And the winner is...
Video: Mark Zammit Cordina
Mgarr’s statue of the Assumption will this evening be carried by a group involved in parish work represented by Kevin Vella, who just after the stroke of midday made the highest offer to win the honour.
In line with a tradition dating back to 1922, four men, egged on by a crowd of parishioners, met by the side of the church where the offering was made.
‘Bids’ started from €2,000 with Mr Ellul submitting the highest, of €8,100, on behalf of his group.
The highest bidder gains the honour of carrying the statue during the procession which starts at 7 p.m. The money goes towards the upkeep of the church.
This tradition started the year the statue was made, when the benefactors who contributed to the purchase of the statue and the rest of the items that went with it were given the right to carry the Assumption.
The statue of the Assumption, made in Marseille, France was restored last year. It had cost £60 and 16 shillings.
Before last year’s restoration, it was last restored in 1958 but that intervention had altered the skin colour and the other hues including those of the drapery.
135 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Frederick muscat
Aug 24th 2010, 22:13
Nirringrazzja lil Knisja Mgarrija li kull sena izomm din it-tradizzjoni biex flimkien naghmlu festa sabiha.
Imgarru u kburi
ray sacco
Aug 24th 2010, 21:13
jason borg:
i am not interested in wasting my money on some ancient useless stupid tradition! i would and i do spend money on other charitable things! regarding tradition, lots of traditions became extinct by time because they became ridiculous at a certain time and age. fighting gladiators in the roman coliseum was a tradition. hunting foxes in britain was a tradition.
Patrick Sacco
Aug 27th 2010, 21:41
That is exactly what will happen, Mr. Sacco.
Only time (ironically) will rid us of this mediocrity.
Wait and see!
And by the way, very nice surname, Sir!
Cassandra Miggiani
Aug 24th 2010, 21:10
What shameful comments. The money raised in this way goes to the most needy and desperate element of our society, as well as the upkeep of our churches. This is a good thing. All you naysayers, how much money do YOU give to charity every month? every year?
You're all hypocrites and I'm ashamed of the lot of you. Without our blessed Mother the Church, Malta would be just like the rest of Europe - in the depths of despair, lawless and perverse.
sandra pace
Sep 7th 2010, 21:22
dear ms miggiani who are you to call us hypocrites what i do i dont show it on the media have you ever heard of the saying of li taghmel idejk il leminija thallix ix xellugija tkun taf !!! of course li naghmlu karita one thing i ask you show us with proof fejn tmur il karita??. so who is the hypocrite now???.
Joanne Camilleri
Aug 24th 2010, 20:08
Nixtieq inkun naf ghalfejn dan il fuss kollu li jinqala kull sena fuq l ghotja tal vara ta l Imgarr !! Jien nahseb li kull min ma jaqbilx ma din id drawwa ferm ghaziza ghalina l Imgarrin, hi kollha ghira ghax jarana tant maqudin fl Imgarr u li norganizzaw festa sabiha u minghajr glied ! Din id drawwa sabiha li ssir kull sena, hi tradizzjoni li gejja minn missierijietna u hadt m'ghandu dritt li jwaqqafielna. U kull min jsejjhila irkant tal vara, nixtieq nghidlu li dan mhux irkant ghax meta tirbah xi haga bl irkant, l oggett tiehdu mieghek u jkun tieghek ghall dejjem, filwaqt li f'dan il kaz, il vara tibqa ta l Imgarrin kollha!! Halluna bi kwietna halli niccelebraw il festa kif irridu ahna, ahna qatt ma nthallna lil haddiehor kif jiccelebra l festa tar rahal tieghu. Viva Santa Marija !!!
sandra pace
Aug 24th 2010, 21:38
icelebrawa il festa ma nahsibx li ghandha x taqsam lghira jirraguna hekk min jara affarijiet materjali hekk tfisser il festa ? li taghti flus biex terfa l-vara? kemm hemm nies li ghandhom bzonn?. Fuq kollox qed naraw aktar kemm il festi huma materjali mhux din biss kull wahda li issir bdan il mod. xi tfisser il festa? traddizjoni li tghati l flus it tlellix u kollox ileqq? vera li kulhadd ghandu dritt jaghmel li jrid pero ftakkru li kristu ma ghazilx tlellix twieled gol faqar biex jghati ezempju. u zgur dawn lezempji ma ahniex nehduhom ghax kollox materjali.
Stefan Sacco
Aug 25th 2010, 08:28
Ms Camilleri, m'ghandi l-ebda dubbju li l-Mgarr ghandkom festa sabiha....imma huwa insult ghalikom l-imgarrin li qed tigu impengija li jekk ma taghmlux dan l-irkant il knisja ma tlehhaqx mal-ispejjez. Il Parocci l-ohra KOLLA ta Malta ilehhqu...intom tridu tirrikoru ghal dan biex tigbru il flus??? Hemm bzonn timbarazzaw il Knisja darba fis sena ghax it tradizzjoni?? Jekk fi 1920 kienu isiru zwigijiet bil hotba ghandhom jibqu isiru bil fors? Min irid jaghti ghandu kull dritt imma mhux nirkanta lill min jerfa il Madonna !!
Patrick Sacco
Aug 27th 2010, 21:32
Kindly wake up Ms./Mrs. Camilleri. We are living in 2010 and no, we are not envious of your worthless piece of wood/stone.
Christopher Grech
Aug 24th 2010, 15:18
Want to know about the truth on the Pharisees and who they are?
http://jahtruth.net/politics.htm
You might be very surprised!
Patrick Sacco
Aug 24th 2010, 14:46
Who said the Pharisees are extinct?
They are here with us!
They have read and studied the Sacred Scriptures and understood...NOTHING!
This is a perversion of the teachings of Jesus Christ!
Shame on the Church!
Christopher Grech
Aug 24th 2010, 13:09
@ Patrick Sacco
Well said! We are now living as in Noah's times (The End Times), and Judgment Day will soon be with us.
Catholics say that the soul will never die! Not true! See Ezekiel here:
18:4 Behold, all souls are Mine; as the soul of the father, so also the soul of the son is Mine: the soul that sinneth, it shall DIE.
Now the Catholics (and other religious denominations) who practice idolatry is a MORTAL SIN, and their soul, not just their physical body will DIE. That is why it is called mortal!
Thus said the Lord, and much in advance for all of you to repent from your sins. It is never too late for priests to wake up and realize all of this.
Some priests who are coming in the light are realizing this, but they must put actions in favour of what Christ stands for, rather than to the contrary.
In order to understand the Bible, you need a key.
http://thewayhomeorfacethefire.net/
Your understanding of the Bible and "The Way" of Christ would never be the same again!
sandra pace
Aug 24th 2010, 12:19
dear melanie cassar you can do what you want with your money but do you think this is charity you can burn them if you want am not taking any of mine for sure:-) do you think you are going to book a seat in heaven weell i dont think soo:-) well you can see the results of the comments :-)
Patrick Sacco
Aug 24th 2010, 11:30
ebay@mgarr.com.mt
Shame on the Church!
No wonder a lot of people argue 'Kristu Iva (Yes to Jesus Christ), Knisja Le (No to the [Catholic] Church)'.
If voting in favour of divorce is a sin, idolatry and greed are mortal sins!
sandra pace
Aug 24th 2010, 12:29
vera li min ghandu l flus ha jroxxhoom u int miss cassar of course ghamel bihom li trid flusek laqwa li mhux flusi ghalmenu niftahar jekk naghmel karita ma nmin ghandu bzonna anke l kristu bieghu ghal flus. paganizmu kbir and i fully agree with you mr patrick sacco. you are 100% right.
Abela J
Aug 24th 2010, 00:34
And all this with the blessing of the same Curia who declared voting for divorce as sin???
Are we talking about the same church founded by Jesus Christ?
Best said in Maltese:
Ghall-flus sallbu 'l Kristu, u jekk jerga' jigi jergghu isallbuh!
Malcolm Seychell
Aug 23rd 2010, 22:40
Alla ma jridx divorzju... imma milli jidher irid loghob tal-flus fuq min se jerfa l-istatwa... din hi il-knisja tal-fqir? ... x'ipokrezija! Ahjar 8,000 euro taghtuhom lid-dar tal-providenza, ghax dawk jaghmlu l-gid zgur.
Tscerri
Aug 23rd 2010, 19:06
Kollha tmaqdru l-knisja.. kemm hawn minkhom li taghtu donazzjonijiet lil foqqra? kulhadd idawwar il kliem t'Alla kif jaqbillu biex ikun komdu.. imiskhom tisthu!!
Abela J
Aug 24th 2010, 00:36
Min imissu jisthi, ezattament, Tscerri?
Joseph Bartolo
Aug 23rd 2010, 15:42
The Roman Catholic Church and all other Churches are The most wealthy societies on all the earth and out of their wealth they give very little while the loyal members of their so called faith, asks for other donations of money, food stuffs, medication and clothing, from the pulpit.
Do you think thats christlike ?
Please Read in your Holy Bible
Matthew Chapter:6:1 - 4 ( Giving to the Needy )
Matthew Chapter 6:19 - 24 ( Treasures in Heaven )
Matthew Chapter 6:25 - 34 ( Do not worry )
Matthew Chapter 7: 15 - 23 ( A tree and its fruit )
Above as you can cleary see is for sets of Holy Scripture, that our Lord and Saviour Jesus the Christ had preached to his followers on the Mount of Olives, also known as the Surmon on the Mount. Read very carefully with the help and guidance of the Holy Ghost and everything will be shown to you. God the almighty Creator and his beloved son Jesus Christ our redeemer in Union with the Holy Ghost help and guide you and your precious family and friends in eternal truth, life and happiness : )
Christopher Grech
Aug 23rd 2010, 14:59
@ C PACE
You write that everyone is twisting the Church's words according to his or her needs.
I am saying that the Church is twisting Christ's and God's Word in the Bible to her needs.
Christ's church is spiritual not in stone. Christ abhors statues, and idols and their worship, as can be seen below!
When are we to OBEY Christ as He says, rather than making up our own rules (be they the church's or by men)?
Steve Pace
Aug 23rd 2010, 13:07
" Stennejt hafna inqas minhabba is sitwazjoni ekonomika " ..... Prosit ... no other member of clergy could have said it better..... ISTHU !
Jason Borg
Aug 23rd 2010, 12:56
Every single day, hundreds of tourists are taken to Mgarr to see the church. The parish does not pocket a single cent from this trade, but Malta's economy benefits from the income. The church needs money for its upkeep and maintenance. Malta's economy and tourist industry do not fork out a single cent. The parish collects the money partly through this auction.
We should be grateful to this parish and community and not butcher them with unjust comments. Armchair critics please take note.
ray sacco
Aug 23rd 2010, 14:55
@jason borg:
so what is it exactly that you're saying:
that tourists come to malta to see the mgarr church???????????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jason Borg
Aug 23rd 2010, 15:17
No. What I am saying is that in our country, churches are considered as a major tourist attraction. Take Mosta Rotunda as another example. Over 400,000 tourists visit it annually, and enter for free. So what is wrong if money is collected, even through auctions, for their upkeep? Are those who came all out against this practice ready to dig into their own pockets to provide the necessary funds?
Stefan Sacco
Aug 23rd 2010, 15:42
But there goes the answer Mr Borg....Did the Parish Priest of Mosta resort to this type of shame to collect money??? Why try to find any type of excuse even if silly as it can be just to defend what is terrible wrong!!
ray sacco
Aug 23rd 2010, 18:49
grazzi kugin
Jason Borg
Aug 24th 2010, 14:41
Maybe the 2 cousins can substitute the money collected by digging in their own pockets. Mill-kliem ghall-fatti.....
Stefan Sacco
Aug 24th 2010, 15:30
For whom and when shall I dig in my pocket is none of your buisness I guess. Li Taghmel l-id il leminija m'ghandiex tkun tafu ix xellugija (gieli smajtha habib??) Facts are that the church in Malta does a lot of good things and yes expenses have to be met but this tradition is mighty wrong and has to be stopped sooner rather then later as it puts the Church in an awkard situation.Qisna xi subbasta tal Qorti !!!! If they want to donate money so be it but not payment against who will carry Our Mother's statue!! SHAMEFUL..... PUNTO E BASTA
A Galea
Aug 24th 2010, 16:50
Ok so if Mgarr church needs the money for its upkeep give it by all means. You can do this anonymously. But to pay for the rights to carry the statue on feast day is by no means charity for the church. What about the poor people of Imgarr, they will never get this opportunity. I do not care to believe in a church that falls to this mediocrity. Jesus Christ would have driven them all away as he did at the temple in Jerusalem had he been there.
CPace
Aug 23rd 2010, 12:17
Paganism.....idolatry.......divorce.........evryone is trying to twist the Church's teachings according to his and her own needs. The Church is not a commodity but a guide to live a life where you will be at peace with yourself. The Church is love thy neighbour, its assisting the poor, its giving out what you have to those who have nothing. This is Christ's teaching
Christopher Grech
Aug 23rd 2010, 11:38
Paganism at large! Traditions of the fathers is STRICTLY prohibited by Christ!
Who are we to obey Christ or traditions of our fathers? Your choice.
Christ would uphold the Second Commandment, which says:
2. YOU shall NOT create an image or likeness of ANYTHING that is IN HEAVEN, or on earth, or under the sea and YOU shall NOT worship or BUY such things. YOU shall NOT bow down to them or serve them for I the "I AM" your God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate (or disobey) Me; and showing mercy unto thousands of them that love (and obey) Me, and KEEP My COMMANDMENTS.
So, not ONLY they make statues, but honour them and SERVE them, and some even BOW down to THEM?!
Do you get the message?
In order to understand better this situation, please read my letter to the archbishop on how the Catholics (and other christians) break the Commandments!
http://100777.com/node/1931
d. borg
Aug 23rd 2010, 11:33
Shame, shame, shame. Il-knisja thanbaq fuq il-materjalismu, imbaghad anke biex terfa l-Madonna, irid ikollok il-flus. U min m'ghandux? Din issejhilha devozzjoni jew fanfarunati? Ghamlulna pjacir u sena ohra turuhiex fuq it-television.
CVella
Aug 24th 2010, 09:02
@ DBorg
U ghamel pjacir lilna jekk ma tifhimx x jigri tigix hawn u tikteb kummenti bhal dawn minajr ma taf xinu il-process. Ghal informazzjoni tieghek avolja il vara tinghata lill-aktar persuna li toffri flus din xorta tghati cans lil persuni ohra jerfaw il vara . Din is-sena stess wihed min nies li prova jihu il vara u ma rebahix xorta kellu ic cans li jerfa ghax xorta inghata ic cans mir-rebbieh. Jigifiri nies bhalkom li ma tafux kif jigru l affarjiet taqbdux tigu hawn u tiktbu erba paroli fil vojt minajr ma tafu xejn. Meta taraw xi haga hekk tigu tiktbu u tahsbu fil-fqar. Il-parrocca tal-Mgarr dejjem tghat sehema biex tghin il-ohrajn izda din hija tradizzjoni antika li baqet tintuza maz-zmien u li sa fej naf jien ma hu qed tamel hsara lil hadd. Fuq kollox dawn il-flus imorru ghal parrocca stess ghax min ximkien l-ispejjez iridu jithalsu u hadd ma qed jisforza il dawn in nies biex jaghtu id donazzjoni taghhom. Dawn jamluha bl inizzjattiva taghhom u ghaliex vera iridu.
axuereb
Aug 24th 2010, 14:44
Prosit!Mhi xejn hlief fanfarunati biex nuru kemm ghandna flus! Jekk il-kapillan ghandu bzonn jirranga n-nicca jaghmel gabra jew xi coffee morning, mela jghamel auction fuq il-vara tal-Madonna! Ahjar il-flus tawhom lil morda jew xi karita. Il-Madonna m'ghandiex bzonn nicca sabiha biex tkun aktar komda! Min jaf x jghid Gesu fuqha din il-haga kieku qieghed fostna! U l-Arcisqof ma jghid xejn fuqhom affarijiet bhal dawn!
Adrian Archer
Aug 23rd 2010, 10:58
Din mhix kwistjoni ta kemm titma tfal u nies b'8100. Min offrihom sinjal li ghandu u biex il-bid tibda minn 2000 Euro, sinjal li hemm min jista' jaghti.
Il-bicca hi li ssir auction biex tintrefa l-vara...din bis-serjeta. Jekk il-flus jinghataw lill- Karita jew ghall-familji fil bzonn, naccetta.
Pero tad-dahk il-bicca...jew tal-biki...ghax ma jitfghuhix ebay ukoll.
Irrelevanti fejn qed imorru l-flus ta don...is-sabiha taf x'inhi...li l-knisja qed tafghas certi regoli fuq min jorganizza l-festi...u fuq l-affarijiet li jaqlghulha l-flus, m'hemmx kontrolli.
GVella
Aug 23rd 2010, 11:49
In an interview on Super 1 TV, the Mgarr parish priest stated that the money collected will NOT be going to charity but will be used to build a new niche to house the statue of the Virgin.
Charles Busuttil
Aug 23rd 2010, 12:19
The crux is that there is discrimination towards those who cannot afford such exorbitant sums of money to carry the statue, and yet wish very much to do so. Because of this 'tradition', their wish may never materialise.
Joyce Cassar
Aug 23rd 2010, 10:43
This practice is an emabarrasement for me as a Catholic. There is no justification which can found in the Gospels for this and I wonder why those involved in the discussions on feast on behalf of the Church declare this practice as sinful!
Stefan Sacco
Aug 23rd 2010, 13:33
Well said Mrs Cassar. Sunday after the 15th August seems like will always be the Sunday of Shame for the Church I belong to. It really beats me why Mg Gouder ( for whom I have great respect ) did not put down his foot on this. This hurts ....believe me..it does hurt...and to be honest I tought something was goinf to be done this year.
Abela J
Aug 24th 2010, 00:41
Spot on Mrs. Cassar / Mr. Sacco..
Two weights - two measures
P. Borg
Aug 23rd 2010, 10:34
Have you ever heard of when Jesus destroyed all the stalls set up in the temple? This is what our church has set up in the place were we are supposed to meet god. The church sees only money.
I suggest that instead of this bid, the names of people interested should be written on a paper and placed in a box and random selection done. Those who have been selected the previous year would not be allowed to present their name to give a chance to everyone. At least in this way there wouldn't be any money involved. But no, our church is not capable of doing so because it is so fond of money that has lost all its' values. It's not a surprise it has it's own bank.
M.gale
Aug 23rd 2010, 09:51
this is all new to me!!!...how sad!! this is all i hv to say "money talks nd' bullshit walks".VIVA L KAPILLAN!
joe black
Aug 23rd 2010, 09:50
Well I can't understand why the church and authorities made such a fuss about games rooms or out lets and allow this shameful practise. It's still BETING isn’t it?
Maybe next year they get a sponsor too since the media is giving it such importance.
This is pure discrimination a restricted club.
Only god knows how many would like to have and not GAINS the honour of carrying the statue during the procession.
Maybe someone from the church big heads would like to comment and tell us if we have to BID to be in God’s favour and if cash counts to have a place in Haven
Alexia Vella
Aug 23rd 2010, 10:06
joe black it's rich of you to compare betting shops which are destroying our families and the Mgarr tradition.
Ernest Vella
Aug 23rd 2010, 09:45
mhux veru paganizmu sfrenat....din hija tradizzjoni ta post partikolari li minflok jonqfu l-flus f'certu affarijiet iwarrbuhom ghal xi haga li huma jhobbu....din ghira ghal gid li ghandu haddiehor...veru hawn il-faqar imma dawn in-nies kapaci jgahtu
J Deguara
Aug 23rd 2010, 09:38
People do whatever they want with their own money - totally agree.
However, when you think of families in poverty, disabled or taking care of disabled children and they you hear the church collecting money through BIDDING from feast fanatics then you feel anger and frustration.
We already have too many riches in our churches, we do not want to see any more competition between parish feasts, we want a stop to all this fanatism. Make good use of your money please.
Stephen Baldacchino
Aug 23rd 2010, 09:02
Paganismu sfrenat
joe borg
Aug 23rd 2010, 08:46
bejgh kollox u imxi warajja ?????????????????
dak bis-serjeta kien qed jghid jew xi cajta?
ghamiltu d-dar t'alla post tan-negozju!!!!!!!!!!!
din zgur cajta ohra!!!!!!!
ara dan kristu veru kien bniedem ihobb idahhak jew inkella hawn min ghawweg kollox kif jolqot lilu biex jistghana min fuq dar hadd iehor.......................
8100 euro taf kemm idumu jieklu nies bihom go pajjizi inqas ixxurtjati minna ................ jekk u meta jaslu hemm .............. ghax mid-dehera il-flus li jingabru ghal karita kolla jinqabdu f'xi tip ta burokrazzija u ma jaslu qatt ma jaslu fid-destinazzjoni
Joe Bonnici
Aug 23rd 2010, 09:50
joe borg flusek ghamel li trid bihom u ahna naghmlu li rridu bi flusna.
H Zammit
Aug 23rd 2010, 09:51
Mhux se nikkummenta fuq il-festa tal-Imgarr. Miniex minn hemm u nahseb qatt ma mort ghal din il-festa. Pero dwar il-kumment tieghek rigward il-flus li jmisshom intbatu karita nistaqsik. INT x'ghamilt din is-sena ghal dawn il-pajjizi inqas ixxurtjati minna? Kemm il-elf ewro baghtilhom. Issa qabbel dak li ghamilt int ma dak li ghamlet u ghadha qed taghmel il-knisja Kattolika bil-missjunarji, lajci ikel, flus u medicini li tibghat. Imbaghad tkellem. Ghax facli tghid lil haddiehor x'ghandu jaghmel bi flusu specjalment meta dan haddiehor hija l-knisja. Nista naqbel jew ma naqbilx ma kif jaghmlu l-festa l-Imgarr, izda b'daqshekk ma ttinix awtorita biex niehu l-opportunita (probabbli minnhabba xi haga ohra li m'ghandha x'taqsam xejn mall-festa tal-Imgarr) nghajjar lill-knisja.
J simpson
Aug 23rd 2010, 08:39
All these negative comments....do you know that the money raised also goes to charity!!!! Kulhadd jitkellem minn ghajnu l'aqwa li maqdru!!!
gcForte
Aug 23rd 2010, 08:28
@ All.......I wish to ask....If somebody left hundreds of acres of land, kilos of gold, lot of buildings, and money to the church, so he /she will have a guarantee place in heaven, would it be a sin ? In this matter of Mgarr, the way I look at it , is that they are bidding TO CARRY the statue of the Madonna, and not buying the statue, or the Madonna herself. Besides everybody can buy a statue of any patron saint. The size depends of how much you want to spend. Because of our catholic believes, nobody is going to give you anything for nothing, not even a small picture of a saint. Besides if my favourite football team wins a cup, I will be the first one to pay ,so I will have the chance to lift it and take some pictures holding it. The clubs can do it, to fork some money, why not the church ?
Andrew Scicluna
Aug 23rd 2010, 08:13
what s wrong helping the church , all those who disagree do they help someone with there money ?
Keep it up Mgar and never mind the negative comments said by those who diagree for helping the needs of the church.
Joe E Galea
Aug 23rd 2010, 08:09
Anke lil Madonna jirkantaw dawn il-kattolici. Il-kilba ghal flus mill-knisja hi inkredibbli.
David Torpiano
Aug 23rd 2010, 09:35
Taqax ghar-ridikolu...Il-flus imorru ghall-ispejjez tal-festa. Ovvjament huwa forma ohra ta' gbir ta' fondi biex dak li jsir jithallas. Hadd ma jisforza lil hadd biex jaghti l-flus sa fejn naf jien. Ghandek kull dritt li ma taqbilx ma' dan imma m'ghandekx dritt takkuza ingustament li qed l-Kattolici qed jirkantaw il-Madonna. Taf meta tirkanta il-Madonna? Meta titfa' t-tajn fuq uliedha, hemmhekk tirkanta l-Madonna!
Orazz Vella
Aug 23rd 2010, 04:15
Kulhadd jinterpreta kif jaqbillu hu. Pero hadd ma qall minn fejn hu ghax kulhadd jaf f'hafna festi ohra xi jsir.
Fl-Imgarr l-ispejjez tal-festa jithalsu mill-irkant u min jofri l-aktar jerfa il-vara, mhux veru li min ma jistax ihallas ma jerfax ghaliex tista terfa ukoll minghajr ma thallas l-ebda penny. U jekk tridu titkazaw ghax intefqu €8,000 bl-irkant araw kemm jintafqu flus f'festi ohra.
Fl-Imgarr il-festa kull sena issir minghajr l-ebda glied ta' baned u l-anqas tghajjir.
Frances Abela
Aug 23rd 2010, 03:52
You cannot stop this long traditon. Maybe the money raised is going towards their Fireworks, Fiestas etc. as well, & some to the poor.
...loved Mgarr last year on holidays from OZ.
E Camilleri
Aug 23rd 2010, 00:14
To better understand this "tradition" or "auction"... (call it whatever you like, no problem!)... one has to accept the fact that a certain amount of fundraising is needed for a feast and other church-related activities. This is just another way how a group of people VOLUNTARILY donate a sum of money to the parish. In other parishes there are other ways of deciding who will carry the statue; some bind themselves to put up & then remove the street decorations etc... I also heard of instances when individuals DEMANDED money to carry a statue! (how is that for some cheek?!) In some of the comments below I seem to detect a tinge of envy towards our lovely village :-)
jcamilleri
Aug 22nd 2010, 23:37
Dejjem ghandhom xi jghidu...basta kontra l-Knisja.
Issa m'hemmx tradizzjonijiet,... l'aqwa li niskreditaw.
Issa m'hemmx spejjes,... l-aqwa li l-qerrieda jgawdu minn fuq dahar haddiehor.
Huma biss jifhmu.. taghhom biss tajjeb.
Halluna.
m vella
Aug 23rd 2010, 08:44
J Camilleri you said , Huma biss jifhmu.. taghhom biss tajjeb, you are talking about the church right :)
Falzon G
Aug 22nd 2010, 21:04
Jesus entered the temple area and drove out all who were buying and selling there. He overturned the tables of the money changers and the benches of those selling doves. "It is written," he said to them, " 'My house will be called a house of prayer,' but you are making it a 'den of robbers.'" ------ Mathew 21:12-13
J.Xuereb
Aug 23rd 2010, 00:42
Good one!!! yeah that's the truth, and the church contradicts her own bible!!
F.Muscat
Aug 23rd 2010, 03:46
"Do not judge, or you too will be judged.
Matthew 7:1
John AZZOPARDI
Aug 22nd 2010, 20:55
Mind your business people who are against those people who made a bid to honor their village feast. I ask you doomsayers. Is it your money. If not, take a hike and mind your business What these people want to do with their money is their business and no one else. Where do you think we are lliving in a communist country. Why don't you go after the government for giving your money to people on social welfare.
John AZZOPARDI
Aug 22nd 2010, 20:48
Mind your business people who are against those people who made a bid to honor their village feast. I ask you doomsayers. Is it your money. If not, take a hike and mind your business What these people want to do with their money is their business and no one else. Where do you think we are living in a communist country. Why don't you go after the government for giving your money to people on social welfare.
m.ellul
Aug 22nd 2010, 22:40
or maybe apart from going to a hike, we can go to Mexico, right.
m vella
Aug 23rd 2010, 08:23
Mr Azzopardi,we will mind our own business but not when our children are watching this BLASPHEME on our TV.
Joe Borg
Aug 23rd 2010, 09:53
m vella since when have you become competent to judge what is blasphemy or not? Who appointed you judge of your brothers and sisters?
J Pace
Aug 22nd 2010, 20:23
What's next?....highest bidder is guaranteed a place in heaven????? I believe that such proceedings are totally against church teachings, but hereagain, as long as the church is not at the wrong end of things, everything goes!
Geoffrey Mifsud Farrugia
Aug 22nd 2010, 19:48
dont blame these poor gamblers who dont know any better. this is how they were brought up and their ancestors before them. blame the church authority that came up with these schemes, and for centuries has kept the control over the local populace by ingraining in the society and the people, certain cultural and folkloristic events such as feasts and what comes with them but not only as a form of social alienation. it makes sad reading indeed. money donated to church should be done in privacy and not by gambling who will carry the village statue. this is idolatry at its best and nothing else.
m vella
Aug 22nd 2010, 19:17
Money money money must be funny in a rich mans world PAGANISEM AT ITS BEST
sandra pace
Aug 22nd 2010, 20:05
Very disgusting that the church permits such more disgusting bidding to carry the statue. Does the church know how many people are in need? this is puuuureeee paganism and again disgusting and disgrace. The money should go to charity my god €8100.
Melanie Cassar
Aug 23rd 2010, 09:56
sandra pace who are you to tell me and others what to do with our money? If I want to burn my money or use it top eat and drink I will do as I please and no one including you is going to interfere. You do what you like with your money and I do whatever I like because frankly it's none of your business.
axuereb
Aug 24th 2010, 14:50
@ Melanie Cassar.
Qatt smajt bil-Puttinu Cares?Taf kemm tista tferrah tfal b somma bhal dik?Minn kliemek tidher li ghandek flus x tahraq, ghalhekk forsi tiftakar f dawn it-tfal darb ohra. Zgur li l-Madonna tiehu hafna gost bik jekk flusek ittihom lil dawn it-tfal minflok taghmlilha nicca.Grazzi.
Carmel Garcia
Aug 22nd 2010, 19:01
Jekk il-knisja ghanda bzonn l-ghajnuna titlob lil-Fidili u dawn zgur jghinuha. Mela naghmlu irkant jew lotterija minn statwa li qed tirraprezenta lil-Ommna Vergni Marija mtella s-sema? Dan x'paganizmu hu?
M. Vella
Aug 22nd 2010, 18:35
Yes, some less fortunate people will never have a change to carry this statue, which in a way is unfair, but don't think that the bidders are all well off people. For them it is an honour to DONATE the sum of money to the church (and here I mean Mgarr Parish Church - and not the church in general). Many of the bidders have ancestors who built and donated time and money for the building of the first parish chuch of Mgarr. The bidders are now following in the footsteps of their ancestors to make sure that they contribute to the upkeep of the church and its treasures. There is not much difference in this donation, than the "traditionally" envelope, that is distributed in every parish during the festa season. It is up to the individual person how much he wants to donate. Happy Feast everyone!
A. Catania
Aug 22nd 2010, 19:50
Actually there's a lot of difference from the 'traditional' donation envelope. In this case, the church is giving priority to those who have money. The church's decision of who is to carry the statue depends only on the amount of money offered by those interested! Double faced!!
David Aquilina
Aug 22nd 2010, 18:30
I was somewhat surprised and disapointed with this story. Only this year whilist on holiday in Malta my son Thomas who is 12 was asking me how people are choosen to carry the statues. I explained that i beleived that people were selected on merit on thier contribution to the church activities and thier village and what a great honour if you were selected. To read that you have to pay quite honestly disgust me!
Peter Korsten
Aug 23rd 2010, 08:46
Well, they do contribute, don't they? The upkeep of a church is not cheap. They had a serious fund-raising problem in my parents' village (in the Netherlands, so it's largely secular, even in the south) where the 15th century Gothic St. Lambert church needed several very costly restorations. There was a restoration from 1997 to 2002, and only recently they finished refurbishing the spire.
azzopardi joseph
Aug 22nd 2010, 18:23
Min jaf kemm hawn familji fil bzonn,ahjar taghtu donazzjoni lill karita milli toffru l flus biex terfaw statwa!!!! Issa taf x jonqos? Nibdew naraw il vari ta Malta fuq E-Bay.....
Grace Vassallo
Aug 23rd 2010, 09:58
azzopardi joseph int ghamel li trid bi flusek u ahna naghmlu li rridu u mhi affari ta' hadd x'naghmlu ahna.
David Hill
Aug 22nd 2010, 18:01
I would have thought it would be better to award the honour of carrying the statue to the group of people who did the most for the Parish over the course of the preceding year, not just who can pay the most. A saying involving Camels and the eye of a needle comes to mind
R.Borg
Aug 22nd 2010, 17:34
Can I suggest something to the Reverend Parish Priest of Mgarr? From next year, please, do not invite the press for such an occasion. There is so much ignorant interpretation around about this tradition. Having it indoors with the interested members of the parish community present as witnesses would be far better. The occasion is intimately connected with a very important Marian Liturgy and the Church should not allow 'malicious' interpretation.
lilian azzopardi
Aug 22nd 2010, 17:57
Well said R.Borg. This misinterpretation of this tradition and even confusing it with divorce is such an ignorant act. Come tonight and see what a wonderful religious feast we have. There are piques from local bands as we have none. If someone wants to give money to the church for the feast, who are you to judge us.
Stefan Sacco
Aug 22nd 2010, 19:43
Who are we to judge you....we are the church....ALL of us...the church is not building...its us....and I am ashamed that nobody has the guts to stop this shameful ridiculous act. ...Ahh Sorry I forgot...TRADITION hux??? We cannot stop it....ghax ila min 1920!! hemm bzonn kappillan ta vera li ghandu some guts f'dar rahal!! Il Bzonnijiet tal irhula l-ohra jintlehqu minghajr il bzonn ta irkant ta Ommna Marija !!
m.ellul
Aug 22nd 2010, 20:13
@lilian azzopardi if you are referring to my post, I am not confusing, I am comparing the acts and that is called reasoning, and none is judging anybody here whether he or she wants to donate money or not, referring to myself, I am disgusted by the instigation with which is used to make people to donate money, is it that much difficult to understand, and what religious feast...aaah yeah based on gambling.
martin saliba
Aug 22nd 2010, 20:42
The occasion is intimately connected with a very important Marian Liturgy and the Church should not allow 'malicious' interpretation. Please tell us what is so important that pagan betting is allowed. There are some people who are so blind that they would find some excuse to defend the church even if it church were to start worshiping satan himself.
J Pace
Aug 22nd 2010, 21:23
Rather than not inviting the press, why not dig deeper inside your pocket throughout the year to avoid such embarrasment!!!!
m.ellul
Aug 22nd 2010, 17:28
totally and utterly disgusting !!! ... this week the curia's pro-vicar said that who voted in favour of divorce would be going against Christ’s teachings and this was a sin. Is this so called "tradition' against Christ's teaching, NOT TO GAMBLE, or what.
Dr. Kevin Mompalao
Aug 22nd 2010, 17:21
And where are the church authorities? Don't they see anythig wrong in this? Why don't they take any action? Or is this something 'worth it'?
ray sacco
Aug 22nd 2010, 21:34
as long as there is financial profit, all is ok for the catholic church, mr,mompalao!
J Brincat
Aug 22nd 2010, 16:57
OIM (Only In Malta)
Jason Borg
Aug 22nd 2010, 17:58
It always amazes me how many people have never ventured out of tiny Malta or at least read a newspaper article about what goes abroad.
martin saliba
Aug 22nd 2010, 20:52
What goes on abroad ..... , Divorce , euthenasia , proper roads , accountability and much more. I didnt add abortion to the list as i am against it , but it to is abroad.
Jason Borg
Aug 23rd 2010, 07:23
Yes, as soon as you venture out of Malta, you start walking on holy land.
Jesmond Micallef
Aug 22nd 2010, 16:49
Money collected goes towards the upkeep of the church. And so it should, with all God's blessings, no doubt. !!
Should people here want to consider a serious argument towards values, well may I suggest the imposition of Church Tax then. In Germany, Church Tax is obligatory and there is only one way not to pay such tax and that is to renounce your belief officially. Indeed, most Christians celebrate Christmas and Easter, as well as other Christian celebrations and tend to think that they do enjoy the complementary holidays associated woth such feasts.
By the way, what about today, Sunday !!. Are there financial allowances that are paid when people work on Sundays, and during the above mentioned Christian feasts ? Why do people sit down and relax reading the news here on this day ? Maybe, its about time people reconsider their "values" indeed.
Awguri lill Mgarrin kollha min gewwa il Germanja.
P. Borg
Aug 23rd 2010, 10:28
Does it mean that if I do not have the money to pay the church tax you named, god will love me less than those who pay it?
Come on, this is totally non sense. Jesus was poor and yet loved everyone and this is the only thing that church should live by. Money are just something invented by humans to divide society into classes and be able to destroy some categories of people. Be sure that if our church imposes some church tax, many fanatic christians will probably leave. Some so called Christian maltese go to church only because it's free.
The church is well known for trying everytime to take money from our pockets in favour of its' preaching while the least one that practices it is the same church. These people are giving away their money because they want to and that's fair enough. But I hope that they are not the first to moan against utility bills. If they have so much money to throw away in favour of tradition they should have enough to pay the bills easily. God will still love and protect all no matter how money they give.
Jesmond Micallef
Aug 23rd 2010, 15:02
P. Borg. Your comment has valid arguments. I was only highlighting a different perspective to the negative comments here. God loves everybody. Giving or donating money has allways been a strength as far as social solidarity is concerned. Whats the problem with this sort of "auction" here ? Its a little bit of fun for a good cause really, and it does show that people still want to participate in the village's Christian Celebration. I tend to prefer such contributions which benefit the whole spiritual community rather then spending money on booze while watching popular collective football, for example !! I do have my own views about certain aspects of the Church but, I strongly believe that the Church does alot of good in society too.
G Falzon
Aug 22nd 2010, 16:31
What a pity! The Roman Catholic Church selecting a group of people (statue bearers) on the value of who can pay most money. Unbelievable. This is a replica of procurement by public tender where funds are the baseline. And Christ overturned the tables of the money changers when he visited the temple 2000 years ago....
victor caruana
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:59
And when we have all this saintlyhood, we want divorce!!!!!!
renald williams
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:56
assumption? according to papal history... may those who love Jesus read His Gospels and the rest of the New Testament... peace and health wishes to all...
New Catholic Encyclopedia admits that the beleif, that not only Jesus went to heaven with body and soul, does not originate from New Testament, but from forged writings of the 4th century (De Transitus Mariae).
Pope Gelasius 1, in 495, condemned this book, as forged and heretical.
papal quote- Dawn il-kotba miktuba minn eretici… Il-Knisja Kattolika u Appostolika Rumana bl-ebda mod ma taccetthom (De Transitus Mariae) … u l-Kattolici ghandhom jevitawhom. … dawn il-kotba… miktuba mill-eretici… nistqarru li gew mhux biss michuda, imma wkoll mwarrbin mill-Knisja Rumana u Appostolika kollha, u kkundannat ghal dejjem, taht ir-rabta li ma tinhalx tas-sahta (anathema), lill-awturi taghhom, u dawk li jaccettawhom.
Pope Harmisdas in 6th century, reconfirmed this condemnation.
Pope Nicholas 1 (865) also quoted this papal decree in a letter he wrote to the Bishops of Gaul.
victor pulis
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:53
@A Callus
Values?! You must be joking!
renald williams
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:52
assumption? according to Jesus and the New Testament
Only Jesus ascended to heaven, with soul and body.
U l-ebda bniedem ma tala’ fis-sema, hlief dak li nizel mis-sema, Bin il-bniedem… John 3:13.
Il-Mulej irtafa’ fis-sema u qaghad fil-leminija t’Alla. Mark 16:19.
U gara, Hu [Kristu] u jberikhom, illi nfired minnhom, u rtafa’ fis-sema. Luke 24:51;
U huma u jharsu fiss lejn is-sema waqt li kien (Gesu’) tiela’. Acts 1:10.
Dak [il-Mulej] li nizel hu dak stess ukoll li tala’ wisq ‘il fuq mis-smewwiet kollha, biex jimla’ kollox. Ephesians 4:10.
Gesu’ Kristu…Li mar fis-sema, u qieghed fil-lemin t’Alla. 1 Peter 3:22.
Only the body of Jesus, did not remain in the grave, and did not turn to dust.
Kristu, li ruhu ma thallietx fl-imwiet, u lanqas gismu ma ra t-tahsir. Acts 2:31.
Imma… ma rax (Gesu’) it-tahsir. Acts 13:37.
Dan nghidilkom issa, huti: Il-laham u d-demm ma jistghux jirtu s-saltna t’Alla; lanqas it-tahsir ma jiret in-nuqqas ta’ tahsir. Ara, sa nghidilkom misteru: Ahna mhux ilkoll immutu, imma LKOLL nitbiddlu. F’waqt wiehed, f’hakka t’ghajn, mad-daqqa ta’ l-ahhar tromba: ghax iddoqq it-tromba, u l-mejtin iqumu bla tahsir, u ahna nitbiddlu. 1 Corinthians 15:50-52.
renald williams
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:50
assumption? according to New Testament and early church history
Some Christians try using Revelation/Apocalypse 12, to teach that not only Jesus,
went to heaven with body and soul. But this also is against Christian teachings...
Kindly note Tghajjat bl-ugigh u t-tbatija biex tehles: a Scriptural sign of sin.
U sinjal kbir deher fis-sema, mara mlibbsa bix-xemx, u l-qamar taht riglejha, u fuq rasha kuruna ta’ tnax il-kewkba: U billi kienet tqila, kienet tghajjat bl-ugigh, u bit-tbatija biex tehles. Revelation/Apocalypse 12:1-17.
Qal [il-Mulej Alla] lill-mara [Eva]: Nkattar qatigh it-tahbit tieghek, u l-hbiela tieghek; bl-ugigh tiled ulied. Genesis 3:16.
Ippolitu-(it-tielet seklu) - Il-mara mlibbsa x-xemx, hu car li ried ifisser il-Knisja."
Victorinus - Il-mara hi l-Knisja; il-profeti, il-qaddisin, l-appostli.
Methodius - Il-mara li dehret fis-sema mlibbsa bix-xemx, u nkurunata bi tnax-il stilla, u ghandha l-qamar b’mirfes riglejha, u ghandha tifel, u qed tbati biex twelled; hi zgur li l-profeti xi drabi sejjhu Gerusalem, kultant Gharusa, kultant muntanja Sijon, kultant it-tempju u t-tabernaklu t’Alla. Hi l-Knisja.
Stefan Sacco
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:49
P.S Lill Fr Antoine Borg....Fr ghati telefonata illejla lill kappillan ta Rahal Gdid u jurik kif tlehhaq mal ispejjez u kif jirnexxilek tirrestawra u iggib knisja titaxxaq tidhol fiha imma minghajr ma zzeffen u tirkanta statwa !! Irid biss ikollok rieda soda u kuragg kbir biex dak li hu hazin tnehhih darba ghal dejjem
renald williams
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:48
assumption according to old testament?
Some Christians, to teach that not-only-Jesus-went-to-Heaven-with-body-and-soul,
try to use Genesis 5:24, Hebrews 11:5, for Henok, and 2 Kings 2:11-12 for Elijah.
But we use, till this day, the words ‘God-took-him’, as meaning one died,
and not went to heaven with body and soul.
But we use, till this day, the words ‘saw death’, as meaning facing a fearful experience.
So ‘did not see death’ means did not face death, in a fearful experience.
Even Paul says he ‘saw-drowning-three-times’ 2 Corinthians 11:25,
but does not mean he litteraly-drowned-three-times,
because obviously he would be dead-by-the-first-drowning.
As for Elijah they did not see him, not because he went to heaven with body and soul,
(an this is even confirmed by Catholic Encyclopedia),
but beacause he was taken somewhere else on-earth, 1 Kings 18:12 and Acts 8:39-40.
Heavens in Hebrew, samayim, means also to be just feet upon the ground,
even by being on a horse and/or on a tree, 2 Samuel 18:9.
Paul explains there are three Scriptural heavens,
birds and clouds are in first heaven Genesis 8:2,
sun and stars are in second heaven Genesis 1:14,
heaven where God is third Heaven Deuteronomy 10:14, 2 Corinthians 12:2-4.
robert micallef
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:41
so much money to go round in Gozo.... i wonder how much of it comes back in income tax and vat.....from what i hear not alot
Jason Borg
Aug 22nd 2010, 16:40
Mr. Expert - this tradition takes place in Malta not in Gozo.
Mario Borg
Aug 23rd 2010, 08:23
Mr Expert,
What about an apology to us Gozo Residents ?
Jason Borg
Aug 23rd 2010, 12:44
Lanqas biss jaghraf id-differenza bejn l-Imgarr ta' Malta u ta' Ghawdex u jrid jippontifika....
Stefan Sacco
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:29
Dokumenti kemm trid....diskussjonijiet u polemiki fuqhom kemm trid....imma kollox jibqa l-istess....Paganizmu 1st class....imma basta tradizzjoni....ma tistax tmisshom hux ghax ilhom min 1920's !!!!
M. J. Mallia
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:12
Am I missing something here? If money is to be collected, why is it not put towards a more deserving cause, rather than the upkeep of the church (for which, no doubt, there are probably enough funds)?
Ronald Debattista
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:08
@Maria..Have a break.have you got nothing else to do.
Your comment is digusting and yes I agree with A Callus,please do go to the Curia tomorrow and resign as being a member of our Church.
Please let people do what they want with their money and don't complain about peoples desicions. SHAME ON YOU.
roderick farrugia
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:04
so those people who do not afford to make a bid because of their respective finances cannot lift there patron at anytime............pajjiz u knijsa tal mickey mouse
Maria vella
Aug 22nd 2010, 14:26
Shame on the church to allow such practices. Is this not taking money from a family in favour of the church? Are these the same people who complain about the high utility bills, is this the same church that complains about poverty on the island yet allows such shameful ignorance in its favour? where is the curia? where are the priests who tell us about sinful decisions? I am ashamed to have been baptised into this organisation. Sometimes Ifeel I am living in a country ruled by the Mullahs against whom many of our belief take up. I wonder who is the worse of the two.
A Callus
Aug 22nd 2010, 14:39
You worry too much about things that do not effect you. If you are 'ashamed to have been baptised into this organisation' go to the Curia tomorrow and ask to resign as a member of the Church, you will not be the first but at least you will not need to live in such a hypocritical state.
Your comments are so out of point and it is obvious that you try to find any opportunity to attack the Church and the traditions of our country. You too are getting carried away by the plague of liberalism that is trying to erode the values and identity of our nation.
Raphael Vassallo
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:00
'You too are getting carried away by the plague of liberalism that is trying to erode the values and identity of our nation'
Well said, A. Callus. As exemplified by the above article, the 'values and identity of our nation' are founded on... MONEY.
Azzopardi Lilian
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:02
@ Maria Vella
It is an honour for the people of Mgarr to give an offer for the carrying of the statue. It is a tradition that has been with us since the statue was made. As Mr. Callus rightly said you are worryng too much about something that does not effect you.
Jason Borg
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:04
What should shame you is the fact that you are firing unfounded accusations at people whom probably you do not know anything about and who have done you no harm.
M Grima
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:07
@A Callus..all this has nothing to do with God and everything to do with idolatry aided and abetted by a Church who very often seems to worship lucre more than than the Deity Himself.
As to the skin hue's of the Statue,whatever they were before or originally or are now.If the Lady was from the middle east,you can be sure she was dark skinned with hair too match and not svelte and blond like some would have her.
M Galea
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:15
Vera hawn hafna problemi f'dan il-pajjiz. Imma ejja ma nghidux hmerjijiet l-ahwa ta, ghax kultant (jew dejjem?!) tohrog tradizzjoni ohra maltija... dik li ngergru fuq kollox!
Joe Vella
Aug 22nd 2010, 15:18
Who are you to tell anyone what to do with their hard earned money. I, for one wouldn't not bey one red cent for such a cause. However, if there are individual out there that are ready to do so, who the hell are you and I to tell them otherwise?
James Galea
Aug 22nd 2010, 16:02
Maria
You can leave the church when ever you want. But then please don’t go fashion parading in the church when you are invited for a baptism, a first communion or a wedding for the eyes of those who can look. People like you criticize the church because it is safe to do so and it so handy cause it does not reply back to you comments. If you read about the Maltese traditions you will learn that the Maltese always cherished their churches and always made huge sacrifices to keep them in good conditions. This is an agreement by the Mgarr’s community so that the money would go for the upkeep of the church. I do not think that anyone from Mgarr ever protested over this agreement and I do not think that you should do so yourself
Mike F Abbot
Aug 22nd 2010, 16:10
@Azzopardi Lilian
the church is taking money for no reason.... of course it effects people - it effects everyone. The church is supposed to teach moral values - not encouraging people to bid, to dig deep in to their pockets and the the pockets of their families to win the honour of doing something they love.
It teaches that money trumps all. (There are a few stories in the bible about that) The richer you are, the more money you can show, the more valued you are. Twist and argue it which ever way you like, and i'm sure many will... The lesson here though is simple. Money = honour.
I mean, come on, if it's all about love and respect, couldn't the church award the honour to members of the community that have contributed to the church or the community through effort and energy they've put in over the past year. People who have worked to improve the lives of others. That would be setting an example to follow.
And no, because something is a tradition, it does not make it right.
Grace Vassallo
Aug 22nd 2010, 18:09
Maria vella is it anyone's business what I do with MY money? What if I want to burn it, use it for drinking, eating, go on holiday or do whatever I want to do with it? Is it not MY money? You and the others attacking this practice simply want to attack our tradition and the Church, but whatever you do you shall not succeed. We shall keep our tradition and you shall not succeed in eliminating the Church.
C.Abela
Aug 22nd 2010, 18:14
I think everyone who is 'searching for ‘inner’ paths and this is a dynamic, that our forefathers, we and future generations will still be doing , will feel let down, when presented with this popular religiosity. Is this ‘popular’ way, due to our manner of expressing faith as Latin people? At times this is genuinely felt. However, our Island’s persistent, grave cultural limitations are a handicapped in making that ‘quality leap’. We are always risking stagnation and mediocrity. May I humbly suggest an alternative to this gloomy scenario, click taize', or jerusalem.cef.fr, on your pc, you will be relieved, at the bout of real fresh air.
Melanie cassar
Aug 22nd 2010, 18:19
Mike F Abbot who are you to question our tradition? If you don't like it too bad for that is what it was, is and is going to continue be. No one asked you for your money. We do with our money as we please.
Mike F Abbot
Aug 22nd 2010, 19:51
@ Melanie cassar i couldn't care less what you do with your money, Melanie. It's the way the church chooses to promote the value of money that i have an issue with. The church is supposed to be a community leader which means it is in a position to influence thousands of people and in my humble opinion should not be advocating things payment for honour. This is not about what an individual or group of people does with their money. It's about how community leader chooses to lead. And, by the way, if i want to question a tradition in my country, i damn well can do.
JOe VELLa
Aug 22nd 2010, 20:13
@Maria vella Boy did you get a mouth full from those who feel different! I must say if it is their money they are entitled to spend it as they see fit, if they want to work all year and blow it in a minute it is their concern. As it is if they want to help other instead or spend it to impress. It is written in 2 Timothy 4:5. But be you vigilant; labour in all things; do the work of an evangelist, fulfill thy ministry. Be sober.
Melanie Cassar
Aug 22nd 2010, 22:24
Mike F Abbot did the Church or anyone ask you for your money? You questioned this tradition and got your answers. This year it was €8,100. Next year it will be more whether you like it or not.
Mike F Abbot
Aug 23rd 2010, 07:57
@Melanie Cassar
clearly you are not reading what i am writing. I'm not concerned about the money, something that many people here supporting the church seem obsessed with. The church hasn't asked me, you are right but it HAS challenged people to publicly show their riches.
I'm concerned about the way the church promotes wealth. The richest get the honour. If it's so important to everyone - then €8000 is not hard to raise by simple asking for donations and including EVERYONE by allowing them to contribute what they feel they can afford. You might find those who contribute less, contribute far more.
And the honour for carrying the statue is still left intact.
oh by the way... the bible has a good lesson Matt 6:2
Charles Zammit
Aug 23rd 2010, 10:04
Mike F Abbot if the Church has asked the people and they agreed who are you to challenge that agreement? No one is forcing them to do so. They are happy with their agreement and they abide with it. Full stop.
Mike F Abbot
Aug 24th 2010, 08:12
Charles Zammit - the church is not asking, the church is challenging. It's providing a trumpet for wealth display. Read what i wrote - i have no issue with what people do with their money. It's what the church does to get it that bothers me. What is so hard to understand?
Mike Shortino
Aug 24th 2010, 10:29
SCANDALOUS!! The Church still uses practices to gain money it used to in the past. By brainwashing people into believing they are doing an honorable thing. Probably in the 1920s they were promised direct access to heaven when they pass away!! If they need money, which they should be using for the greater good rather then restoring the church, they could easily sell some the the riches the posses! The church has been one of the most successful businesses out there, creating stories and brainwashing us to be able to control us and make money. It makes me happy to see them getting exposed in this way.. because the time has come were people stand on their own feet and see the truth...