Windsurfer recounts 45-minute encounter with a shark
Updated -
A 35-year-old windsurfer from Valletta has recounted how he clung to his windsurfer last Saturday as a three-metre shark circled it for three quarters of an hour.
David Bonavia said that this was the first time in 16 years of windsurfing that he had seen a shark, although he had seen sharks while he was safely in a boat.
Mr Bonavia said he was off Fort St Elmo when he noticed a fin next to his windsurfer and he fell into the sea in panic. He quickly scrambled back onto his board and then could see that the fin belonged to a shark. It kept circling the board for about 45 minutes.
His initial efforts to wave for help were unsuccessful and he was also unable to pull up his sail because of the strong wind.
Suddenly the shark charged into the sail and bit a piece off, he said.
He then used a metal hook on his harness to hit the fish the next time it came near. The shark then started keeping its distance.
Eventually Mr Bonavia said, he managed to wave down a tourist boat which alerted the AFM and he was rescued by a launch and treated for severe shock in hospital.
Mr Bonavia urged other wind surfers to keep a proper lookout.
He does not intend to return to windsurfing 'for now'.
114 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
C.Mallia
Aug 11th 2010, 14:58
Did you know that sharks site seeing in Malta Could be effected by climate change? Now that the climate in Malta is getting hotter, Malta is becoming a host to many species which are adapted to this type of water. Do you remember the Man-O-Warrior (jellyfish) sited in the beginning of this year?? Do you think it came to Malta for a holiday ? -- it came because of Climate change and i will keep on saying this.
Another story: Yesterday on my way back to Malta from Gozo .. me and my family saw something in the water. It was 9pm in the dark and the Ferry's lights outside were switched off for some reason or another. I thought it was a low flying bird but some saw it as a FIN .. i don't know if it was a bird or a fish .. i know many people will start reporting more shark sightings after the news of this windsurfer, but i am not making it all up and what i've saw may be some kind of shark.
anyway ... i'm glad david is still in one piece :)
Fenech MD
Aug 11th 2010, 14:38
Are we sure that the increase in the number of sharks seen too close to our shores is not due to the Tuna fish farms?
Austin Zammit
Aug 11th 2010, 15:08
Defenetly mr Fenech MD
Andy Fransson
Aug 11th 2010, 10:47
Well, I do not know if this is true or not but the effect is severe... Now I need to do present a lot of counter arguments to my wife before she lets me go windsurfing :)
Joke aside, luckily no one was hurt - thank God for that. But even if this is true, a single relatively harmless encounter, does not pose threat to everyone. No need to panic.
Face it we live on an island surrounded by open sea... We all have to accept the fact that there are risks involved when you go out on the sea, whether on a surfboard or a cruiser...
J.Camilleri
Aug 11th 2010, 09:45
Why all this fuss when the famous discovery channel filmed about great white sharks in Malta. it's obvious even now with all these massive ships coming into our seas. Not surprised at all with this lucky escape news.
P.Galea
Aug 11th 2010, 10:38
Probably it was a shark, but no one can claim it was a Great White, unlike the one on YouTube that is shot at ... May I remind you that the doc about Sharks in the Med went to some measures as trying to see a live Great White and ended with a small patrol from our harbour and took hours fedding chum with nothing to see. Also remember the Maltese scuba doc that went to some shark sighting in Filfa and encountered nothing. So lets not raise a big alarm, occasionally we see sharks near our shores BUT I guess the biggest are among us and swallow us alive!
Charlene Gauci
Aug 11th 2010, 07:58
as far as i know the shark does not turn upside down. how come he said it turned and he saw its white side? if a shark is turned upside down it will enter a trans and sort of be hpnothized.
Ray Micallef
Aug 13th 2010, 00:34
Brava Charlene...that's exactly what happens to a shark! If you manage to cup its nose with your hand and turn it over..its like short ciruiting its brain, its nose sensors known as Ampouli of Lorenzini stop working in keeping the shark alert and it will stay there lifeless till you turn it back over again and release it. I have seen it done.
In fact that is now what experts tell us to do if , God forbid a shark grabs hold of you: either punch it hard in its gills because that provokes a reaction just like it would if you were to suddenely pinch someone's nose so they jump away because they will suffocate otherwise or indeed grab its nose or 'snout' as it is known and pull it up and back very hard so hopefully it will release its jaws around you.
nella bencini
Aug 11th 2010, 02:04
Between Dec 09 and march '10, while swimming in Fond Ghadir area, I spotted not one but two fins, and in both cases I was told they may have been 'tuna' ! About a month or so ago, again I spotted a fin going in a straight line between Exiles and Fond Ghadir... and the next morning, a tuna was found in the same area. So what's not to believe with this story?
We have fish farms which are too close to land, and we have endless cruise liners and sharks are known to follow them. See National Geographic on this subject, as well as the experiences of some of those who have encountered them and commented on this page.
I don't blame David Bonavia for not wanting to return to windsurfing, just like I will think twiice about swimming in winter on my own.
John Zammit
Aug 10th 2010, 23:06
I'm very sorry to say, but i find it very hard to believe that the shark did attack the sail. From my experience of windsurfing, when one panicks while being strapped on the harness, the immediate reaction is to fall onto the sail- since youre tied to it., which more often than not, results in the sail tearing. Also, the bite marks that show on his sail, resemble nothing at all like a real shark bite...it would look more like: http://i.telegraph.co.uk/telegraph/multimedia/archive/01449/surfboard_1449697i.jpg
The fact that his 'bite mark' is a hole in the center of the sail makes me doubt even more the entry point of the shark since no sides were touched!
Im not saying he didnt see the shark..im sure he did, but it is more likely that he panicked and tore the sail himself than anything else..... thats just my theory.
Austin Zammit
Aug 11th 2010, 15:16
I am sorry to tell you that you are not an experianced surfer Mr John Zammit, you know that almost everytime you have not enough wind in the sail you tend to fall backwards not forward, this was David's case.
John Zammit
Aug 11th 2010, 17:46
Austin Zammit,, you dont go out with a harness if its not windy!! and yes it was a windy day when it happend. he even said that he had to do a water start! to do a water start you need a strong wind with a 5.2 sail!! im sorry but i still think that the whole see in his sail was done by him falling onto it!
Joseph Galea
Aug 10th 2010, 23:03
May I ask, why all this scepticism?! Someone saw a shark, so what? why its so hard to believe?
For your information, there are 47 different species of sharks in the Mediterranean, 15 of them potentially dangerous. And guess what, Malta is located in the center of the Mediterranean and the waters around Malta, which are rich in migratory fish and tuna are one of their preferred spots.
The waters around Filfla are also a well know breeding area for white sharks (hance the area is protected)
So lets face the truth, its not that difficult to encounter a shark in Maltese waters (even if this truth hurts the turism industry who would prefer to keep this information hidden from everyone)
So, lets stop bla bla and say the guy is making everything up. He didnt said that he saw a talking shark, he said that he saw a shark which is perfectly normal and not something out of this world! (Like many people are trying to make it!)
John Buhagiar
Aug 10th 2010, 22:23
I don't know why so many are sceptical in believing this man...this is not a debatble sighting but a clear encounter...if it was not a shark then what was it? no one seems to give another suggestion of what it was that in 45 mins you wonn't be able to tell...45 mins would allow someone a very good chance to get a very good look...this ...circling behaviour is very typical of sharks...also the guy stoped and flagged down a tourist ship...agreed to an interview on the local newspaper...filed a police report and furthermore there were other eyewitnesses and physical evidence (damage to the sails) what more do you want...i challenge Mr sharkman in saying that sharks loose interest very quickly...they have been known to follow life rafts for months...never giving up on sensing that someone is in a vulnerable situatuion... furthermore a possible reason as to why the sails suffered limited damage could be due to the design of the sharks jaw which would make it very difficult for it to bite a flat surface as even though its jaw extends when it bites this is not enough to grip...
Teresa Pace
Aug 10th 2010, 19:44
You were indeed lucky. It must have been a terrifying experience. Fancy a shark for a pet? Too close for comfort. I don't blame you if you never go back to windsurfing. Thank your lucky stars but above all thank God that you are still here in one piece!
Chris Borg
Aug 10th 2010, 21:20
why 'above all thank God that you are still here in one piece!'
since, by your reasoning, it was God's creature that attacked him in the 1st place. Just saying...
john darmanin
Aug 10th 2010, 21:37
I believe Mr. Bonavia.
So far we have only had this encounter. With all these Tuna fish farms around the island, I am not at all surprised about sharks coming in so close to our shores.
PAUL ZERAFA
Aug 10th 2010, 21:55
MY DEAR VICTOR PULIS AND JERREMY CAMMILLERI.
HAVING BEEN POURING TROUGH SOME PREVIOUS COMMENTS I CAME ACROSS YOUR ANSWEARS TO MY REMARKS.
PERMIT ME TO TELL YOU THAT I SAID THE WORD ""PIXXIPLAMTU" ACCORDING TO WHAT WE CALL IT IN MARSAXLOKK .AT THIS POINT KNOWING THAT YOU MAY BE ALSO KEEN ON THE SUBJECT ,I WANT YOU BEAR IN MIND THAT THERE IS ALSO A FISH CALLED"" PLAMTU "BUT THIS RESEMBLES MORE A SMALL TUNA FISH CALLED "TUNNAGG" OR A TUMBRELL.
IN OUR VILLAGE ,A HUTA BAJDA IS TO BE MEANT FOR A PAGELLA FTIT KBIRA , PAGRU
DENTICI AND SOME OTHERS.BECAUSE THEY HAVE WHITE FLESH.
THE IDEA OF CALLING A GREAT WHITE A GABDOLL IS QUITE AWAY .THE GABODOLJO AS IS CALLED IN ITALIAN WHEREAS THE WORD GABDOL DERIVED IS A BIG HARMLES CREATURE FEEDS ON PLANCTON DIVERS SWIMS TRANQUILL ALONG THE GABDOLL,TOUGH THERE IS SOME OLD STORIES ABOUT THE GABDOLL.
REGARDING THE OTHER NAME YOU SAID OF PORBEAGLE I MAY DEBATE YOU SINCE WE DO MAKE A LITTLE DISTINCTION IN THE GREAT WHITE ACCORDING TO THE NUMBER OF THEET LAYERS IT MAY HAVE.
YOU CAN PHONE ME ON 79425340
THANKS IN APPRECIATION.
PAUL ZERAFA
Aug 10th 2010, 22:00
TERESA PACE
WOMEN MAKES TOO MUCH FUSS FROM SUCH A STORIE'
BELIEVE ME ,A SHARK WILL NOT EAT MORE THAN HALF OF YOU.
Teresa Pace
Aug 11th 2010, 11:22
@ Paul Zerafa
Oh that's very comforting to know!
Fiona Vella
Aug 10th 2010, 18:41
Obviously I cannot say whether Mr Bonavia is telling the truth or not. But each year during the summer season, we hear such stories which eventually (and thankfully) turn out to be fake.
I regard such bad humour as acts of cruelty since once such stories are out, people get terrified of swimming and the lovely summer season turns sour for them.
I do hope that should the respective authorities confirm that such individuals have been making up a story to cause public alarm or to attract attention, relevant actions are taken against them.
louise barbara
Aug 10th 2010, 18:39
shame on all of you , whom are making this story as if it was made up or not true. david bonavia has nothing to do with tourism , he is just a normal guy , that has the sea for passion. he didn't ask for the media , but seeing that the media called for an interview , he felt that he had to say something about his shocking experience , for the people's lives , as to be careful not to not to go swimming, and instead of appreciation he is getting negativity from some people . well it was a sincere warning from a personal experience , but in a way sometimes its better to shut up ,and warn the people whom you know , cause this is what you get back , from being kind hearted enough for the sake of other people . thanks to all that supported
Chris Grillo
Aug 10th 2010, 20:36
I agree....what would David gain by setting this up? He would have more to lose!!!! Kuragg guy!
J.Borg
Aug 11th 2010, 08:48
Lets face it, this guy is no Rodney Fox, a survivor of a GWS attack turned into a conservor, David just had a very bad experience with a sea creature that probably both were aliens to each other. Personally what I do not fancy is the bravado experience ...
Charles Grima
Aug 10th 2010, 18:09
I do not know David Bonavia, but really, I don't see why people should doubt him and subject his experience to ridicule.
My brother is in the AFM rescue, and the stories he tells me of illegal immigrants brought up (by him personally) from the depths especially near Filfla, largely bitten through, is nothing short of hair-raising. Half-moon bites across from arm-pit to thighs are common...
And having seen proof myself, I am not only inclined to believe, but cannot imagine why people should doubt David Bonavia.
With our fish farms, I cannot think of a reason why we do not have more sightings... free food for what is basically an eating machine.
People find it easy to mock...and I don't really care...I know it's the truth.
j micallef
Aug 10th 2010, 18:02
Considering that we have a large fish farm smack in the mouth of St.Paul's Bay and very, very close to the shore, people should be warned that the odds of having predators around is not insignificant. Families - locals and tourists - throng the shores and beaches of St.Paul's Bay and Qawra - oblivious of the ominous dangers lurking beneath them or close to them because of the close proximity of the fish farm.
Whatever happened to the solemn promise by Government (I still remember ex-Minister Refalo saying it during his term of office) that fish farms were all to be re-located at least 6 kilometers out at sea, and somewhere off Delimara !
Steve Sant
Aug 10th 2010, 17:46
I believe it, because about 25 years ago, sailing with a mirror 10 in the same place, me and my friend Peter Paul saw this huge shadow under the boat. We both got a shock and sat in the middle of the mirror 10 for almost ten minutes. It was much larger than the sailing boat I remember and it was quite a shock to both of us. A few years later, me and my brother saw a large fish, same place, come up and roll over, it had no fin but it was huge. We were in a 21 foot boat this time and it rocked us about with its rolling. I can assure you, large fish do come in and out of this port.
M.Avellino
Aug 10th 2010, 17:20
Where is the theme from jaws?
Elton Grech
Aug 10th 2010, 16:39
Shark Attack ?
For one I've been more intrigued by the number of Shark Experts thanks to the Discovery Channel than by the attack in itself.
S MICALLEF
Aug 10th 2010, 16:19
WITH ALL DUE RESPECT TO THE INTEGRITY OF MR BONAVIA, I CANT FOR THE LIFE OF ME IMAGINE HOW AFTER HAVING A SHARK SWIMMING AROUND YOU FOR 45 MINUTES AND EVEN GETTING SO CLOSE THAT HE HAD TO FEND IT AWAY WITH HIS HOOK, HE STILL CANT BE SURE IF THE FISH WAS A SHARK OR NOT. MAYBE WE SHOULDNT EXPECT HIM TO TELL US WHAT SPECIES OF SHARK IT WAS , HOWEVER HE SHOULD BE CERTAIN THAT IT WAS A SHARK. I HOPE THAT THIS HAS'NT GOT ANYTHING TO DO WITH THE FAKE STORIES WE HAD LAST YEAR ABOUT A "GREAT WHITE " WHICH WAS PULLED ONTO THE SHORE AT ST GEORGES BEACH.
iS IT POSSIBLE THAT SOMEONE IS TRYING TO HARM THE TOURISM INDUSTRY? I WONDER.
Bernard Galea
Aug 10th 2010, 16:15
This is potentially one of the ludicrous stories I have ever heard in my life...
1. A shark circling for 45 minutes is highly unlikely. It is highly unlikely that a shark would express such continued curiousity in Mr. Bonavia... was he bleeding or injured?
2. As someone who windsurfs regularly... The idea of hitting the shark with the 'metal' part of the harness is senseless. The idea of Mr. Bonavia 'valiantly' repelling the shark with this bit of metal (which is just over half a metre long) while heroic.. is daft.
3. The hole in the sail as shown in the picture, is symptomatic of a sail being torn as the windsurfer falls through it, an all too common occurrence in windsurfing.
4. Mr. Bonavia, if you have been windsurfing for 16 years... then why the choice of Fort St. Elmo? Hardly a known hotspot for windsurfing in the islands, especially given the wind direction on Saturday.
5. Mr. Bonavia, if you have been windsurfing for 16 years, uphauling the sail would be unnecessary.. certainly you would been able to waterstart quickly (a basic windsurfing skill)... where strong wnids are not a hindrance... but a help.
Harry Forrester
Aug 10th 2010, 17:36
Spot on! My point exactly (as mentioned further below or on the previous link)...For me, he lost all credibility by showing us the windsurfing sail, which is quite possibly the result of falling through it (if anything, the shark would have ripped the whole sail, not just the thin plastic component), and by claiming to fend off a 3m shark with a tiny harness hook...anyway, made for pleasant early morning reading...
Austin Zammit
Aug 11th 2010, 15:40
Bernard , you dont know the person and reasons why he goes windsurfing from Valletta and surroundings, and yes he was an experianced windsurfer but one thing you surely don't know is that when you are at sea, even the slightest shadow on the water gives you the shivers, let alone having a creature swimming around you. The only sure thing that happens is to panic and freeze in fear.
D.Bonello
Aug 10th 2010, 12:55
I know the guy personally for a long time. He's not the type who make up stories. If he said he encountered a shark i suggest people to be aware. Who watch discovery channel knows that Malta makes part of a triangle where the great white shark often is found. Besides if you ask fishermen, they will tell you that its not the first time a shark was caught. I for one, will be cautious when i go swimming.
N. Attard
Aug 10th 2010, 12:31
I cannot understand all this fuss. The shark was seen in the sea, and not walking on the pavement or shopping in sliema. These creatures belong to the sea and there is where they are expected to be.
Sharks are the ones in danger from us and not vice versa. Their numbers have been dwindling a lot especially thanks to the nonsense shark fin soup delicacy in Asian countries. Shark attacks are very rare and it is only in films that these animals are relentless killers.
L Vella
Aug 10th 2010, 12:22
kullhadd gharef sakemm jigu hu wicc ma wicc ma xi Great White - the Med is the breathing place for sharks - the tuna of last month (which was washed up ashore) is not part of the norm to find it lying on the Sliema shores! i dont think it was sunbathing!
we do have sharks - depends on how many fish farms we are going to do...the more over fishing we have the more sharks will lurk in our waters!!!!!
R. Azzopardi
Aug 10th 2010, 11:43
Stop kicking up a fuss. The sea belongs to sea creatures, not to humans. They have every right to be there. I would be just as petrified as this gentleman if I were to see one but one sighting is not going to stop me from practicing my favourite pastime - scuba diving. I've got dives planned almost every day this week and I'm not going to cancel them.
J Brincat
Aug 10th 2010, 11:40
With all the tuna farming in our midst, it is a wonder that such sighting are not more frequent - unless they are and we are not told!
Francesca Vincenti
Aug 10th 2010, 10:41
It is possible that David Bonavia encountered a shark - and yes it could also have been a curious Tuna. Both are common in our waters at this time of the year as the great white notoriously follows the tuna migration routes. Surfboards draw curiosity since they resemble turtles to a shark, a natural food source for them. It would be a mistake to doubt that sharks do not frequent (although sadly not too regularly) our waters. Being a windsurfer myself, I have sailed around our shores in all seasons since 1981. I have encountered a total of 6 sharks to date. The largest one however, was not spotted locally but between Malta/Sicily in the 80's during a race. It trailed me closely in light winds & calm clear water for a number of minutes before sinking into the deep again. Please remember that sharks play a vital role in keeping the delicate balance of the seas in check & such sightings give hope that the seas are still alive & kicking. They are not to be feared but protected. So before poking fun at someone's experience or going on a mission to destroy sharks - THINK
Chris Fenech
Aug 10th 2010, 18:13
You couldn't have said it better. Gee whizz, one wonders why no fuss is kicked about all the sharks on land !
A.Galea
Aug 10th 2010, 10:28
Be Careful...Better safe than sorry!!!!
Jon Abela
Aug 10th 2010, 09:54
History repeats itself. Synonymous to this event was the fatal Great White shark attack upon Jack Smedly in St. Thomas Bay. The continous practice of breeding large fish close to our shores will result in attracting larger and dangerous species such as sharks towards our shores. This issue has been repeatedly been proven within the Meditterranean throughout the years. A lucky escape for Mr. Bonavia. Let's not get into detail of the real name of the GWS. The facts are simple: Tuna Farms= GWS or Mako's. Now it's up to the authorithies to anaylse such situations and evaluate the consequences and probabilities of repetitive episodes like these. Sharks have always been present in the Med and we cannot stop them from living and breeding around our waters.
G.J Buttigieg
Aug 10th 2010, 09:39
Dear All,
I am abit cynical. Could this be a stunt which might have to do with giving free exposure of the energy drink on the gentleman's t shirt recently introduced to Malta. One might ask?
isabelle borg
Aug 10th 2010, 11:25
I hope, for your sake, that you're not serious.
John Bezzina
Aug 10th 2010, 14:40
I agree with Mr. Buttigieg, in fact this was going to be my 6th point (see my other posting further down) but I decided to drop the issue.... Now, I am not too sure that I did the right thing... This story is getting fishy!!
J.Borg
Aug 10th 2010, 09:36
Mr Bonavia,
I believe you that you have been bumped in by a shark, which from your account was acting more out of curiosity and more interested in the board and sail, still you were in danger of receiving a bite to check what was the strange object of interest.
But if you had doubt what BIG fish was; so how come you had chance to see the attacker face to face 'biting' your sail and you had your chance to defend with your belt? Sorry the last part is very romanticised ...
sharon gauci
Aug 10th 2010, 09:27
Oh please, now that we saw a "fish"its suddenly a shark. Actually no even better its a white shark. How sure are we that this was a shark or not some other big fish.I remember years ago when they thought the same and suddenly the fin belonged to another type of fish. I am sure that in the Maltese waters there are sharks around however thanks to our lovely fishing nets they are caught, slaughtered and most probably end up on our dish being sold as another sort. I am looking forward to see if we suddenly start hunting all the sharks in our water cos they are dangerous... wouldnt be surprised.
P. Azzopardi
Aug 10th 2010, 08:27
I don't know what's swimming out there, but maybe the shark was actually here for a reason. Keep in mind that a month ago a dead tuna was washed ashore at Ghar id-Dud Sliema, which isn't very far from where the windsurfer encountered the shark.
http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20100716/local/somethings-fishy
http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20100715/local/dead-fish-causes-sliema-inconvenience
L Vella
Aug 10th 2010, 08:18
greenpeace and sea shepherd were right few months ago! leave the tuna in the sea - free - the more tuna farms and fish farms we are having the more sharks we are attracting. The Med is the breathing place of great whites and believe me the bite in the sail aint no bite of a tuna or dolphin! its summer and the authorities dont want to scare the people from swimming. just be careful not to attract them! Thank God nothing happened to Mr. Bonavia and hope you recover well from your shock :) I dont blame you...its an experience you will never forget!
Susan Farrugia
Aug 10th 2010, 08:16
Maltese idea of fish, big fish = Great White SHARKKKKKKKKKK!!!!!! lol he wasn’t hungry took him 45min without eating him or he wanted to play hux.
C.L.Attard
Aug 10th 2010, 04:54
This report raises such a rumpus, yet isnt it ironic that we Maltese give the Great White the most humble, no-frills name possible - Huta Bajda? :-)
I dont see the need to make any fuss or panic. Given the vast amount of water sport and activities that go on in our waters every day, such an incident is so rare as to be deserve to be called a freak incident. As scary as it was for Mr Bonavia, we all know we're an island surrounded by sea, which is the home of all kinds of fish, including sharks. They have more right to be there than we do. Im sure windsurfers take this as part of the deal, as do their counterparts in other countries.
Then of course if we choose to breed their food within our immediate waters, slaughter tuna with the blood that creates, etc, can we really be so surprised if the odd shark happens to stroll in for a sniff? If anything let's consider ourselves lucky such incidents are and stay that way.
R Vella
Nov 25th 2010, 04:05
Great white in Maltese is Kelb Abjad . Huta bajda is another fish. I`m not correcting you or something ;) Also i would like to add that some people said that in the case of Mr.Jack Smedley the shark was a porbeagle (pixxiplamtu) which to me is absurd. The British Navy divers found nothing at all ,so according to me it must have been a big shark. Mr Bonavia said when the shark or fish was beneath him it was white ,GWS doesn`t look white when seen from above.
P Sciberras
Aug 10th 2010, 01:59
Some years ago we saw a documentary on Great Whites. Interestingly enough, it was said that the largest Great White ever caught was in Malta. Here is some info taken from
http://dsc.discovery.com/sharks/largest-great-white-shark.html ;
Turning the page away from fishing lore to the scientific literature still reveals discrepancy and confusion about great white size. Over the past two decades, most researchers accepted that the largest great white was a 23-foot individual caught in 1987 off the coast of Malta by Alfredo Cutajar. More recent studies on information concerning the specimen suggest its length had been exaggerated. One possible problem is that sharks, like all fish, are composed mostly of water. As a result, they can dry out and shrink over time. This happened in 2008 to a colossal squid housed at the Te Papa museum in New Zealand. There is no question the squid shrunk after months of storage upon capture, but now the measurements only reflect its size upon validated scientific examination.
Alex 'the Sharkman' Buttigieg
Aug 10th 2010, 09:23
The so called 23 ft shark caught in 1987 was never considered as the biggest and researchers always had doubts about the size. The reason for this was the fact that when the various parts of the shark measures (i.e. head, jaws, teeth, fins, tail, bulk.....) were compared to those of known specimens, these corresponded to the sizes of slightly smaller sharks. It is also worth noting, that in a report (with photos) published the next day, in the local "Nazzjion Taghna" it states that the shark was 18ft. long. What ever the case, It was still a big shark.
iCocker
Aug 10th 2010, 09:49
Thallatx il-hass mal-basal! Mr Scibberas
Sharks have a skeleton, tough it is made of cartridge and are invertebrates. Squids are mullasks! Sharks are not filled with water but muscle!!!!
Still the Great White caught in Malta was big, probably the biggest ever caught in the Med, still it mighthave been measured out of proportion. I remember as a kid seeing the massive shark being lifted up at Marsaxlokk, and in an eye of a boy it was massive. If we do not still have clear size, from the jaws, which I recall it is in private hands [pity is not in our N.History Museum at least loaned] one can still assess the size and also from the many photos taken, as you can easily compare with a human being!
Still the 'fish' that encountered MrBonavia, can't be labled at the WhitePointer, it can easily have been a Mako, a Pobeagle or any other one ... maybe David can shed more insight in what he saw as he saw the assailant face to face, he claims ...
Stephen Baldacchino
Aug 10th 2010, 00:05
last year in July we were 16 miles of ghar dalam me and my friend with two boats fishing and a shark fin surfaced between us but after a couple of seconds it went down under the boat and never saw it again. In front of us tuna was jumping so I think it was more interested in the tuna than to a fiber glass boat. we calculated it was a 15-16 ft shark but don't know what kind it was. the fine was some 2ft high. It was a bit scary but me on a boat, it was interesting, not like this man which was face to face in the water with him. I think he was more than lucky that it attacked the sail not the board.
M Warrington
Aug 9th 2010, 23:31
Imma anke fuq huta irridu naqbdu polemika!!!! Mr. Bonavia thank God you were unhurt! Swimmers, windsurfers watch out!!
John Bezzina
Aug 9th 2010, 22:49
5 things strike me as odd...
a) How come it took Mr. Bonavia 45 min to encounter a boat, in what is a relatively busy location with all the comings and goings to the harbour. Not to mention the fact that this point might also be visible from numerous points on land.
b) How come Mr. Bonavia was unable to identify the type of fish that he encountered. I am sure that after 45 min I would have at least a minimal idea of the looks of this creature and try to identify it from the Internet.
c) It struck me as odd that a shark would spend 45 min going around and around Mr. Bonavia and doing nothing else... is this normal behaviour?
d) 1 minuscule hole in the windsurfer does not strike me as being produced by a tooth, I am no shark expert but I am sure that a 3 meter shark would produce much more damage had he bitten the sale.
e) How come a boat full of tourists and no one took a photo of this creature?
Enlightenment please!!
Alex 'the Sharkman' Buttigieg
Aug 10th 2010, 10:33
Agreed. It is not normal for sharks to stick around circling a potential "meal" for 45 minutes without having tasted it and found it appetizing first. Sharks lose interest very quickly if there is no food.
I too have doubtful issues:
1) Why did Mr. Bonavia not try to make it back to shore but stayed there for 45 minutes? With over 16 years of windsurfing experience it could not have been such a big task.
2) Mr. Bonavia states that at times, the shark went under and "turned over showing a white underside". This is also not a known behavior and is very odd
3) A sail floats horizontally on the surface so unless the shark came up and breached directly through the centre of it, totally destroying it, there is no way to cause that tear. There are NO teeth marks.
4) According to Mr. Bonavia, the tourists on the rescue boat all thought he was tired but when he told them what happened, an "Australian" (coincidence?) said he saw the shark!!
Yes there could have been a shark, (you find these creatures in the sea), and it could have "bumped" the board, but this was no attack.
Xmun Abela
Aug 9th 2010, 22:48
Tuna attracts Preadators....The larger the prey.......The larger hunter.... What do you expect ? - I've got no problems with regulations as regards fisheries and but it is a fact....
M Micallef
Aug 9th 2010, 22:16
In the 80s and early 90s I worked on the sea - almost constantly. I saw Sharks around Malta and numerous ones.
It is rare to see them so near the coast - but not impossible;
I have seen sharks coming close to the boat I was on - and showing behaviour very similar to the one described by the surfer.
They seem not sure about our presence - and if they are hungry they may probe and stay around to see whether they can get an easy meal. I think the shadow of a windsurfer will definately attract an inquisitive shark. Also they try to assess what type of material they are dealing with - if they sense metal, plastics etc they may loose interest and go away.
Very difficult to say whether this is a great white or not - but I have doubts - if this was a gerat white, he would not still be alive.
B Lanzon
Aug 11th 2010, 16:55
I wonder, were there tuna farms at the time too?? Or could it just possibly be that we are smack in the middle of the shark's natural habitat??
john d. farrugia
Aug 9th 2010, 21:39
Sharks in local waters are more frequent that most of you think. Among a number of sightings I've witnessed a "two foot plus" dorsal fin circling around a dead cow (probably thrown overboard) about 5 miles off Ta' Cenc. Proportionally the fish was definitely more than 12ft. And I can tell the difference between a dolphin and a shark :)
Paul Busuttil
Aug 9th 2010, 21:32
I used to work at the fish farm at St Paul's Islands. Here we used to farm Sea Bass and Sea Bream. Naturally curious predators used to hang around the nets, Large tunny and amberjack, hoping for a stray free meal....Now however we have larger fish in captivity....Tuna themselves. Who in turn are predated upon by sharks....one species being the Great White itself. So it would only be natural to sight a great white around the Maltese waters.......I am not surprised at all with this encounter I just hope to God no one gets hurt.
Wilfred Camilleri
Aug 9th 2010, 20:51
I know sharks have a very bad reputation and unfortunately it is true they can harm humans or even cause fatal attacks, but please do keep in mind this animal is in it's natural habitat and we (humans) can be listed as fair game when we are in the water. It's an animal to be treated with respect and not destroyed - it's very much needed in the sea's Eco system - so I really hope no jaws panic happens and gets the Maltese in shark exterminators - it would be a disaster to our sea.
Joseph Camilleri
Aug 9th 2010, 20:24
wow.. nobody blamed GonziPN ... or the par idejn sodi ... yet!
Karl Consiglio
Aug 9th 2010, 20:20
The Med ain't no giant swimming pool.
Christopher Debattista
Aug 9th 2010, 19:56
Malta is in fact a breeding ground for many sharks including Great whites. They also breed in the sea basins of France . They come near since the sea currents don't propagate and the sea is warmer than the Atlantic ocean
Stephen Baldacchino
Aug 10th 2010, 00:19
Just for everybody's Info....According to the Discovery Channel film crew which was hear to film sharks in Malta, They told us these words " If you Maltese would know what you have in your waters you would never go to swim" and when asked why, he told me that we are in the very center were the great white sharks gives birth to there young. Than I asked him why we don't have shark attacks like other countries and his reply was that they only come here to give birth and stay far out at sea and they don't come for food, they just give birth and return to there origins.......but some times one or more individuals will venture near shore. and if you don't believe, ask the guy in this video..
paul zerafa
Aug 9th 2010, 19:47
MY FRIEND AND ALL ,A SHARK OF THE KIND (GREAT WHITE IS IN MALTESE CALLED,"PIXXIPLAMTU") AND STOP CALLING IT"" KELP IL -BAHAR " WHEN THE SAID FISH SURFACE IT IS GENERALLY IDENTIFIED AS THE BACK FIN AND THE TAIL FIN SURFACE TOGETHER THUS YOU SEE TWO FINS ONE AFTER THE OTHER APPART ,ACCORDING THE SIZE OF THE FISH. WAS YOUR SURF BOARD INSPECTED TO DECIDE IF THE BITE IS THAT OF A PIXXIPLAMTU??
victor pulis
Aug 9th 2010, 20:52
Paul The great white shark is called huta bajda in Maltese the pixxiplamtu is the Porbeagle shark a close relative of the great white along with the Mako shark. Their caudal fins (tails) are homo cercal that is the upper and lower lobes are more or less the same size as opposed to the tail of the tiger shark for example. therefore when swimming near the surface the tail may not show. From the video clip there was no bite mark but a tear in the sail fabric, and just a finger sized hole. a shark would have bitten the surf board or sail to test if it was edible.
Jeremy J Camilleri
Aug 9th 2010, 21:09
Paul..A shark in Maltese is called Gabdoll..Pixxiplamtu is a Porbeagle.
Actually, kelb il bahar is a Great White, also known as huta bajda..
Neil Sant
Aug 10th 2010, 08:51
Actually 'gabdoll' refers to the sperm whale. Victor Pulis is right. Pixxiplamtu is the porbeagle shark.
Alfred Grech
Aug 9th 2010, 19:34
I can imagine how this man is feeling. I was attacked by a 24ft Great White Shark sometime around 1995 when it tried to bite my 13 foot boat while fishing for Lampuki about two to three miles north out of St. Pauls Island. On that day after the DOI where informed the AFM confirmed that it was a Great White. Great Whites will sensor the blood scent of the fish being slaughtered and blood drained out; from miles and miles away sharks comes close. However, the shark would not find anything to attack and would become ferocious; attacking anything which comes into its way.
James Herrera
Aug 9th 2010, 21:13
24ft = 7.13metres. My God that was some hell of a shark lol .... You sure about your measurments?
I. Galea
Aug 10th 2010, 00:12
same thing happened to my grandfather, a couple of years later. the shark was bigger than his luzzu. he said he thought it was tuna, so he tried to catch it, but turned out to be a shark which started thrashing about in the water and almost sunk the boat, then it swam off towards comino. Grandad never went fishing alone after that.
Neil Sant
Aug 10th 2010, 08:48
24 feet long? That would make it a world record! I doubt it was as big as that. Still, terrifying nonetheless!
C Cassar
Aug 9th 2010, 19:03
looks like someone here wants to make a story. This area is frequented by dolphins. in the flesh these can seem quite large and are very often mistaken for sharks due to their dorsal fins breaking the surface. Much fuss about nothing.
Chris Ellul
Aug 9th 2010, 19:37
This "much fuss about nothing" as you blatently put it, caused this windsurfer much distress and a ruptured sale. By the looks of it you have plenty of experience with sharks and dolphins so don't withold your credentials. Can you say for certain, with your undeniable first hand experience, that this was indeed a dolphin judging by its appearance, movement and character? I think I'll stick to the windsurfer's story, not to mention the handful of witnesses. This guy was lucky he was not hurt!
Alfred Grech
Aug 9th 2010, 19:39
Dear Mr. Cassar, you are still young and if for any reason you do not believe that Great Whites are around I invite you to have a swim somewhere around the said area; if you have the guts!
Clive Xuereb
Aug 9th 2010, 20:39
Mr Cassar, Im a kitesurfer who spotted a fin on sat off Exiles sliema, i was kitesurfing around 200m off the coast. I have seen hundreds of dolphins and i can confirm this was no dolphin, it surfaced slowly, and very different than a dolphin, i hope u start believing
Claudio Carta
Aug 9th 2010, 21:42
Pixxiplamtu is a Porbeagle which is very close to a Great White which in turn is called Kelb il-Bahar Abjad.
This is a case of pure curiosity from the shark which could not make out what it was looking at and that is when it checked.
M. Saliba
Aug 9th 2010, 18:57
Iva anki fuq shark ma naqblux Malta. Nahseb l-ahjar jixghel xemgha ta ratal w jghid gietni tajjeb. GHamel sew avzana. RApport l-ghassa? ma nafx ghalxiex.
Robert Camenzuli
Aug 9th 2010, 18:56
Perfect timing for the Gozo - Malta swim that will be held on the 21st of this month! I hope I will forget what I just read in 2 weeks!
axuereb
Aug 9th 2010, 23:36
Good luck with that! I hope the authorities will keep a look out for this shark (?) for the safety of all undertaking the Malta-Gozo swim.
Stefan Debattista
Aug 9th 2010, 18:53
I'm not surprised that the sharks are telling their other shark friends to hang around Malta with all those tuna farms we have so close to shore spewing all that food and attracting other tuna friends. If I were shark I'd hang around Malta for sure. Stefan - Maltese Sailor/Windsurfer
J. Borg
Aug 9th 2010, 18:06
The FISH FARMS littering our shores and bays are attracting sharks as well. Not only are they ruining our tourism by polluting the sea - now we may also have a fatality... However it seems the authorities are turning a blind eye when fish farms operators are concerned. Shrouded party financing may explain such illogical stance!
B Camilleri
Aug 9th 2010, 18:39
Yes Mr. Borg it is because of the fish farms that this shark was near Valletta. Come to think of it, how many fish farms are there in the Valletta area? In round figures please. Yes that's right ZERO, that's a nice round figure
Stefan Debattista
Aug 9th 2010, 18:55
How long do you think it takes a shark to swim from St Pauls Bay to Valletta Mr Camilleri?
Joe Gauci
Aug 9th 2010, 21:07
B Camilleri do you think it will take a hundred years for a shark to swim from the fish farms off Marsascala and the other ones near Mellieha and Gozo? This is apart from contaminating our seas.
RGatt
Aug 11th 2010, 11:19
Sharks keep away from polluted water.
Claire Busuttil
Aug 9th 2010, 16:04
In Malta we think that we are different from other countries.....no shark attacks, no natural disasters, well actually in our area, there should be sharks and even whales. The thing is that this huge fish that attacked this guy, could have been also a dolphin, they could be dangerous as well.
Joseph Micallef
Aug 9th 2010, 18:22
I never thought that dolphins can be dangerous. I always considered them docile. Call me naive maybe! I never heard of a dolphin attacking a human being though!
Mario Busuttil
Aug 9th 2010, 18:44
Maybe i suggest everyone to see a Shark Week on Discovery channel or a similar program,only a Shark could do things that this fellow saw like goes around him slowly all the times so than it will attack instantly at the right moment and also sharks attack wind surfers or something similar that floats because for them it'seasier to catch ......
Harry Forrester
Aug 9th 2010, 19:55
@Mario Sharks typically attack surfers (not windsurfers), as when paddling on their boards to catch a wave, it looks like the motion of a seal to the shark circling beneath. Apart from that, I'm sure David Bonavia is relieved that he is ok, but some elements of his story seem a bit far fetched... i) hitting the shark with the metal piece of the harness - im quite sure that if a shark went to attack him, he WOULD NOT have been fended off by such a weapon... ii) the cut on the sail at 2:30 is nothing like a shark bite..it is just small hole in the sail - if a shark bit it, you'd see a much bigger tear..Yes, further on in the footage, you will see a big tear on the sail, but i have a similar tear in my windsuring sail as a result of falling through it..im quite sure a shark bite would have cut through the whole of the sail, and not just the thin plastic component.. The story could be true, but i think it is exagerrated.
Claire Busuttil
Aug 9th 2010, 20:17
@Joseph Micallef, Dolphins and also Killer whales, the amazing orcas, do not attack humans to eat them, but if they are nervous, being a big fish (also a dolphin can be huge compared to a human being) can be of course dangerous. My grandpa, while fishing on a small boat, in Xghajra, long ago, he was also attacked by a dolphin, who apparently wanted to play of tease him, but he for sure was terrified, until the animal went away!
Jeremy J Camilleri
Aug 9th 2010, 21:04
Dolphins have attacked, and even killed humans ...but a dolphin is not a fish...
Otherwise, I believe that this story is much ado about nothing. SHarks do not prey on humans, and even in shark infested waters, attacks are generally rare.
victor pulis
Aug 9th 2010, 15:59
The surfboard was examined by the police and returned to its owner.
Are the police competent in identifying the shark from any bite marks if any?
And why was this incident kept under wraps considering the risk?
Finally, I agree with Wendy. It's their world, the only one they've got and any one venturing into the sea is taking a calculated risk.
Denis A. Darmanin
Aug 9th 2010, 15:54
Sightings of a large dorsal fin and even large ripples in the sea have been noted all throughout last week off Valletta's Marsamxett rocky foreshores, mainly near il-Cable and near the Fossa areas. On a particular day when currents were inwards, heads of large fish were noted floating near the former Waterpolo pitch.
The referred attack on the windsurfer had occured a number of days ago. So was it hushed not to scare people from swimming? Such sightings should be taken seriously and announced to save lives and accidents should the alarm be real. Better a false alarm than anything worse!
Peter Shaw
Aug 9th 2010, 15:26
It seems the young man escaped from the jaws of death! (pun intended)
wendy mamo
Aug 9th 2010, 15:06
well, its an ocean-thats where sharks live-thats their territory! i dont see what the big fuss is about, i mean we all know that there are plenty of sharks in the med. simple solution-if u dont wanna get attacked keep away from deep seas.... it's their territory and we are the ones invading it after all !!!
Greg Nowell
Aug 9th 2010, 15:36
I agree with your comments about The Oceans and Seas are the Sharks territory and home, but if you believe that there are plenty of Sharks in the Mediterranean you are sadly mistaken. Nearly all large species of Sharks Blues, Makos, Porbeagle and White populations have been decimated by constant overfishing and the global problem of Fining.
The windsurfer was lucky enough to see one, alive and swimming, which is more than many people can say. Sharks are not interested in us, yet our interest to have them in a bowl or on a plate is wiping out 100 million per year.
If this continues then sadly they will dissapear from the Mediterranean waters forever. Only a change of attitude and a willingness to make a difference will stop this.
Derek Fenech
Aug 9th 2010, 15:47
Just for your info the Mediterranean is a sea not an ocean
Jason Galea
Aug 9th 2010, 16:01
Wendy, bl-ikbar rispett imma ma nahsibx li qieghdha titkellem tajjeb hekk.
Jekk il-bahar taghna ma ghadux 'safe' li nghumu fih, nahseb ghandna dritt inkunu nafu QABEL mhux wara li tigri xi fatalita`!
Dr Francis Saliba
Aug 9th 2010, 16:22
Sharks are known to attack swimmers even in one meter deep seawater - not only in "deep" water!
Claudio Carta
Aug 9th 2010, 16:36
Sharks have always been around and just because something like this happened, it does not make it more dangerous than before. If it was a shark as speculated, it could already be miles off. Most of these sharks tend to keep moving and not loiter in the same area.
M.BEZZINA
Aug 9th 2010, 17:36
Kieku int kont fil bahar u tara pixxispad jaqbez hdejk ukoll tippanikja...ahseb wara kelb il bahar!!Ma nafx kif tirragunaw kultant...tahsbu li aw Malta differenti min postijiet ohra!!
dvella
Aug 9th 2010, 13:45
"said he saw a shark that was about three metres long circling him."
I think a Marine science expert should be given the task to carry on such investigations concerning the case and wonder if we have any on the police force capable to do so!! So the final outcome?
Just a simple police report!!
victor rodenas
Aug 9th 2010, 13:13
The top triangular part of a sail looks like the fin of a big fish,it could be that the shark taught it was an injured dolphin or tuna fluttering in the rough sea and attacked.Nobody said that there are no sharks in the Med.Sea ,remember that one of the biggest White Sharks was caught off Wied iz- Zurrieq some time ago.Humans are not the proper food for sharks...too boney...but when an annimal grows old and its usual prey eludes it ,then it will eat anything to survive.
L. Calleja
Aug 9th 2010, 12:48
The surfer was close to Valletta and Marsamxett beach. Swimmers in this area need to keep an eye and be cautious. It is usual to spot a shark in our waters but not a shark attacking a person.
Clive Xuereb
Aug 9th 2010, 12:34
I am in a position to confirm a sighting for this fish. I am a kitesurfer who was kiting off exiles Sliema on Saturday afternoon, at a point i spotted a fin 3m away from me, this fish surfaced slowly and went back down on its side.
Karl Axisa
Aug 9th 2010, 18:59
@ Dear Clive Rather than trying to get in the lime light, did you bother to log a report with the police as soon as possible? As far as I know Exiles is a very popular bathing area. Given the depth of the water there, an attack on unsuspecting swimmers was possible. I do reckon that on the day the sea was rough so most probably few where tempted to take the dip but.... Such a situation begs for civic responsibility as with all situations involving others.
clive xuereb
Aug 9th 2010, 20:47
Dear Karl, I love the sea and would not be happy of such sighting, if u think im trying to get in the limelight i can post my facebook profile with my comment before this story surfaced. No i did not bother to file a police report as i believed this was a large tuna, i never imagined a shark was few meters away from me. I take full responsibility of my sighting and my comments. Again i spotted the fish approximately 200m off exiles.