Eyebrows raised after former Commissioner Borg joins Brussels PR company
Transparency campaigners are worried that a PR company which lobbies the EU on maritime issues has managed to engage former maritime affairs commissioner Joe Borg and one of his assistants, according to the EU Observer.
It said the alarm was raised after Dr Borg was engaged to work for Fipra, a PR consultancy actively lobbying on maritime issues in Brussels.
The European Commission last month gave Dr Borg the green light to work at the firm, saying: "In view of the fact that Mr Borg's envisaged activity falls outside the scope of his portfolio during his time in office," it did not even need to convene its Ethics Committee, a body which examines potential conflict of interest when commissioners leave the EU.
Dr Borg is to join his old colleague, John Richardson, a former director in the European Commission's "Directorate General Mare," the EU's maritime and fisheries department, until August 2008, who the next month became Fipra's "maritime policy and diplomacy special advisor."
Corporate Europe Observatory, the EU transparency watchdog, has sharply criticised the developments, noting that Fipra had not even signed up to the commission's own lobbyist registry.
"These two unacceptable revolving doors cases show that the commission's narrow interpretation makes the rules applying to former commissioners and commission staff totally irrelevant," the group's Erik Wesselius said. "Fipra appear to have bought up the top of the EU's maritime department lock, stock and barrel."
A total so far of six of the 13 EU commissioners who retired earlier this year have now gone on to work for banks, lobbying firms, insurance companies and airlines.
The crux of Messrs Borg and Richardson's defence is that their new activities do not overlap with their old commission jobs, EU Observer said.
Dr Borg, when notifying the commission of his new post, said he is "in principle not going to advise clients on matters related to his former commission portfolio." When contacted by EUobserver, Mr Richardson said: "The role I play is in advising companies on their dealings with governments. That's clearly in the public interest."
Fipra's chairman, Peter Lehrell, told the EU Observer website:
"Mr Borg will not be performing any tasks related to his past portfolio whatsoever, although I would like the right to go back to the commission and say: 'Do you mind if we do?'" he added. "He was Maltese foreign minister for a while ...I hired him because we don't have any representation there and I need a good man in Malta."
The website said Dr Borg was recruited by the PR agency after a meeting with Fipra's Ukko Metsolo, who is married to Roberta Metsola Tedesco Triccas, a legal attache in the Maltese mission to the EU.
4 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Silvan Said
Jul 14th 2010, 17:10
A difficult dilemma indeed
On the one hand, why shouldn't a capable person like Dr Borg have the right to get the best opportunities based on his experience and competence? If persons who occupied high sensitive office are not able to move on to greener pastures then you can only expect mediocrity to take over and people who fear to let go of their office.
On the other hand, it is clearly an ethical issue when a commissioner who held such power becomes a player connected to the field he sought to direct. This also applies to regulators and Dr Borg is not the first person in Malta who joined a player in the market after working as a regulator of the same industry he regulated. Or even sat on boards of regulators whilst directing enterprises in the same market.
Members of any profession have a code of ethics and conduct and they should be guided by this code in their decisions and their conduct especially when presented with a potential conflict of interest. Usually, when such conflicts arise, the advise is to decline to act entirely.
Mary Smith
Jul 14th 2010, 04:32
This makes one wonder what really happens at the top and how decisions that affect millions of people are taken.
This is the same recipe with lobbyists everywhere; they swarm the Governing Capitals of both Europe and North America, buying favour for their cause, whether it is fighting pollution standards, relaxing labour legislation and increasing the retirement age, to the introduction of Genetically Modified Foods or have a drug approved for human use without adequate testing. The list is endless.
I urge all to watch this video "Sweet Misery" about the sweetener Aspartame:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P-usbGZez40
g. scerri
Jul 12th 2010, 11:47
Read the British online press and find out similar goings-on by Peter Lord Mendelson who too enjoyed a stint in Brussels. The stories are all the same. It's a pot of gold shared by all the elites in the club. Joe Borg would be a fool to miss out and return to the wilderness here. And a fool he isn't. Neither is any of our MEPs. All those who are able to, ought to make their way as quickly as possible to this gold mine. It's theirs for the taking.
N. Bonello
Jul 12th 2010, 22:46
And ours for the paying.