advert

Foreigners overcharged for identical products

Foreigners are charged more than locals when buying identical products from the same establishments, an exercise conducted by The SundayTimes has shown.

One quarter of stores, kiosks and bars visited by this newspaper charged more to a foreigner speaking English than to a Maltese person speaking the national language for the same product.

Sixteen stores, kiosks and bars were visited in popular tourist areas in Valletta, St Julian’s, Paceville, Tarxien and Rabat.

At each location, a Maltese journalist ordered a selected item in Maltese, while a British journalist posing as a tourist ordered the same item in English.

The journalists ordered the same product directly after one another and obtained receipts in all cases when the foreigner was charged more.

TheSundayTimes only visited retailers where prices of items were not clearly displayed, which is illegal under the Price Indication Regulations of the Consumer Affairs Act.

At a confectionary in Merchants Street, Valletta, on August 26, the Maltese journalist paid €1.20 for a small bottle of cola, while the British journalist was charged €1.50 for the same item immediately afterwards.

On the same day, a political party club in Republic Street, Valletta, perhaps demonstrated why it displays a sign saying ‘tourists welcome’ outside – the barman there charged the Maltese journalist €1.30 for a bottle of lager, but moments later he charged the British ‘tourist’ €1.40 for the same item.

Yesterday at a store in St George’s Road, St Julian’s, the attendant charged the British journalist €1.25 for a two-litre bottle of mineral water. A few minutes later, the same woman charged the Maltese journalist €1 for the product.

And Anglo-Maltese solidarity was somewhat lacking at a certain establishment in Merchants Street, Valletta, yesterday; the British journalist was charged the Anglo price of €2, while the local journalist was charged the Maltese price of €1.75 for an equivalent large can of lager. Although the other places visited did not display the prices of all their products as required by law, they did not attempt to charge different prices for the same product to the journalists.

Foreigners who spoke TheSundayTimes came up with numerous anecdotes about instances when they believe they were ripped off.

One Briton recalled a time he was eating in Mdina with his Maltese girlfriend, whom the waitresses presumed was also foreign, and right in front of them one waitress told another in Maltese to charge them for two scoops of ice cream instead of the one they had ordered.

Another foreigner working in Valletta recalled that for weeks he was charged 90 cents for his daily cup of coffee at a cafe close to his place of work. When the staff at the cafe started to recognise him they began charging him 70 cents instead, but lost a formerly loyal customer.

“Despite the drop in price, I would rather buy my coffee elsewhere than pay people I know were cheating me,” he said.

Odette Vella of the Consumer and Competition Department, who writes a weekly consumer column in TheSundayTimes, emphasised it is illegal for any retailer to purposely charge different prices for the same product.

Ms Vella said every product for sale should have a price which is displayed in a manner that is unambiguous, easily identifiable and clearly legible.

If consumers believe they have been overcharged, or if they know of a trader that does not display its prices, they can report these traders to the Enforcement Directorate within the Consumer and Competition Department on Freephone 8007 4400.

Advert

139 Comments

Post comment

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Mandy Spiteri

Sep 6th 2010, 23:37

Interesting you should mention the 'Karozzin'. My niece was over from the UK in August, and she was asked for € 50 for a ride on the famous 'Karozzin'. She knocked the owner down to € 15, then she was so annoyed that she would have been ripped off had she settled for the € 50 fee, so she told him to stuff his ride where the sun don't shine!!!

A. Bialczak Melbourne

Sep 7th 2010, 15:47

I was lucky then because I only paid 12 euros for my karozzin ride last August !!!

e duncan

Sep 5th 2010, 16:23

This should not happen but it does!! Prices should be clearly displayed and there is where enforcement should come in. In Asia tourists pay a premium....but you get to know about it beforehand. Shame on these so called business persons, they are very short sighted. It takes a while to build a good reputation, but such incidents mar the good work done. MTA should be more vigilant!!!

ray sacco

Sep 6th 2010, 07:25

i bet that the GRTU will come out and say that the establishments are not charging foreigners more than the maltese, but they are charging the maltese less than the foreigners!

a vella

Sep 6th 2010, 12:28

GRTU lost credibility long time ago. That is why maltese are preferring to buy directly online and letting local retailers moaning about less of sales.

Peter Cassar

Sep 5th 2010, 14:51

Joseph N Attard Name it so that everyone will know and not go there.

Paul Smith

Sep 5th 2010, 13:55

This does not happen all over europe. this only happens in Club Med countries like Greece, Spain Italy, Portugal, Malta, Cyprus and other club Med countries. Notice anything familiar with these countries? All very corrupt, tax avoidance is massive and all apart from maybe Cyprus are in unpayable debt which will eventually destroy the single European currency. Watch Greece default under severe austerity and wanton protests with violence soon, a country where nobody really pays what they owe in income tax and corruption between the politico's is blatant - sound familiar Malta?

Philip Cassar

Sep 5th 2010, 14:55

Mandy Spiteri I am sure you misunderstood her because she must have meant that it is natural for Maltese not to order chips separately because they expect to have chips with hamburgers.

Mandy Spiteri

Sep 5th 2010, 22:37

No, I did not misunderstand her at all...... I know what I heard.

Mandy Spiteri

Sep 5th 2010, 22:56

My point was, that if the burger is 5 euro for arguments sake, and for the Maltese it comes with chips, it still costing the tourist more, because they have to pay extra for the chips if they want it. That was my point! It's not the first time I've been over charged, now I have learn Maltese and whenever I am in a shop I ask for things in Maltese, but it shouldn't have to be that way! Having said that, it didn't stop me being charged 5 euros for just over a 'wizna patata' from a Sweiqi greengrocer, when at my local shop in Sliema it costs only 2 euros! It's a joke!

robert micallef

Sep 5th 2010, 13:26

yes they did the same thing to my wife who is foreign. she got an umbrella and paid 5 euro for it at 16.00hrs and the guy came to pick it up at 18.00 hrs.

Jean-Marc Camilleri

Sep 5th 2010, 13:20

x'gandu x'jaqsam? so if i understand you correctly, in order to buy a bottle of water i must 1. give the impression i'm maltese so i could get it cheap 2. shop around all mellieha to see who has the cheapest water, (and try my luck again by using point 1)!
EFA was wanted YOU, the consumer, to enjoy the best prices, so get a life. Keep in touch with EU competition laws. EFA's Prime Minister era is over, a number of years ago now, and is a respected politician as much as Guido and Mintoff, both for their achievements and political strength. Why include politicians in such a discussion? Times change, and laws do too, so lets keep this discussion in context and not roam too far.

T Camilleri

Sep 5th 2010, 15:03

Jean-Marc Camilleri not give the impression that you are Maltese, but that the people overcharging are following what Eddie Fenech Adami had told them and he also told the people to go from shop to shop to find the cheapest prices. I said that I don't agree with this, but this is what happens when an ex-prime minister give such advise and habits are hard to break. As for EU competition law, that's exactly what it is. There is no price controls and you compete with different prices. Isn't this what's happening Jean-Marc? Again I don't agree and agree with price control, but I guess that you will tell me that this should not be so since you believe in the EU competition law.

Jane Sammut

Sep 5th 2010, 15:07

T Camilleri, what you forgot to mention is that the same Eddie Fenech Adami had said "Ha joghlew il-prezzijiet, Ha joghlew il-prezzijiet."

Joe Falzon

Sep 5th 2010, 13:24

You astound me -- what an attitude! Why should tourists pay more than the Maltese? They're not asking to be treated differently, but no one likes to be ripped off blatantly either. You are a D.H.

Markus Behmann

Sep 5th 2010, 13:33

It might be "fair" from your point of view, but it is simply impossible because if this what you say shall happen, a product needs to have a billion different prices due to the fact that prices differ from region to region.
Just try to get a better job and stop cheating / blaming other people when it is your fault that your wage is low.
In other countries the shop would be closed and the business license scrapped, additionally to a proceeding because of discrimination.

M.cachia

Sep 5th 2010, 14:12

Please tell me you're being sarcastic. If not I really hope you've got nothing to do with tourists, and it's people like you that harm our country. If you Can't afford a £3.50 bottle of water then don't go holidaying in London is the obvious way to go about it.

ms ghoare

Sep 5th 2010, 16:09

Are you for real,if you are finding a bottle expencive then you should stayed in Malta and not gone on holiday to London you would have got a pack of six 2 liters bottles for that price,but the argument here is that they charge diffrent prices to tourists from the Maltese which is unfair and it is stealing. Unfortunatly this ALSO happenes in GREECE, ITALY,and in CYPRUS which most off the English living there are selling up and moving else where as they are fed up being taking for a ride

Jeremy Psaila

Sep 5th 2010, 16:11

Why are you all so surprised? Enemalta charges different people different rates depending on their income... Even Gozitans get a better deal on nearly everything, be them Ferry tickets or solar energy feed in tariffs!

So is that not discrimination?

Well by the same principle I still believe that I should be charged less than a Briton when I go to the UK and that British tourists can afford to pay a little bit extra than I can. It's called social justice.

So it's the Law that should be changed not my job, my holiday destinations or any of my purchasing preferences!

M.cachia

Sep 5th 2010, 16:26

I see so basically you want to do whatever you like and not pay for it. Stinks of Communism at best. Unfortunatly for you, you have to live according to your means - if you can't afford something, tough, you should save up or you should have studied for longer and got a better job.

j grech

Sep 5th 2010, 18:02

ARE YOU FOR REAL,i do hope that you are not dealing with members of the public,foreigners will pay the going price of the country they visit what they dont like to find out is that they have paid an inflated price because they are visitors, many times my husband because he lived and worked abroad and has an out side accent has been ripped off because the trader thinks he is loaded which is not the case he retired back here on his pension, shame on you and the mentality of people like you ,that mentality shows and thats what puts malta down

Jeremy Psaila

Sep 5th 2010, 19:01

@M.Cachia You still haven't clarified why Gozitans can get away with lower cost Ferry tickets and better solar energy feed-in tariffs! Why do single mother get lower cost homes? Why do pensioners get on and off the bus for half the cost?? Different prices for different people... That is the motto of our country! So why are you so surprised! If you disagree with the principle of fleecing the tourist, then you have to disagree with all the rest!

Victor Carmelo Sciberras

Sep 6th 2010, 11:09

Sorry Jeremy but your argument don't hold water. You might be getting a lower wage than us in the UK, although a lot of foreigners are getting similar wages to you we still have a much higher cost of living than you. For instance does your local council charge you £1200 a year council tax for the privilege of living in your own house that you bought and paid for like we do here. This is just one of many things we pay more here, others include car/house insurance road tax etc. This is not the issue as I live in a big tourist area of the Jurassic coast and we locals also get overcharged by unscrupulous vendors in high season, me in particular as I still have a Maltese accent even after 45 years living here. London is high on the list of overcharging especially from street vendors so Malta and Gozo are no exception. But that you happen to get a lower wage does not justify overcharging regardless of of whoever you are or whatever you earn, it is still stealing.

Charles Sammut

Sep 5th 2010, 13:27

Whenever I was in countries south of Malta, they do to us there, far worse than what we do to them here. So stop playing the race card. It is so worn out and tattered, it can be spotted a mile out.

Mario Aquilina

Sep 6th 2010, 00:12

While you are on the Mater Dei subject:

Did you know that say, if you are a Staff Nurse and you would like to bring a guest with you into the Staff canteen for a bite, that your guest will be refused entry, while on the other hand, the Bus Drivers are allowed to eat in this same canteen.

What I would like to know is, as to whether the public bus drivers are employed by Mater Dei Hospital or by ADT/Transport Malta, and how they managed to get this perk.

alfred curmi

Sep 5th 2010, 11:58

Dear Peter,

Of course they do. They use their ill-gotten gains to light a candle or two in front of a pagan statue and have their sins forgiven!

alfred curmi

Sep 5th 2010, 12:04

Dear Peter,
Of course they do go to church. They use their ill-gotten gains to light a candle or two in front of some saintly image to have their sins forgiven!

Brian Maloret

Sep 5th 2010, 10:48

I am also an Englishman who has lived here for a number of years in which time I have been and have seen blatant overcharging of foreigners by vendors especially the roadside fruit and veg merchants. This is nothing short of racial discrimination and the Maltese should be ashamed of themselves in allowing it to happen. Are any of the vendors in this article who overcharged foreigners going to be prosecuted and if not why not?

axuereb

Sep 5th 2010, 10:36

Naqbel perfettament "name and shame" ha nibbokotjaw dawn l-istabbillimenti! Kulhadd irid issir sinjur m ilum ghall ghada hawn Malta. Minflok niehdu hsiebu lit-turist naraw kif naghmlu ha ngerxuh, jistaw mhux jghamlu kampanji tal-Malta Tourism Authority biex ingibu n-nies. Certu nies jahsbu li m hawnx fejn tmur vaganza fid-dinja, li ahna biss nezistu! U mbaghad neqirdu li ma jigux turisti! Ma Jfux li l-kelma tigri f sekonda llum bl-internet!

Philip Sultana

Sep 5th 2010, 11:11

But that is the point! It is NOT done around the world! It is only done in underdeveloped societies.

Ramon Mizzi

Sep 5th 2010, 10:22

Totally agree with you Steve. Totally agree.

axuereb

Sep 5th 2010, 10:42

Totally agree! Thank God for online shopping. a case in point: a particular item from a shop in a popular St Julian s shopping mall costs 44Euros. The same item from a popular online shopping site costs 6.99 Sterling!!!!!!!!! Why the exorbitant difference in price? No one a lot of Maltese are resorting to online shopping for clothes, gadgets, toys etc.

Philip Sultana

Sep 5th 2010, 11:20

Not everywhere, C Borg, only in primitive societies!

Anthony Azzopardi

Sep 5th 2010, 11:23

And will these "investigative journalists" kindly investigate what happens to us Maltese when we are tourists abroad?
In Switzerland at this very moment they are considering a license to pick mushrooms. One price for the Swiss and another one for foreigners...

J.Agius

Sep 5th 2010, 10:47

Prosit u nigu qisna it Tunesija!
Iz- Zija darba qaltli li ghawn hafna negozji min fejn tghazel!!Fejn ma jghogbokx biddel.Qalet fejn tiekol tajjeb ma tharisx lejn il kont u fejn ma jghogobix ma tergax Tmur!! "u Zi fuq is safar".
Meta ma jkollix noqod d- dar!! Kliem ix xih zomm fih spiccat tghidli.Mhux ahjar tmur tghamel xi
part time flok tkun blogger!!Mohhok biss fuq in nies!! Grazzi Zi.ghandek ragun!!!!

gcForte

Sep 5th 2010, 12:00

J.Aguis.............U min qalilek li ahna differenti mit Tunezija........fejn jithlu prezzijiet u ingann lil ta Tunes nghalmuhom. Jekk tasal wasla sa fuq xi monti tkun taf x`qeghed nghejd. Liz zija ghejdilha li illum mhux bhal dari, jekk tmur tiekol, ikun hemm il menu fuq barra bil prezzijiet u meta tithol gor resturant jergaw ituk l-istess menu. Ghallura jekk tkun trid xi platt kawlata tkun taf min qabel kemm ser thallas, issa jekk ma toghogobiex mix problema tieghi. Sewwa qaltlek sabiex ma toqodx tiblogja u tghejd bin nies. ghal i`jista ikun, zijtek mhux bhal ziti hux, tmur il quddies u wara tghoqod tghejd fuq dik u fuq l-ohra, ziti biddlet il persjani xi ghaxar darbiet, ghax ittella u tnizzel mitt darba kull jum........nahseb taf ghalhiex.

J.Agius

Sep 5th 2010, 14:13

Inzertat iz zija tieghi ma kienitx tmur quddies !! Pero marret it Tunezija u daret nofs id dinja u bhal hafna turisti li jigu Malta kienet tghidli bhal Malta ma ghawnx!Kienet Kburija li kienet Maltija.Mietet u ma hallietli xejn.Sewwa ghamlet nefqet kollox!!Ghalmitni li flok noqod nghid fuq in nies bhaz zija tieghek nahdem u nsiefer halli nkun naf fuq xhiex nitkellem!!Mhux nmaqdar dak kollu li hu malti!

j grech

Sep 5th 2010, 14:05

it should not have needed journalist to do this study if the said department were doing their job you can use the free phone number but you will never get feed back to any action taken which means the department are still sitting on their behind doing nothing and getting paid for it, why could the department not have used mystery shoppers in pairs one maltese and one foreigner to go at random to any location and any outlet and then act on the outcome, how many foreigners live on this island and spend their foreign pension here like i do and that pension disappears with-in no time with being ripped off, what would happen if every foreigner left the island and took their pension with them, when i am due my maltese state pension i will leave the island taking my maltese pension with me as in the eu i can do this, what then?

axuereb

Sep 5th 2010, 10:51

it would be agreat idea if we could have an online site whereby people can put down names of supermarkets, greengrocers ect who overcharge, obviously naming the product and the price charged for it. I am sure the abuse would stop when the customers stop going!

M.cachia

Sep 5th 2010, 13:59

If you look carefully at the text you can identify each of the shops

Tommy Lee

Sep 5th 2010, 09:43

Name them.The more logical ways that is.

K.Anastasi

Sep 5th 2010, 09:11

You are soooooo right Ruth.

t. borg

Sep 5th 2010, 09:29

@a. calleja. x'email email ma tarax li tkun tahli l-hin! kont ilmentajt fuq hwienet ghax bla prezzijiet bhal tal-madum u hafna ohrajn. qaluli li se jmorru imma jaghtuh hmistax cans jaghmel il-prezzijiet. l-istess bhal tal-medicini

C. Busuttil

Sep 5th 2010, 09:38

There you go ... the source of knowledge is finally unveiled!!

D. Farrugia

Sep 5th 2010, 09:49

With the only exception that in Gozo they overcharge foreigners AND Maltese!

gcForte

Sep 5th 2010, 09:52

The difference is that the Maltese rip off the foreigners, and the Gozitans rip off kemm the foreigners and the Maltese.

jean-marc camilleri

Sep 5th 2010, 10:01

l'Ghaxdwin jaghmluhom lil kumpatrifoti taghhom stess, ahseb u ara. tista tkun aghar minn hekk??? tisraq lil huk ukoll???

Azzopardi V

Sep 5th 2010, 10:04

@ Mr Galea, Gozo have its own problems, 3 different prices, 1 for the Gozitan, 1 for the Maltese and the other for the foreigners! As like Parking fines on a thousand wrong parking in a street you'll notice who's maltese, with the ticket on the windscreen! It is a Gozitan saying No? Malti Xriku ....... u .........!

I would like to ask to try this in other countries like tourist areas to see if it is actually happening only in Malta or not! by my experience, we are not alone!!!

M Vella

Sep 5th 2010, 11:23

@ Jean Marc Camilleri @ d farrugia @gcforte

Kumbinazzjoni l-Hallieq tefa' l-hziena Ghawdex u t-tajbin Malta. U halluna tridx...mur staqsi lil tar-ristoranti kemm isiru complaints ghalxejn mill-Maltin wara li l-ikel ikunu hatfuh biex jifrankaw xi haga jew biex ma jhallsu xejn...Mur staqsi lil tal-flats u farmhouses kif iridu joqghodu b'seba' ghajnejn ghax kien hemm kazi fejn anke' geyser qalghu biex jehduh id-dar!

Il-qaddisin fis-sema qeghdin u mis-sema l-isfel kulhadd xorta!

Jean Marc Camilleri

Sep 5th 2010, 11:50

@ M Vella

imnalla hemm hafna Maltin ghandhom post Ghawdex ghax kieku fix Xitwa lanqas ghandkom biex tghaddu.....ghalfejn ghandu jehel kulhadd ghax xi hadd qala' l geyser? ghalfejn hemm min izomm EUR1 ta flixkun ilma zghir (u minghajr ircevuta)? u tghidli le, ghax graw lili u lil min kien mieghi...ghawdex m hemmx kontroll, sakemm ma jkunx hemm xi karozza maltija ipparkjata hazin u jiccumbaha xi warden....

M.cachia

Sep 5th 2010, 13:57

Mr. Vella, when we were hosting a student conference in Malta a few years back, we took a number of the delegates up to Gozo for a day. We went to the Rabat market and one of our forieghn friends wanted a Sun Hat: her price €8.50. when he heard us speak in Maltese he asked 'Di Maghkhom?' and the price went down to €5.00, one of my friends is Gozitan, and he said 'Isma jien Ghawdxi ta' and the price went down to €3.50. You might get ripped off sometimes in Malta but it seems the rip-off you get in Gozo is a constant and inflated one.

M Vella

Sep 5th 2010, 17:46

@ Jean Marc Camilleri - Believe me when I tell you that incidents like the one I mentioned are not a rare incident... I am not negating the overpricing to tourists in Gozo. But this article proves that it's Malta's issue too. Your argument is flawed as you find it too easy to sanctify Maltese and demonise Gozitans...But anyway, extremists exist everywhere hux... Imissek tghid imnalla hemm hafna Maltin ghandhom post Ghawdex ha jkunu jistghu jisolhu is-sussidju offrut mil-gvern lill-Ghawdxin fuq it-trasport bil-vapur... Tippuntax subghajk siehbi ghax turi kemm int intelletwalment limitat.... @ M Cachia what seems to be inflated is your argument...you're not a special human species and are vulnerable to abuse just like we are....I'm against abuse both in Malta and in Gozo..... Incidentally, this article pointed out abuse taking place in Malta...why do you feel the need to shift the problem to Gozo only...

Advert
Advert