BWSC 'masters at getting things done their way' - Bartolo
Labour MP Evarist Bartolo said in parliament today that while the culprit had not been caught yet, it was very clear that there was corruption in the power station tendering process.
Speaking in Parliament, Mr Bartolo hit out at the local representative of BWSC, the Danish company which was awarded the contract and who, he said, had boasted that he had high level contacts in Enemalta and the political field. Mr Mizzi used to go to Enemalta so often, he said, that no one continued to ask for his identity, Mr Bartolo said.
Mr Mizzi used to go to speak to a senior official who was present Parliament for this sitting, but had not been seriously questioned, Mr Bartolo said.
But, Mr Bartolo said, he was also of the view that Mr Mizzi was only the small fish in all this and a bigger fish was involved.
The Labour MP also hit out at the chairman of Enemalta , Alex Tranter, saying did not believe his statements and was not fooled by his claim that he did not know about the involvement of his employer Zaren Vassallo at an early stage of proceedings.
As for the Director of Contracts, Mr Bartolo said it was shameful, after all this and after the S&R Handaq debacle, that his contract was being renewed when he should have been shown the door.
The power station contract published today, Mr Bartolo said, omitted the list of sub-contractors, including many foreign companies which were being sued for corruption. He sometimes wondered why, when this tender was issued, the government had not said "only corrupt companies need apply".
Malta's name had been smeared with some of the most corrupt companies. There was no hard evidence of corruption in this contract, the auditor had said, but Mr Bartolo added, there were suspicions that were bigger than the Luqa monument.
It was shameful, Mr Bartolo said, how the contract goalposts had been repeatedly moved to accommodate BWSC. For example, the government had wanted a gas-firing plant, and ended up with one using heavy fuel. The environment/emission thresholds were so unsuitable for BWSC, that the government was made to change them.
BWSC were so good at getting things done their way, that had they been the Malta football team, they would even have found ways and means to win the world cup.
Mr Bartolo said that even unsigned e-mails which originated from BWSC showed that the power station plant selected by Malta was unsuitable because it was unreliable, entailed high maintenance costs, and had a short lifespan. It was no wonder that the maintenance agreement would be limited to five years.
Connections could be found throughout the tendering process and it was no wonder that the auditor could not find people who could cooperate, Mr Bartolo said. Even within a lawyers' office there were lawyers who worked for Mr Mizzi and used to work for Enemalta and others who worked for BWSC.
But not only was there a network of friends who made no distinction between private and professional interests, but there was also a climate of fear, with some people fearful of openly disclosing what they knew. Among them was an engineer who told him that as early as 2005, he was told that the decision had been taken on who would win the contract.
It was no surprise, Mr Bartolo said, that the EU directive which the government had not yet transposed in Maltese law, related to public procurement.
The Labour MP said he agreed with Nationalist MP Franco Debono on the need for a law to regulate political party funding and transparency in this area, so that one would not have corrupt gangs who controlled how decisions were taken.
6 Comments
Post comment
Please sign in or create your Account to post comments.
Lawrence Fenech
May 7th 2010, 10:18
Dawru il-Gvern ma subghajhom u specjalment dawk li hadu l-4,000,000 Euro.
Jimmy Magro
May 6th 2010, 21:23
After each general eelction, the candidates are duty bound to make a declaration that they respected the capping on election spending. This is made under oath.
I suggest that all members of Parliament, EneMalta employees, Department of Contracts employees, and Mr. Joe Mizzi would make a declaration under oath that they have not received any money (in any shape or form) from any company involved in the tendering process of this particular tender.
C Falzon
May 6th 2010, 19:51
I've seen it mentioned many times statements such as "government had wanted a gas-firing plant". I find it very strange that the government would have actually wanted that as gas is very rarely a good choice of fuel for a power station. Normally it is used when the power station can be sited close to the well head and is owned by the same owners of the well. In our case we would have to get it by refrigerated tanker ships or possibly a very long pipeline. The transport often ends up costing more than the gas itself.
My impression is that the original intention was for combined cycle gas turbines , similar to the ones already in use at Marsaxlokk, without any specific mention of what fuel they would run on.
Anyone have some reference to some document, website or something indicating the government's intention to go for gas as fuel? I have spent some time searching but have not managed to find anything relevant.
Paul Borg
May 6th 2010, 20:53
Gas oil is different.
Wenzu Vella
May 6th 2010, 22:44
The say goes, that where there is smoke there is fire: in this case it seems that this fire is as big as a VOLCANO. It just simply STINCK.......
SMuscat
May 7th 2010, 09:02
Dear Mr. Falzon, The enemalta electrical generation plan specifically concludes that it ' identifies the use of Combined Cycle Gas Turbines (CCGT) as the only generating plant able to comply with the present expected emissions limits in 2020. It also highlights the need for 200 MW of local generation to be replaced either by new generating plant or by a cable interconnection. In order to minimise the local cost of electricity these CCGT plants should be fired with gas which implies that a local supply of gas, either through a pipeline or a terminal will also be required.' This is natural gas and not 'gas oil' (the expensive stuff Saudi Arabia sells) and also please note that your statement about natural gas is rarely a good choice then all of Europe make very bad choices. the link to the plan is this, enjoy reading it http://www.enemalta.com.mt/filebank/documents/Generation%20Plan%20%2821.06.06%29.pdf