Advert

Windsurfer recounts 45-minute encounter with a shark

Updated -

A 35-year-old windsurfer from Valletta has recounted how he clung to his windsurfer last Saturday as a three-metre shark circled it for three quarters of an hour.

David Bonavia said that this was the first time in 16 years of windsurfing that he had seen a shark, although he had seen sharks while he was safely in a boat.

Mr Bonavia said he was off Fort St Elmo when he noticed a fin next to his windsurfer and he fell into the sea in panic. He quickly scrambled back onto his board and then could see that the fin belonged to a shark. It kept circling the board for about 45 minutes.

His initial efforts to wave for help were unsuccessful and he was also unable to pull up his sail because of the strong wind.

Suddenly the shark charged into the sail and bit a piece off, he said.

He then used a metal hook on his harness to hit the fish the next time it came near. The shark then started keeping its distance.

Eventually Mr Bonavia said, he managed to wave down a tourist boat which alerted the AFM and he was rescued by a launch and treated for severe shock in hospital.

Mr Bonavia urged other wind surfers to keep a proper lookout.

He does not intend to return to windsurfing 'for now'.

Advert

114 Comments

Post comment

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

Austin Zammit

Aug 11th 2010, 15:08

Defenetly mr Fenech MD

P.Galea

Aug 11th 2010, 10:38

Probably it was a shark, but no one can claim it was a Great White, unlike the one on YouTube that is shot at ... May I remind you that the doc about Sharks in the Med went to some measures as trying to see a live Great White and ended with a small patrol from our harbour and took hours fedding chum with nothing to see. Also remember the Maltese scuba doc that went to some shark sighting in Filfa and encountered nothing. So lets not raise a big alarm, occasionally we see sharks near our shores BUT I guess the biggest are among us and swallow us alive!

Ray Micallef

Aug 13th 2010, 00:34

Brava Charlene...that's exactly what happens to a shark! If you manage to cup its nose with your hand and turn it over..its like short ciruiting its brain, its nose sensors known as Ampouli of Lorenzini stop working in keeping the shark alert and it will stay there lifeless till you turn it back over again and release it. I have seen it done.

In fact that is now what experts tell us to do if , God forbid a shark grabs hold of you: either punch it hard in its gills because that provokes a reaction just like it would if you were to suddenely pinch someone's nose so they jump away because they will suffocate otherwise or indeed grab its nose or 'snout' as it is known and pull it up and back very hard so hopefully it will release its jaws around you.

Austin Zammit

Aug 11th 2010, 15:16

I am sorry to tell you that you are not an experianced surfer Mr John Zammit, you know that almost everytime you have not enough wind in the sail you tend to fall backwards not forward, this was David's case.

John Zammit

Aug 11th 2010, 17:46

Austin Zammit,, you dont go out with a harness if its not windy!! and yes it was a windy day when it happend. he even said that he had to do a water start! to do a water start you need a strong wind with a 5.2 sail!! im sorry but i still think that the whole see in his sail was done by him falling onto it!

Chris Borg

Aug 10th 2010, 21:20

why 'above all thank God that you are still here in one piece!'
since, by your reasoning, it was God's creature that attacked him in the 1st place. Just saying...

john darmanin

Aug 10th 2010, 21:37

I believe Mr. Bonavia.

So far we have only had this encounter. With all these Tuna fish farms around the island, I am not at all surprised about sharks coming in so close to our shores.

PAUL ZERAFA

Aug 10th 2010, 21:55

MY DEAR VICTOR PULIS AND JERREMY CAMMILLERI.
HAVING BEEN POURING TROUGH SOME PREVIOUS COMMENTS I CAME ACROSS YOUR ANSWEARS TO MY REMARKS.
PERMIT ME TO TELL YOU THAT I SAID THE WORD ""PIXXIPLAMTU" ACCORDING TO WHAT WE CALL IT IN MARSAXLOKK .AT THIS POINT KNOWING THAT YOU MAY BE ALSO KEEN ON THE SUBJECT ,I WANT YOU BEAR IN MIND THAT THERE IS ALSO A FISH CALLED"" PLAMTU "BUT THIS RESEMBLES MORE A SMALL TUNA FISH CALLED "TUNNAGG" OR A TUMBRELL.
IN OUR VILLAGE ,A HUTA BAJDA IS TO BE MEANT FOR A PAGELLA FTIT KBIRA , PAGRU
DENTICI AND SOME OTHERS.BECAUSE THEY HAVE WHITE FLESH.
THE IDEA OF CALLING A GREAT WHITE A GABDOLL IS QUITE AWAY .THE GABODOLJO AS IS CALLED IN ITALIAN WHEREAS THE WORD GABDOL DERIVED IS A BIG HARMLES CREATURE FEEDS ON PLANCTON DIVERS SWIMS TRANQUILL ALONG THE GABDOLL,TOUGH THERE IS SOME OLD STORIES ABOUT THE GABDOLL.
REGARDING THE OTHER NAME YOU SAID OF PORBEAGLE I MAY DEBATE YOU SINCE WE DO MAKE A LITTLE DISTINCTION IN THE GREAT WHITE ACCORDING TO THE NUMBER OF THEET LAYERS IT MAY HAVE.
YOU CAN PHONE ME ON 79425340
THANKS IN APPRECIATION.

PAUL ZERAFA

Aug 10th 2010, 22:00

TERESA PACE
WOMEN MAKES TOO MUCH FUSS FROM SUCH A STORIE'
BELIEVE ME ,A SHARK WILL NOT EAT MORE THAN HALF OF YOU.

Teresa Pace

Aug 11th 2010, 11:22

@ Paul Zerafa

Oh that's very comforting to know!

Chris Grillo

Aug 10th 2010, 20:36

I agree....what would David gain by setting this up? He would have more to lose!!!! Kuragg guy!

J.Borg

Aug 11th 2010, 08:48

Lets face it, this guy is no Rodney Fox, a survivor of a GWS attack turned into a conservor, David just had a very bad experience with a sea creature that probably both were aliens to each other. Personally what I do not fancy is the bravado experience ...

Harry Forrester

Aug 10th 2010, 17:36

Spot on! My point exactly (as mentioned further below or on the previous link)...For me, he lost all credibility by showing us the windsurfing sail, which is quite possibly the result of falling through it (if anything, the shark would have ripped the whole sail, not just the thin plastic component), and by claiming to fend off a 3m shark with a tiny harness hook...anyway, made for pleasant early morning reading...

Austin Zammit

Aug 11th 2010, 15:40

Bernard , you dont know the person and reasons why he goes windsurfing from Valletta and surroundings, and yes he was an experianced windsurfer but one thing you surely don't know is that when you are at sea, even the slightest shadow on the water gives you the shivers, let alone having a creature swimming around you. The only sure thing that happens is to panic and freeze in fear.

Chris Fenech

Aug 10th 2010, 18:13

You couldn't have said it better. Gee whizz, one wonders why no fuss is kicked about all the sharks on land !

isabelle borg

Aug 10th 2010, 11:25

I hope, for your sake, that you're not serious.

John Bezzina

Aug 10th 2010, 14:40

I agree with Mr. Buttigieg, in fact this was going to be my 6th point (see my other posting further down) but I decided to drop the issue.... Now, I am not too sure that I did the right thing... This story is getting fishy!!

R Vella

Nov 25th 2010, 04:05

Great white in Maltese is Kelb Abjad . Huta bajda is another fish. I`m not correcting you or something ;) Also i would like to add that some people said that in the case of Mr.Jack Smedley the shark was a porbeagle (pixxiplamtu) which to me is absurd. The British Navy divers found nothing at all ,so according to me it must have been a big shark. Mr Bonavia said when the shark or fish was beneath him it was white ,GWS doesn`t look white when seen from above.

Alex 'the Sharkman' Buttigieg

Aug 10th 2010, 09:23

The so called 23 ft shark caught in 1987 was never considered as the biggest and researchers always had doubts about the size. The reason for this was the fact that when the various parts of the shark measures (i.e. head, jaws, teeth, fins, tail, bulk.....) were compared to those of known specimens, these corresponded to the sizes of slightly smaller sharks. It is also worth noting, that in a report (with photos) published the next day, in the local "Nazzjion Taghna" it states that the shark was 18ft. long. What ever the case, It was still a big shark.

iCocker

Aug 10th 2010, 09:49

Thallatx il-hass mal-basal! Mr Scibberas

Sharks have a skeleton, tough it is made of cartridge and are invertebrates. Squids are mullasks! Sharks are not filled with water but muscle!!!!

Still the Great White caught in Malta was big, probably the biggest ever caught in the Med, still it mighthave been measured out of proportion. I remember as a kid seeing the massive shark being lifted up at Marsaxlokk, and in an eye of a boy it was massive. If we do not still have clear size, from the jaws, which I recall it is in private hands [pity is not in our N.History Museum at least loaned] one can still assess the size and also from the many photos taken, as you can easily compare with a human being!

Still the 'fish' that encountered MrBonavia, can't be labled at the WhitePointer, it can easily have been a Mako, a Pobeagle or any other one ... maybe David can shed more insight in what he saw as he saw the assailant face to face, he claims ...

Alex 'the Sharkman' Buttigieg

Aug 10th 2010, 10:33

Agreed. It is not normal for sharks to stick around circling a potential "meal" for 45 minutes without having tasted it and found it appetizing first. Sharks lose interest very quickly if there is no food.

I too have doubtful issues:

1) Why did Mr. Bonavia not try to make it back to shore but stayed there for 45 minutes? With over 16 years of windsurfing experience it could not have been such a big task.

2) Mr. Bonavia states that at times, the shark went under and "turned over showing a white underside". This is also not a known behavior and is very odd

3) A sail floats horizontally on the surface so unless the shark came up and breached directly through the centre of it, totally destroying it, there is no way to cause that tear. There are NO teeth marks.

4) According to Mr. Bonavia, the tourists on the rescue boat all thought he was tired but when he told them what happened, an "Australian" (coincidence?) said he saw the shark!!

Yes there could have been a shark, (you find these creatures in the sea), and it could have "bumped" the board, but this was no attack.

B Lanzon

Aug 11th 2010, 16:55

I wonder, were there tuna farms at the time too?? Or could it just possibly be that we are smack in the middle of the shark's natural habitat??

Stephen Baldacchino

Aug 10th 2010, 00:19

Just for everybody's Info....According to the Discovery Channel film crew which was hear to film sharks in Malta, They told us these words " If you Maltese would know what you have in your waters you would never go to swim" and when asked why, he told me that we are in the very center were the great white sharks gives birth to there young. Than I asked him why we don't have shark attacks like other countries and his reply was that they only come here to give birth and stay far out at sea and they don't come for food, they just give birth and return to there origins.......but some times one or more individuals will venture near shore. and if you don't believe, ask the guy in this video..

victor pulis

Aug 9th 2010, 20:52

Paul The great white shark is called huta bajda in Maltese the pixxiplamtu is the Porbeagle shark a close relative of the great white along with the Mako shark. Their caudal fins (tails) are homo cercal that is the upper and lower lobes are more or less the same size as opposed to the tail of the tiger shark for example. therefore when swimming near the surface the tail may not show. From the video clip there was no bite mark but a tear in the sail fabric, and just a finger sized hole. a shark would have bitten the surf board or sail to test if it was edible.

Jeremy J Camilleri

Aug 9th 2010, 21:09

Paul..A shark in Maltese is called Gabdoll..Pixxiplamtu is a Porbeagle.
Actually, kelb il bahar is a Great White, also known as huta bajda..

Neil Sant

Aug 10th 2010, 08:51

Actually 'gabdoll' refers to the sperm whale. Victor Pulis is right. Pixxiplamtu is the porbeagle shark.

James Herrera

Aug 9th 2010, 21:13

24ft = 7.13metres. My God that was some hell of a shark lol .... You sure about your measurments?

I. Galea

Aug 10th 2010, 00:12

same thing happened to my grandfather, a couple of years later. the shark was bigger than his luzzu. he said he thought it was tuna, so he tried to catch it, but turned out to be a shark which started thrashing about in the water and almost sunk the boat, then it swam off towards comino. Grandad never went fishing alone after that.

Neil Sant

Aug 10th 2010, 08:48

24 feet long? That would make it a world record! I doubt it was as big as that. Still, terrifying nonetheless!

Chris Ellul

Aug 9th 2010, 19:37

This "much fuss about nothing" as you blatently put it, caused this windsurfer much distress and a ruptured sale. By the looks of it you have plenty of experience with sharks and dolphins so don't withold your credentials. Can you say for certain, with your undeniable first hand experience, that this was indeed a dolphin judging by its appearance, movement and character? I think I'll stick to the windsurfer's story, not to mention the handful of witnesses. This guy was lucky he was not hurt!

Alfred Grech

Aug 9th 2010, 19:39

Dear Mr. Cassar, you are still young and if for any reason you do not believe that Great Whites are around I invite you to have a swim somewhere around the said area; if you have the guts!

Clive Xuereb

Aug 9th 2010, 20:39

Mr Cassar, Im a kitesurfer who spotted a fin on sat off Exiles sliema, i was kitesurfing around 200m off the coast. I have seen hundreds of dolphins and i can confirm this was no dolphin, it surfaced slowly, and very different than a dolphin, i hope u start believing

Claudio Carta

Aug 9th 2010, 21:42

Pixxiplamtu is a Porbeagle which is very close to a Great White which in turn is called Kelb il-Bahar Abjad.

This is a case of pure curiosity from the shark which could not make out what it was looking at and that is when it checked.

axuereb

Aug 9th 2010, 23:36

Good luck with that! I hope the authorities will keep a look out for this shark (?) for the safety of all undertaking the Malta-Gozo swim.

B Camilleri

Aug 9th 2010, 18:39

Yes Mr. Borg it is because of the fish farms that this shark was near Valletta. Come to think of it, how many fish farms are there in the Valletta area? In round figures please. Yes that's right ZERO, that's a nice round figure

Stefan Debattista

Aug 9th 2010, 18:55

How long do you think it takes a shark to swim from St Pauls Bay to Valletta Mr Camilleri?

Joe Gauci

Aug 9th 2010, 21:07

B Camilleri do you think it will take a hundred years for a shark to swim from the fish farms off Marsascala and the other ones near Mellieha and Gozo? This is apart from contaminating our seas.

RGatt

Aug 11th 2010, 11:19

Sharks keep away from polluted water.

Joseph Micallef

Aug 9th 2010, 18:22

I never thought that dolphins can be dangerous. I always considered them docile. Call me naive maybe! I never heard of a dolphin attacking a human being though!

Mario Busuttil

Aug 9th 2010, 18:44

Maybe i suggest everyone to see a Shark Week on Discovery channel or a similar program,only a Shark could do things that this fellow saw like goes around him slowly all the times so than it will attack instantly at the right moment and also sharks attack wind surfers or something similar that floats because for them it'seasier to catch ......

Harry Forrester

Aug 9th 2010, 19:55

@Mario Sharks typically attack surfers (not windsurfers), as when paddling on their boards to catch a wave, it looks like the motion of a seal to the shark circling beneath. Apart from that, I'm sure David Bonavia is relieved that he is ok, but some elements of his story seem a bit far fetched... i) hitting the shark with the metal piece of the harness - im quite sure that if a shark went to attack him, he WOULD NOT have been fended off by such a weapon... ii) the cut on the sail at 2:30 is nothing like a shark bite..it is just small hole in the sail - if a shark bit it, you'd see a much bigger tear..Yes, further on in the footage, you will see a big tear on the sail, but i have a similar tear in my windsuring sail as a result of falling through it..im quite sure a shark bite would have cut through the whole of the sail, and not just the thin plastic component.. The story could be true, but i think it is exagerrated.

Claire Busuttil

Aug 9th 2010, 20:17

@Joseph Micallef, Dolphins and also Killer whales, the amazing orcas, do not attack humans to eat them, but if they are nervous, being a big fish (also a dolphin can be huge compared to a human being) can be of course dangerous. My grandpa, while fishing on a small boat, in Xghajra, long ago, he was also attacked by a dolphin, who apparently wanted to play of tease him, but he for sure was terrified, until the animal went away!

Jeremy J Camilleri

Aug 9th 2010, 21:04

Dolphins have attacked, and even killed humans ...but a dolphin is not a fish...

Otherwise, I believe that this story is much ado about nothing. SHarks do not prey on humans, and even in shark infested waters, attacks are generally rare.

Greg Nowell

Aug 9th 2010, 15:36

I agree with your comments about The Oceans and Seas are the Sharks territory and home, but if you believe that there are plenty of Sharks in the Mediterranean you are sadly mistaken. Nearly all large species of Sharks Blues, Makos, Porbeagle and White populations have been decimated by constant overfishing and the global problem of Fining.
The windsurfer was lucky enough to see one, alive and swimming, which is more than many people can say. Sharks are not interested in us, yet our interest to have them in a bowl or on a plate is wiping out 100 million per year.
If this continues then sadly they will dissapear from the Mediterranean waters forever. Only a change of attitude and a willingness to make a difference will stop this.

Derek Fenech

Aug 9th 2010, 15:47

Just for your info the Mediterranean is a sea not an ocean

Jason Galea

Aug 9th 2010, 16:01

Wendy, bl-ikbar rispett imma ma nahsibx li qieghdha titkellem tajjeb hekk.
Jekk il-bahar taghna ma ghadux 'safe' li nghumu fih, nahseb ghandna dritt inkunu nafu QABEL mhux wara li tigri xi fatalita`!

Dr Francis Saliba

Aug 9th 2010, 16:22

Sharks are known to attack swimmers even in one meter deep seawater - not only in "deep" water!

Claudio Carta

Aug 9th 2010, 16:36

Sharks have always been around and just because something like this happened, it does not make it more dangerous than before. If it was a shark as speculated, it could already be miles off. Most of these sharks tend to keep moving and not loiter in the same area.

M.BEZZINA

Aug 9th 2010, 17:36

Kieku int kont fil bahar u tara pixxispad jaqbez hdejk ukoll tippanikja...ahseb wara kelb il bahar!!Ma nafx kif tirragunaw kultant...tahsbu li aw Malta differenti min postijiet ohra!!

Karl Axisa

Aug 9th 2010, 18:59

@ Dear Clive Rather than trying to get in the lime light, did you bother to log a report with the police as soon as possible? As far as I know Exiles is a very popular bathing area. Given the depth of the water there, an attack on unsuspecting swimmers was possible. I do reckon that on the day the sea was rough so most probably few where tempted to take the dip but.... Such a situation begs for civic responsibility as with all situations involving others.

clive xuereb

Aug 9th 2010, 20:47

Dear Karl, I love the sea and would not be happy of such sighting, if u think im trying to get in the limelight i can post my facebook profile with my comment before this story surfaced. No i did not bother to file a police report as i believed this was a large tuna, i never imagined a shark was few meters away from me. I take full responsibility of my sighting and my comments. Again i spotted the fish approximately 200m off exiles.

Advert
Advert