Advert

Entrepreneur sold fake Viagra over the internet

A young entrepreneur who began selling counterfeit Viagra by e-mail was given a suspended jail term and fined €23,000 after pleading guilty.

Brady Abela, 24, from Tarxien sold the fake pills, an exact pharmacological replica of the original manufactured by American pharmaceutical giant Pfizer Inc, over the internet.

It was only after a Pfizer employee was alerted to an e-mail advertising the website offering the supposed Viagra pills for sale that the company contacted the Maltese authorities to trace the culprit.

Police Inspector Yvonne Farrugia had testified that the pills were identical even in appearance, down to the trademark blue colour, the shape and the Viagra distinctive markings and box. It even included the instruction pamphlet.

Mr Abela admitted to selling the pills, breaching trademark laws and manufacturing counterfeit items.

Magistrate Jacqueline Padovani, said that it resulted that since the Medicines Authority had not taken part in the proceedings against Mr Abela, the court could not find him guilty of placing a medicinal item on the market without a licence.

She quoted article 100 of the Medicines Act stipulating that if the "Licensing authority believes that a person has committed an offence against this Act or any regulations or rules made there-under, the authority shall give notice in writing to such person, describing the offence of which the person is accused, indicating the steps to be taken to remedy the offence and the penalty which he is required to pay in respect of that offence".

The magistrate noted that once such a procedure was not followed she could neither find Mr Abela guilty of illegally selling the item wholesale and acting as a pharmacist without a licence, as demanded by the Medicine Act.

The court ruled that the €23,000 fine could be paid over a three-year period.

The magistrate ordered that Mr Abela's two hard drives be destroyed after a court expert saved his family photos.

Lawyer Toni Abela appeared for Mr Abela.

Lawyers Joseph Giglio and Luigi Sansone appeared for Pfizer Inc.

Advert

6 Comments

Post comment

Comments are submitted under the express understanding and condition that the editor may, and is authorised to, disclose any/all of the above personal information to any person or entity requesting the information for the purposes of legal action on grounds that such person or entity is aggrieved by any comment so submitted.

At this time your comment will not be displayed immediately upon posting. Please allow some time for your comment to be moderated before it is displayed.

Your User Profile is incomplete.
Please click here to complete your profile before posting comments.

KJ Tabone

Apr 17th 2010, 15:51

Just to clarify, generic medicines are not an exact replica of the original product. They cannot contain anything that infringes any trademarks or patents, including colours and tablet markings amongst others. If the tablets in the case above were identical in appearance to the original product but weren't made by Pfizer then they cannot be generics but are counterfeits, or 'fakes' (in the same way that one can find fake handbags or trainers with a certain logo at a fraction of the price). Whether these 'fake' tablets actually contain the ingredient or not is another story. I know of cases where placebos were passed off as the original thing.

If in doubt always buy you medicines from an authorised dealer i.e. a pharmacy!!

KJ tabone

Apr 17th 2010, 16:50

Also, generic versions of Viagra are still not available because the patent on the ingredient hasn't expied yet. The only version of this product available on the market is that manufactured by Pfizer and nothing else.

Mark Grima

Apr 17th 2010, 18:43

sorry but the article says "exact pharmacological replica" - note the word pharmacological meaning it works the same as the original - indeed generic tablet have the same therapeutic effect as those tablets by the innovator because they have the same pharmacological mechanism

however generic tablets can have different markings, appearance and formulation like Tabone said in order not to infringes any trademarks or patents

but pharmacologically MUST BE THE SAME and these tablets were a pharmacological replica

Mark Grima

Apr 17th 2010, 18:49

Tabone note that tablets produced by the innovator company in this case Pfizer can NEVER be called GENERICS!

Generics are pharmacological replica of the original tablets (eg Pfizer Viagra) produced by 3rd companies once the patient period of the innovator for that drug has expired.

Advert
Advert